Exercise-induced hyperthermia syndrome (canine stress syndrome) in four related male English springer spaniels.

OBJECTIVE: This retrospective study describes the signalment, clinical presentation, diagnostic findings, and mode of inheritance in four young male English springer spaniel dogs with presumptive canine stress syndrome.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Appropriate cases were located through medical searches of medical records of two large private referral centers. Inclusion criteria comprised of English springer spaniel dogs with tachypnea and hyperthermia that subsequently developed weakness or collapse, with or without signs of hemorrhage, soon after a period of mild-to-moderate exercise. The pedigrees of the four affected dogs, as well as eleven related English springer spaniels, were then analyzed to determine a presumptive mode of genetic inheritance.
RESULTS: Four dogs met the inclusion criteria. All four were male, suggesting the possibility of a recessive sex-linked heritable disorder. Pedigree analysis suggests that more dogs may be potentially affected, although these dogs may have never had the concurrent triggering drug/activity/event to precipitate the clinical syndrome. There was complete resolution of clinical signs in three of the four dogs with aggressive symptomatic and supportive therapy, with one dog dying during treatment.
CONCLUSION: Dogs with canine stress syndrome have the potential for rapid recovery if treated aggressively and the complications of the disease (eg, coagulopathy) are anticipated. All four dogs were male, suggesting the possibility of a recessive sex-linked mode of inheritance. Further genetic analyses should be strongly considered by those involved with the English springer spaniel breed, either with a genome-wide association study using canine single-nucleotide polymorphism arrays or whole-genome sequencing of affected and closely related dogs.

Introduction

Malignant hyperthermia (MH) is a clinical syndrome that has been reported in a variety of species, most notably humans, pigs, and dogs.1,2 When fully developed, it is charac-terized by muscle rigidity, hyperthermia (often rapid in onset), tachypnea, metabolic acidosis, hypercarbia, and cardiac arrhythmias.3 More subtle or abortive presentations of canine MH have also been reported. Furthermore, several classic signs of porcine and human MH are typically lacking in canine MH patients. For example, canine MH is not typically characterized by lactic acidosis or the early onset of muscle rigidity.

The term “canine stress syndrome” (CSS) has been borrowed from pigs (viz porcine stress syndrome) and echoed in subsequent publications to describe such cases, but the entity remains poorly defined.4,5 It is often used in relation to both true MH cases and exercise-induced hyperthermia syndrome (EIHS) which shares some similarities with MH. EIHS/CSS is generally self-limiting, responding to aggressive supportive therapy, without the requirement for specific therapy with dantrolene. EIHS has been identified in many breeds, including a male English springer spaniel (ESS) and a greyhound.6,7

EIHS/CSS is apparently precipitated by moderate-to-severe exercise in genetically susceptible dogs, although it is plausible additional triggers need to be present concurrently. The syndrome initially consists of a variable combination of hyperthermia, muscle cramping, tachypnea, and eventually collapse, with or without dyspnea. Some dogs develop seizures as part of the syndrome. Clinicopathologic abnormalities include hemoconcentration, hyperlactatemia, respiratory alkalosis, and increased muscle-enzyme activities in serum.5 Later, consumptive coagulopathy can develop, in addition to a variety of other life-threatening sequelae.

The following case series describes four suspected cases of EIHS/CSS and subsequent investigations suggesting a possible hereditary predisposition. All four affected individuals were entire male ESSs that were 2–3 years of age at the time of presentation. All were closely related. This is the first case series of EIHS cases, and our findings echo the first case recorded by Rand and O’Brien, also in an entire male ESS.6

Materials and methods

Medical records of the Small Animal Specialist Hospital and the Animal Referral Hospital between 2012 and 2014 were searched using the respective practice-management software utilizing the keywords “exercise-induced”, “hyperthermia”, and “heat stroke”. Four ESSs with signs consistent with EIHS and collapse were located. Data retrieved from the records included signalment, historical observations, clinical signs, physical findings, laboratory-test results, imaging findings, treatment protocols, and outcome (including whether the patient survived or not and whether disease recurred subsequently). The pedigrees of all affected dogs were retrievable. Our preliminary findings were presented at College Science Week in July 2015, the annual meeting of the Australian and New Zealand College of Veterinary Scientists, in an attempt to obtain data from other similarly affected dogs. Unfortunately, no further cases could be recruited into this study.

