Manuel Souto1, Jorge Romero1, Joaquín Calbo2, Iñigo J Vitórica-Yrezábal3, José L Zafra4, Juan Casado4, Enrique Ortí1, Aron Walsh2,5, Guillermo Mínguez Espallargas1. 1. Instituto de Ciencia Molecular (ICMol) , Universidad de Valencia , c/Catedrático José Beltrán, 2 , 46980 Paterna , Spain. 2. Department of Materials , Imperial College London , London SW7 2AZ , United Kingdom. 3. School of Chemistry , University of Manchester , Oxford Road , Manchester M13 9PL , United Kingdom. 4. Departamento de Química Física , Universidad de Málaga , 29071 Málaga , Spain. 5. Department of Materials Science and Engineering , Yonsei University , Seoul 03722 , Korea.
Abstract
"Breathing" metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) that involve changes in their structural and physical properties upon an external stimulus are an interesting class of crystalline materials due to their range of potential applications including chemical sensors. The addition of redox activity opens up a new pathway for multifunctional "breathing" frameworks. Herein, we report the continuous breathing behavior of a tetrathiafulvalene (TTF)-based MOF, namely MUV-2, showing a reversible swelling (up to ca. 40% of the volume cell) upon solvent adsorption. Importantly, the planarity of the TTF linkers is influenced by the breathing behavior of the MOF, directly impacting on its electrochemical properties and thus opening the way for the development of new electrochemical sensors. Quantum chemical calculations and Raman spectroscopy have been used to provide insights into the tunability of the oxidation potential.
"Breathing" metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) that involve changes in their structural and physical properties upon an external stimulus are an interesting class of crystalline materials due to their range of potential applications including chemical sensors. The addition of redox activity opens up a new pathway for multifunctional "breathing" frameworks. Herein, we report the continuous breathing behavior of a tetrathiafulvalene (TTF)-based MOF, namely MUV-2, showing a reversible swelling (up to ca. 40% of the volume cell) upon solvent adsorption. Importantly, the planarity of the TTF linkers is influenced by the breathing behavior of the MOF, directly impacting on its electrochemical properties and thus opening the way for the development of new electrochemical sensors. Quantum chemical calculations and Raman spectroscopy have been used to provide insights into the tunability of the oxidation potential.
Metal–organic
frameworks (MOFs) are crystalline porous materials
formed by inorganic building units and organic linkers that find several
applications such as gas storage and separation, sensing, and catalysis.[1] Although chemical makeup and robustness of MOFs
have been key features in terms of possible industrial applications,
during the past years there has been a growing interest in the design
of flexible MOFs which undergo structural changes upon exposure to
physical or chemical stimuli.[2−4] However, among the ∼70000
MOFs reported to date, only ∼100 exhibit flexible or “breathing”
behavior in response to an external stimulus.[3,5,6] Typically, the reversible transformations
in flexible MOFs occur through well-defined phase transitions between
wide-pore and narrow-pore forms, as exemplified by the case of MIL-53.[7,8] On the contrary, MOFs exhibiting large flexibility without well-defined
transitions are extremely rare.[5] This behavior
is known as continuous breathing or “swelling”, and
the prototypical example of such behavior is the family of MIL-88.[9,10] In both MIL-53 and MIL-88, the breathing behavior is driven by the
rotation of the linkers with respect to the inorganic secondary building
units (SBUs) based on a “kneecap” mechanism. However,
there are not many examples in which the breathing motion is based
on the flexibility of the ligand.[11,12]Breathing
MOFs are even more interesting if they are able to tune
the physical properties upon structural changes since they could be
