Gieljam Johannes Roode1, Kurt-Wilhelm Bütow2. 1. Senior lecturer, Department of Anatomy, University of Pretoria, P/Bag x 323, Arcadia, 0007, South Africa, Email: giel.roode@up.ac.za giel.roode@up.ac.za. 2. Consultant Professor, Department of Maxillo-Facial and Oral Surgery, University of Pretoria, PO Box 1266, Pretoria, 0001, South Africa; Email: kurt@butow.co.za.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Chlorhexidine is seen as the golden standard of disinfectants. It is widely used to clean surgical sites; however, many studies indicate resistance of pathogens to chlorhexidine. One study indicated that pathogenic microorganisms were isolated from the soft palate cleft region in 57% of patients with facial clefts. The objectives of our study were to determine (1) if chlorhexidine application is effective in removing pathogens from the surgical site in these patients, and (2) if any pathogens are isolated, determine if they are resistant to other antimicrobials. DESIGN: A descriptive observational study. SETTINGS: A private practice that specializes in facial cleft surgery, with a country-wide patient base. All procedures were executed by one oral and maxillofacial surgeon. PARTICIPANTS: All patients (N=50) who presented for primary repair of the soft palate cleft were included in the study. INCLUSION CRITERIA: written consent from parent(s), and patient cleared as systemically healthy by a pediatric physician. EXCLUSION CRITERIA: patient(s) with systemic infections (eg, flu) and/or any local infections (eg, tonsillitis). There were 25 males and 25 females with an average age of 7 months and 16 days included in the study. METHODS: Swabs were taken from the surgical site of all 50 patients with cleft soft palate and were sent for culture, identification and antimicrobial sensitivity. The swabs were taken before disinfecting the site as well as after 2 minutes of disinfecting the surgical site with chlorhexidine. Results were compared against each other. RESULTS: Positive cultures with 28 different pathogenic microorganisms that were identified in 47 patients before cleaning the surgical site with the chlorhexidine. The most dominant pathogens were K. pneumonia (n=22), H. influenza (n=18) and S. aureus (n=10). Of the pathogens found, 13 (46%) were still present on the swabs taken after disinfecting with chlorhexidine. K. pneumonia (n= 13), H. influenza (n=11) and S. aureus (n=9) were still the most prevalent pathogens. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated that 61 of the total of 113 pathogens isolated (54%), survived after 2 minutes of disinfecting the surgical and surrounding area with chlorhexidine, thus intensifying the chances of post-operative infection.
OBJECTIVES:Chlorhexidine is seen as the golden standard of disinfectants. It is widely used to clean surgical sites; however, many studies indicate resistance of pathogens to chlorhexidine. One study indicated that pathogenic microorganisms were isolated from the soft palate cleft region in 57% of patients with facial clefts. The objectives of our study were to determine (1) if chlorhexidine application is effective in removing pathogens from the surgical site in these patients, and (2) if any pathogens are isolated, determine if they are resistant to other antimicrobials. DESIGN: A descriptive observational study. SETTINGS: A private practice that specializes in facial cleft surgery, with a country-wide patient base. All procedures were executed by one oral and maxillofacial surgeon. PARTICIPANTS: All patients (N=50) who presented for primary repair of the soft palate cleft were included in the study. INCLUSION CRITERIA: written consent from parent(s), and patient cleared as systemically healthy by a pediatric physician. EXCLUSION CRITERIA: patient(s) with systemic infections (eg, flu) and/or any local infections (eg, tonsillitis). There were 25 males and 25 females with an average age of 7 months and 16 days included in the study. METHODS: Swabs were taken from the surgical site of all 50 patients with cleft soft palate and were sent for culture, identification and antimicrobial sensitivity. The swabs were taken before disinfecting the site as well as after 2 minutes of disinfecting the surgical site with chlorhexidine. Results were compared against each other. RESULTS: Positive cultures with 28 different pathogenic microorganisms that were identified in 47 patients before cleaning the surgical site with the chlorhexidine. The most dominant pathogens were K. pneumonia (n=22), H. influenza (n=18) and S. aureus (n=10). Of the pathogens found, 13 (46%) were still present on the swabs taken after disinfecting with chlorhexidine. K. pneumonia (n= 13), H. influenza (n=11) and S. aureus (n=9) were still the most prevalent pathogens. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated that 61 of the total of 113 pathogens isolated (54%), survived after 2 minutes of disinfecting the surgical and surrounding area with chlorhexidine, thus intensifying the chances of post-operative infection.
Authors: A T Brown; J A Shupe; R E Sims; J L Matheny; T T Lillich; J B Douglass; P J Henslee; T P Raybould; G A Ferretti Journal: Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Date: 1990-12
Authors: Norman Lippmann; Christoph Lübbert; Thorsten Kaiser; Udo X Kaisers; Arne C Rodloff Journal: Lancet Infect Dis Date: 2014-04 Impact factor: 25.071
Authors: Elizabeth A Mann-Salinas; Denar D Joyner; Charles H Guymon; Catherine L Ward; Christopher R Rathbone; John A Jones; Kevin S Akers Journal: J Burn Care Res Date: 2015 Nov-Dec Impact factor: 1.845
Authors: Leila Vali; Sarah E Davies; Lindsay L G Lai; Jayshree Dave; Sebastian G B Amyes Journal: J Antimicrob Chemother Date: 2008-01-28 Impact factor: 5.790