Results

Signalment and seasonal occurrence

All four patients were entire male ESSs. All were used by the police as “sniffer dogs” for the detection of illicit drugs, flares, explosives, and so forth. The dogs were part of the same police-dog unit, although they were housed in different homes, with their respective handlers. One dog presented at 23 months of age, one at 26 months of age, and two at 32 months (although one of these dogs had a previous episode of possible collapse at 22 months of age, but did not require veterinary attention at the time). Two of the four dogs presented in spring, one presented in summer, and the final dog presented in autumn (Table 1).

Table 1

Summary of signalment in four male entire English springer spaniels with exercise-induced hyperthermia (canine stress syndrome)

Clinical features	Case 1	Case 2	Case 3	Case 4
Age at presentation (months)	26	23	32	32
Veterinary intervention	Same day	~36 hours	Same day	<6 hours
Season	Spring	Spring	Autumn	Summer
Tachycardia	Yes	Yes	Unknown	Yes
Tachypnea	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Ambulatory	No	Yes	Yes, but “ataxic” in all limbs	No
Hemorrhage	Yes	Yes (footpads, ecchymoses, and melena)	No	No
Rectal body temperature (°C)	40.1	38.8	39.3	39.9
Outcome	Survived	Survived	Died	Survived

Historical findings

All dogs presented with a history of collapse or weakness after mild-to-moderate exercise. Three of the four dogs were tachypneic, which did not improve with rest. Three of the four dogs became weak, which progressed to complete collapse. Two dogs had clinical evidence of coagulopathy with spontaneous bleeding. Two of the four dogs subsequently vomited. Three of the four dogs presented to a veterinarian within 24 hours of an exercise-induced illness developing. The remaining dog presented after more than 24 hours but less than 48 hours after the antecedent event (Table 1).

Physical and neurological examination findings on presentation

Hyperthermia (rectal temperature, >39.2°C) was present in three of the four dogs (Table 1). The highest recorded rectal temperature for any case was 41°C. All four dogs were tachypneic. Three were tachycardiac. Two were nonambulatory and obtunded. One of the four dogs was ambulatory, but “ataxic” (or weak) in both pelvic limbs. Two dogs had evidence of a coagulopathy, one with hemorrhage from the prepuce and carpal/tarsal pads of three paws, while the other bled from both forepaws. Other abnormalities included a generalized motor seizure (one dog), muscle fasciculations (one dog), absent menace response associated with slow pupillary light reflexes (one dog), injected mucous membranes (two dogs), and abdominal distension (one dog) (Table 1).

Diagnostic tests

One patient did not have any laboratory tests or diagnostic imaging performed. Complete blood counts and serum biochemistry analyses were performed in the other three dogs, with results outlined in Table 2. Measurements with observed values outside the reference interval (RI) were detected on the complete blood count in two of four dogs (one dog had mature neutrophilia and thrombocytopenia, and one dog had mild reticulocytosis). A manual packed cell volume (PCV) and total plasma protein concentration were determined in two of four dogs: hemoconcentration was evident in two of four dogs, with PCV of 52% and 67%, respectively. Serum biochemistry measurements were outside the RI in three of four dogs, including decreased inorganic phosphorus concentration (two of four dogs), increased inorganic phosphorus concentration (one of four dogs), increased urea concentration (one of four dogs), increased creatinine concentration (one of four dogs), increased gamma-glutamyl tranferase activity (one of four dogs), increased total bilirubin concentration (one of four dogs), and increased ALT activity. Creatine kinase (CK) activity was only assessed in one dog at presentation, and was moderately elevated (1,815 U/L); in this patient, alanine transaminase (ALT) activity was within the RI, and aspartate aminotransferase activity was not determined. A repeat CK measurement was made subsequently, with a marked elevation (16,882 U/L) 24 hours after presentation, although seizure activity may have contributed to this increase.