exploited for sensing or chemical-reporting applications. Recently,
Farha and co-workers presented a Zr-based breathing MOF with flexible
pyrene ligands where the linker conformational modifications are reflected
in changes in its optical properties.[12]On the other hand, redox-active MOFs[13] have attracted a great deal of attention due to their potential
application in electrocatalysis,[14] electrochromic
devices,[15] conductors,[16] and switches.[17] In particular,
tetrathiafulvalene (TTF)-based MOFs are promising systems for the
development of multifunctional materials due to the intrinsically
redox, electron-donor, and conducting properties of the TTF ligand.[18−21] Along this line, Zhou and co-workers have demonstrated the reversible
modulation of the breathing behavior of a TTF-based MOF upon oxidation
and reduction of the TTF through modification of the linker’s
flexibility.[22]Very recently, we
have reported a highly stable and TTF-based MOF,
namely MUV-2 (MUV: Materials of University of Valencia),
which shows a hierarchical crystal structure with mesoporous one-dimensional
channels and orthogonal microporous channels.[23] This hierarchical MOF, based on 6-connected [Fe3(μ3O)(COO)6] SBUs and tetratopic tetrathiafulvalene
tetrabenzoic (TTFTB4–) ligands, shows high thermal
and chemical stability, and has proven to be an efficient catalyst
for the aerobic oxidation of dibenzothiophenes.Herein, we report
on the continuous breathing behavior of MUV-2 upon solvent
adsorption by exploiting the flexibility
of the boat-shaped TTFTB ligand (Figure ). The reversible swelling of ca. 40% was
studied in terms of cell dimensions between four different crystal
structures of MUV-2(, where X = 29, 31, 33, and 35, which were determined by single-crystal
X-ray diffraction as well as by the effect of different solvents on
the framework by powder X-ray diffraction. Interestingly, the cell
volume of the crystal structures is directly related to the degree
of bending or planarity of the TTFTB ligands. Otherwise, the dihedral
angles of the TTFTB linkers have a direct influence on the ionization
energy of the molecules and, therefore, on the oxidation potential
of MUV-2, as confirmed by quantum chemical calculations
of the energy associated with electron removal. The tunability of
the electrochemical properties of MUV-2 based on the
breathing behavior has been demonstrated to have potential application
as an electrochemical sensor. This is the first example of how the
breathing behavior promoted by guest inclusion and based on a flexible
ligand can modulate the redox properties of a MOF.
Figure 1
Schematic representation
of the breathing behavior of MUV-2 upon solvent adsorption.
Schematic representation
of the breathing behavior of MUV-2 upon solvent adsorption.
Results and Discussion
X-ray Diffraction Analysis
MUV-2 was synthesized,
washed, and characterized as previously
described.[23] Single-crystal X-ray diffraction
data were collected at the I19 beamline facilities at Diamond Light
Source (UK) that were used to determine four different isolated phases
of MUV-2 during the breathing motion (see the Supporting Information). As previously reported,[23] the MUV-2 crystal structure is
hexagonal (space group P-62m) and,
on the basis of the connection of six Fe3O(COO)6 SBUs and tetratopic TTFTB ligands, it can be simplified as a 3,6-connected
network with ttp topology.[24] This non-interpenetrated
structure shows hexagonal mesoporous channels of ca. 3 nm in diameter
along the c-axis direction formed by 6 TTFTB linkers
and 6 SBUs (Figure ). On the other hand, microporous channels of ca. 1 nm formed by
2 TTFTB ligands and 2 SBUs are disposed orthogonal to the mesoporous
ones.
Figure 2
Overview of the crystal structure of MUV-2 showing
the hexagonal mesoporous channels along the c-axis
(top) and microporous channels orthogonal to the microporous ones
(bottom). The gray, yellow, red, and orange balls represent the C,
S, O, and Fe atoms, respectively. For simplicity, hydrogens are omitted.
