| Literature DB >> 29670337 |
Kanta Kumar1,2, Sabrina R Raizada3, Christian D Mallen4, Rebecca J Stack5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) causes painful joint inflammation and is incurable, but treatments control RA. Drug regimens are complex, and patients often do not take their medication as expected. Poor medication adherence can lead to poorly controlled disease and worse patient outcomes. Biologics treatments are expensive and require full engagement from patients. We have previously shown that patients from Black ethnic minority backgrounds do not fully engage into treatment plan. This study explored the patients' experiences in and satisfaction toward receiving information about biologics and future support preferences in South Asian patients with RA.Entities:
Keywords: biologic treatment; ethnicity; illness beliefs; patient perceptions; rheumatoid arthritis
Year: 2018 PMID: 29670337 PMCID: PMC5894650 DOI: 10.2147/PPA.S153741
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Patient Prefer Adherence ISSN: 1177-889X Impact factor: 2.711
Figure 1Topic guide used to facilitate interview discussions.
Abbreviations: DMARDs, disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs; RA, rheumatoid arthritis.
Demographic data of the patients interviewed
| Gender | Level of education | Age | Employment status | Disease duration (years) | Current medication |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patient 1 (female) | Primary | 54 | Retired | 10 | DMARDs, steroids, and biologic agents |
| Patient 2 (female) | University | 45 | Retired due to RA | 2 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 3 (female) | Secondary | 53 | Factory worker | 5 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 4 (female) | University | 51 | Pharmacy technician | 4 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 5 (female) | Secondary | 42 | Nursery teacher | 10 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 6 (female) | Primary | 59 | Homemaker | 12 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 7 (female) | Secondary | 60 | Retired due to RA | 19 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 8 (female) | Primary | 62 | Homemaker | 18 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 9 (female) | Secondary | 55 | Factory worker | 9 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 10 (female) | Primary | 67 | Retired due to RA | 7 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 11 (male) | Secondary | 50 | Manager | 6 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 12 (male) | Secondary | 52 | Security officer | 9 | DMARDs, steroids, and biologic agents |
| Patient 13 (female) | University | 51 | Lawyer | 7 | DMARDs, steroids, and biologic agents |
| Patient 14 (female) | Primary | 53 | Homemaker | 12 | DMARDs, steroids, and biologic agents |
| Patient 15 (female) | Secondary | 64 | Retired due to RA | 14 | DMARDs, steroids, and biologic agents |
| Patient 16 (female) | Secondary | 52 | Manager | 5 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 17 (male) | Secondary | 49 | Factory worker | 19 | DMARDs, steroids, and biologic agents |
| Patient 18 (female) | University | 47 | Manager | 5 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 19 (female) | Secondary | 54 | Teacher assistance | 8 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
| Patient 20 (female) | Primary | 51 | Factory worker | 7 | DMARDs and biologic agents |
Abbreviations: DMARDs, disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs; RA, rheumatoid arthritis.
Quotes (Q) relating to current provision of information regarding biologics journey and understanding of rheumatoid arthritis
| Q1: I had suffered so much and when they suggested this new medication [Enbrel] I just jumped to the chance of getting better than I was. My doctor told me all about how this medication was really helping many patients to get better so I thought why not give it a go. [male English-speaking patient] |
| Q2: When I look back at how many they have tried I didn’t think anything would work and the side effects of these were worse than the others. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q3: Well it takes three months to take effect you think right after three months something will happen then you discover about six months down the line nothing is happening then you change to another then another. When you go back to the rheumatology department they just try another one you do wonder if they know what they know what they are doing. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q4: I have been through so many treatments I must say that I still don’t understand why some of the treatments are not working … if I am honest I don’t understand the arthritis they say it’s different in my knees than my hands. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
Notes: The interviews were undertaken by KK, who is fluent in English, Hindi, and Punjabi languages. All interviews were digitally audiotaped. Interviews were transcribed verbatim by an independent transcribing company.
Quotes (Q) relating to experiences and perceptions of biologics
| Q5: I was so much pain free and thought this was fantastic. I had my life back. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q6: […] To look at me now there is nothing wrong with me I am just a normal person. I can do everything in the day you know. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q7: I do feel better with this drip now than the other medicines I tried. [female Punjabi-speaking patient] |
| Q8: I have tried so many things now I just don’t know whether this new drug will work. I just keep thinking the others didn’t so it is matter of waiting to see how well this will control the pain. [male Punjabi-speaking patient] |
| Q9: I don’t [know] why I wasn’t given these a lot sooner why wait so long I know they were saying my markers were low but my life was really disrupted by it all. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q10: I do really think this all should [have] come sooner. I just couldn’t understand why I had to wait three years. [male Punjabi-speaking patient] |
| Q11: If you ask me this has been all waste of time. I wasn’t responding to any medications so why was there a long delay? [female Punjabi-speaking patient] |
| Q12: It is very frustrating because I don’t think the rheumatologist really understand what we as patients go through. After a while you just give up with them. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q13: Well I was thinking if the first medicines didn’t work that’s why they are trying another one which I thought would. I had to go to India and speak to my doctor over there who told me these medicines would make me worse. [female Hindi-speaking patient] |
Notes: The interviews were undertaken by KK, who is fluent in English, Hindi, and Punjabi languages. All interviews were digitally audiotaped. Interviews were transcribed verbatim by an independent transcribing company. Nine patients chose to be interviewed in Punjabi. The transcripts in Punjabi were translated and transcribed into English directly from the audiotapes.