Table 2

Hematology-, biochemistry-, and coagulation-profile results

Analyte	Case 1	Case 2	Case 3	Case 4	Reference interval
Urea (mmol/L)	WRI	29	Not done	9.1	2.5–9.6
Creatinine (μmol/L)	WRI	172	Not done	204	44–159
Inorganic phosphorus (mmol/L)	0.29	3.05	Not done	0.56	0.81–2.2
Alkaline phosphatase activity (U/L)	WRI	208	Not done	87	23–212
γ-Glutamyltransferase activity (U/L)	WRI	13	Not done	2	0–7
Total bilirubin (μmol/L)	WRI	16	Not done	8	0–15
Alanine aminotransferase activity (U/L)	WRI	NA	Not done	65	10–100
Alanine aminotransferase during hospitalization (U/L)	WRI	NA	Not done	77562558	10–100
Creatine kinase activity (U/L)	NA	NA	Not done	1,815	10–200
Creatine kinase activity during hospitalization (U/L)	NA	NA	Not done	16,8827,5441,37977	10–200
Lactate (mmol/L)	Not done	Not done	Not done	2.7	<3
Total plasma protein (g/L)	WRI	70	Not done	73	52–82
Hematocrit (%)	WRI	67	Not done	55	37–61
Platelet count (× 109/L)	WRI	20	Not done	264	148–484
aPTT (seconds)	89	>300 seconds	Not done	96	72–102
aPTT during hospitalization (seconds)	>300, 143, 109	Within reference interval (number not specified)	Not done	>300>300204106100110	72–102
PT (seconds)	19	>100	Not done	17	11–17
PT during hospitalization (seconds)	>100	19	Not done	>100>100>10071417	11–17

Abbreviations: aPTT, activated partial thromboplastin time; NA, not available; PT, prothrombin time; WRI, within reference interval (stated as such, but values not recorded).

Peripheral oxygen saturation determined using pulse oximetry was reduced (90% saturation, RI >93%) in the one dog so tested. In-house coagulation measurements were performed in three of four patients at presentation using an in-house Idexx Coag Dx analyzer. Prothrombin time (PT) was prolonged in two of four dogs, with values of 19 seconds and >100 seconds (RI 12–17 seconds). Activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT) was elevated in one of four dogs, with a value of >300 seconds. In one patient whose coagulation measurements were normal on presentation, PT and aPTT were prolonged to 100 seconds and >300 seconds, respectively, when retested 12 hours after presentation. In another dog whose coagulation times were mildly abnormal at presentation (PT 19 seconds, aPTT within the RI), PT and aPTT were >100 seconds and >300 seconds, respectively, when retested 12 hours after presentation.

Urinalysis was performed in three of four dogs, and results are summarized in Table 3. Hematuria was present in all cases tested. A snake venom-detection kit (BioSCL Pty Ltd, Melbourne, Australia) was used to assay urine collected within 24 hours of first clinical signs emerging in two of four dogs, both testing negative. In one of those dogs, it was performed twice at 12-hour intervals, both kits testing negative. A urine recreational drug-screening kit (Drug Alert®; Frostbland Pty Ltd, Sydney, Australia) capable of detecting amphetamines, barbiturates, benzodiazepines, cocaine, methamphetamine, methylenedioxymethamphetamine, morphine, methadone, opiates, phencyclidine, tricyclic antidepressants, and marijuana was performed in two dogs. Both tested negative.

