Sho Takahashi1. 1. Department of Neurosurgery, Takahashi Neurosurgery and Dermatology Clinic, Japan.
Abstract
A 15-month retrospective study of 1,000 outpatients was conducted to determine the exact cause of general dizziness. The most common diagnosis in all analyzed cases was cervicogenic general dizziness (89%). The majority of the patients who underwent magnetic resonance imaging of the cervical spine had narrow spinal canals. Measuring the anteroposterior diameter of the spinal canal in each case was critical to obtain an accurate diagnosis in line with the diagnostic criteria used. General dizziness may develop because of inappropriate neck posture over long periods of time in individuals with some form of underlying cervical disease. The causes of general dizziness were different between male and female patients and between patients of different age groups. Triggers leading to general dizziness included engaging in farming, gardening, or weeding activities for long periods of time, particularly in elderly women. Selection of the appropriate muscle relaxant type and dosage is important in the treatment of patients with cervicogenic general dizziness who also experience a stiff neck and shoulders. Following treatment, 90% of patients no longer experienced general dizziness or exhibited clear improvements in their symptoms within 1 week. The results of this study emphasize the importance of cervicogenic general dizziness, which is due to cervical vertebral lesions and is exacerbated by excessive stress on the cervical spine.
A 15-month retrospective study of 1,000 outpatients was conducted to determine the exact cause of general dizziness. The most common diagnosis in all analyzed cases was cervicogenic general dizziness (89%). The majority of the patients who underwent magnetic resonance imaging of the cervical spine had narrow spinal canals. Measuring the anteroposterior diameter of the spinal canal in each case was critical to obtain an accurate diagnosis in line with the diagnostic criteria used. General dizziness may develop because of inappropriate neck posture over long periods of time in individuals with some form of underlying cervical disease. The causes of general dizziness were different between male and female patients and between patients of different age groups. Triggers leading to general dizziness included engaging in farming, gardening, or weeding activities for long periods of time, particularly in elderly women. Selection of the appropriate muscle relaxant type and dosage is important in the treatment of patients with cervicogenic general dizziness who also experience a stiff neck and shoulders. Following treatment, 90% of patients no longer experienced general dizziness or exhibited clear improvements in their symptoms within 1 week. The results of this study emphasize the importance of cervicogenic general dizziness, which is due to cervical vertebral lesions and is exacerbated by excessive stress on the cervical spine.
Entities:
Keywords:
cervicogenic; general dizziness; muscle relaxants; narrow spinal canal
General dizziness is a symptom frequently encountered in everyday clinical practice.
However, the causes of this symptom are highly varied and can often be difficult to treat.
In addition, reaching a definitive diagnosis in patients with general dizziness can prove
difficult. At our hospital, patients who complain of general dizziness despite having no
intracranial disease presentation and no clear signs of inner ear dysfunction or systemic
conditions, patients complaining of severe dizziness for which treatments attempted by
multiple medical facilities have failed to achieve adequate results, and patients with
refractory dizziness and those with dizziness of an unknown cause are frequently
treated.This study was a retrospective analysis of the patients who visited our hospital with a
chief complaint of general dizziness. Herein, I primarily consider cervicogenic general
dizziness, which was the most common cause of our patients’ symptoms.
Patients and Methods
This study included 1,000 patients (299 men and 701 women) who visited our hospital during
a 15-month period between June 2013 and September 2014 with a chief complaint of general
dizziness. The patients’ ages ranged from 9 to 91 years, and the mean age was 62.0 years.
All study participants provided informed consent, and the study design was approved by the
appropriate ethics review board. Men in their 70s were the most prominent group of patients.
The women in the study exhibited a trend of increasing prevalence of general dizziness with
increasing age up to their 70s (Figures 1 and 2).
Figure 1
Number of male patients with general dizziness in each age group.
Figure 2
Number of female patients with general dizziness in each age group.
