Christina M Yuan1, Robert Nee2, Dustin J Little2, Rajeev Narayan3, John M Childs4, Lisa K Prince2, Rajeev Raghavan5, James D Oliver2. 1. Nephrology Service, and christina.m.yuan.civ@mail.mil. 2. Nephrology Service, and. 3. San Antonio Kidney Disease Center, San Antonio, Texas; and. 4. Department of Pathology, Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, Maryland. 5. Selzman Institute for Kidney Health, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas.
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Practicing clinical nephrologists are performing fewer diagnostic kidney biopsies. Requiring biopsy procedural competence for graduating nephrology fellows is controversial. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS: An anonymous, on-line survey of all Walter Reed training program graduates (n=82; 1985-2017) and all United States nephrology program directors (n=149; August to October of 2017), regarding kidney biopsy practice and training, was undertaken. RESULTS: Walter Reed graduates' response and completion rates were 71% and 98%, respectively. The majority felt adequately trained in native kidney biopsy (83%), transplant biopsy (82%), and tissue interpretation (78%), with no difference for ≤10 versus >10 practice years. Thirty-five percent continued to perform biopsies (13% did ≥10 native biopsies/year); 93% referred at least some biopsies. The most common barriers to performing biopsy were logistics (81%) and time (74%). Program director response and completion rates were 60% and 77%. Seventy-two percent cited ≥1 barrier to fellow competence. The most common barriers were logistics (45%), time (45%), and likelihood that biopsy would not be performed postgraduation (41%). Fifty-one percent indicated that fellows should not be required to demonstrate minimal procedural competence in biopsy, although 97% agreed that fellows should demonstrate competence in knowing/managing indications, contraindications, and complications. Program directors citing ≥1 barrier or whose fellows did <50 native biopsies/year in total were more likely to think that procedural competence should not be required versus those citing no barriers (P=0.02), or whose fellows performed ≥50 biopsies (P<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Almost two-thirds of graduate respondents from a single military training program no longer perform biopsy, and 51% of responding nephrology program directors indicated that biopsy procedural competence should not be required. These findings should inform discussion of kidney biopsy curriculum requirements.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Practicing clinical nephrologists are performing fewer diagnostic kidney biopsies. Requiring biopsy procedural competence for graduating nephrology fellows is controversial. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS: An anonymous, on-line survey of all Walter Reed training program graduates (n=82; 1985-2017) and all United States nephrology program directors (n=149; August to October of 2017), regarding kidney biopsy practice and training, was undertaken. RESULTS: Walter Reed graduates' response and completion rates were 71% and 98%, respectively. The majority felt adequately trained in native kidney biopsy (83%), transplant biopsy (82%), and tissue interpretation (78%), with no difference for ≤10 versus >10 practice years. Thirty-five percent continued to perform biopsies (13% did ≥10 native biopsies/year); 93% referred at least some biopsies. The most common barriers to performing biopsy were logistics (81%) and time (74%). Program director response and completion rates were 60% and 77%. Seventy-two percent cited ≥1 barrier to fellow competence. The most common barriers were logistics (45%), time (45%), and likelihood that biopsy would not be performed postgraduation (41%). Fifty-one percent indicated that fellows should not be required to demonstrate minimal procedural competence in biopsy, although 97% agreed that fellows should demonstrate competence in knowing/managing indications, contraindications, and complications. Program directors citing ≥1 barrier or whose fellows did <50 native biopsies/year in total were more likely to think that procedural competence should not be required versus those citing no barriers (P=0.02), or whose fellows performed ≥50 biopsies (P<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Almost two-thirds of graduate respondents from a single military training program no longer perform biopsy, and 51% of responding nephrology program directors indicated that biopsy procedural competence should not be required. These findings should inform discussion of kidney biopsy curriculum requirements.
Authors: Robert W Rope; Kurtis A Pivert; Mark G Parker; Stephen M Sozio; Sylvia Bereknyei Merell Journal: J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2017-04-20 Impact factor: 10.121
Authors: Y Martins; R I Lederman; C L Lowenstein; S Joffe; B A Neville; B T Hastings; G A Abel Journal: Br J Cancer Date: 2012-02-28 Impact factor: 7.640
Authors: Ceara Tess Cunningham; Hude Quan; Brenda Hemmelgarn; Tom Noseworthy; Cynthia A Beck; Elijah Dixon; Susan Samuel; William A Ghali; Lindsay L Sykes; Nathalie Jetté Journal: BMC Med Res Methodol Date: 2015-04-09 Impact factor: 4.615
Authors: Christina M Yuan; Dustin J Little; Eric S Marks; Maura A Watson; Rajeev Raghavan; Robert Nee Journal: Clin J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2020-06-23 Impact factor: 8.237
Authors: Daria Emelianova; Marios Prikis; Christopher S Morris; Pamela C Gibson; Richard Solomon; Geoffrey Scriver; Zachary T Smith; Anant Bhave; Joseph Shields; Michael DeSarno; Abhishek Kumar Journal: BMC Nephrol Date: 2022-06-25 Impact factor: 2.585
Authors: J P Burke; T Pham; S May; S Okano; S K Ratanjee; Z Thet; J K W Wong; S Venuthurupalli; D Ranganathan Journal: BMC Nephrol Date: 2021-08-26 Impact factor: 2.388
Authors: Gregory L Braden; Arlene Chapman; David H Ellison; Crystal A Gadegbeku; Susan B Gurley; Peter Igarashi; Ellie Kelepouris; Marva M Moxey-Mims; Mark D Okusa; Troy J Plumb; Susan E Quaggin; David J Salant; Mark S Segal; Stuart J Shankland; Stefan Somlo Journal: Clin J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2020-08-12 Impact factor: 8.237