Quotes (Q) relating to factors influencing willingness to try biologics
| Q14: Every time they tried a different medication I kept on thinking right this one will cure me. However, that didn’t happen you know. but now I have accepted that this will not be cured it doesn’t matter how hard they try. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q15: I was just thinking I want my career back and for me to being [be] a mum again. I was really lonely with other medications because they didn’t do anything for me I felt lifeless but with this it was really great. I got back to work. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q16: I had enough information plus I had looked up things myself. [male English-speaking patient] |
| Q17: If it wasn’t for my family members I wouldn’t have been able to make a decision on this medication. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q18: I did look at Arthritis Research UK for more information. That I found useful but I hadn’t heard of National Rheumatoid Arthritis Society. [male English-speaking patient] |
| Q19: I must say I haven’t heard of National Rheumatoid Arthritis Society. I used social media to hear patient stories on tocilizumab. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q20: I couldn’t really understand why I was now going to take the injections. It did worry me. Yes, so, I did ask the doctor in India also my son said “mum don’t take it until we ask the doctors over there” so when he told me that this was very serious medicines, I didn’t feel it was for me. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q21: I am concerned about the side effects but what I can do? I have no other choice. The doctors in India said the look if you can’t function then you have to take it. My children also said mum you have to have it that’s the only way now to get better. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q22: I will not take the medicine from here (UK) I am only taking the remedies given to me by the doctor in India. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q23: I did look up at some herbal stuff and my husband wanted me to try them first. But soon I realised these were not going to do anything for me. The swelling was there I wasn’t getting any better. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q24: I did try the ayurvedic medicines. This did help at the start. I thought the swelling had gone down but this only lasted for a short time. [male English-speaking patient] |
| Q25: There are so many side effects to this [Humira] I don’t think it is safe to take them. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q26: I talked to my doctor in India and he gives the advice. [female non-English-speaking] |
Notes: The interviews were undertaken by KK, who is fluent in English, Hindi, and Punjabi languages. All interviews were digitally audiotaped. Interviews were transcribed verbatim by an independent transcribing company.
Quotes (Q) relating to recommendations on the desired information to fully understand the use of biologics
| Q27: There are lot of us who still don’t understand what RA is. If the other medications [referring to DMARDs] didn’t work then what to say these would? [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q28: I have to go with the flow really. Some days are good and some are not. RA does this so I have to take a day at a time really that’s all you can do. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q29: While you are trying so many medicines, you start thinking will I ever get better. You need that hope and motivation really. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q30: Group discussions would be good to hear what others have found being on these medications. Sharing that experience would really help us because you do start to feel as if you are the only one suffering with this disease. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q31: If I had a something like a video to watch then my thoughts on my treatments would be different. You can should developed something like where you can see the person talking on this topic. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q32: When I go out and start talking to my friends I hear more than I have in the department. You start feeling very lonely with this condition it will never go away so I think it would help to have something that we can view and listen to and feel more comfortable and think look I am not the only one with it. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q33: I think it is really important to say that it is treatable I know we can’t cure it so it can be controlled – that you are not alone in this – err and it is important to say it is continued treatable condition that the journey goes on. You need to say having the treatments gives you better life and how we can weigh up the side effects with benefits. In terms of the disease you don’t have to suffer, I think there is great deal of perception it is seen as old person disease so you have to take that thought away. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q34: In a lot of the Asian women there is the concept that it is what is it they start believing that they have to suffer. But in fact they can do something about it. Oldness is has changed now. If we want medicines to work we have to be part of that plan. So we have to get involved. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q35: I think it should start from what this problem is about where it comes from, why it is better one day and not others, how we can help ourselves like one hand there is medication but what else can be done. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q36: If I am honest one thing I couldn’t understand why etanercept took so long to mention. I think if the doctors know these medications are coming in line why not explain this plan to patients. I think that would help having the feelings of non-hope. It is luck sometimes of which ones will work but the action plan should be discussed. [male patient English-speaking] |
| Q37: It is good to know that future research is still going on because that gives us hope you are trying for us and that would help us to get involved. [female non-English-speaking patient] |
| Q38: When I was first diagnosed I thought this could be cured but as time went on that didn’t happen so you need to tell people what treatment does so that we can manage those expectations. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q39: It is no good telling me after two years that there are still treatment options why don’t you discuss everything at the start so that I can see what you are working with otherwise, my perception is rheumatologist don’t know what they are doing. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q40: My GP is good I know that he took his time at the beginning but he gets all the letters from here and he reads them every time I go he will ask me how I am getting on. So they are important. [female English-speaking patient] |
| Q41: The hospitals are busy so therefore I do hope that because my bloods at the GP practice and get my prescriptions from there. I do hope that I can get consistency with the GP let’s see. I think better networking and better IT system between the two settings would enable us to work with both GP and hospital side. [male English-speaking patient] |
| Q42: I hardly see my consultant maybe every 12 months it would be nice to discuss things with GP between this time periods. [female English-speaking patient] |
Notes: The interviews were undertaken by KK, who is fluent in English, Hindi, and Punjabi languages. All interviews were digitally audiotaped. Interviews were transcribed verbatim by an independent transcribing company.