Table 3

Urinalysis, urine-drug, and venom-screening test results

Test	Case 1	Case 2	Case 3	Case 4
Recreational drug-detection kit	Negative	Not done	Not done	Negative
Snake venom-detection kit	Negative on 2 tests	Not done	Not done	Negative
Blood (dipstick)	4+	4+	Not done	2+, 3+
Bilirubin (dipstick)	Negative	3+, 2+	Not done	Negative
pH (dipstick)	9	5, 7	Not done	6.5, 7
Glucose (dipstick)	Negative	Negative	Not done	Negative
Protein (dipstick)	Negative	Negative, trace	Not done	Negative
Ketones (dipstick)	Negative	Negative	Not done	Negative
Leukocytes (dipstick)	Negative	Negative	Not done	2+, 3+

A four-lead electrocardiogram was performed in one patient, demonstrating sinus tachycardia. Thoracic and abdominal imaging (either radiography and/or ultrasound examinations) were performed to screen for the presence of free abdominal fluid in two dogs. No fluid was evident in either case. Previous genetic testing revealed two dogs were polymerase chain reaction-negative for the phosphofructokinase deficiency variant known to occur in ESS, while the other two dogs (cases 1 and 2) were carriers for phosphofructokinase. These two dogs were neither more nor less affected by EIHS signs than the other two dogs.

Case 4 underwent additional genetic testing. Screening for the mutation in the DNM1-gene variant highly associated with exercise-induced collapse in Labrador retrievers was performed by the Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory, University of Minnesota, and proved to be negative.8 A genetic test for the RYR1V547A variant, associated with canine MH in a study by Roberts et al, was performed by Laboklin in the UK and tested as normal (wild type).9

Treatment, outcome, and necropsy findings

The management of the four cases is summarized in Table 4. Case 1 was treated with aggressive intravenous (IV) crystalloids (Hartmann’s solution), active cooling by hosing limbs using cold tap water, oxygen supplementation via a tight-fitting face mask, IV metronidazole, and sedation using IV acepromazine and IV butorphanol. The dog developed diarrhea, without hematochezia or melena. Hyperthermia resolved within 30 minutes of initiating treatment. Within 2 hours, the patient was ambulatory and had an improved demeanor. The dog subsequently developed a coagulopathy within 12 hours of presentation. Ongoing therapy included IV ticarcillin clavulanate, subcutaneous (SC) maropitant, four transfusions of fresh frozen plasma, IV esomeprazole and oral vitamin K1 supplementation. He recovered fully, and was discharged 72 hours after presentation.

Table 4

Treatment administered within first 48 hours of admission

Treatment	Case 1	Case 2	Case 3	Case 4
Methadone	No	Unknown	0.2 mg/kg IM	0.1 mg/kg IV PRN
Butorphanol	0.2 mg/kg IV	No	No	No
Active cooling	Hosing of pelvic limbs	No	No	No
Oxygen supplementation	Via face mask	No	No	No
IV fluids	Hartmann’s solution at 140 mL/h	Hartmann’s, unknown rate	Yes, unrecorded type and rate	Hartmann’s at 125 mL/h
Antimicrobials	Metronidazole, unknown dose IV every 12 hours; ticarcillin–clavulanic acid 50 mg/kg rate IV every 8 hours	Cefazolin, unrecorded dose IV; enrofloxacin 5 mg/kg IV	Metronidazole, unknown dose IV; amoxicillin–clavulanic acid unknown dose SC	Metronidazole 10 mg/kg IV every 12 hours; ampicillin 20 mg/kg IV every 8 hours
Vitamin K	2.5 mg/kg PO	Yes, but dose and route of administration unrecorded	No	2.5 mg/kg SC
Fresh frozen plasma transfusion	4 units	No	No	2 units
Other	Maropitant 1 mg/kg SC every 24 hours; esomeprazole 0.7 mg/kg IV every 24 hours	Dexamethasone 0.25 mg/kg SC	NA	Levetiracetam 16 mg/kg IV every 8 hours; esomeprazole 1 mg/kg IV every 24 hours; maropitant 1 mg/kg IV every 24 hours; metoclopramide 1 mg/kg/day IV; sucralfate 1 g PO every 12 hours

Abbreviations: IM, intramuscular; IV, intravenous; NA, not applicable; PO, per os (by mouth); PRN, pro re nata (as needed); SC, subcutaneous.

