BACKGROUND: Although commonly prescribed, the evidence to support exercises therapy (ET) and conservative management for the treatment of full-thickness rotator cuff tears (FTT) is equivocal. PURPOSE: The purpose of this systematic review of the literature was to determine the current level of evidence available for ET in the treatment of FTT and to provide a formal Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) Working Group of recommendation. METHODS: Five databases were systematically searched to evaluate the effectiveness of ET for FTT. Inclusion criteria: experimental or observational studies of adults clinically diagnosed with FTT, or massive, or inoperable tears that contained a treatment group that received ET for FTT. Exclusion criteria included: history of surgical repair, concurrent significant trauma, neurological impairment, and level V studies. Articles were assessed for quality, the level of evidence (I - V) and GRADE of recommendation (A to F) was determined. Data extraction included: demographics, specific interventions, and outcomes. RESULTS: One thousand, five-hundred and sixty-nine unique citations were identified, 35 studies were included: nine randomized controlled studies, six cohort studies, 15 case series and five case reports. There were 2010 shoulders in 1913 subjects with an average age of 64.2 years, 54% males, 73% of tears were > 1 cm and 37% were classified as massive. Based on studies that reported, >58% of tears were > 1 year and 73% were atraumatic. Of the non-operatively treated cohorts that reported the respective outcomes: 78% improved in pain (9/10 cohorts that reported statistically significant differences [stat-sig] p<0.05), 81% improved in ROM (14/14 cohorts that reported, met stat-sig), 85% improved in strength (7/8 cohorts that reported, met stat-sig), 84% improved in functional outcomes (17/17 cohorts that reported, met stat-sig). Dissatisfied outcomes occurred in 15% of patients, who then transitioned to surgery. CONCLUSION: The current literature indicates GRADE B recommendation (moderate strength) to support the use of ET in the management of FTT. There is further need for well-designed randomized controlled trials. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2a.
BACKGROUND: Although commonly prescribed, the evidence to support exercises therapy (ET) and conservative management for the treatment of full-thickness rotator cuff tears (FTT) is equivocal. PURPOSE: The purpose of this systematic review of the literature was to determine the current level of evidence available for ET in the treatment of FTT and to provide a formal Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) Working Group of recommendation. METHODS: Five databases were systematically searched to evaluate the effectiveness of ET for FTT. Inclusion criteria: experimental or observational studies of adults clinically diagnosed with FTT, or massive, or inoperable tears that contained a treatment group that received ET for FTT. Exclusion criteria included: history of surgical repair, concurrent significant trauma, neurological impairment, and level V studies. Articles were assessed for quality, the level of evidence (I - V) and GRADE of recommendation (A to F) was determined. Data extraction included: demographics, specific interventions, and outcomes. RESULTS: One thousand, five-hundred and sixty-nine unique citations were identified, 35 studies were included: nine randomized controlled studies, six cohort studies, 15 case series and five case reports. There were 2010 shoulders in 1913 subjects with an average age of 64.2 years, 54% males, 73% of tears were > 1 cm and 37% were classified as massive. Based on studies that reported, >58% of tears were > 1 year and 73% were atraumatic. Of the non-operatively treated cohorts that reported the respective outcomes: 78% improved in pain (9/10 cohorts that reported statistically significant differences [stat-sig] p<0.05), 81% improved in ROM (14/14 cohorts that reported, met stat-sig), 85% improved in strength (7/8 cohorts that reported, met stat-sig), 84% improved in functional outcomes (17/17 cohorts that reported, met stat-sig). Dissatisfied outcomes occurred in 15% of patients, who then transitioned to surgery. CONCLUSION: The current literature indicates GRADE B recommendation (moderate strength) to support the use of ET in the management of FTT. There is further need for well-designed randomized controlled trials. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2a.
Authors: Jay D Keener; Leesa M Galatz; Georgia Stobbs-Cucchi; Rebecca Patton; Ken Yamaguchi Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2014-01-01 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: Seth L Sherman; Stephen Lyman; Panagiotis Koulouvaris; Andrew Willis; Robert G Marx Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2008-02-10 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Luke T Mattar; Adam J Popchak; William J Anderst; Volker Musahl; James J Irrgang; Richard E Debski Journal: J Shoulder Elbow Surg Date: 2022-01-26 Impact factor: 3.507
Authors: Joseph Maalouly; Antonios Tawk; Dany Aouad; Hicham Abdel Nour; Elias Saidy; Ghadi Abboud; Georges El Rassi Journal: Int J Surg Case Rep Date: 2020-02-21
Authors: Joseph Maalouly; Antonios Tawk; Dany Aouad; Ali Abdallah; Mohammad Darwiche; Ghadi Abboud; Georges El Rassi Journal: Asia Pac J Sports Med Arthrosc Rehabil Technol Date: 2020-03-05
Authors: Xu Zhang; Dan Wang; Zuyong Wang; Samuel Ka-Kin Ling; Patrick Shu-Hang Yung; Rocky S Tuan; Dai Fei Elmer Ker Journal: J Orthop Translat Date: 2022-08-24 Impact factor: 4.889
Authors: Paolo Di Benedetto; Francesco Mancuso; Luca Tosolini; Michele Mario Buttironi; Alessandro Beltrame; Araldo Causero Journal: Acta Biomed Date: 2021-07-26