Number of male patients with general dizziness in each age group.Number of female patients with general dizziness in each age group.I used the various definitions established by the Japan Foundation for Equilibrium Research
(1987) to diagnose cervicogenic general dizziness. These definitions are as follows: “In
many cases, the cause of vertigo lies in the cervical region, as a result of events such as
rotation or extension of the neck, or abnormalities of the equilibrium sensation”;
“repeatedly occurring vertigo”; “symptoms affecting the neck, particularly cervical
neuralgia, sympathetic tenderness, and vertigo accompanied by autonomic nervous symptoms”;
“vertigo, dizziness, or imbalance caused by abnormal afferent input from the neck, in cases
in which no organic vestibular impairment is observed”; and “a lack of disorders leading to
vertigo involving areas other than the cervical region”[1],[2],[3]).Patients with no cerebral, systemic, or other non-cervical disorders were treated for
cervicogenic general dizziness even if cochlear symptoms such as hearing loss could not be
excluded. Of these patients, those meeting the following criteria were diagnosed with
cervicogenic general dizziness:a) Abnormal cervical findings on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and neck stressb) No abnormal cranial MRI findings, and neck stressLesions such as cervical spinal canal stenosis (defined as an anterior-posterior diameter
of the spinal canal less than 12 mm at the levels of several vertebral bodies), degenerative
cervical spondylosis, cervical disc herniation, ossification of the posterior longitudinal
ligament (OPLL), and syringomyelia were assessed using cervical MRI in order to aid in the
diagnosis of cervical spinal disorders.No systemic symptoms, such as hypertension, diabetes, or anemia, or cochlear symptoms were
observed, although no cause of general dizziness was identified on cranial MRI. Although the
patients’ conditions were well controlled, many experienced general dizziness. Many of these
patients had cervicogenic symptoms, such as hypertonia of the neck and scapular muscle
group, and met the above criterion listed under a) (patients who placed stress on their
necks prior to the manifestation of dizziness).The following section describes the diagnostic imaging procedures, causation, treatment
methods, and prognoses of the general dizziness cases treated at our hospital in this
retrospective study.
Results
Pathological causes of dizziness disorder
Most of the 1,000 patients with general dizziness in this study had cervicogenic general
dizziness (n = 899; 90%), followed by drug-induced general dizziness (27 patients,
pregabalin: 8, antihypertensive drugs: 9, other causative drugs), cerebrovascular
infarction (13 patients), orthostatic hypotension (10 patients), concussion (5 patients),
overwork (5 patients), benign seizure-induced general dizziness (3 patients), vasovagal
reflex (3 patients), anemia (3 patients), psychogenic disorders (2 patients), and 1
patient each with cerebral hemorrhage, cerebellar atrophy, hypertensive emergency, and the
common cold. Three patients had general dizziness due to other causes, and 23 had general
dizziness due to unknown causes (2%).
Symptoms and imaging findings in patients with cervicogenic general dizziness
Of the patients diagnosed with cervicogenic general dizziness, 744 (83%) presented with
lightheadedness, and 155 patients (17%) exhibited rotatory vertigo. Seven-hundred and six
patients (79%) presented with stiff shoulders, 416 (46%) had a sensation of a heavy head
or headache (tension-type headache), 198 (22%) had numbness of the hands/upper
extremities, 104 (12%) had scapular pain, and 46 (5%) had tinnitus. It was believed that
the tinnitus was the result of tension applied to the neck and scapular muscle group,
which also affected the ossicular muscles. Therefore, tinnitus in the patients in this
study was determined not to be a cochlear symptom (these symptoms disappeared in all cases
following treatment with a muscle relaxant). It is not unusual for nystagmus to occur in
patients with cervicogenic general dizziness as a result of lightheadedness, rotatory
vertigo, or anterior or posterior flexion of the neck. However, no distinct
characteristics were observed during the diagnosis. This symptom was thus deemed to have
little value in diagnostic confirmation. Eighty-four of the 193 patients who did not
experience stiff shoulders complained of a headache or a heavy head sensation believed to
be indicative of a tension-type headache. Based on these observations, 790 patients (88%)
diagnosed with cervicogenic general dizziness were determined to have hyperflexion of the
neck, scapular muscles, or temporalis muscle.Cervical MRI was performed in 600 of 899 patients diagnosed with cervicogenic general
dizziness (67%). Cervical spinal canal stenosis was diagnosed in 544 of these patients
(91%), degenerative cervical spondylosis was found in 40 patients, herniated cervical
spinal discs were found in 11 patients, and 1 patient each was diagnosed with OPLL,
cervical scoliosis, and syringomyelia. The anteroposterior spinal canal diameters in
patients diagnosed with cervicogenic general dizziness with underlying spinal canal
stenosis ranged from 4.0 mm to 11.6 mm (mean: 9.0 mm). Cranial MRI was performed in all
299 patients who did not undergo cervical MRI. We confirmed that no causal factors for
general dizziness were present within these patients’ skulls.