Case 2 was treated with vitamin K, IV crystalloids, a single injection of dexamethasone sodium phosphate, IV cefazolin, and IV enrofloxacin at the primary veterinary clinic and then referred to a veterinary specialist center. Vitamin K1 supplementation was continued, together with a unit of frozen plasma, IV maropitant, and IV ampicillin. The patient developed profuse salivation and diarrhea with melena. He made a full recovery, and was discharged 48 hours after presentation.

Case 3 developed vomiting, diarrhea, hematochezia, and melena. He was treated with IV crystalloids (Hartmann’s solution), SC amoxicillin–clavulanic acid, IV metronidazole, and intramuscular (IM) methadone. The following day, the patient remained recumbent, but was responsive. He continued to have hemorrhagic diarrhea and developed petechiation, although further laboratory assessment of hemostasis was not undertaken. He suffered a cardiac arrest, and resuscitation attempts were unsuccessful. Necropsy examination and histological examination of tissues collected postmortem showed accelerated autolytic changes and mild neutrophilic mucosal infiltration of the small bowel, plus loss of mucosal epithelium associated with severe acute hemorrhage into the intestinal lumen. There was also severe acute hemorrhage in multiple other organs, particularly the lungs, stomach, and liver. There was no definitive histological evidence for a specific causation, and no evidence of a preexisting pathological process that might have accounted for this etiopathogenesis. Thrombosis of large or small vessels, consistent with disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC), was not apparent.

Case 4 was treated with IV crystalloids, SC vitamin K1, IV maropitant, IV metronidazole, IV ampicillin, IV esomeprazole, IV levetiracetam, oral sucralfate, and 2 units of fresh frozen plasma. He developed hematochezia, melena, diarrhea, and vomiting with hematemesis. He was discharged 3 days after presentation, with complete resolution of all clinical signs.

Familial occurrence

Pedigree information was available for all four dogs and eleven related dogs (Figure 1A). The genetic relationship between the four affected dogs and 37 additional related individuals is presented in Figure 1. Two dogs were siblings. All four dogs were closely related, with a common grandsire from generation I (Figure 1A). Additional investigation beyond additional pedigree analysis into affected and unaffected litter-mates and related dogs was recommended but declined. There is no known history of any other related dogs or related dogs being affected by this type of clinical scenario. From pedigree observation, recessive sex-linked genetic transmission was hypothesized (Figure 1B), although an autosomal-recessive mode of inheritance cannot be excluded. Blood (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid [EDTA]-anticoagulated and frozen) from the surviving dogs and tissue blocks from the dog that died have been archived for planned genetic investigations.

Figure 1

Multigenerational pedigree representing affected males segregating for canine stress syndrome.

Notes: Circles represent female and squares represent males. Solid symbols represent the affected dogs included in the study. (A) Pedigree representing the relationship between the four affected males and 37 additional related individuals. (B) Pedigree hypothesizing the inheritance of the disease allele under a recessive X-linked transmission. Half-filled circles represent the hypothesized inheritance of mutated allele from the maternal side.

