| Literature DB >> 29733341 |
Bethany Kate Bareham1, Eileen Kaner1, Liam Patrick Spencer1, Barbara Hanratty1.
Abstract
Background: alcohol presents risks to the health of older adults at levels that may have been 'safer' earlier in life. Moderate drinking is associated with some health benefits, and can play a positive role in older people's social lives. To support healthy ageing, we must understand older people's views with regards to their drinking. This study aims to synthesise qualitative evidence exploring the perceptions and experiences of alcohol use by adults aged 50 years and over.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 29733341 PMCID: PMC6322501 DOI: 10.1093/ageing/afy069
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Age Ageing ISSN: 0002-0729 Impact factor: 10.668
Brief descriptive summaries of included studies with key limitations identified in quality appraisal
| Article and country | Aims | Sample | Data collection methods and analysis | Author-identified key themes | Key limitations and comment on richness from quality appraisal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abrahamson Abrahamson | To investigate how old people—who during their lives have experienced the displacement of drinking’s moral border from soberness to moderate drinking—are presenting themselves, and their values, and attitudes towards alcohol To examine changes in women’s relationship to alcohol during the 1960s | Written responses to autobiographical questions Qualitative thematic analysis Narrative construction and rhetoric motives | Sober repertoire; Moderation repertoire Scene and co-agents; Scene and counter-agents; Choice of the protagonist; Alcohol as agency | Lack of transparency in reporting of study design and methods; lack of exploration of study limitations and biases; thick description with reference to trends and contextual details. Inconsistent transparency in reporting; thick description in places with some contextual details and trends presented. | |
| Aitken | To understand the meanings of alcohol use for older people who use alcohol and to understand older people’s reasons for drinking and identify the discourses they draw on to construct their alcohol use. | Semi-structured interviews, Discourse analysis | A ‘social life’ discourse; A ‘drinking to relax’ discourse; The ‘health issue’ discourse; A ‘problem’ discourse | Lack of transparency in reporting; thick description in places with some contextual details presented and many exemplary quotes | |
| Billinger | Examines how older adults reason their relationship with alcohol and how they see the boundaries between what is acceptable and unacceptable drinking | Focus groups, Hermeneutic interpretation analysis | How the participants described the role of alcohol in their childhood; How participants described their first experience with alcohol; The participants’ definition of their current alcohol consumption; The boundary between acceptable and unacceptable alcohol use; Other people’s means of dealing with alcohol | No exploration of author biases presented; thick description rich with contextual detail, characteristics and trends. | |
| Bobrova | Investigated gender differences in drinking patterns and the reasons behind them among men and women in the Russian city of Novosibirsk | Semi-structured interviews, Framework approach and inductive and thematic analysis | Traditional drinking patterns; Individual drinking patterns; Perceived reasons behind the gender differences in drinking | Lack of transparency in reporting; thinner description with some details presented of sample and context linked to study findings. | |
| Burruss | Exploring alcohol use among a subpopulation of older adults in congregate living, specifically a continuing care retirement community | In-depth interviews, Thematic analysis | Drinking as habit/routine; Peers as catalysts for increased consumption; Alcohol use and congregate living | Lack of transparency in reporting; thick description of study findings supported with contextual detail. | |
| Dare | To explore What role does alcohol play in older people’s lives? What factors facilitate or constrain alcohol use in different residential settings? How does setting influence older people’s alcohol use? | In-depth interviews, Thematic analysis | Alcohol and social engagement; Alcohol and relaxation; Alcohol, work and leisure; Social engagement; Social norms; Self-imposed regulations; Driving; Convenient and regular access to social activities; Driving and setting | Inconsistent transparency in reporting; thick description of study findings exploring differences between contexts. | |
| del Pino | To understand unhealthy alcohol use behaviours in socially disadvantaged, middle-aged and older Latino day labourers. | Semi-structured interviews, Grounded theory | Perceived consequences of unhealthy alcohol use on physical and mental health; The impact of unhealthy alcohol use on family relationships; The family as a key factor in efforts to change behaviour | Lack of transparency in reporting; thick description in places within context of individual characteristics, but no trends presented. | |