Overview of the crystal structure of MUV-2 showing
the hexagonal mesoporous channels along the c-axis
(top) and microporous channels orthogonal to the microporous ones
(bottom). The gray, yellow, red, and orange balls represent the C,
S, O, and Fe atoms, respectively. For simplicity, hydrogens are omitted.The breathing behavior of MUV-2 was studied in terms
of four isolated crystal structures determined by single-crystal X-ray
diffraction using synchrotron radiation, denoted as MUV-2(29, 31, 33, and 35) in accordance
with the a and b unit cell parameters
(Figure ). The crystal
structure of MUV-2 is contracted and expanded through
the ab plane, whereas the c cell
parameter remains almost unaltered, retaining in all four structures
the same symmetry (hexagonal) and space group (P-62m). The as-synthesized structure, MUV-2(33) (Figure c), shows
a significant contraction upon drying treatment, providing the narrowest
form, namely MUV-2(29) (Figure a). Upon adsorption of different solvents,
the unit cell gradually increases, obtaining intermediate crystal
structures such as MUV-2(31) (Figure b). The largest unit cell is observed using
pyridine as guest, producing MUV-2(35) (Figure d), in which three pyridines
molecules are coordinated to the Fe3O(COO)6 SBU
replacing the three H2O molecules. The reversible continuous
breathing behavior through the ab plane is based
on the flexibility of the TTFTB ligands, becoming much more planar
upon solvent adsorption, and also on the partial rotation of the Fe3O(COO)6 SBUs. The shape of the pore changes from
a triangle in MUV-2(29) to a hexagon in MUV-2(35), with a significant change of the distance between the calculated
centroid of the C=C central bond of adjacent TTFs (16.7 vs
29.5 Å, respectively) (Figure ) and a total expansion of ca. 40% in the crystal structure
volume (9427 vs 13163 Å3).
Figure 3
Crystal view of the pore
opening evolution of (a) MUV-2(29) (a = b = 29.4 Å; c = 12.5 Å),
(b) MUV-2(31) (a = b = 31.9 Å; c = 12.5 Å),
(c) MUV-2(33) (a = b = 33.3 Å; c = 12.4 Å), and (d) MUV-2(35) (a = b = 35.4
Å; c = 12.1 Å) forms. The gray, yellow,
red, orange, and blue ellipsoids represent the C, S, O, Fe, and N
atoms, respectively. For simplicity, hydrogens are omitted.
Crystal view of the pore
opening evolution of (a) MUV-2(29) (a = b = 29.4 Å; c = 12.5 Å),
(b) MUV-2(31) (a = b = 31.9 Å; c = 12.5 Å),
(c) MUV-2(33) (a = b = 33.3 Å; c = 12.4 Å), and (d) MUV-2(35) (a = b = 35.4
Å; c = 12.1 Å) forms. The gray, yellow,
red, orange, and blue ellipsoids represent the C, S, O, Fe, and N
atoms, respectively. For simplicity, hydrogens are omitted.According to the single-crystal
structures, the reversible expansion
and contraction of ∼40% between MUV-2(29) and MUV-2(35) occurs primarily through the ab plane. This reversible expansion and contraction can also be observed
using an optical microscope by exposing few desolvated single crystals
of MUV-2(29) to pyridine solvent (Figure S2). The exposure of the single crystals to pyridine
produces a reversible expansion between 20 and 30% of the width of
the crystal, in agreement with the crystal indexing, which reveals
that mesoporous channels are oriented along the length of the crystal
(Figure S3). After evaporation of the pyridine
solvent, the crystals recover the initial dimensions.The evolution
of the planarity of the TTFTB linker with the breathing
behavior was analyzed by means of the dihedral angle (θ) formed
by the two dithiole rings (planes S1–C1–C2–S2
and S3–C5–C6–S4) in the different crystal structures.
The angles were found to be 69°, 54°, 41°, and 9°
for MUV-2(29), MUV-2(31), MUV-2(33), and MUV-2(35), respectively (Figures and S4). Moreover,
the torsion angles of S2–C3–S1–C1, which are
also related to the degree of planarity of the TTF,[25] decreased when the cell volume was increased, with
values of 32°, 26°, 17°, and 14°, respectively.
Figure 4
Partial
views of the TTFTB ligand for the crystal structures of
(a) MUV-2(29), (b) MUV-2(31), (c) MUV-2(33), and (d) MUV-2(35) highlighting the
dihedral angles between the planes formed by the two dithiole rings
(θ = 69°, 54°, 41°, and 9°, respectively).
Partial
views of the TTFTB ligand for the crystal structures of
(a) MUV-2(29), (b) MUV-2(31), (c) MUV-2(33), and (d) MUV-2(35) highlighting the
dihedral angles between the planes formed by the two dithiole rings
(θ = 69°, 54°, 41°, and 9°, respectively).
