Pulegone (PGN), a monoterpene ketone, is a significant
constituent of several mint (Mentha) species and their
derived volatile oils, including peppermint (Mentha
piperita), spearmint (Mentha spicata), European
pennyroyal (Mentha pulegium L.) and American
pennyroyal (Hedeoma pulegioides L.) (1). The
pennyroyal leaves are used to prepare tea, which has been
recommended as an aromatic stimulant, carminative,
emmenagogue, and a headache remedy.Thus, the induced
impacts are unpredictable and dangerous. Beside high
consumption through different varieties of pennyroyals,
low levels of pure PGN are used for flavoring foods,
drinks, and dental products (2).It should be noted that intake of PGN also leads to
exposure to menthofuran, which is a major metabolite
of PGN in the body (3). According to several reports,
PGN and its metabolites such as piperitenone, piperitone,
menthofuran, and menthone have several cytotoxic
impacts on various tissues (2, 4). No treatment-mortality
was observe d in male or female rats which received
0, 9.375, 18.75, 37.5, 75, or 150 mg of PGN/kg body
weight in corn oil by gavage, 5 days per week for 14
weeks. However, the two highest doses (75 and 150 mg/
kg) caused several adverse effects including, weight
loss, increased absolute and relative liver and kidney
weights, hyaline glomerulopathy, bile duct hyperplasia
and hepatocyte hypertrophy (5).In another study, PGN administration at the doses of
0.75 mg/kg and 150 mg/kg resulted in superficial necrosis
of the bladder epithelium and exfoliation (6). In line with
this issue, several cases of pennyroyal toxicity have been
reported (7, 8). Most cases have occurred in adult women
who used pennyroyal as an abortifacient and some of
these cases have even resulted in death (2). The ability
of liver cytochromes (CYPs) to catalyze PGN oxidations
have been examined previously. It has been shown that
CYP2E1, CYP1A2, and CYP2C19 are able to oxidize
PGN to menthofuran (2). Indeed, in several tissues such
as the ovary, placenta, brain and testis the estrogen
receptors (Ers) are involved/co-expressed in encoding
the enzyme aromatase p450 (9-11). The CYP enzymes
directly aromatize the androgens to estrogen, which in
turn plays essential roles in follicular growth and various
ovarian physiological functions (12, 13).The effects of estrogen are mediated by two distinct
estrogen receptors, Er-α(14) and Er-ß
(15, 16) that both
regulate expression of a variety of different genes. Any
disruption in the expression of these genes affects the
estrogen signaling system, leading to reduced proliferation
and differentiation in both male and female gonads (16,
17). Correlating with the enclosed interactions of CYPs
and Ers, it should be noted that ERα knockout (αERKO)
leads to severe ovarian hemorrhage cyst generation,
failure of follicular growth and maturation as well as
ovulation (14, 15). However, the ßERKO
mice exhibit
grossly normal ovarian tissue with follicles at different
stages of growth/development but fewer corpora lutea
(18, 19).Lastly, it has been shown that, there is a link between
groups of genes including, ERs and progesterone
receptors (PRs) with Bcl-2 and p53, which significantly
affects the apoptosis and/or proliferation ratio (20).
Indeed, Bcl-2 and p53 are considered as genes that
are responsible for the initiation, progression and
completion of apoptosis. Accordingly, Bcl-2 promotes
cell survival by inhibiting protease activation and is
known as a key regulator of apoptosis at early stages
(21, 22). The p53 has been dubbed the guardian of the
cell’s genome as it stabilizes and accumulates in the
nucleus of cells with DNA damage that are undergoing
replication. Therefore, p53 is both positively or
negatively associated with apoptosis (23, 24).Considering the role of aromatase enzymes in oxidizing
PGN, the present study was designed to evaluate the
probable effect of PGN on ovarian Cyp19 (as a main
enzyme involved in PGN metabolism). Moreover, we
aimed to analyze the effect of chronic exposure to PGN
on ovarian histological features. Ultimately, in order to
illustrate the possible roles of genes involved in follicular
atresia, the mRNA levels and immunohistochemical
measurements of the co-associated genes such as Bcl-2,
p53, Erα and Erß were investigated.