| Edgar | Investigate how the process of retiring and ageing shapes alcohol use and its role in the lives of retired people Explore the meaning and uses of alcohol in retirement Explore the lives of older people more broadly, including social networks, interests and family life Capture the intersections of gender, age and socioeconomic status in shaping the experience of retirement and how it relates to alcohol use. This was achieved by including men and women, three specific age groups, and those from areas categorised as ‘more deprived’ and ‘less deprived’, according to the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) Consider service and policy implications flowing from an enhanced understanding of alcohol use in later years. | Semi-structured interviews, Thematic analysis | Routes into retirement; drinking routines; ‘keeping busy’: work and leisure in retirement; adapting to changing social networks; processes offering protection: adapting drinking routines | Inconsistent transparency in reporting; thick description of findings presented, supported by contextual detail with trends conveyed. | |
| Gell | To explore What purpose(s) does drinking serve for older adults? What kind of knowledge do older adults have of the relationship between health and alcohol consumption? Why do older adults change (or maintain) their alcohol consumption over time? What mechanisms lead to a change or maintenance of alcohol consumption behaviour in older adults after change in health? | Semi-structured interviews, Thematic and framework analysis | Current alcohol consumption among interview participants; Changes in alcohol consumption among interview participants; Psychological capability; Reflective motivation; Automatic motivation; Physical opportunity; Social opportunity | Thick description of findings; quotes at times appeared to be used out of original context to support the points made. | |
| Haarni and Hautamaki | To analyse the relationship third-age people have with alcohol: how does long life experience affect drinking habits and what are those habits actually like in the everyday life of older adults? | Biographical and semi-structured interviews, Content and biographical analysis | Different kinds of drinking career; The ideal of moderation; Ageing, generation and period of time | Study limitations were not considered in reporting; thick description of study findings with contextual detail provided; quotes at times appeared to be used out of original context to support the points made. | |
| Johannessen | To investigate older peoples’ experiences with and reflections on the use and misuse of alcohol and psychotropic drugs among older people | Narrative interviews, Phenomenological-hermeneutic analysis | To be a part of a culture in change; To explain use and misuse | Potential biases of research team were not explored; thin description of study findings with no discussion of sample characteristics or trends in the data. | |
| Joseph | To examine the alcohol-infused leisure practices of a group of older Afro-Caribbean men in Canada and the ways alcohol consumption at cricket grounds plays an integral role in the reproduction of club members’ gender as well as their homeland cultures, age, class and national identities | Observations and interviews, Inductive analysis | Drunkenness as a mask of physical degeneration; Drunkenness as temporal escape from femininity and family; Alcohol brands as class and (trans)nationality markers | Insufficient reporting of study limitations; thick description of study findings presented with rich contextual detail. | |
| Kim | To explore the drinking behaviour of older Korean immigrants | Semi-structured focus groups, Thematic analysis | Reasons for drinking among men versus women; Health and alcohol; Signs of problem drinking; drinking in immigrant life; Reasons for a change in drinking behaviour; Religion | Potential biases of research team were not explored; thick description of study findings with trends explored and rich contextual detail provided. | |
| Reczek | To provide insight into the processes that underlie the alcohol trajectories of mid- to later-life men’s and women’s heavy alcohol use identified in the quantitative results | In-depth interviews, Inductive analysis | The gendered context of (re)marriage; The gendered context of divorce | Inconsistent transparency in reporting; potential biases of research team were not explored; thick description of study findings presented with rich contextual detail and exploration of trends. | |
| Sharp | To understand the communication between community-based older adults and their physicians regarding their alcohol use | Semi-structured interviews, Interpretive phenomenological analysis | Factors that hinder alcohol conversations; Characteristics that promote positive patient-doctor relationships | Unclear whether the sample was appropriate for the purpose of the study as most participants had never discussed alcohol use with their physician; thin description of study findings with no supporting excerpts or exploration of trends. | |