Causes of cervicogenic general dizziness
Patient interviews revealed that the etiology of general dizziness symptoms differed
depending on patient sex and age. Of all patients with cervicogenic general dizziness, 712
(79%) were able to recall episodes in which an excessive load was placed on the neck,
which was then considered to cause their symptoms. The incidence of cervicogenic general
dizziness by season was also examined in the 186 men and 489 women who visited our
hospital between June 2013 and May 2014.The symptoms of male patients in their teens up to their 50s were often associated with
their occupations. Specifically, desk work, such as operating a personal computer (PC) for
long periods of time, was often a symptom trigger in these patients (Figures 3A and 3B). In elderly male patients, gardening activities, such as landscaping and tree
planting, were the most common triggers, although long periods of viewing television in an
awkward posture, such as when lying on one’s side, was also a frequent trigger (Figure 3C).
Figure 3
A: Causes of general dizziness in male patients between the age of 10 and 29 years
(n = 19). B: Causes of general dizziness in male patients between the age of 30 and
59 years (n = 68). C: Causes of general dizziness in male patients over the age of
60 years (n = 115).
A: Causes of general dizziness in male patients between the age of 10 and 29 years
(n = 19). B: Causes of general dizziness in male patients between the age of 30 and
59 years (n = 68). C: Causes of general dizziness in male patients over the age of
60 years (n = 115).In female patients in their teens up to their 50s, long periods of desk work, including
PC operation, childcare activities such as piggybacking and hugging, or caring for
grandchildren were the most frequent symptom triggers (Figures 4A and B). In young women, maintaining a forward leaning posture for long periods during
activities such as smartphone use, playing video games, and studying were also common
symptom triggers (Figure 4A). In female patients
aged 60 and older, gardening activities, such as landscaping and weeding, triggered
symptoms much more frequently during the spring (March to May 2014) and fall seasons
(September to November 2013) (Figures 4C and
5B). In addition, lying down on one’s side for a long period of time with a
straining neck posture during activities such as watching TV or reading was found to be a
frequent symptom trigger during the winter months (December 2013 to February 2014) (Figure 4C).
Figure 4
A: Causes of general dizziness in female patients between the ages of 10 and 29
years (n = 36). B: Causes of general dizziness in female patients between the ages
of 30 and 59 years (n = 185). C: Causes of general dizziness in female patients over
the age of 60 years (n = 289).
A: Causes of general dizziness in female patients between the ages of 10 and 29
years (n = 36). B: Causes of general dizziness in female patients between the ages
of 30 and 59 years (n = 185). C: Causes of general dizziness in female patients over
the age of 60 years (n = 289).Although the number of male patients with general dizziness increased slightly in the
autumn when harvesting chores are common, there were few changes in symptom prevalence
throughout the year (Figure 5A). In contrast, the number of female patients with general dizziness tended to
increase in the spring when patients began engaging in long periods of agricultural and
gardening activities (Figure 5B). In addition,
the number of male and female patients decreased slightly during the summer months (June
to August 2013) when outdoor activities are more common, while the number of male patients
increased slightly, and the number of female patients decreased slightly during the winter
months (Figures 5A and 5B).
Figure 5
A: Number of patients with general dizziness by season (men). B: Number of patients
with general dizziness by season (women).
A: Number of patients with general dizziness by season (men). B: Number of patients
with general dizziness by season (women).