Discussion

The objective of this study was to further define EIHS/CSS in a kindred of ESS dogs and to attempt to determine if there was an identifiable mechanism for genetic inheritance. To summarize the clinical findings, all dogs developed broadly similar signs in response to mild-to-moderate exercise. The dogs were housed separately and developed EIHS/CSS under different specific circumstances, suggesting that the syndrome was not related to some common environmental circumstance or toxicant. Apart from moderate exertion, no other triggers were identified. The dogs were closely related intact males, including two littermates. This raises the possibility that the predisposition to the development of this syndrome is inherited more likely as a recessive sex-linked trait or less likely as an autosomal-recessive condition, as the chance of an autosomal trait affecting four of four male dogs would be 6%. If consideration is made of the previous ESS reported from Canada, also of male sex, then the likelihood of sex-linked inheritance is even higher.6 Analysis of the genetic relationship between the four affected dogs from Australia for which we have a pedigree is consistent with sex-linked inheritance, although at this stage in our investigations autosomal-recessive transmission cannot be completely excluded (Figure 1). Further observations and studies should be able to establish whether all putative carrier females have a common female ancestor, consistent with sex-linked inheritance. The presence of four cases from Australia and one from Canada suggested the causal gene is likely to be well dispersed among the ESS population worldwide.

In human medicine, the variability of presentation of MH has resulted in it being considered a syndrome, rather than a single disease.3 This syndrome results from the breakdown of the calcium-sequestration mechanism in the sarcoplasmic reticulum of skeletal muscle. Multiple genetic and environmental factors affect the way the disease is expressed phenotypically.2,3 In man, susceptibility to MH is often inherited as an autosomal-dominant disorder, for which there are at least six genetic loci of interest, most prominently RYR1.10,11 MH susceptibility is also phenotypically and genetically related to central core disease, an autosomal-dominant disorder characterized both by MH signs and myopathy. Most people with MH susceptibility have few or no symptoms or signs unless they are exposed to a triggering agent, and the same is true of the equivalent disease in pigs.1,12 The most common triggering agents are volatile anesthetic gases or depolarizing muscle relaxants. In rare cases, the biological stresses of physical exercise or heat may act as the trigger.1,2,13

There is a limited veterinary literature suggesting that abnormal calcium release from the sarcoplasmic reticulum of skeletal muscle can be triggered by exercise or stress in dogs with a particular genetic background, just as multiple triggers for the syndrome’s expression exist in the pig.5 This EIH or CSS has been reported previously in an ESS and a greyhound, and there are anecdotal reports of further cases.6,7

The seminal report of exercise-induced MH in an ESS was described by Rand and O’Brien.6 The dog was 2 years of age and male, comparable to the dogs of the present study. In this report, there was increased erythrocyte osmotic fragility, hypercontracted muscle fibers, and muscle fasciculations after inhalation of halothane, consistent with MH. The dog also demonstrated muscular hypersensitivity to caffeine, a more definitive diagnostic in vitro test for MH. However, prophylactic administration of dantrolene (a drug that specifically blocks Ca2+ release from the sarcoplasmic reticulum) did not prevent EIH in this individual. The authors referred to this presentation as “aborted malignant hyperthermia reaction”, a “malignant hyperthermia-like reversible syndrome”, or “canine stress syndrome”, and it seems likely that whatever the condition is called, the four dogs we report here were afflicted by the same entity.

Three of the cases described occurred independently, without awareness of similar clinical signs in other affected dogs. The final case (case 4) presented to the primary author after she had the opportunity of reviewing the case notes of the three previous cases. Based on this characteristic “illness script” or anchoring heuristic (ie, true anchor), EIHS/CSS was considered the most likely diagnostic possibility.14–16 This logical shortcut facilitated the rapid selection of appropriate diagnostic tests and a cogent targeted treatment regimen. Unfortunately, additional investigations specific to MH were not undertaken, as the caffeine contracture test is invasive and thus expensive (as it requires collection of a muscle biopsy under general anesthesia, plus the costs of testing at a specialist human laboratory), and the halothane-challenge test was considered an unacceptable risk to the patient, especially as IV dantrolene was not readily available. It would be ideal, however, if such tests were undertaken, and supplemented by the full range of histochemical tests on fresh frozen muscle biopsies at a specialist laboratory, possibly including transmission electron microscopy.