| Stanojevic-Jerkovic | To describe drinking patterns in older people, to identify the most common risk factors and protective factors for hazardous or harmful drinking, older people’s empowerment for resisting social pressure to drink and their knowledge about low risk drinking limits | Focus groups, Thematic analysis | Factors that stimulate drinking; Factors hindering drinking; Factors that for some people encourage drinking, for others hinder it; Behaviour in a drinking company; Seeking for help; Familiarity with the recommendations for low-risk drinking; Further findings | Potential biases of research team were not explored; thick description of study findings with rich contextual detail and some exploration of trends. | |
| Tolvanen | To examine the ways in which older people in Finland talk about their use of alcohol. It also aims to shed light on the meaning of alcohol use in the context of social ageing | Structured interviews, Discourse and conversation analysis | Alcohol use as discussed by older people; Who is the ‘one’ who drinks? | Insufficient transparency in reporting; questionable suitability of data for qualitative analysis; thick description of findings with contextual trends presented. | |
| Tolvanen and Jylha | To explore how alcohol use was constructed in life story interviews with people aged 90 or over | Semi-structured/life story interviews, Discourse analysis | I and others: The use of alcohol as a moral issue; Men’s and women’s drinking; Alcohol as a man’s destiny and a threat to the happiness of homes; Alcohol use as part of social interaction; Alcohol use as a health issue | Inconsistent transparency in reporting; limitations and potential biases of research team were not explored; thick description of findings in places with trends presented; limited discussion of findings in relation to participant characteristics. | |
| Vaz De Almeida | To explore social and cultural aspects of alcohol consumption in a sample of older people living in their own homes, in eight different European countries | Semi-structured interviews, Grounded theory | Alcohol consumption narratives of older people; Gender differences in the narratives; Specific cultural differences between the eight countries | Inconsistent transparency in reporting; reported methods of analysis did not appear compatible with data collected; thinner description of data with some exploration of trends but descriptive themes; quotes lacked depth where presented. | |
| Ward | To generate a wider evidence base by exploring the circumstances in which older people drink, the meaning that drinking alcohol has for them and its impact, acknowledging that this can be a pleasurable and positive experience, as well as something that can have adverse health, financial, personal and interpersonal impacts | Semi-structured interviews and focus groups, Thematic analysis | Drinking practices and styles; What affects drinking styles; Seeking help | Inconsistent transparency in reporting; insufficient exploration of limitations and biases; thick description of findings with some trends presented. | |
| Watling and Armstrong | To identify attitudes that might influence drink-driving tendency among this group of women and further show how these attitudes vary across countries | Semi-structured interviews, Thematic analysis | Findings were not organised under theme headings | Potential biases of research team were not explored; thinner description of findings with inconsistent provision of contextual data. | |
| Wilson | To elucidate the views of older individuals aged over 50 years about alcohol consumption, health and well-being, to inform future targeted prevention in this group To gain an in-depth understanding of experiences of, and attitudes towards, support for alcohol-related health issues in people aged 50 and over Explored concurrent alcohol and medication use, as well as the use of alcohol for medicinal purposes, in a sample of individuals in mid to later life | In-depth interviews and semi-structured focus groups, Grounded theory and discursive analysis | Alcohol identities; Health and changing drinking behaviour; gendered patterns of drinking Drinking in mid to later life; Deciding to change; Experiences of primary care; Experience of detoxification and rehabilitation; Experience of counselling and therapy Drinking and using medication regardless of consequences; Health professionals being unaware of alcohol use; Reducing or stopping alcohol consumption because of medication; using alcohol to self-medicate; differences related to gender and age | Potential biases of research team were not explored; thick description on findings with trends presented and rich contextual detail. Inconsistent transparency in reporting; thick description of findings with trends presented and rich contextual detail. Inconsistent transparency in reporting; thick description of data with rich contextual detail. |
Figure 1.PRISMA flow diagram depicting the flow and number of studies identified and then excluded at each stage during identification of papers for inclusion in this review.