Drug therapy for cervicogenic general dizziness
Correction is most important when symptoms are accompanied by excessive tension of the
neck and scapular muscles or a tension-type headache. Muscle relaxants and opioid drugs
were used in all 790 cases determined to be caused by tension-type headaches or excessive
tension of the neck, scapular muscles, or temporalis muscle. Muscle relaxants with
stronger effects were selected in the majority of the cases. Doses of 1–6 mg per day of
tizanidine were generally administered to non-elderly patients, and milder drug regimens,
such as 40–60 mg per day of afloqualone, were prescribed for elderly patients. Another
commonly prescribed drug was eperisone, which was prescribed at doses of 100–150 mg per
day. Dantrolene may also be effective in intractable cases. The above findings indicate
that the selection of muscle relaxant drug type and dose were made on a patient-by-patient
basis to ensure that the underlying causes of the symptoms were addressed appropriately
and effectively. When the effects of typical muscle relaxants were inadequate, a
dibenzodiazepine-class or benzodiazepine-class anxiolytic drug with muscle relaxant
effects was used in combination with Chinese herbal medicines, such as peony and licorice
decoctions (Shakuyakukanzoto), which is a neurotropin used as a
therapeutic agent. This medicine is used to suppress pain affecting the lower body and to
improve blood circulation in the upper body. Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs were
also used, as appropriate, to address upper body pain symptoms, including headache, as
such symptoms can create a vicious circle that exacerbates tension on the neck and
scapular muscles. Tocopherolnicotinate and opioid drugs were used in combination in
patients without stress on the neck and scapular muscles. These patients were also
provided with comprehensive lifestyle guidance to help them avoid excessive stress on the
neck.
Cervicogenic general dizziness prognosis
General dizziness improved in all cases within a short period, provided that a suitable
drug therapy was selected, and patients were able to adjust their trigger behaviors.
General dizziness symptoms disappeared or exhibited clear evidence of improvement within 1
week in 806 patients (90%) and within 2 weeks in another 33 patients (4%). Improvement
first appeared after 1 month in 18 patients (2%) and after 2 months in 3 patients (0.3%).
No improvement was observed in 39 patients (4%). The subsequent clinical course for these
patients is unknown. In cases wherein general dizziness improved, understanding the causal
condition and reducing the amount of stress placed on the neck resulted in no recurrences
during the shortest observation period of 3 months. General dizziness symptoms only
recurred repeatedly when patients resumed placing excessive stress on the neck.
Actual case examples
Case 1: 54-year-old female patient
Chief complaint: Recurrent lightheadedness and rotatory vertigoHistory of present disease: The patient works as a cook and began experiencing
recurrent lightheadedness and rotatory vertigo several years earlier, with episodes
lasting for 1–2 days. These episodes were occasionally accompanied by occipital pain.
The patient’s condition was often exacerbated when she moved her head. Two days before
examination, the patient experienced a rotative vertigo episode lasting for 1 day and
took time off from work. She visited our hospital when her symptoms did not improve. The
patient had never sought medical attention regarding her dizziness symptoms in the
past.Diagnosis and clinical course: Based on the patient interview, the patient was
suspected of having cervicogenic general dizziness, as she complained of severe shoulder
stiffness occasionally becoming pronounced at the right upper extremity. Cervical MRI
revealed spinal canal stenosis and mild cervical spondylotic lesions (Figure 6). In addition to drug therapy (tizanidine, diphenidol, and sodium loxoprofen),
the patient was advised to avoid straining her neck as much as possible and to take
breaks as needed. General dizziness symptoms and headache disappeared almost completely
by the time she returned to work 1 week later, during which time the patient continued
drug therapy. The patient has had no recurrence of general dizziness symptoms for over 1
year.