Breathing
Behavior upon Solvent Adsorption
The powder X-ray diffraction
(PXRD) pattern of the activated material
shows that the (100) peak appears at 2θ = 3.45° after solvent
removal, in agreement with the contracted MUV-2(29) crystal
structure. This peak shifts toward lower degrees after MUV-2(29) is soaked with different solvents during 24 h (Figure ). As also observed in MIL-88,[9,10] the breathing behavior is very selective, and the pore opening depends
on the nature of the solvent. Strongly polar solvents such as pyridine,
which is coordinated to the Fe3O(COO)6 SBU replacing
the water molecules, generate the largest pore opening with a PXRD
pattern similar to the one simulated from the crystal structure of MUV-2(35). Otherwise, exposure to ethanol, water, toluene,
and acetonitrile yields intermediate cell variations with PXRD patterns
similar to the ones simulated from MUV-2(33) and MUV-2(31) crystal structures, thus showing a continuous breathing
behavior. Interestingly, PXRD patterns with ethanol, water, and toluene
show the presence of two principal peaks, which can be related to
a decrease of symmetry. The different breathing behavior of the solvents
can be explained by the coordination of the polar organic solvent
molecules with the inorganic Fe3O(COO)6 SBUs
(as observed in the case of pyridine) or by weak interactions with
the organic linkers, a behavior which is similar to that of the MIL-88
family.[9,10] Moreover, the reversible swelling of MUV-2(35) was confirmed by heating the soaked material with
pyridine obtaining the initial desolvated PXRD pattern (Figure S5). It is important to note that the
EPR spectra of MUV-2 in the different solvents do not
show the presence of any signal related to TTFTB•+ radical cation, indicating that the TTFTB moieties remain in
the neutral state (Figure S6). Moreover,
thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of MUV-2 in different
solvents was performed to determine the amounts of solvent molecules
included in the pores in each case (Figure S7).
Figure 5
Evolution of PXRD patterns for MUV-2 after soaking
with various solvents at room temperature. Simulated diffraction patterns
of MUV-2(29), MUV-2(31), MUV-2(33), and MUV-2(35).
Evolution of PXRD patterns for MUV-2 after soaking
with various solvents at room temperature. Simulated diffraction patterns
of MUV-2(29), MUV-2(31), MUV-2(33), and MUV-2(35).
Quantum-Chemical Calculations
Based
on the significant conformational changes of the TTF moiety observed
in the different crystal structures, we aimed to analyze the impact
of the TTF curvature on the electronic structure and redox properties
of MUV-2. First, the minimum-energy structure of MUV-2 was obtained upon full ion and lattice relaxation under
the density functional theory framework. The range-separated hybrid
exchange-correlation HSE06 functional was employed along with the
“Tier 1” numerical basis set using the FHI-AIMS package[26−28] (see the SI for full computational details).
A high-spin configuration for the Fe atoms was adopted in line with
the experimental evidence.[23] The optimized
structure of MUV-2 (Figure S8) compares well with the X-ray structure of as-synthetized MUV-2(33) and provides optimized lattice parameters of a = 34.03 Å, b = 34.06 Å, c = 12.15 Å, α = 90.4°, β = 89.5°,
γ = 120.2°, a TTF boat dihedral angle of θ = 46.24°,
and a pore opening (distance between centroid of the C=C central
bond of adjacent TTFs) of 23.95 Å. Note that substitution of
the two coordinating water molecules by acetonitrile or pyridine barely
affects the TTF tilting, with a boat dihedral angle θ of 44.82
and 45.53°, respectively (Figure S9). The breathing behavior of MUV-2 must therefore be
originated from long-range electrostatic effects (solvent polarity)
and/or medium-range electron correlation effects (noncovalent interactions).[10]Analysis of the electronic density of
states (DoS) indicates a small bandgap of 0.86 eV originated in the
β-spin manifold (Figure a). Projected DoS (PDoS) allows unequivocal assignment of
the frontier crystal orbitals (FCOs): the highest occupied crystal
orbital (HOCO) belongs to the organic TTF ligand, whereas the lowest
unoccupied crystal orbital (LUCO) is localized in the inorganic cluster
(Figures a and S10). Visualization of the electronic eigenstate
densities confirmed the nature of the FCOs with a HOCO (Figure b) analogous to the highest
occupied molecular orbital of TTF (Figure S11) and a d-orbital HUCO localized on the Fe atoms
(Figure c). These
results suggest that reduction of the MOF must occur in the inorganic
cluster, whereas oxidation processes will be centered in the TTF-based
ligand. The spin density of the MUV-2 oxidized by one-electron
per TTFTB ligand (unit cell with three positive charges) confirmed
the electron density extraction from the TTF moiety upon oxidation
(Figure S12).