In all four ESS dogs, it was thought that the clinical changes induced by exercise were considerably disproportionate to the intensity of the effort, even when factoring in additional elements, such as environmental temperature, humidity, and the like. As a result, our speculation was that these dogs likely: 1) had an underlying myopathy with the potential to cause EIH, yet not sufficiently severe to meet the stringent criteria for classic MH; that 2) hyperthermia and or changes in skeletal muscle somehow gave rise to secondary disease processes, in which a DIC-like consumptive coagulopathy was prominent; and 3) this in turn resulted in gastrointestinal ischemia, diarrhea with or without blood loss into the gut lumen, and seizures. The delayed elevation of CK activity in one patient (case 4) provides supporting evidence for a primary myopathic process, possibly with a component of reperfusion injury (consistent with the observed delay in increased CK activity in serum), with a secondary cascade of changes (perhaps triggered by hyperthermia or key molecules released from affected myofibers) impacting on numerous body systems. However, CK elevation can be associated with muscle damage, and may not be associated with primary muscle disease. Therefore, the cause of the increase in CK from 1,815 U/L before the seizure to 16,882 U/L after the seizure may have been multifactorial. A weakness of the present case studies was absence of serial determinations of CK activity and urinary myoglobin, initially at presentation and subsequently. CK activity was not determined in the remaining dogs, as they were seen as emergencies, and this enzyme is not typically included in the cassettes and panels used for routine in-house biochemistry testing in the respective emergency facilities. Delayed disease features, such as coagulopathy and consumptive thrombocytopenia, provide circumstantial evidence for such a pathophysiologic chronology. The reason for ancillary testing for snake envenomation in many cases with coagulopathy reflects the importance of this entity in Australia (ie, availability heuristic), while the commonness of anticoagulant rodenticide poisoning explains the frequency with which vitamin K1 was administered “just in case”.14 The reason for hematuria perhaps reflected the generalized tendency to bleed and a leaky glomerular barrier.

There may be some similarities with exercise-induced rhabdomyolysis syndromes, which have limited representation in the veterinary literature, but are more widely reported in human and horses. Hematuria, however, was documented in case 4, rather than myoglobinuria, and what is important in the dogs investigated in this study is the exercise was not considered to be extreme or excessive either immediately prior to or in the 24 hours preceding the development of signs. All four dogs were considered fit, and exercised regularly. Most of the exercise-induced inherited metabolic myopathies in people result in rhabdomyolysis and myoglobinuria.15 However, in people with MH, myoglobinuria typically occurs only in the most severe cases.15

The University of Cambridge Veterinary School’s Inherited Diseases in Dogs Database lists MH in ESSs as being of unknown inheritance. It is pertinent that all four cases of the present report and the earlier case from Canada occurred in ESS dogs. Furthermore, the four affected dogs were all male. All four dogs had a common grandsire, which would be spurious if the inheritance was indeed sex-linked, as of the sex chromosomes, only the Y chromosome is transmitted from sires to male offspring. Given the close familial relationship of these breeds, provocative testing of putative female carriers as well as affected dogs would seem compelling, if possible. Obtaining DNA specimens (via EDTA blood or cheek swabs) from all affected and closely related dogs would seem logical, with a view to either: 1) sample as many individuals from the pedigree as possible and utilize the canine single-nucleotide polymorphism chip to perform a genome-wide association scan to localize the trait to a chromosomal region (perhaps on the X chromosome) and scan for candidate genes or 2) obtain whole-genome sequences for a “trio” consisting of one affected male dog, an unaffected female sibling (such as an older sibling known to have been subjected to heavy exercise and/or thermal stress without developing any signs), and one parent (dam or sire).