Figure 6
Case 1: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Case 1: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Case 2: 83-year-old female patient
Chief complaint: Recurrent rotatory vertigoCurrent medical history: The patient began experiencing repeated rotatory vertigo
episodes starting 2 years prior to the visit. Treatment received from multiple medical
facilities proved ineffective. The physicians whom the patient had previously visited
were unable to identify the cause of the patient’s symptoms.Diagnosis and clinical course: The patient often engages in typical gardening
activities, such as weeding, and experiences repeated, momentary back pain episodes
(greater occipital neuralgia). The patient’s subjective symptoms other than general
dizziness included mild shoulder stiffness, numbness of the right hand, and right
shoulder pain. Cervical MRI revealed spinal canal stenosis and degenerative cervical
spondylosis (Figure 7). Drug therapy was prescribed (eperisone, betahistine mesylate, and celecoxib) in
addition to lifestyle guidance, instructing the patient to refrain from long periods of
weeding and similar activities. As a result, the patient’s general dizziness symptoms
disappeared within 1 week, and her subsequent course has been favorable.
Figure 7
Case 2: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Case 2: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Case 3: 89-year-old female patient
Chief complaint: Recurrent rotatory vertigo and lightheadednessCurrent medical history: The patient began experiencing repeated rotatory vertigo and
lightheadedness episodes starting 4–5 years ago. Despite receiving treatment from
several medical institutions, her symptoms did not improve.Diagnosis and clinical course: The patient often does farm work in the fields and
experienced general dizziness, a heavy head sensation, and shoulder stiffness when
turning her head upwards. Cervical MRI revealed spinal canal stenosis and degenerative
cervical spondylosis (Figure 8). The patient was started on drug therapy (afloqualone, difenidol, and
Ryokyojutsukanto [tuckahoe, cassia twig, largehead atractylodes, and
licorice decoction, a Chinese herbal medicine]) and was prescribed lifestyle guidance
instructing her to refrain from long periods of field work and to occasionally take
breaks as needed. As a result, the patient’s symptoms disappeared within 1 week.
Figure 8
Case 3: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Case 3: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Case 4: 78-year-old female patient
Chief complaint: Recurrent rotatory vertigo and lightheadednessCurrent medical history: The patient had experienced repeated episodes of rotatory
vertigo and lightheadedness since entering her 50s. Although she had visited several
medical facilities, the cause of her condition remained unclear. The patient had no
improvement in her general dizziness episodes.Diagnosis and clinical course: The patient engages in gardening activities such as
weeding, generally for long periods of time. She often feels that her head is weighted
down and that her shoulders have become stiff. A cervical MRI revealed spinal canal
stenosis and degenerative cervical spondylosis (Figure 9). In addition to drug therapy (afloqualone and sulpiride), the patient was
provided with lifestyle guidance, including the recommendation to avoid long periods of
gardening. The patient’s dizziness symptoms disappeared 1 week after initiating
treatment. Subsequently, the patient had no recurrence of general dizziness symptoms for
2 years.
Figure 9
Case 4: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Case 4: Sagittal MRI (0.3-T), cervical cross-section, T2-weighted image.
Discussion
Although “general dizziness” is commonly encountered in routine practice, reaching an
accurate diagnosis remains challenging even with modern medical techniques. The condition is
thus still a frequent subject of debate.In Kaetsu area of Niigata Prefecture, it is estimated that sudden cases of severe rotatory
vertigo and cases complicated by cochlear symptoms are often first admitted to an emergency
outpatient facility at a hospital in a neighboring city or are referred to an
otorhinolaryngology practitioner. As such, when diagnosing patients presenting with general
dizziness symptoms, it is important to consider that typical otorhinolaryngological
conditions are likely to have already been eliminated during prior examinations. When
considering the majority of the patients with general dizziness admitted to our hospital, I
presume that the causal illness was not discovered by the patient’s previous physicians or
was intractable. Alternatively, the patient may have visited our hospital for examination
after repeated symptom episodes raised concerns regarding intracranial conditions. The
population of patients with general dizziness visiting our hospital is highly likely to
differ from that seen by otorhinolaryngologists, neurologists, internal medicine physicians,
or general practitioners. Nevertheless, in this study of patients with significant general
dizziness symptoms admitted to our hospital, the primary causal disorder in patients without
typical otorhinolaryngological diseases was cervicogenic general dizziness. I also found
that the most common causal disorder varied by patient age and sex. I discuss the causes of
cervicogenic general dizziness, its mechanism of onset, and treatment options in the
following sections.
