| Literature DB >> 29699539 |
Sheila V Kusnoor1, Taneya Y Koonce2, Suzanne T Hurley3, Kalonji M McClellan2, Mallory N Blasingame2, Elizabeth T Frakes2, Li-Ching Huang4, Marcia I Epelbaum2, Nunzia B Giuse5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Addressing social and behavioral determinants of health (SBDs) may help improve health outcomes of community clinic patients. This cross-sectional study explored how assessing SBDs can be used to complement health data collection strategies and provide clinicians with a more in-depth understanding of their patients.Entities:
Keywords: Community health clinic; PRAPARE; Social determinants of health
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 29699539 PMCID: PMC5921557 DOI: 10.1186/s12889-018-5453-2
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Public Health ISSN: 1471-2458 Impact factor: 3.295
Participant characteristics and health history
| Characteristics | Participants ( |
|---|---|
| Median age (IQR) | 38 (26.5–54.5) |
| Gender | |
| Male | 30/100 (30%) |
| Female | 67/100 (67%) |
| Transgender | 3/100 (3%) |
| Ethnicity | |
| Hispanic or Latino | 7/100(7%) |
| Not Hispanic or Latino | 90/100 (93%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 3/100 (3%) |
| Race | |
| Asian only | 3/100 (3%) |
| Pacific Islander only | 0/100 (0%) |
| White only | 42/100 (42%) |
| Native Hawaiian only | 0/100 (0%) |
| Black/African American only | 36/100 (36%) |
| American Indian/Alaska Native only | 0/100 (0%) |
| Other only | 7/100 (7%) |
| Two or more races only | 5/100 (5%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 7/100 (7%) |
| Farmworker status | |
| Yes | 0/100 (0%) |
| No | 100/100 (100%) |
| Veteran status | |
| Yes | 6/100 (6%) |
| No | 94/100 (94%) |
| Language Preference | |
| English | 95/100 (95%) |
| Language other than English | 5/100 (5%) |
| General Health | |
| Excellent | 14/100 (14%) |
| Very good | 22/100 (22%) |
| Good | 32/100 (32%) |
| Fair | 23/100 (23%) |
| Poor | 7/100 (7%) |
| Do not know/Not sure | 1/100 (1%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 1/100 (1%) |
| Health Condition History | |
| High blood pressure | 45/100 (45%) |
| High cholesterol | 28/100 (28%) |
| Heart attack | 3/100 (3%) |
| Heart disease | 10/100 (10%) |
| Stroke | 5/100 (5%) |
| Asthma | 22/100 (22%) |
| Skin cancer | 3/100 (3%) |
| Other cancer | 4/100 (4%) |
| COPD | 14/100 (14%) |
| Arthritis | 30/100 (30%) |
| Depression | 39/100 (39%) |
| Kidney disease | 3/100 (3%) |
| Diabetes | 14/100 (14%) |
Data are proportions (%) or medians (interquartile range). COPD chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, IQR interquartile range
Social determinants of health domains
| Domain | Participants (n = 100) |
|---|---|
| Median number of household family members (IQR) ( | 2 (1–3) |
| Housing Status | |
| Has housing | 87/100 (87%) |
| Does not have housing | 10/100 (10%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 3/100 (3%) |
| Housing Stability | |
| Worried about losing housing | 17/100 (17%) |
| Not worried about losing housing | 78/100 (78%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 5/100 (5%) |
| Education | |
| Less than high school degree | 15/100 (15%) |
| High school diploma or GED | 37/100 (37%) |
| More than high school | 46/100 (46%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 2/100 (2%) |
| Employment | |
| Unemployed | 27/100 (27%) |
| Part-time or temporary work | 24/100 (24%) |
| Full-time work | 26/100 (26%) |
| Otherwise unemployed but not seeking work | 21/100 (21%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 2/100 (2%) |
| Insurance | |
| None/uninsured | 20/100 (20%) |
| Medicaid | 28/100 (28%) |
| CHIP Medicaid | 1/100 (1%) |
| Medicare | 20/100 (20%) |
| Other public insurance (not CHIP) | 7/100 (7%) |
| Other public insurance (CHIP) | 2/100 (2%) |
| Private insurance | 20/100 (20%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 2/100 (2%) |
| Income | |
| Median household income (IQR) ( | $19,600 ($9, 897 - $35,750) |
| Range | $3000 – $105,000 |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 40/100 (40%) |
| Invalid response | 4 /100 (4%) |
| Incomea (n = 56) | |
| At or below 100% FPL | 25/56 (45%) |
| Above 100% FPL | 31/56 (55%) |