The test for the RYR1-gene variant associated with canine MH was negative in case 4. This specific mutation was identified by Roberts et al, and results in autosomal-dominant canine MH, the gene encoding the skeletal muscle calcium-release channel (RYR1).9 Historically, researchers interested in the molecular basis for canine MH established a breeding colony starting with a mixed-breed male dog that had survived an in vivo halothane–succinylcholine challenge. However, one of the contributing authors of the aforementioned paper from the Department of Veterinary Biomedical Sciences, University of Minnesota indicated the search for that specific canine variant had stopped, since they never found another dog with that mutation in over 24 subsequent tests (J Mickelson, personal communication).

Case 4 was negative when tested for the DMN1-gene variant associated with exercise-induced collapse in Labradors.8 In this syndrome, dogs develop an abnormal gait, tachycardia, and significant respiratory alkalosis after exercise. However, cases of EIC have not yet been described as having other systemic signs, such as coagulopathy.

Future investigation of the EIHS/CSS phenotype would include detailed assessment of well-characterized canine patients, serial determination of CK activity (and also ALT and aspartate aminotransferase activities) during an attack, and also (after vigorous exercise or thermal stress) conducting electrodiagnostic studies under general anesthesia in an attempt to detect a cryptic myopathy, obtaining fresh and fixed muscle-biopsy specimens for detailed histological and ultrastructural investigations, again in the search of a myopathy predisposing to MH or an MH-like episode, and archiving DNA from all affected dogs, their normal siblings, and parents, to permit future molecular investigations harnessing the power of modern canine genomics. In a study by O’Brien et al, erythrocyte osmotic fragility and CK tests did not distinguish between what they termed a “malignant-hyperthermia” dog and healthy control dogs.4

The lack of muscle biopsies in these cases reflects the limitation of a retrospective study. Postexercise lactate and pyruvate levels were not determined, and such measurements may have been useful in characterizing the cause if myopathy was the primary underlying condition. However, a serum lactate determination was in the RI in case 4 within 24 hours of presentation.

None of the four cases had a measured core body temperature that one would have expected to cause DIC or any other of the sequelae associated with heatstroke. Normal dogs can have a body temperature greater than 41°C with strenuous exercise.17 However, rectal temperature at the time of exercise intolerance was never recorded, and all cases had some delay prior to seeking veterinary attention.

Once the genetic variant is characterized, a simple polymerase chain reaction test can be developed and used to screen the entire ESS breed worldwide and exclude carriers from the breeding program. This should enable the detection of both carriers and dogs at risk for EIHS/CSS. In addition, it might represent an interesting model for some corresponding human disease state. Ultimately, the greatest value in developing such a test is for detecting dogs that might potentially be subjected to stressful triggers, which might then give rise to a life-threatening crisis. Identified dogs can then be appropriately monitored.

Despite one of the four dogs dying in this study, dogs suffering from EIHS/CSS can make a speedy recovery if given aggressive supportive therapy (often with the requirement for fresh frozen plasma). Indeed, the severity of the disease and rapid turnaround with timely supportive therapy appear to be distinguishing features of this entity. Awareness of the features of this syndrome that develop after presentation, such as coagulopathy, signaling the requirement for fresh frozen plasma or even fresh whole blood, will likely improve survival of affected dogs.

Conclusion

This study analyzed the potential for inheritance of suspected CSS in the ESS breed, due to the similar presentation of four young male ESSs, as well as describing the clinical syndrome of CSS, with discussion of the pertinent yet limited veterinary literature concerning CSS. Common causes of exercise intolerance were eliminated in the cases included in the study, but the exact cause is yet to be determined. This study provides evidence that the mode of inheritance is more likely X-linked and unlikely (although possible) to be autosomal-recessive. Further genetic characterization and testing should be strongly considered by those involved with the ESS breed. Identification of this syndrome may allow for closer observation of related dogs that may have a genetic predisposition for this disease but remain asymptomatic, as well as identifying any possible triggers that precipitate clinical signs.