Figure 6
(a) Electronic density
of states (DoS) calculated at the DFT-HSE06
level of theory for the optimized geometry of MUV-2.
The highest occupied state (EF) is set
to 0 eV. Spin-up (up) and spin-down (dn) are differentiated with opposite
signs. The contribution of the ligand atoms to the DoS is included.
(b, c) Eigenstate densities (isovalue = 0.001) for the HOCO and LUCO,
respectively, of the β-spin channel.
(a) Electronic density
of states (DoS) calculated at the DFT-HSE06
level of theory for the optimized geometry of MUV-2.
The highest occupied state (EF) is set
to 0 eV. Spin-up (up) and spin-down (dn) are differentiated with opposite
signs. The contribution of the ligand atoms to the DoS is included.
(b, c) Eigenstate densities (isovalue = 0.001) for the HOCO and LUCO,
respectively, of the β-spin channel.To analyze the impact of the breathing motion into the electrochemical
properties of MUV-2, experimental X-ray crystal structures
were further employed to achieve geometries with variable TTF curvature
(see the SI). The schematic representation
of the FCOs versus the characteristic TTF boat dihedral angle θ
shows a significant stabilization of 0.41 eV for the TTF-centered
HOCO going from θ = 30.87° to 66.11° (Figure ). This stabilization has already
been reported in molecular systems containing the TTF unit, and is
ascribed to an inefficient 6π-electron delocalization that disrupts
its donor ability upon deviation from planarity.[29−31] Otherwise,
the Fe-centered LUCO remains practically unaffected upon TTF bending,
with an energy range of [−4.30, −4.40] eV. As a result,
an increase of >0.3 eV in the electronic bandgap is predicted going
from MOF structures with a planar TTF to those with a highly curved
ligand (Figure ).
Figure 7
One-electron
energy diagram of the frontier crystal orbitals of MUV-2 with different values for the TTF boat dihedral angle
θ as defined in Figure . The electronic bandgap (in eV) for the extreme cases is
indicated. Dashed lines are included to guide the eye.
One-electron
energy diagram of the frontier crystal orbitals of MUV-2 with different values for the TTF boat dihedral angle
θ as defined in Figure . The electronic bandgap (in eV) for the extreme cases is
indicated. Dashed lines are included to guide the eye.We took advantage of the localized nature of the
HOCO into the
π-conjugated TTF core to analyze the electrochemical properties
of MUV-2 upon ligand bending by performing high-level
molecular calculations. The minimum-energy structure of the TTFTB
moiety in its neutral (fully protonated) form was obtained at the
DFT-PBE0/cc-pVDZ level of theory in the gas phase (Figure S11). Starting from this geometry, a relaxed scan was
performed at the same level by varying the characteristic TTF boat
dihedral angle. Theoretical calculations predict a small energy penalty
upon boat bending, with a large conformational space 0° <
θ < 80° accessible within 5 kcal/mol (Figure S17). Initial analysis of the molecular orbitals indicates
a significant stabilization of the TTF-centered highest occupied molecular
orbital (HOMO) upon bending (from −4.93 eV at θ = 4.84°
to −5.69 eV at θ = 87.34°; Table S4), in good accord with the solid-state calculations (Figure ).The first
ionization potential (IP) of the TTFTB ligand was then
calculated along the relaxed scan to estimate the effect of the breathing
motion into the oxidation potential of MUV-2 (see the SI). As shown in Figure , the IP of TTFTB monotonically decreases
upon planarization (6.60 eV at θ = 87.34° vs 6.08 eV at
θ = 37.61°). It is well-known that the TTF unit planarizes
upon one-electron oxidation.[32,33] However, the effect
in IP due to the strained rigidity of the ligand in MUV-2 is calculated to be only of 0.10 eV at the minimum-energy boat dihedral
angle θ = 35.72° (adiabatic IP = 5.97 eV). Further planarization
of the ligand leads to a small decrease of IP, with the lowest value
of 5.95 eV at θ = 4.84°. Theoretical calculations therefore
predict a significant change in the electrochemical properties of MUV-2 upon swelling, with a systematic increase in ease of
oxidation upon planarization of the TTFTB ligand.