| Material Security | |
| Food | 18/100 (18%) |
| Utilities | 11/100 (11%) |
| Medicine or health care (medical, dental, mental health, vision) | 27/100 (27%) |
| Phone | 12/100 (12%) |
| Clothing | 12/100 (12%) |
| Child care | 5/100 (5%) |
| Other | 3/100 (3%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 1/100 (1%) |
| Transportation | |
| Lack of transportation affected medical appointments/medicine | 15/100 (15%) |
| Lack of transportation affected non-medical meetings/appointments | 10/100 (10%) |
| Transportation has not affected meetings/appointments | 80/100 (80%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 2/100 (2%) |
| Social Integration and Support | |
| Less than once a week | 14/100 (14%) |
| 1 or 2 times a week | 26/100 (26%) |
| 3 to 5 times a week | 22/100 (22%) |
| More than 5 times a week | 34/100 (34%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 4/100 (4%) |
| Stress | |
| Not at all | 20/100 (20%) |
| A little bit | 24/100 (24%) |
| Somewhat | 22/100 (22%) |
| Quite a bit | 15/100 (15%) |
| Very much | 14/100 (14%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 4/100 (4%) |
| Invalid answer (participant chose more than one response) | 1/100 (1%) |
| Depression (PHQ-2 Score)a ( | |
| Negative screen (< 3) | 67/88 (76%) |
| Positive screen (≥ 3) | 21/88 (24%) |
| Physical activity (EVS classification)a ( | |
| Inactive | 14/92 (15%) |
| Insufficiently active | 55/92 (60%) |
| Sufficiently active | 23/92 (25%) |
| Tobacco use | |
| Never smoker | 54/100 (54%) |
| Former smoker | 16/100 (16%) |
| Current every day or current some day smoker | 28/100 (28%) |
| Unknown if ever smoked | 2/100 (2%) |
| Alcohol use (AUDIT-C score)a (n = 92) | |
| Negative screen (women < 3, men < 4) | 80/92 (87%) |
| Positive screen (women ≥ 3, men ≥ 4) | 12/92 (13%) |
| Emergency Expense of $400 | |
| Pay with cash or cash equivalent | 30/100 (30%) |
| Pay with non-cash or non-cash equivalent | 59/100 (59%) |
| Pay with combination of cash and non-cash equivalent | 11/100 (11%) |
| Emergency expense of $400b ( | |
| Would not be able to pay for expense | 30/70 (43%) |
| Credit card, pay over time | 12/70 (17%) |
| Borrowing from a friend or family member | 33/70 (47%) |
| Sell something | 10/70 (14%) |
| Payday loan, deposit advance, or overdraft | 7/70 (10%) |
| Bank loan or line of credit | 5/70 (7%) |
| Other | 3/70 (4%) |
| Largest emergency expense could pay with cash or checking/savings account** (n = 70) | |
| Under $100 | 45/70 (64%) |
| $100 to $199 | 16/70 (23%) |
| $200 to $299 | 2/70 (3%) |
| $300 to $399 | 4/70 (6%) |
| Over $400 | 2/70 (3%) |
| Left blank | 1/70 (1%) |
| Incarceration History | |
| Yes | 2/100 (2%) |
| No | 98/100 (98%) |
| Refugee | |
| No | 98/100 (98%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 2/100 (2%) |
| Safety | |
| Yes | 82/100 (82%) |
| No | 11/100 (11%) |
| Unsure | 4/100 (4%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 3/100 (3%) |
| Domestic Violence | |
| Yes | 5/100 (5%) |
| No | 91/100 (91%) |
| Unsure | 3/100 (3%) |
| Chose not to answer/Left blank | 1/100 (1%) |
Data are proportions (%) or medians (interquartile range). Percentages may not equal 100% due to rounding. aFor reporting purposes, the denominators of the Federal Poverty Level, depression, physical activity, and alcohol use domains only consider responses for whom data/scores could be calculated. Reasons for non-calculation of scores include participant non-response, responses that the question was not understood, and responses that the participant did not know the answer to the question. In the case of the AUDIT-C, scores were also not calculated for transgender patients, as the scoring algorithm is gender binary. bFor consistency with the Federal Reserve Board’s reporting, this data is shown only for those respondents who indicate they would pay for the expense either in whole or in part using non-cash or its equivalent. AUDIT-C = Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test, Brief Screen; CHIP Children’s Health Insurance Program, IQR interquartile range, EVS Exercise Vital Sign, FPL Federal Poverty Level, GED General Equivalency Diploma, PHQ-2 Patient Health Questionnaire-2
Fig. 1Frequency distribution of social determinant needs