Supporting quotes for the key themes presented
| Theme: | Supporting quotes: |
|---|---|
| (1) Routines and rituals | Drinking routines could help older people stay in touch in their relationships:
‘Bonnie and I still enjoy a scotch in the evening… and the way we start off, we have a little bit of scotch. And actually that goes way back. That was when we were both working, we’d come home and have scotch. So it’s a pattern that we’re used to. And we usually then just sit and chat and talk about what’s happening the next day.’ female Change in drinking habits could adversely affect older people’s social opportunities:
‘The same group, every Friday without fail. There was eight of us and well, there’s seven go now because I don’t go up [since I stopped drinking] and they’ve said to me, ‘oh, come up, we miss the, sort of, banter and all that sort of thing…’ but, yeah, as I say, I miss the company more than I miss the drink.’ Routinised drinking practices could hold symbolic meaning, and were a ritual in relaxation during spare time:
‘You know the end of the day – in the evening on the weekend I think it’s time to relax and I find that glass of wine is part of that ritual of starting to enjoy the evening.’ Female, The number of drinking contexts could increase with increasing spare time associated with retirement:
‘I think possibly it’s tempting to drink more when you retire… I go out more for lunch and go out more with friends because I’ve got time to do it, so possibly linked to that yes [I drink more]’ Women’s suggestion of more equal expectations between genders with regards to drinking:
‘[ F2] I think a lot of the men go out a lot more. The older men do still drink. Because that’s their only entertainment really, isn’t it? I would say middle aged men –‘ ‘[F5] I don’t think it’s just men. I think ladies can drink just as much as men.’ ‘[F2] I’m talking about going out for a drink though, you know. Do you think the older ladies do?’ ‘[F5] Oh yeah, I would say so.’ Female focus group |
| (2) Self-image as a responsible drinker | Older adults present themselves as controlled and responsible drinkers, idealising moderation and perceiving themselves to be at low risk of harm from their drinking:
‘Drunk? No, I haven’t really been for a while. I have to say that for the past ten years I’ve managed so that I’ve never been in that bad a way, that I’ve always known what I’ve been doing. Haven’t been out of my senses, like, when you get to bed, you ask which country, what time and where are we. It’s all been so well. I mean, as I’ve gotten older I’ve also gotten wiser and know when to stop. Learnt how to know how to stay in control.’ Older adults’ image of what an older drinker should be:
‘As a pensioner one drinks a bit more often but less at each occasion. You don’t have any pressures, it’s not as rushed to go to bed. You have more opportunity to eat nice food but it isn’t about getting drunk anymore.’ Male, More problematic older drinkers concealed their higher consumption by drinking in private, avoiding pressures to align their drinking:
‘I do not enjoy going out and meeting people, sitting in pubs and shouting at the top of my voice. When I come home, this is my haven, I want to be here… say I had my friend come over, and she’s very moderate, she drinks like a little… you know. So I feel embarrassed then. So I’d rather drink on my own.’ Female Reduced responsibilities in later life could enable increased opportunity for alcohol consumption:
‘I don’t really consider the fact that you shouldn’t be drinking midday, that you shouldn’t be drinking late at night, that you shouldn’t be drinking when ‘this and that’. I don’t mean to imply that I drink a lot, but I do drink, I will drink when I feel like drinking… It changed after I turned 40ish. But now that I am retired I have even more freedom, when you’re working you can’t have a glass of wine with lunch. But now I can’ Female Self-imposed limits and rules maintained controlled drinking patterns:
‘I don’t like drinking during the day, and would only have the odd drink during the day. Once I have a drink, I would tend to keep drinking. I don’t normally drink before 6 pm. Those are my internal rules, it limits the alcohol intake. I don’t feel right after drinking during the day, which is why I tend not to.’ Female Rules and limits to restrict drinking were also employed by heavier drinkers:
