Barry S Willer1, Michael R Tiso, Mohammad N Haider, Andrea L Hinds, John G Baker, Jeffery C Miecznikowski, John J Leddy. 1. Departments of Psychiatry (Drs Willer, Haider, and Hinds), Orthopedics and Sports Medicine (Drs Haider and Leddy), Nuclear Medicine (Dr Baker), and Biostatistics (Dr Miecznikowski), University at Buffalo, SUNY, New York; and Departments of Internal Medicine and Sports Medicine, Ohio State University, Columbus (Dr Tiso).
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To compare retired professional contact sport athletes with age-matched noncontact sport athletes on measures of executive function and mental health. SETTING: The University Concussion Management Clinic. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-one retired National Football League (NFL) and National Hockey League (NHL) players (mean age 56 years) and 21 age-matched noncontact sport athlete controls. DESIGNS: Case control. MAIN MEASURE: The self- and informant-reported Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function-Adult form (BRIEF-A); Wisconsin Card Sorting Test; Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System; Trail Making Part A and B; Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale; Neuropsychological Assessment Battery; List Learning; Controlled Oral Word Association Test; Beck Depression Inventory; Beck Anxiety Inventory; and Personality Inventory of the DSM-5. RESULTS: Former NFL and NHL players perceived themselves to have some impairment in 2 of the 9 domains of executive function on the BRIEF-A; however, their informants reported no difference when compared with informants of noncontact athletes. No significant differences were found when comparing contact sport athletes with noncontact athletes on objective neuropsychological testing. Contact sport athletes qualified as clinically anxious and had more "unusual beliefs and experiences," although they remained within with age-based norms. CONCLUSION: Participation in contact sports at the professional level may not lead to later-life executive dysfunction, as the popular media and some research currently suggest.
OBJECTIVE: To compare retired professional contact sport athletes with age-matched noncontact sport athletes on measures of executive function and mental health. SETTING: The University Concussion Management Clinic. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-one retired National Football League (NFL) and National Hockey League (NHL) players (mean age 56 years) and 21 age-matched noncontact sport athlete controls. DESIGNS: Case control. MAIN MEASURE: The self- and informant-reported Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function-Adult form (BRIEF-A); Wisconsin Card Sorting Test; Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System; Trail Making Part A and B; Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale; Neuropsychological Assessment Battery; List Learning; Controlled Oral Word Association Test; Beck Depression Inventory; Beck Anxiety Inventory; and Personality Inventory of the DSM-5. RESULTS: Former NFL and NHL players perceived themselves to have some impairment in 2 of the 9 domains of executive function on the BRIEF-A; however, their informants reported no difference when compared with informants of noncontact athletes. No significant differences were found when comparing contact sport athletes with noncontact athletes on objective neuropsychological testing. Contact sport athletes qualified as clinically anxious and had more "unusual beliefs and experiences," although they remained within with age-based norms. CONCLUSION: Participation in contact sports at the professional level may not lead to later-life executive dysfunction, as the popular media and some research currently suggest.
Authors: Patria A Hume; Alice Theadom; Gwyn N Lewis; Kenneth L Quarrie; Scott R Brown; Rosamund Hill; Stephen W Marshall Journal: Sports Med Date: 2017-06 Impact factor: 11.136
Authors: Jeremy Strain; Nyaz Didehbani; C Munro Cullum; Sethesh Mansinghani; Heather Conover; Michael A Kraut; John Hart; Kyle B Womack Journal: Neurology Date: 2013-05-24 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Robert A Stern; Daniel H Daneshvar; Christine M Baugh; Daniel R Seichepine; Philip H Montenigro; David O Riley; Nathan G Fritts; Julie M Stamm; Clifford A Robbins; Lisa McHale; Irene Simkin; Thor D Stein; Victor E Alvarez; Lee E Goldstein; Andrew E Budson; Neil W Kowall; Christopher J Nowinski; Robert C Cantu; Ann C McKee Journal: Neurology Date: 2013-08-21 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Peter Elwood; Julieta Galante; Janet Pickering; Stephen Palmer; Antony Bayer; Yoav Ben-Shlomo; Marcus Longley; John Gallacher Journal: PLoS One Date: 2013-12-09 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Jaclyn B Caccese; Grant L Iverson; Kenneth L Cameron; Megan N Houston; Gerald T McGinty; Jonathan C Jackson; Patrick O'Donnell; Paul F Pasquina; Steven P Broglio; Michael McCrea; Thomas McAllister; Thomas A Buckley Journal: J Neurotrauma Date: 2019-09-20 Impact factor: 5.269
Authors: Samuel R Walton; Zachary Y Kerr; Rebekah Mannix; Benjamin L Brett; Avinash Chandran; Jonathan D DeFreese; Michael A McCrea; Kevin M Guskiewicz; William P Meehan; Ruben J Echemendia Journal: Sports Med Date: 2021-11-13 Impact factor: 11.136
Authors: Carrie Esopenko; Jessica Meyer; Elisabeth A Wilde; Amy D Marshall; David F Tate; Alexander P Lin; Inga K Koerte; Kimberly B Werner; Emily L Dennis; Ashley L Ware; Nicola L de Souza; Deleene S Menefee; Kristen Dams-O'Connor; Dan J Stein; Erin D Bigler; Martha E Shenton; Kathy S Chiou; Judy L Postmus; Kathleen Monahan; Brenda Eagan-Johnson; Paul van Donkelaar; Tricia L Merkley; Carmen Velez; Cooper B Hodges; Hannah M Lindsey; Paula Johnson; Andrei Irimia; Matthew Spruiell; Esther R Bennett; Ashley Bridwell; Glynnis Zieman; Frank G Hillary Journal: Brain Imaging Behav Date: 2021-01-06 Impact factor: 3.978
Authors: Vincent Gouttebarge; João Mauricio Castaldelli-Maia; Paul Gorczynski; Brian Hainline; Mary E Hitchcock; Gino M Kerkhoffs; Simon M Rice; Claudia L Reardon Journal: Br J Sports Med Date: 2019-06 Impact factor: 13.800
Authors: Michael L Alosco; Yorghos Tripodis; Inga K Koerte; Jonathan D Jackson; Alicia S Chua; Megan Mariani; Olivia Haller; Éimear M Foley; Brett M Martin; Joseph Palmisano; Bhupinder Singh; Katie Green; Christian Lepage; Marc Muehlmann; Nikos Makris; Robert C Cantu; Alexander P Lin; Michael Coleman; Ofer Pasternak; Jesse Mez; Sylvain Bouix; Martha E Shenton; Robert A Stern Journal: Front Hum Neurosci Date: 2019-12-20 Impact factor: 3.169
Authors: Karen Hind; Natalie Konerth; Ian Entwistle; Patria Hume; Alice Theadom; Gwyn Lewis; Doug King; Thomas Goodbourn; Marianna Bottiglieri; Paula Ferraces-Riegas; Amanda Ellison; Paul Chazot Journal: Sports Med Date: 2021-11-18 Impact factor: 11.928
Authors: Benjamin L Brett; Amy M Nader; Zachary Y Kerr; Avinash Chandran; Samuel R Walton; J D DeFreese; Kevin M Guskiewicz; Michael McCrea Journal: J Int Neuropsychol Soc Date: 2021-02-10 Impact factor: 2.892