Importance of distinguishing cervicogenic general dizziness from benign paroxysmal
positioning vertigo
Benign paroxysmal positioning vertigo (BPPV) is a condition that has recently come to be
considered the most common cause of general dizziness in Japan, with some reports stating
that the condition accounts for approximately 40% of all cases of peripheral
vertigo[4]). BPPV is a
benign disorder that causes dizziness due to stimulation of the semicircular canal
interior after otoliths are unintentionally detached from the equilibrium plaque of the
utricular macula when the head is tilted in certain directions. In actual clinical
practice, BPPV can be diagnosed under a broad definition including many instances wherein
a BPPV diagnosis is reached when nystagmus or vertigo alone is observed when the head or
neck is moved, even when no dizziness appears. BPPV diagnoses are also believed to be
frequently made in many cases wherein dizziness or nystagmus appear only when a specific
head position is adopted. This condition is also believed to be common in patients with
cervicogenic general dizziness. Although our hospital did not perform detailed evaluations
of each of the patients included in this study using otorhinolaryngological tests, only
0.3% of the 1,000 patients had the potential to be diagnosed with BPPV under our stringent
diagnostic criteria. As the treatment methods for the two conditions are completely
different, providing differential treatment regimens for patients with cervicogenic
general dizziness and for those with BPPV is of high clinical importance.
Recognition of cervicogenic general dizziness
Cervicogenic dizziness was first described in a 1926 paper by Barre as a type of general
dizziness induced by cervical arthritis. This condition is also referred to as Barre-Lieou
Syndrome today[5]). Ryan and
Cope later published a report in 1955 describing general dizziness caused by cervical
spinal abnormalities, particularly spondylosis. In this paper, the condition was referred
to as “cervicogenic vertigo”, a term that others have continued to use[6], [7]). Numerous reports on cervicogenic general
dizziness have been published in Europe and the United States. Currently, the more
clinically oriented name “cervicogenic vertigo (general dizziness, imbalance)” is used to
describe the condition. This condition is regarded as important in both Europe and the
United States[1], [4], [8],[9],[10],[11],[12],[13]), although it has a surprisingly low level of recognition in
Japan[3]). It is important
to recognize that general dizziness is frequently triggered by excessive stress placed on
the cervical spine. In patients presenting with cervicogenic general dizziness, the
presence of an underlying cervical spine condition can be confirmed using cervical MRI
examination. In addition, the attending physicians can easily determine whether the
patient engages in activities that cause him/her to place excessive stress on the neck
prior to the manifestation of general dizziness symptoms. In this study, spinal canal
stenosis was found to be a complicating condition in approximately 90% of patients in whom
cervical MRI was performed. In addition, although the causes of general dizziness symptoms
differed depending on patient age and sex, it was confirmed that patients in all cases
adopted postures that placed excessive stress on the neck.
Mechanism of onset for general dizziness arising from vertebral disorders
Lightheadedness was used to describe approximately 80% of the general dizziness findings
in this study. However, estimating the site of injury or the causative disorder based only
on differences in presentation between rotatory vertigo and lightheadedness proved
difficult.Discussion of the pathways involved in cervicogenic general dizziness often begins with
the neural pathways of the vestibular system. There is also a peripheral vestibular system
serving as a descending nerve tract. The brainstem and cerebellum are also involved, as
they comprise the central vestibular system. The vestibulospinal tract is located in the
cervical spinal cord. The lateral vestibulospinal tract communicates with the otolith
input (linear acceleration and gravity) and supplies all cervical, thoracic, and lumbar
spinal cord segments, while the medial vestibulospinal tract transmits semicircular canal
input (angular acceleration) and supplies the cervical spinal cord only. In addition, the
cerebellar spinal cord tract, which is an ascending nerve tract that sends sensory
information from the lower body and trunk to the cerebellum, can become a source of
general dizziness following neck injury.When shoulder stiffness persists because of cervical spinal disorders, the cervical
sympathetic nerves can become tense. This may cause general dizziness as a result of an
autonomic imbalance. Symptoms, including headache, general dizziness, tinnitus, stiffness
of the neck and scapular muscles, retrobulbar pain, general malaise, and palpitations
caused by Barre-Lieou syndrome[5],
[15]), may appear as
a result of whiplash accidents or cervical spondylosis and are encountered relatively
frequently.Although the number of related cases may be small, insufficient circulation to the
cerebellum and the brainstem due to osteophytes narrowing the vertebral artery (observed
in patients with cervical spondylosis) is believed to cause general dizziness symptoms.
