OBJECTIVE: To identify preoperative characteristics to help in selecting laparoscopy or laparotomy in Crohn disease (CD). SUMMARY BACKGROUND: Laparoscopy in CD is associated with high rates of conversion. METHODS: All patients undergoing abdominal surgery for CD in 2004 to 2016 by the senior author. Patients operated by laparoscopy, laparotomy, and converted to open were compared. RESULTS: Four hundred fifty-eight procedures were performed in 427 patients [F:M 1:1; median age = 41 (12-95) yrs], through laparotomy (n = 157, 34%) or laparoscopy (n = 301, 66%). Laparotomy rates decreased over time. Concomitant surgical procedures requiring laparotomy continued to dictate an open approach throughout the study. Sixty-five cases (21.6%) required conversion to laparotomy which occurred within 15' from start of case in 77%. Most common reasons for conversion included dense adhesions (34%), pelvic sepsis with fistulizing disease (26%), large inflammatory mass (18%), and thickened mesentery (9%). After multivariate analysis, predictive factors for conversion included recurrent disease after previous small bowel resection, thickened mesentery, large inflammatory mass, and extensive disease. CONCLUSION: Despite the increasing experience with laparoscopy in CD, one-fifth of selected cases still need conversion. Recurrent disease with dense adhesions, pelvic sepsis with fistulizing disease, large inflammatory mass, and thickened mesentery are all conditions predisposing to a conversion. When the severity of these conditions is known preoperatively or a simultaneous procedure requires a laparotomy, an open approach should be considered; if laparoscopy is selected, conversion to laparotomy can be decided early in the performance of the case.
OBJECTIVE: To identify preoperative characteristics to help in selecting laparoscopy or laparotomy in Crohn disease (CD). SUMMARY BACKGROUND: Laparoscopy in CD is associated with high rates of conversion. METHODS: All patients undergoing abdominal surgery for CD in 2004 to 2016 by the senior author. Patients operated by laparoscopy, laparotomy, and converted to open were compared. RESULTS: Four hundred fifty-eight procedures were performed in 427 patients [F:M 1:1; median age = 41 (12-95) yrs], through laparotomy (n = 157, 34%) or laparoscopy (n = 301, 66%). Laparotomy rates decreased over time. Concomitant surgical procedures requiring laparotomy continued to dictate an open approach throughout the study. Sixty-five cases (21.6%) required conversion to laparotomy which occurred within 15' from start of case in 77%. Most common reasons for conversion included dense adhesions (34%), pelvic sepsis with fistulizing disease (26%), large inflammatory mass (18%), and thickened mesentery (9%). After multivariate analysis, predictive factors for conversion included recurrent disease after previous small bowel resection, thickened mesentery, large inflammatory mass, and extensive disease. CONCLUSION: Despite the increasing experience with laparoscopy in CD, one-fifth of selected cases still need conversion. Recurrent disease with dense adhesions, pelvic sepsis with fistulizing disease, large inflammatory mass, and thickened mesentery are all conditions predisposing to a conversion. When the severity of these conditions is known preoperatively or a simultaneous procedure requires a laparotomy, an open approach should be considered; if laparoscopy is selected, conversion to laparotomy can be decided early in the performance of the case.
Authors: G Pellino; D S Keller; G M Sampietro; I Angriman; M Carvello; V Celentano; F Colombo; F Di Candido; S Laureti; G Luglio; G Poggioli; M Rottoli; S Scaringi; G Sciaudone; G Sica; L Sofo; S Leone; S Danese; A Spinelli; G Delaini; F Selvaggi Journal: Tech Coloproctol Date: 2020-03-14 Impact factor: 3.781
Authors: Shin Jeong Pak; Young Il Kim; Yong Sik Yoon; Jong Lyul Lee; Jung Bok Lee; Chang Sik Yu Journal: World J Gastroenterol Date: 2021-11-07 Impact factor: 5.742
Authors: Giuseppe S Sica; Sara Di Carlo; Stefano D'Ugo; Claudio Arcudi; Leandro Siragusa; Laura Fazzolari; Livia Biancone; Giovanni Monteleone; Maurizio Cardi; Simone Sibio Journal: Gastroenterol Res Pract Date: 2020-02-28 Impact factor: 2.260