| Literature DB >> 29951414 |
Bahram Delgoshaei1, Mohammadreza Mobinizadeh2, Reyhaneh Mojdekar3, Elham Afzal4, Jalal Arabloo5, Efat Mohamadi5.
Abstract
Background: Telemedicine is an expanded term in health information technology that comprises procedures for transmitting medical information electronically to improve patients' health status. The objective of this research is to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of telemedicine interventions in various specialty areas.Entities:
Keywords: Economics; Review; Telemedicine
Year: 2017 PMID: 29951414 PMCID: PMC6014807 DOI: 10.14196/mjiri.31.113
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Med J Islam Repub Iran ISSN: 1016-1430
Search strategy for Cochrane library
| No. | Search strategy | Number of papers |
| #1 | Telemedicine | 1073 |
| #2 | MESH descriptor Telemedicine explode all trees | 20 |
| #3 | (#1 OR #2) | 1073 |
| #4 | (#3 In Economic Evaluations) | 83 |
Search strategy for Centre for Review and Dissemination
| No. | Search strategy | Number of papers |
| #1 | (Telemedicine) IN NHSEED | 90 |
| #2 | MESH descriptor Telemedicine explode all trees IN NHSEED | 84 |
| #3 | (#1 OR #2) | 102 |
The characteristics of included papers
| Author (Reference) | Year | Country | Population | Intervention (type of telemedicine) | Comparison | Outcome indicators |
|
Datta et al.
( | 2010 | USA | Hypertensive veterans | A nurse-administered, tailored information bimonthly for 2 years via telephone | Nonintervention | Cost per life-year saved |
|
Agha et al.
( | 2002 | USA | Rural population | Outpatient pulmonary subspecialty consultations via telemedicine (tele - pulmonary) | 1- Routine care (patients travel from a remote site to the hub site to receive care) 2- On-site care (patients receive care at the remote site) | Cost per patient/year |
|
Nelson et al.
( | 2011 | USA | Stroke patients | Telestroke a 2-way, audiovisual technology that links stroke specialists to remote emergency department physicians and their stroke patients | Usual care | Costs, qualityadjusted life years (QALYs) incremental cost-effectiveness ratios |
|
Graves et al.
( | 2009 | Australia | Adults with established chronic diseases | Telephone counseling intervention for physical activity and diet | Usual Care | Cost per quality adjusted life year gained |
|
Crow et al.
( | 2009 | USA | Women with DSM-IV bulimia nervosa or eating disorder | Telemedicine cognitive behavioral therapy | Face-to-face cognitive behavioral therapy | Cost per recovered (abstinent) subject |
|
Ryan et al.
( | 2012 | UK | 288 adolescents and adults with poorly controlled asthma | Mobile phone supported self-monitoring of asthma | Standard paper based monitoring | Changes in scores on asthma control questionnaire and self efficacy |
|
Rein et al.
( | 2011 | USA | People with diabetes with no or early diabetic retinopathy | Telemedicine screening | Self-referral, biennial evaluation, and annual evaluation | Cost per quality adjusted life year gained |
|
Franzini et al.
( | 2011 | USA | ICU patients | Tele-ICU program | Nonintervention | Average daily costs, costs per case, and costs per patient |
|
Eminović et al.
( | 2010 | Netherlands | Patients were referred to one of the recruited dermatologists | Teledermatology | Conventional process | Costs per dermatology patient care episode |
|
Dowie et al.
( | 2009 | UK | Babies and children | A telecardiology service introduced alongside outreach clinics | Conventional | Clinical outcomes and mean NHS costs per patient |
|
Whited et al.
( | 2005 | USA | Diabetic populations | Non-mydriatic digital teleophthalmology system (Joslin Vision Network) | Traditional clinicbased ophthalmoscopy examinations with pupil dilation | The number of true positive cases of proliferative diabetic retinopathy detected, the number of patients treated with panretinal laser photocoagulation, and the number of cases of severe vision loss averted |
|
Aoki et al.
( | 2004 | USA | Prison inmates with type 2 diabetes | Teleophthalmology in evaluating diabetic retinopathy | Nonteleophthalmology | Cost per qualityadjusted life years(QALYs) |
|
Loane et al.
( | 2001 | Australia | 274 patients required a hospital outpatient dermatology referral | Real time teledermatology | Conventional care | Cost per patient |
|
Wooton et al.
( | 2000 | Australia | 204 general practice patients requiring referral to dermatology services | Real time teledermatology | Conventional consultation | Cost-benefit analysis |
|
Wu et al.
( | 1995 | USA | Patients with arrhythmias associated with intermittent central nervous system or cardiac symptoms. | Transtelephonic arrhythmia monitoring | Ambulatory ECG | Cost-effectiveness |
|
Stoloff et al.