Physical pressure on the vertebral artery or vertebral nerves accompanying the cervical
vertebrae or resulting from lateral punctures will cause bending and narrowing of the
vertebral artery during neck movements. This would, in turn, lead to so-called
vertebrobasilar artery insufficiency (Power’s syndrome)[14]). Although evaluation of the vertebrobasilar
artery using MRA was not performed during this study, MRA is believed to be necessary to
eliminate this and similar potential causal disorders during diagnosis.
Spinal canal stenosis and cervicogenic general dizziness
Although diagnostic criteria for cervical vertebral canal stenosis exist, severe symptoms
that would necessitate surgery in actual clinical cases often do not appear in mild cases
where the anteroposterior diameter of the spinal canal is approximately 10–12 mm. However,
it is important to recognize regarding long-term stresses on the neck that even mild cases
of spinal canal stenosis can induce general dizziness.
Treatment and prognosis of cervicogenic general dizziness
Continued placement of excessive stress on the neck during neck and scapular muscle group
flexion can prolong or exacerbate cervicogenic general dizziness symptoms. Of the patients
with cervicogenic general dizziness examined in this study, 90% had remission of their
symptoms within 1 week of initiating appropriate treatment. Relieving excessive tension on
the neck and scapular muscle groups is the most important therapeutic factor in achieving
rapid improvement in cervicogenic general dizziness symptoms[3], [11], [16]). In the patients examined during this study, drug therapies
with weak muscle relaxant effects, such as afloqualone and tolperisone, had sufficient
effects, while drugs with stronger effects, such as tizanidine, often required extremely
high dosages of 6 mg per day and required the concomitant use of several types of muscle
relaxants. When these muscle relaxants did not achieve sufficient results, tranquilizers
and Chinese herbal medicines such as peony and licorice decoctions
(Shakuyakukanzoto) and arrowroot decoctions
(Kakkonto), were used concomitantly. Tranquilizers such as
thienodiazepine and benzodiazepine were similarly used to relieve muscle tension if
necessary. Gaining a thorough understanding of the particular characteristics of each
patient and knowledge regarding the actions and side effects of different drug therapies
are necessary when selecting muscle relaxants or other drugs and determining appropriate
dosages.Patients must be provided with adequate information to convince them to adjust their
behaviors related to their neck condition based on an accurate diagnosis in order to
achieve timely improvement and to prevent the recurrence of general dizziness. It is also
important to provide lifestyle guidance to patients to help them avoid placing excessive
stress on the neck. This includes avoiding the maintenance of stressful neck postures for
long periods of time. Based on the cases involving general dizziness in this study, it
appears that not only appropriate drug therapy but also well-planned lifestyle guidance
can contribute to high rates of successful treatment outcomes.
Conclusion
General dizziness may be induced following engagement in repetitive activity patterns that
are common in modern life and that place excessive stress on the neck in the presence of
underlying cervical spinal conditions. Treatment of excessive tension placed on the
cervical/scapular muscle group or the temporal muscle can result in improvements in general
dizziness symptoms within 1 week. It is also extremely important to advise patients to
monitor their own cervical condition and to adjust lifestyle habits that place too much
stress on the neck for extended periods. It should also be emphasized that cervicogenic
general dizziness is an important contemporary lifestyle disorder that can be treated.A nearly identical version of this paper was published in the Journal of the
Japanese Association of Rural Medicine in the Japanese language in 2016[17]).
Conflicts of Interest
The author has no conflicts to disclose regarding the publication of this paper.