‘I’m probably the one in the group to drink the most. Not outrageously, but when you say winebox; dear god I have a glass from my winebox every night! Sometimes I’ll think, one bottle that should be enough for a couple of days. Just to re-focus myself and make me think a little. It’s not at the state where I would run to the neighbours and steal from their cellar. But I can think; this isn’t good! It is something – dependent they call it. It is extremely rare that I’ll end up intoxicated, I think. But still I can feel like the dependency is there… I always take the car when I go anywhere now, for that reason alone. So that I don’t have to…’ Female |
| (3) Alcohol and the ageing body | Some believed that not drinking could be negative for health, because alcohol was perceived to be protective to health:
‘So being a teetotaller can be hazardous to your health too! I’m in the middle of the road with what the experts seem to say that is a healthy level of consumption, if there is such a thing, keep it down to a drink a day and I’ll not do it every day, seem to be the feeling. A small amount of alcohol does have some benefits.’ Male Perceived health benefits of particular drinks served to justify older people’s drinking:
‘My consultant told me that whiskey was only 2nd to red wine for heart disease, and if it’s good enough for him it’s good enough for me [during cardiac rehabilitation].’ Male Some used alcohol to help with physical ailments:
‘It is said that whiskey is healthy. In any case, for me, it is soothing for my stomach and can sometimes act as a medicine’ Alcohol use could be relied upon to cope with stressors or mental health issues in later life:
‘Well, [my partner] couldn’t have any [alcohol] in the last six months [of his life]. I drank, coz I was so anxious. It’s easy to say that one is using because of this and that, but at times I was so distressed that alcohol made me feel better in that situation. And the worse [my partner] got in hospital – I, when I got back from the hospital and had a little alcohol, I could get some sleep and it helped. I sort of relaxed. I was just so anxious about it, I got used to it back then. I should have guessed back then that it wouldn’t end well. But I didn’t think of it like that back then. You can’t know beforehand that that’s how it’s going to turn out.’ Female, aged 62 years Intoxication could be seen as one of life’s remaining pleasures, leading heavier drinkers to maintain their drinking:
‘I’d like to cut it down altogether, but even the last time – I cannot be going away and just sitting on my own. I don’t smoke, I don’t have nowt else and that’s the only pleasure I’ve got – drinking.’ Male, aged 61 years Some older people justified maintaining their drinking by identifying alternative explanations for health issues:
‘I started to think about what I was consuming that might be, erm… having an effect. And the obvious one is drink, but I didn’t want to stop having a drink. But I honed in on citrus… and I thought I wonder, you know, people had said to me there was a connection between citrus fruit, and I wasn’t eating a great amount of fruit, the occasional apple, banana whatever, so I stopped and, dare I say it, touch wood… I haven’t had gout since… It’s a popular explanation for gout, people say oh you’re drinking too much red wine or something… that’s a throwaway remark that everybody seems to make and I ignored it because I found the solution was there for me and with no adverse effects.’ Male Heavier drinking was justified through the lack of noticeable effects on the individual’s health:
‘I’m 55, I’m perfectly fit, I don’t run about beating everyone up, I’m not incontinent, I’m perfectly healthy, I get a check for my stroke, which coincidentally, they check my bloods, they check my liver, check my pancreas, check my kidneys you know, everything’s fine, so how is half a dozen pints doing any irreparable damage?’ Male, aged 56 years |
| (4) Access to alcohol | Drink driving legislation could constrain older people’s drinking:
‘If I know I have to drive, I will just have a light beer, or sometimes I will just go without altogether. I find that easier because you don’t have to worry about whether you have gone over the limit. Driving has killed a lot of social drinking, particularly living down here (an outer metropolitan suburb). If I’m in Perth, I very seldom drink, if at all. It is a long drive and I’m not only worried about RBT (random breath testing). But I don’t want to feel sleepy. It’s the driving mainly that would affect whether or not I will have a drink.’ Male Some binged on alcohol when the money was available:
‘I drink usually when I receive the pension – it is a small holiday. We buy food and I drink chekushku [a quarter of a litre of vodka], 250 g. Beer I drink about once a week. It is sold in big plastic bottles, 1.5 l each. So, I usually finish it during the evening watching TV’ Male, aged 69 years |