| Literature DB >> 30111363 |
Deepa Jeevanantham1,2,3, Venkadesan Rajendran4,5,6, Line Tremblay2,3, Céline Larivière2,3, Andrew Knight1,2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Patients with multiple myeloma (MM) are often treated with chemotherapy, radiation, and, if indicated, autologous stem cell transplant. In addition to side effects of the treatment, patients with MM often have bone pain, pathological fractures, spinal cord compressions, fatigue, and muscle weakness, which negatively impact functional performance and quality of life. Currently, there are no related guidelines for safe and effective physiotherapy (PT) management. Accordingly, the aim of the present study is to develop guidelines for effective physiotherapy management of patients with MM by systematically reviewing and evaluating the available evidence followed by a consensus process to specifically describe the research questions as detailed below. METHODS/Entities:
Keywords: Guidelines; Multiple myeloma; Physiotherapy
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30111363 PMCID: PMC6094887 DOI: 10.1186/s13643-018-0785-7
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Syst Rev ISSN: 2046-4053
PICO (population, intervention, control, and outcomes)
| Review question | What are the available evidence for the following: |
| Population | Multiple myeloma or myeloma or plasma cell myeloma |
| Intervention | Physiotherapy or physical therapy, ambulation, mobilization, mobility, functional mobility training, exercise, strength training, endurance training, cardio-pulmonary exercise, aerobics exercise, anaerobic exercise, high-intensity exercise, low-intensity exercise, home-based exercise, multi-modal exercise, flexibility exercise, physical activity, pain management, and fatigue management |
| Comparator | Stated interventions compared with placebo or no interventions |
| Outcomes | All possible outcomes |
Search terms used for each research questions (PubMed)
| Research questions | Search terms |
|---|---|
| Safely mobilizing patients with multiple myeloma in an acute care setting | ((((("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesion*")) AND ("acute care" OR hospital OR Inpatient))) AND ("early mobili*" OR Mobili* OR "Early ambulat*" or ambulat* |
| Effective pain management in patients with multiple myeloma | (((("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesion*"))) AND (Pain OR "Pain Manag*" OR "Cancer Pain")) |
| Physiotherapy (PT) management in patients with multiple myeloma receiving chemotherapy | (((("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesion*")) AND (Physiotherapy OR "physical therapy" OR ambulat* OR mobili* OR "functional mobility training" OR exercis* OR "strength training" OR "endurance training" OR "cardio?pulmonary exercis*" OR "aerobic exercis*" OR "anaerobic exercis*" OR "high intensity exercis*" OR "low intensity exercis*" OR "home based exercis*" OR "multi-modal exercis*" OR "flexibility exercis*" OR "physical activity")) AND (chemotherap* OR "high-dose chemotherap*")) |
| PT management in patients with multiple myeloma receiving radiation | (((("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesion*")) AND (Physiotherapy OR "physical therapy" OR ambulat* OR mobili* OR "functional mobility training" OR exercis* OR "strength training" OR "endurance training" OR "cardio?pulmonary exercis*" OR "aerobic exercis*" OR "anaerobic exercis*" OR "high intensity exercis*" OR "low intensity exercis*" OR "home based exercis*" OR "multi-modal exercis*" OR "flexibility exercis*" OR "physical activity")) AND (Radiation* OR “Radiation therapy”)) |
| PT management in patients with multiple myeloma receiving a stem cell transplantation | (((("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesion*")) AND (Physiotherapy OR "physical therapy" OR ambulat* OR mobili* OR "functional mobility training" OR exercis* OR "strength training" OR "endurance training" OR "cardio?pulmonary exercis*" OR "aerobic exercis*" OR "anaerobic exercis*" OR "high intensity exercis*" OR "low intensity exercis*" OR "home based exercis*" OR "multi-modal exercis*" OR "flexibility exercis*" OR "physical activity")) AND (“stem cell transplant*” OR “h?ematopoietic stem cell transplant*” OR “bone marrow transplant*”)) |
| PT management in patients with multiple myeloma receiving a stem cell transplantation | (((("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesions")) AND (Physiotherapy OR "physical therapy" OR ambulat* OR mobili* OR "functional mobility training" OR exercis* OR "strength training" OR "endurance training" OR "cardio?pulmonary exercis*" OR "aerobic exercis*" OR "anaerobic exercis*" OR "high intensity exercis*" OR "low intensity exercis*" OR "home based exercis*" OR "multi-modal exercis*" OR "flexibility exercis*" OR "physical activity")) AND (“stem cell transplant*” OR “hematopoietic stem cell transplant*” OR “bone marrow transplant*”)) |
| Management of fatigue and muscle weakness in patients with multiple myeloma | ((("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesion*")) AND ("fatigue manag*" OR "cancer related fatigue" AND ("muscle weakness" OR "cancer related muscle weakness" OR "muscle weakness manag*")) |
| Management of fatigue and muscle weakness in patients with multiple myeloma | (("Multiple Myeloma" OR Myeloma OR "Plasma Cell Myeloma" OR "Haematological Cancer" OR "Bone Lesion*")) AND ("fatigue manag*" OR "cancer related fatigue" OR "muscle weakness" OR "cancer related muscle weakness" OR "muscle weakness manag*") |
Levels of evidence
| Level | Criteria |
|---|---|
| I | Evidence obtained from high-quality diagnostic studies, prognostic or prospective studies, cohort studies or randomized controlled trials, meta analyses or systematic reviews (critical appraisal score |
| II | Evidence obtained from lesser-quality diagnostic studies, prognostic or prospective studies, cohort studies or randomized controlled trials, meta |
| III | Case-controlled studies or retrospective studies |
| IV | Case studies and case series |
| V | Expert opinion |
Reprinted from Kaplan SL, Coulter C, Fetters L. Developing evidence-based physical therapy clinical practice guidelines. Pediatr Phys Ther. 2013;25:257–270, with permission of Wolters Kluwer Health Inc.
Definition of Grades of Recommendation for action statements
| Grade | Recommendation | Quality of Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| A | Strong | A preponderance of level I studies, but least 1 level I study directly on the topic support the recommendation. |
| B | Moderate | A preponderance of level II studies but at least 1 level II study directly on topic support the recommendation. |
| C | Weak | A single level II study at less than 25% critical appraisal score or a preponderance of level III and IV studies, including statements of consensus by content experts support the recommendation. |
| D | Theoretical/foundational | A preponderance of evidence from animal or cadaver studies, from conceptual/theoretical models/principles, or from basic science/bench research, or published expert opinion in peer-reviewed journals supports the recommendation. |
| P | Best practice | Recommended practice based on current clinical practice norms, exceptional situations where validating studies have not or cannot be performed and there is a clear benefit, harm, or cost, and/or the clinical experience of the guideline development group. |
| R | Research | There is an absence of research on the topic, or higher-quality studies conducted on the topic disagree with respect to their conclusions. The recommendation is based on these conflicting or absent studies. |
Reprinted from Kaplan SL, Coulter C, Fetters L. Developing evidence-based physical therapy clinical practice guidelines. Pediatr Phys Ther. 2013;25:257–270, with permission of Wolters Kluwer Health Inc.