Figure 8
Ionization potential
(IP) calculated for the TTFTB ligand molecule
from total energy differences at the DFT-PBE0/cc-pVDZ level of theory
as a function of the characteristic TTF boat dihedral angle θ.
The adiabatic IP calculated for TTFTB as shown as a red cross.
Ionization potential
(IP) calculated for the TTFTB ligand molecule
from total energy differences at the DFT-PBE0/cc-pVDZ level of theory
as a function of the characteristic TTF boat dihedral angle θ.
The adiabatic IP calculated for TTFTB as shown as a red cross.
Electrochemical
Properties
Encouraged
by the theoretical results demonstrating the influence of the breathing
motion on the electrochemical properties of MUV-2, solid-state
cyclic voltammetry (CV) and differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) of MUV-2 were performed in different solvents (Figure ). We have previously reported
the CV of MUV-2 in CH3CN up to 1.6 V (vs Ag/AgCl),
which showed a reversible redox peak attributed to the reduction process
of Fe3+/Fe2+ around −0.9 V, but no peak
related to the oxidation of the TTFTB linkers was observed.[23] Upon increasing the potential up to 3 V, the
CV of MUV-2 shows an irreversible redox peak at 2.2 V,
which can be attributed to the oxidation process of the TTFTB units
(Figures and S20). To investigate the relationship between
the Fe and TTFTB moieties, the Randles–Sevcik equation[34] was used to determine the Fe/TTFTB molar ratio,
which was found to have a value of 1.8. This value is close to the
formula of MUV-2 (two Fe3O SBUs per three
TTFTB linkers).
Figure 9
Solid-state cyclic voltammetry (CV) and differential pulse
voltammetry
(DPV) of MUV-2 in CH3CN (blue line), DMF (orange
line), and pyridine (red line) using TBAPF6 0.1 M as electrolyte
and 0.1 V/s scan rate. Platinum wire was used as the counter electrode
and silver wire as the pseudoreference electrode. Ferrocene was added
as internal standard. All potentials are reported versus Ag/AgCl.
Solid-state cyclic voltammetry (CV) and differential pulse
voltammetry
(DPV) of MUV-2 in CH3CN (blue line), DMF (orange
line), and pyridine (red line) using TBAPF6 0.1 M as electrolyte
and 0.1 V/s scan rate. Platinum wire was used as the counter electrode
and silver wire as the pseudoreference electrode. Ferrocene was added
as internal standard. All potentials are reported versus Ag/AgCl.The solid-state CV of MUV-2 in pyridine shows that
the formal redox potential assigned to the oxidation of TTFTB significantly
decreases, and two irreversible redox waves were observed at 1.02
and 1.16 V attributed to the two oxidation processes of TTFTB to TTFTB•+ and TTFTB2+, respectively (Figures and S20). These oxidation potentials are closer to those reported for other
TTF-based MOFs.[19] The decrease of the oxidation
potential of MUV-2 when using pyridine as solvent can
be explained by the increased planarity of the TTFTB linkers, which
significantly decreased the ionization potential as demonstrated by
the theoretical calculations. Interestingly, when using a solvent
such as DMF, which produces an intermediate degree of swelling and
planarity of the TTFTB ligands, the formal oxidation potential is
slightly higher than that in pyridine (1.40 V) (Figures and S21). Hence,
the electrochemical properties of MUV-2 can be modulated
by the solvent-induced breathing behavior.Based on the idea
that the electrochemical properties can be tuned
by the effect of the different solvents on the breathing behavior,
DPV measurements of MUV-2 in CH3CN were performed
in the range of 0–2.4 V after addition of consecutive aliquots
of pyridine (Figure ). The oxidation peak which initially appears at 2.2 V gradually
shifts toward lower potentials when pyridine is added, in agreement
with the lower ionization potential of MUV-2 when it
is soaked with pyridine due to planarization of the TTFTB linker.