Materials and Methods
In this experimental study, PGN was bought from Sigma
Co. (CAS NO: 89-82-7). The acridine-orange was purchased
from sigma chemical Co. (St. Louis, MO, USA). Tween
80 was obtained from Merk (Germany). The rabbit anti-
mouse primary antibodies for Erα and Erß
(Biocare, USA)
as well as CD31 (Gennova, Spain) were assigned from
Pishtaz Teb Co. (Iran). The 3,3’-Diaminobenzidine (DAB)
chromogen was from Agilent technologies Co. (DAKO,
Turkey). Mounting medium for immunohistochemical
analysis (VECTASHIELD) was from Vector Laboratories
(Burlingame, CA, USA). Other used materials were standard
commercial laboratory chemicals.
Animals and expermintal groups
For this study, we used 40 mature (average of 10 weeks
old) albino mice (Urmia University, Iran) with high
heterozygosity and average weight of 20-25 g. Mice were
divided into experimental and control groups (10 mice
for each group) and kept under standard experimental
conditions (constant temperature and 12-hour light
regime). Animals were fed soy-free feed. The diet and
water were administered ad libitum and all stress factors
were reduced to a minimum.Experimental groups were treated with different
concentrations of PGN, which was administrated orally
by gavage. The experimental group was divided into 3
subgroups: a- received 25 mg/kg PGN, b- received 50 mg/
kg PGN and c- received 100 mg/kg PGN. The animals in
the control group received 2% solution of Tween 80 as
the solvent for PGN (25). The animals received PGN and
Tween 80 for 35 continuous days. All necessary ethics
were considered during the study and the procedures were
approved by the Ethical Committee of Urmia University
(number AECVU/136/2016).
Histological analyses
After 35 days, the ovaries were dissected and fixed in 10%
formalin for 72 hours. Then, the ovaries were seperated
from per-ovarian tissues under high magnification using a
stereo microscope (Olympus, Japan). The routine sample
processing was performed for the right and left ovaries
(5 ovaries from each side, total 10 ovaries from 5 mice
of each experimental group) and samples were embedded
in paraffin blocks which were serially cut using a rotary
microtome and stained with hematoxylin-eosin. For
histomorphometric analyses, follicles were classified into
preantral (<100 and 100-200 µm) and antral (201-400 µm).Follicular morphology was examined under light
microscope with ×200 magnification. Follicles with
an intact layer of normal granulosa and flattened theca
cells, oocytes with ordinary cytoplasm and nuclei were
considered as normal follicles. Follicles were classified
as abnormal if we witnessed granulosa cells (GCs)
dissociation, early antrum formation, GCs luteinization
and floatation in antrum. Follicular count was estimated
by counting follicles in all serially prepared slides.
Moreover, the atretic preantral and antral follicles were
counted in serial sections for each sample and compared
between groups (26).
Fluorescent assessment of RNA damage
The RNA damage was assessed based on the
Darzynkiewicz method (27). In brief, the ovaries were
washed out with ether alcohol and cut using a cryostat (8
µm). The prepared sections were then fixed by different
concentrations of ethanol for 15 minutes. The sections
were rinsed in acetic acid (1%) and then washed in
distilled water. The specimens were stained in acridineorange
for 3-5 minutes and counterstained in phosphate
buffer (pH=6.85). After that, the slides were checked for
change in fluorescent colors in calcium chloride. The loss
of RNA in necrotic follicular cells was characterized by
faint red stained RNA. The normal cells were marked
bright red at the apex of the nucleus.
Apoptosis detection using terminal transferase and
biotin-16-dUTP
In order to analyze programmed death of single cells,
the terminal transferase and biotin-16-dUTP staining
technique was used. In brief; the sections (6 µm) were
immersed twice in xylene for 5 minutes and then 2
immersions were performed for hydration in 100%
ethanol for 3 minutes and then the slides were rinsed in
distilled water. The slides then were digested in Proteinase
K [10 mg/ml stock in 100 mM Tris-HCl (pH=7.5), 10
mM EDTA] and rinsed in PBS (pH=7) 2 times, 3 minutes
each. The slides were pre-incubated in TdT reaction
buffer (Enzyme reagent 100 µl, label reagent 900 µl) for
10 minutes. Following pre-incubation, the slides were
incubated in TdT reaction mixture for 1-2 hours at 37°C
in a humidified chamber.To stop the reaction stage, the slides were rinsed in stop
reaction buffer (NaCl 1.75 g, Sodium citrate, Trihydrate
0.88 g, distilled water 100 ml) for 10 minutes. The sections
were incubated in FITC-Avidin D in phosphate-buffered
saline (PBS) for 30 minutes at room temperature. After 3
immersions in PBS, the slides were counterstained in PI.