( | 1998 | USA | Patients | Various technologies (telephone and fax, e-mail and Internet, video teleconferencing (VTC), teleradiology, and diagnostic instruments | - | The man-day savings and quality-of-care enhancements |
|
Sicotte et al.
( | 2004 | Canada | Children suffering from cardiac pathologies | Paediatric cardiology teleconsultation | Conventional care | Incremental costeffectiveness ratio, cost per patient journey avoided |
|
Kildemoes et al.
( | 2004 | Denmark | Patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI) | The public campaign with prehospital telemedicine diagnostics | - | Cost per life year |
|
Van der et al.
( | 2010 | Scotland | Patients whose symptoms suggested possible cancer of the airways | Tele-endoscopy clinics | Conventional, mainland clinic | Average cost per patient |
|
Jackson et al.
( | 2008 | USA | Infants with BW less than 1251 g | Telemedicine for retinopathy of prematurity (ROP) management | Standard ophthalmoscopy | Costs per quality-adjusted life year gained |
|
Simon et al.
( | 2009 | USA | Consecutive primary care patients starting antidepressant treatment | Telephone care management and telephone psychotherapy for depression | Usual care | Outpatient health care costs, depression-free days, incremental net benefit |
The list of excluded paper and exclusion reason
| No. | Paper Title | Exclusion reasons |
| 1 |
Cost-benefit of the telecardiology service in the state of Minas Gerais: Minas
Telecardio project ( | Lack of relevant outcomes |
| 2 |
Reducing the cost of frequent hospital admissions for congestive heart failure: a
randomized trial of a home telecare intervention ( | Lack of relevancy between costs and outcomes |
| 3 |
Clinical and economic outcomes of the electronic intensive care unit: results from
two community hospitals ( | Lack of relevancy between costs and outcomes |
| 4 |
Economic evaluation of telephone self-management interventions for blood
pressure control ( | Lack of relevancy between costs and outcomes |
| 5 |
Assessment of the clinical outcomes and cost-effectiveness of the management of
systolic heart failure in Chinese patients using a home-based intervention ( | Lack of relevancy between costs and outcomes |
| 6 |
Multicenter randomized trial on home-based telemanagement to prevent hospital
readmission of patients with chronic heart failure ( | Lack of relevancy between costs and outcomes |
| 7 |
The efficacy and cost-effectiveness of a community weight management
intervention: a randomized controlled trial of the health weight management
demonstration ( | Lack of relevant control |
| 8 |
Diagnostic and cost effectiveness of telemonitoring the pediatric pacemaker patient
( | Lack of relevancy between costs and outcomes |
| 9 |
Are there time and cost savings by using telemanagement for patients on
intensified insulin therapy: a randomized, controlled trial ( | Lack of relevancy between costs and outcomes |
| 10 |
National use of thrombolysis with alteplase for acute ischaemic stroke via
telemedicine in Denmark: a model of budgetary impact and cost-effectiveness ( | Lack of relevant control |
| 11 |
The cost-effectiveness of technology transfer using telemedicine ( | Lack of relevant control and cost calculations |
| 12 |
Economic analysis of a telemedicine intervention to improve glycemic control in
patients with diabetes mellitus: illustration of a novel analytic method ( | Lack of relevant control |
| 13 |
Effect of a multiple-site intensive care unit telemedicine program on clinical and
economic outcomes: an alternative paradigm for intensivist staffing ( | Lack of cost calculations |
| 14 |
Cost-effective use of telemedicine and self-monitoring of blood glucose via
Diabetes Tele Management System (DTMS) to achieve target glycosylated
hemoglobin values without serious symptomatic hypoglycemia in 1,000 subjects
with type 2 diabetes mellitus: a retrospective study ( | Lack of relevant control and cost calculations |
| 15 |
Cost-effectiveness analysis of a rural telemedicine collaborative care intervention
for depression ( | Lack of relevant control |
| 16 |
Costs and benefits of personalized healthcare for patients with chronic heart failure
in the care and education program "Telemedicine for the Heart" ( | Lack of relevant control |
| 17 |
Resource costs and quality of life outcomes for homebound elderly using
telemedicine integrated with nurse case management ( | Lack of separate cost calculations |
| 18 |
Cost analysis of telehomecare ( | Lack of relevant control and outcomes |
| 19 |
Home telehealth reduces healthcare costs ( | Lack of relevant control and cost calculations |
| 20 |
Cost-effectiveness analysis of telemedical devices for pre-clinical traffic accident
emergency rescue in Germany ( | Lack of relevant control |
Fig. 1