After addition of 100 μL (1% v/v) and 300 μL (3% v/v)
of pyridine, the oxidation potential moves to 2.0 and 1.8 V, respectively.
Moreover, we also observe the appearance of new peaks in the range
of 1.0–1.5 V, which are close to the oxidation peak of MUV-2 using exclusively pyridine as solvent (Figure ). The presence
of numerous peaks indicates different degrees of breathing behavior
probably due to diffusion effects. In addition, CV measurements performing
the same procedure (Figure S23) also show
a gradual shift of the oxidation peak toward lower potential. Thus,
consecutive addition of pyridine induces the expansion toward MUV-2(35) form and the consequent planarization of TTFTB linkers
producing significant changes in its electrochemical response.
Figure 10
Differential
pulse voltammetry (DPV) of MUV-2 in CH3CN
after consecutive addition of aliquots of pyridine using
TBAPF6 0.1 M as electrolyte. Platinum wire was used as
the counter electrode and silver wire as the pseudoreference electrode.
Differential
pulse voltammetry (DPV) of MUV-2 in CH3CN
after consecutive addition of aliquots of pyridine using
TBAPF6 0.1 M as electrolyte. Platinum wire was used as
the counter electrode and silver wire as the pseudoreference electrode.Motivated by the idea of isolating
the oxidized MOF (ox-MUV-2) to study the pore opening
of the system, we oxidized MUV-2 deposited on the electrode
applying a constant potential (1.8 V
using DMF as solvent, or 1.1 V using pyridine as solvent). EPR spectra
demonstrate that the TTFTB linkers were oxidized to TTFTB•+ in agreement with the presence of the typical signal for the radical
cation species centered at g = 2.006 (Figure S25). However, the PXRD pattern shows
that crystallinity is decreased (Figure S26), and IR spectra suggest that some of the TTFTB linkers are uncoordinated
to the metal due to the presence of bands at 1691 cm–1 assigned to free C=O groups (Figure S27). This suggests that an irreversible decarboxylation upon oxidation
is produced related to the Kolbe reaction, as it has been observed
for other TTF-bearing carboxylic moieties.[35,36] Some electrochemical studies performed on different TTF-bearing
carboxylic acids suggest that a decarboxylation process occurs only
during the second oxidation step (the formation of the dication species),
which is irreversible.[37] In the case of MUV-2, it is not possible to control the oxidation up to the
radical cation state since the two oxidation peaks are very close.
Raman Spectroscopy
The vibrational
fingerprint of MUV-2 can provide structural information
on the dynamics and of the structural changes in the interior of the
pores under a variety of conditions.[38,39] Hence, a complete
study of the vibrational Raman properties of desolvated MUV-2, upon solvation with pyridine, acetonitrile, and DMF (py-MUV-2, ACN-MUV-2, and DMF-MUV-2) and electrochemically
oxidized (ox-MUV-2) has been carried out with two different
Raman laser excitation lines (633 and 785 nm, shown in Figure and Figure S28, respectively).
Figure 11
Raman spectra (633 nm) of desolvated MUV-2 (purple
line) and solvated with acetonitrile (blue line), DMF (orange line),
and pyridine (red line) and electrochemically oxidized ox-MUV-2 (black line) at 298 K in solid state. See Figure S29 for a larger spectral range.