Then, the slides were rinsed in PBS and mounted with anti-
fading mounting medium (28). All slides were analyzed
using a fluorescent microscope (Zeiss, Germany).
Immunohistochemical assessment of angiogenesis
Tissue sections were heated at 60°C for approximately 25
minutes in a hot air oven (Venticell, MMM, Einrichtungen,
Germany). The tissue sections were de-paraffinized in
xylene and rehydrated using an alcohol gradient (96,
90, 80, 70, 50%). A 10 mM sodium citrate buffer was
used for the antigen retrieval process. Then, the IHC
staining was conducted according to the manufacturer’s
protocol (Biocare, USA). Briefly; endogenous peroxidase
was blocked in a peroxidase blocking solution (0.03%
hydrogen peroxide containing sodium azide) for 5
minutes.Tissue sections were then washed gently with washing
buffer and subsequently incubated with CD31 (1:500)
biotinylated primary antibodies for 15 minutes. The
sections were rinsed gently with washing buffer. The
slides were then incubated in a humidified chamber
with a sufficient amount of streptavidin-horseradish
peroxidase (HRP) (streptavidin conjugated to horseradish
peroxidase in PBS containing an anti-microbial agent) for
15 minutes. Subsequently, the tissue sections were rinsed
gently in washing buffer and placed in a buffer bath. Then
the slides were incubated with DAB chromogen for 5
minutes, followed by washing and counter staining with
hematoxylin for 5 seconds.The sections were then dipped in weak ammonia (0.037
M) 10 times, rinsed with distilled water and covered
with cover slips. Positive immunohistochemical
staining was observed as brown stains under a light
microscope (×100 and ×400 magnification). The
vessels were classified into 1-5 µm and 5-10 µm as
newly generated vessels and previously existing
vessels. The vascular distribution per mm2 of the
ovarian tissue was compared between groups.
Immunohistochemical analyses for ERα and ERß
The same protocol as IHC staining of the CD31 was
performed for IHC of the ERα and ERß. Meanwhile the
specific primary antibodies were used for each protein.
The positive-stained cells were counted per 100 cells and
compared between groups.
RNA isolation
Total RNA was extracted from ovaries of experimental
and control animals. For this extraction we used a Sina
Clon RNA extraction kit (SinaGen, Iran). To each ovarian
sample, 1 ml of Tris reagent was added and the tissue
was then homogenized in a Precellys 24 homogenizer
(Bertin Technologies, Aix-en-Provance, France).
Subsequently, the samples were processed according to
the manufacturer’s instructions. Isolated RNA was stored
at -70°C. The RNA quality and purity were measured with
a NanoDrop-1000 spectrophotometer (Thermo Scientific,
Washington, USA).
Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction
Using reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction
(RT-PCR), cDNA was synthesized in a 20 µl reaction
mixture containing 1 µg RNA, oligo (dT) primers (1 µl)
5X reaction buffer (4 µl), RNAse inhibitor (1 µl), 10 mM
dNTP mix (2 µl) and MMuLV reverse transcriptase (1
µl) according to the manufacturer’s protocol (Fermentas,
GmbH, Germany). The cycling protocol for 20 µl reaction
mixture was 5 minutes at 65°C followed by 60 minutes
at 42°C, and 5 minutes at 70°C to terminate the reaction.The obtained cDNA was stored at -20°C. PCR
conditions were run as follows: general denaturation
at 95°C for 3 minutes, followed by 40 cycles of 95°C
for 20 seconds; annealing temperature (62°C for Erα,
58°C for Erß, 54°C for p53, 58°C for Bcl-2, 55°C for
Cyp19 and 63°C for Gapdh) for 45 seconds; elongation
at 72°C for 1 minute and a final 72°C for 5 minutes.
Specific primers were designed and manufactured
by CinnaGen (Iran). The sequences, products size
and annealing temperature for each of the primer
pairs is depicted in Table 1. Final PCR products wereanalyzed on 1.5% agarose gel electrophoresis and the
densitometric analysis of the bands was done by using
PCR Gel analyzing software (ATP, Iran). The control
was set at 100% and experimental samples were
compared to the control.Sequences of the primer pairs used
Blood sampling and hormonal analyses
The blood samples from corresponding animals were
collected directly from the heart and the serum was
separated by centrifugation (3000 g for 5 minutes) and
subjected to assessment for serum progesterone and
estrogen concentrations. Progesterone and estrogen were
measured with the electrochemilunescence method.
