PURPOSE: Women with lower urinary tract symptoms are often diagnosed based on a predefined symptom complex or a predominant symptom. There are many limitations to this paradigm as often patients present with multiple urinary symptoms which do not perfectly fit the preestablished diagnoses. We used cluster analysis to identify novel, symptom based subtypes of women with lower urinary tract symptoms. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We analyzed baseline urinary symptom questionnaire data obtained from 545 care seeking female participants enrolled in the LURN (Symptoms of Lower Urinary Tract Dysfunction Research Network) Observational Cohort Study. Symptoms were measured with the LUTS (lower urinary tract symptoms) Tool and the AUA SI (American Urological Association Symptom Index), and analyzed using a probability based consensus clustering algorithm. RESULTS: Four clusters were identified. The 138 women in cluster F1 did not report incontinence but experienced post-void dribbling, frequency and voiding symptoms. The 80 women in cluster F2 reported urgency incontinence as well as urgency and frequency but minimal voiding symptoms or stress incontinence. Cluster F3 included 244 women who reported all types of incontinence, urgency, frequency and mild voiding symptoms. The 83 women in cluster F4 reported all lower urinary tract symptoms at uniformly high levels. All but 2 of 44 LUTS Tool and 8 AUA SI questions significantly differed between at least 2 clusters (p <0.05). All clusters contained at least 1 member from each conventional group, including continence, and stress, urgency, mixed and other incontinence. CONCLUSIONS: Women seeking care for lower urinary tract symptoms cluster into 4 distinct symptom groups which differ from conventional clinical diagnostic groups. Further validation is needed to determine whether management improves using this new classification.
PURPOSE:Women with lower urinary tract symptoms are often diagnosed based on a predefined symptom complex or a predominant symptom. There are many limitations to this paradigm as often patients present with multiple urinary symptoms which do not perfectly fit the preestablished diagnoses. We used cluster analysis to identify novel, symptom based subtypes of women with lower urinary tract symptoms. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We analyzed baseline urinary symptom questionnaire data obtained from 545 care seeking female participants enrolled in the LURN (Symptoms of Lower Urinary Tract Dysfunction Research Network) Observational Cohort Study. Symptoms were measured with the LUTS (lower urinary tract symptoms) Tool and the AUA SI (American Urological Association Symptom Index), and analyzed using a probability based consensus clustering algorithm. RESULTS: Four clusters were identified. The 138 women in cluster F1 did not report incontinence but experienced post-void dribbling, frequency and voiding symptoms. The 80 women in cluster F2 reported urgency incontinence as well as urgency and frequency but minimal voiding symptoms or stress incontinence. Cluster F3 included 244 women who reported all types of incontinence, urgency, frequency and mild voiding symptoms. The 83 women in cluster F4 reported all lower urinary tract symptoms at uniformly high levels. All but 2 of 44 LUTS Tool and 8 AUA SI questions significantly differed between at least 2 clusters (p <0.05). All clusters contained at least 1 member from each conventional group, including continence, and stress, urgency, mixed and other incontinence. CONCLUSIONS:Women seeking care for lower urinary tract symptoms cluster into 4 distinct symptom groups which differ from conventional clinical diagnostic groups. Further validation is needed to determine whether management improves using this new classification.
Authors: John O L DeLancey; Dee E Fenner; Ken Guire; Divya A Patel; Denise Howard; Janis M Miller Journal: Am J Obstet Gynecol Date: 2010-06 Impact factor: 8.661
Authors: Anne P Cameron; Christina Lewicky-Gaupp; Abigail R Smith; Brian T Helfand; John L Gore; J Quentin Clemens; Claire C Yang; Nazema Y Siddiqui; H Henry Lai; James W Griffith; Victor P Andreev; Gang Liu; Kevin Weinfurt; Cindy L Amundsen; Catherine S Bradley; John W Kusek; Ziya Kirkali Journal: J Urol Date: 2017-10-28 Impact factor: 7.450
Authors: John O L DeLancey; Elisa R Trowbridge; Janis M Miller; Daniel M Morgan; Kenneth Guire; Dee E Fenner; William J Weadock; James A Ashton-Miller Journal: J Urol Date: 2008-04-18 Impact factor: 7.450
Authors: Karin S Coyne; Louis S Matza; Zoe S Kopp; Christine Thompson; David Henry; Debra E Irwin; Walter Artibani; Sender Herschorn; Ian Milsom Journal: BJU Int Date: 2008-03-11 Impact factor: 5.588
Authors: Brennan M R Spiegel; Ron D Hays; Roger Bolus; Gil Y Melmed; Lin Chang; Cynthia Whitman; Puja P Khanna; Sylvia H Paz; Tonya Hays; Steve Reise; Dinesh Khanna Journal: Am J Gastroenterol Date: 2014-09-09 Impact factor: 10.864
Authors: Cindy L Amundsen; Margaret E Helmuth; Abigail R Smith; John O L DeLancey; Catherine S Bradley; Kathryn E Flynn; Kimberly S Kenton; H Henry Lai; David Cella; James W Griffith; Victor P Andreev; J Eric Jelovsek; Alice B Liu; Ziya Kirkali; Claire C Yang Journal: Neurourol Urodyn Date: 2019-11-25 Impact factor: 2.696
Authors: Gang Liu; Victor P Andreev; Margaret E Helmuth; Claire C Yang; H Henry Lai; Abigail R Smith; Jonathan B Wiseman; Robert M Merion; Bradley A Erickson; David Cella; James W Griffith; John L Gore; John O L DeLancey; Ziya Kirkali Journal: J Urol Date: 2019-05-23 Impact factor: 7.450
Authors: Nazema Y Siddiqui; Brian T Helfand; Victor P Andreev; Joseph T Kowalski; Megan S Bradley; H Henry Lai; Mitchell B Berger; Margaret G Mueller; Jennifer A Bickhaus; Vignesh T Packiam; Dee Fenner; Brenda W Gillispie; Ziya Kirkali Journal: J Urol Date: 2019-10-09 Impact factor: 7.450
Authors: Alice B Liu; Qian Liu; Claire C Yang; James W Griffith; Abigail R Smith; Margaret E Helmuth; H Henry Lai; Cindy L Amundsen; Bradley A Erickson; J Eric Jelovsek; Nnenaya Q Agochukwu; Margaret G Mueller; Victor P Andreev; Kevin P Weinfurt; Kimberly S Kenton; Matthew O Fraser; Anne P Cameron; Ziya Kirkali; John L Gore Journal: J Urol Date: 2019-08-08 Impact factor: 7.450
Authors: Victor P Andreev; Margaret E Helmuth; Gang Liu; Abigail R Smith; Robert M Merion; Claire C Yang; Anne P Cameron; J Eric Jelovsek; Cindy L Amundsen; Brian T Helfand; Catherine S Bradley; John O L DeLancey; James W Griffith; Alexander P Glaser; Brenda W Gillespie; J Quentin Clemens; H Henry Lai Journal: PLoS One Date: 2022-06-10 Impact factor: 3.752
Authors: Alayne D Markland; Liang Shan; Sonya S Brady; Pamela J Schreiner; Stephen Sidney; Stephen K Van Den Eeden; Cora E Lewis Journal: Urology Date: 2021-06-02 Impact factor: 2.633