Grant W Waterer1, Wesley H Self2, D Mark Courtney3, Carlos G Grijalva2, Robert A Balk4, Timothy D Girard5, Sherene S Fakhran6, Christopher Trabue7, Paul McNabb7, Evan J Anderson8, Derek J Williams2, Anna M Bramley9, Seema Jain9, Kathryn M Edwards2, Richard G Wunderink3. 1. University of Western Australia, Perth, WA, Australia; Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL. Electronic address: grant.waterer@uwa.edu.au. 2. Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN. 3. Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL. 4. Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL. 5. University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA. 6. John H. Stroger, Jr. Hospital of Cook County, Chicago, IL. 7. University of Tennessee Health Science Center/Saint Thomas Health, Nashville, TN. 8. Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA. 9. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Adults hospitalized with community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) are at high risk for short-term mortality. However, it is unclear whether improvements in in-hospital pneumonia care could substantially lower this risk. We extensively reviewed all in-hospital deaths in a large prospective CAP study to assess the cause of each death and assess the extent of potentially preventable mortality. METHODS: We enrolled adults hospitalized with CAP at five tertiary-care hospitals in the United States. Five physician investigators reviewed the medical record and study database for each patient who died to identify the cause of death, the contribution of CAP to death, and any preventable factors potentially contributing to death. RESULTS: Among 2,320 enrolled patients, 52 (2.2%) died during initial hospitalization. Among these 52 patients, 33 (63.4%) were ≥ 65 years old, and 32 (61.5%) had ≥ two chronic comorbidities. CAP was judged to be the direct cause of death in 27 patients (51.9%). Ten patients (19.2%) had do-not-resuscitate orders prior to admission. Four patients were identified in whom a lapse in quality of care potentially contributed to death; preexisting end-of-life limitations were present in two of these patients. Two patients seeking full medical care experienced a lapse in in-hospital quality of pneumonia care that potentially contributed to death. CONCLUSIONS: In this study of adults with CAP at tertiary-care hospitals with a low mortality rate, most in-hospital deaths did not appear to be preventable with improvements in in-hospital pneumonia care. Preexisting end-of-life limitations in care, advanced age, and high comorbidity burden were common among those who died.
BACKGROUND: Adults hospitalized with community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) are at high risk for short-term mortality. However, it is unclear whether improvements in in-hospital pneumonia care could substantially lower this risk. We extensively reviewed all in-hospital deaths in a large prospective CAP study to assess the cause of each death and assess the extent of potentially preventable mortality. METHODS: We enrolled adults hospitalized with CAP at five tertiary-care hospitals in the United States. Five physician investigators reviewed the medical record and study database for each patient who died to identify the cause of death, the contribution of CAP to death, and any preventable factors potentially contributing to death. RESULTS: Among 2,320 enrolled patients, 52 (2.2%) died during initial hospitalization. Among these 52 patients, 33 (63.4%) were ≥ 65 years old, and 32 (61.5%) had ≥ two chronic comorbidities. CAP was judged to be the direct cause of death in 27 patients (51.9%). Ten patients (19.2%) had do-not-resuscitate orders prior to admission. Four patients were identified in whom a lapse in quality of care potentially contributed to death; preexisting end-of-life limitations were present in two of these patients. Two patients seeking full medical care experienced a lapse in in-hospital quality of pneumonia care that potentially contributed to death. CONCLUSIONS: In this study of adults with CAP at tertiary-care hospitals with a low mortality rate, most in-hospital deaths did not appear to be preventable with improvements in in-hospital pneumonia care. Preexisting end-of-life limitations in care, advanced age, and high comorbidity burden were common among those who died.
Authors: Lionel A Mandell; Richard G Wunderink; Antonio Anzueto; John G Bartlett; G Douglas Campbell; Nathan C Dean; Scott F Dowell; Thomas M File; Daniel M Musher; Michael S Niederman; Antonio Torres; Cynthia G Whitney Journal: Clin Infect Dis Date: 2007-03-01 Impact factor: 9.079
Authors: Seema Jain; Wesley H Self; Richard G Wunderink; Sherene Fakhran; Robert Balk; Anna M Bramley; Carrie Reed; Carlos G Grijalva; Evan J Anderson; D Mark Courtney; James D Chappell; Chao Qi; Eric M Hart; Frank Carroll; Christopher Trabue; Helen K Donnelly; Derek J Williams; Yuwei Zhu; Sandra R Arnold; Krow Ampofo; Grant W Waterer; Min Levine; Stephen Lindstrom; Jonas M Winchell; Jacqueline M Katz; Dean Erdman; Eileen Schneider; Lauri A Hicks; Jonathan A McCullers; Andrew T Pavia; Kathryn M Edwards; Lyn Finelli Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-07-14 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Thomas S Valley; Michael W Sjoding; Andrew M Ryan; Theodore J Iwashyna; Colin R Cooke Journal: JAMA Date: 2015 Sep 22-29 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: James D Chalmers; Joanne K Taylor; Pallavi Mandal; Gourab Choudhury; Aran Singanayagam; Ahsan R Akram; Adam T Hill Journal: Clin Infect Dis Date: 2011-09 Impact factor: 9.079
Authors: M J Fine; T E Auble; D M Yealy; B H Hanusa; L A Weissfeld; D E Singer; C M Coley; T J Marrie; W N Kapoor Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 1997-01-23 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Mihaela S Stefan; Randa Jaber; Peter K Lindenauer; Jane L Garb; Janet Fitzgerald; Michael B Rothberg Journal: JAMA Intern Med Date: 2015-05 Impact factor: 21.873
Authors: Julio A Ramirez; Timothy L Wiemken; Paula Peyrani; Forest W Arnold; Robert Kelley; William A Mattingly; Raul Nakamatsu; Senen Pena; Brian E Guinn; Stephen P Furmanek; Annuradha K Persaud; Anupama Raghuram; Francisco Fernandez; Leslie Beavin; Rahel Bosson; Rafael Fernandez-Botran; Rodrigo Cavallazzi; Jose Bordon; Claudia Valdivieso; Joann Schulte; Ruth M Carrico Journal: Clin Infect Dis Date: 2017-11-13 Impact factor: 9.079
Authors: Antoni Torres; James D Chalmers; Charles S Dela Cruz; Cristina Dominedò; Marin Kollef; Ignacio Martin-Loeches; Michael Niederman; Richard G Wunderink Journal: Intensive Care Med Date: 2019-01-31 Impact factor: 17.440
Authors: Charles S Dela Cruz; Scott E Evans; Marcos I Restrepo; Nathan Dean; Antonio Torres; Isabel Amara-Elori; Shanjana Awasthi; Elisabet Caler; Bin Cao; James D Chalmers; Jean Chastre; Taylor S Cohen; Alan H Cohen; Kristina Crothers; Y Peter Di; Marie E Egan; Charles Feldman; Samir Gautam; E Scott Halstead; Susanne Herold; Barbara E Jones; Carlos Luna; Michael S Niederman; Raul Mendez; Rosario Menendez; Joseph P Mizgerd; Roomi Nusrat; Julio Ramirez; Yuichiro Shindo; Grant Waterer; Samantha M Yeligar; Richard G Wunderink Journal: Ann Am Thorac Soc Date: 2021-07