Raman spectra (633 nm) of desolvated MUV-2 (purple
line) and solvated with acetonitrile (blue line), DMF (orange line),
and pyridine (red line) and electrochemically oxidized ox-MUV-2 (black line) at 298 K in solid state. See Figure S29 for a larger spectral range.The 785 and 633 nm Raman spectra of the desolvated sample
are dominated
by the presence of three main bands in the 1650–1400 cm–1 interval: the band at 1607 cm–1 (i.e., due to the C=C stretching vibration of the benzene
moieties), the band at 1540 cm–1 (i.e., assigned
to the C=C stretching mode of the TTF moiety), and the broad
band at 1413 cm–1 (i.e., arising from the stretching
modes of the carboxylate groups). See Figures S18 and S19 for the simulated Raman spectra. Importantly, the
relative Raman intensity pattern of these bands consists of the strongest
band at 1413 cm–1 followed by the band at 1607 cm–1 with medium intensity. In the case of the electrochemically
oxidized ox-MUV-2, the spectral intensity pattern in
the 1650–1400 cm–1 interval is reversed compared
with the unoxidized material, with the strongest feature now at 1607
cm–1 and those at 1440–1400 cm–1 as medium bands. In addition, two new weak bands appear at 1501
and 1438 cm–1, which are assigned to those Raman
modes in the oxidized TTF moiety that result from the frequency softening
of the C=C stretching modes upon oxidation of the TTF unit.Solvation causes structural changes that make their Raman spectra
resemble that of the oxidized material. This is inferred by the relative
intensity pattern of the bands at 1607 (strongest) and 1440–1400
cm–1 (medium), and by the appearance of new bands
at 1501 and 1440–1410 cm–1 in the solvated
samples in analogy with the Raman spectrum for ox-MUV-2. Since oxidation of TTF produces its backbone planarization, the
spectral similitude with the solvated materials indicates that solvation
also produces the planarization of the TTF unit of MUV-2. Looking more in detail to the 1440–1400 cm–1 region of the solvated samples, significant differences are found
between the spectra. Whereas four peaks are observed for py-MUV-2, a main band with two shoulders is resolved in ACN-MUV-2 (for DMF-MUV-2 the solvent bands prevent further comparisons).
It seems that the spectral changes in this region are less marked
for ACN-MUV-2 than for py-MUV-2 (one peak
in the former and four peaks in the latter), revealing that adsorption
of acetonitrile induces smaller changes in the Raman spectra. This
is in perfect agreement with the structural features obtained by X-ray
diffraction.
Conclusions
In summary,
we have reported the continuous breathing behavior
of a TTF-based MOF, namely MUV-2, which shows up to 40%
of a reversible expansion upon solvent adsorption. Interestingly,
the planarity of the TTF linkers is influenced by the breathing behavior
as demonstrated by single-crystal X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy.
Theoretical calculations show that the degree of planarity of the
TTF ligands has a direct influence on the electrochemical properties
and the tunability of the oxidation potential of MUV-2 upon adsorption of solvents. These results open the way to develop
new electrochemical sensors based on the breathing behavior and new
materials with pore opening control upon application of electrochemical
potential.
Authors: Pravas Deria; Diego A Gómez-Gualdrón; Wojciech Bury; Herbert T Schaef; Timothy C Wang; Praveen K Thallapally; Amy A Sarjeant; Randall Q Snurr; Joseph T Hupp; Omar K Farha Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2015-10-03 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Patricia Horcajada; Christian Serre; Guillaume Maurin; Naseem A Ramsahye; Francisco Balas; María Vallet-Regí; Muriel Sebban; Francis Taulelle; Gérard Férey Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2008-05-03 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Lucy E Darago; Michael L Aubrey; Chung Jui Yu; Miguel I Gonzalez; Jeffrey R Long Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2015-12-07 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Alexander E J Hoffman; Louis Vanduyfhuys; Irena Nevjestić; Jelle Wieme; Sven M J Rogge; Hannes Depauw; Pascal Van Der Voort; Henk Vrielinck; Veronique Van Speybroeck Journal: J Phys Chem C Nanomater Interfaces Date: 2018-01-08 Impact factor: 4.126
Authors: Jiaze Xie; Jan-Niklas Boyn; Alexander S Filatov; Andrew J McNeece; David A Mazziotti; John S Anderson Journal: Chem Sci Date: 2019-12-04 Impact factor: 9.825