The intra-assay coefficient variance for estradiol and
progesterone were, 5.9% (for 10 measurements) and
4.8% (for 10 measurements), respectively. Inter-assay
coefficients variances of 8.9% (for 10 measurements)
and 9.9% (for 10 measurements) were also calculated for
estrogen and progesterone, respectively.
Statistical analyses
All results are presented as mean ± SD. Differences
between quantitative histological and hematological
data were analyzed with two-way ANOVA, followed by
Bonferroni test, using Graph Pad Prism 4.00 and P<0.05
was considered as statistically significant.
Results
Pulegone increased follicular atresia
Histological analyses showed that PGN, in a dose
dependent manner, enhanced follicular atresia at both
preantral and antral stages. Accordingly, the animals
given high doses (100 mg/kg) of PGN demonstrated
significantly (P<0.05) higher percentage of atretic follicles
versus the medium dose (50 mg/kg) and low dose (25 mg/
kg) groups. The PGN-exposed ovaries exhibited pie size
(<100 µm) atretic follicles in the cortex. The oocytes of
the preantral follicles were found without nuclei and a
faint eosinophilic and vacuolated cytoplasm. The GCs
of the atretic preantral follicles were observed to have
enlongated shapes. Antral atretic follicles appeared to
be void of an oocyte and showed dissociated granulosa
cells, increased thickness of the zona pelucida and noncontinuous
cumulus oophorus (Fig .1A-Q).
Fig.1
Cross section from ovaries. A. Control, B. Low dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed (25 mg/kg), C. Medium dose PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg), D. High dose
PGN-exposed groups. Significantly higher antral follicles distribution and active ovary were seen in the control group. PGN reduced the follicular growth
in a dose dependent manner. Note the small size (arrows) and antral (thick arrows) atretic follicles in the cortex region of PGN-exposed groups, E. Normal
primary, F. Early secondary, G. Late secondary, H. Tertiary, I. Graafian follicles are presented in figures, J. Missing oocyte in atretic primary follicle, K.
Centrifugal nuclei (CN) and luteinized granulosa cells (LGs) in atretic early secondary follicle, L. Disappeared oocyte (DO) associated with necrosis of
granulosa cells (GCN) in atretic late secondary follicle, M. Cytoplasmic vacoulation (CV) of oocyte in atretic tertiary follicle, N. Cumulus cells abnormality
(CCs) in atretic graafian follicle (H&E staining, ×200 and ×400 magnifications), O. Mean changes of primordial and primary, P. Secondary and antral follicles
total count per ovary, and Q. Percentage of atretic primordial and primary (P&P), and secondary and antral (S&A) follicles per ovary in different groups. All
data are presented as mean ± SD. Different letters represent significant (P<0.05) differences between marked groups.
Pulegone induced necrosis and apoptosis
In order to evaluate the necrotic follicular and stromal
cells, a special fluorescent staining for mRNA damage
was performed. Observations demonstrated that, PGN
(remarkably at dose of 100 mg/kg) increased mRNA
damage and elevated the necrotic cells distribution.
The software analyses for the necrotic cells (cells with
yellowish RNA content) and the intact cells distribution
(cell with dense red stained RNA content) showed a
significant elevation in the distribution necrotic cells in
300 µm of the PGN-exposed ovarian stroma. Comparing
the percentage of follicles with necrotic cells between
test and control groups showed a remarkable elevation
in the high dose (100 mg/kg) group. This impairment
was revealed significantly (P<0.05) in lower in low (25
mg/kg) and medium (50 mg/kg) PGN-receiving groups
(Fig .2A-Q).
Fig.2
Fluorescent staining for mRNA damage. A. Control, B. Low
dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed (25 mg/kg), C. Medium dose PGN-
exposed (50 mg/kg), D. High dose PGN-exposed groups. Cross
sections from PGN-exposed groups show dose dependent enhancementin the distribution of ovarian and follicular necrotic cells, E. Normal
cells with intact mRNA content (red stained and marked with arrows)
in intact primary, F. Secondary, G. Tertiary, H. Graafian follicles.
However, the follicles in the right hand column are demonstrate
mRNA damage in atretic follicles, exhibiting necrotic cells with faintstained yellowish red RNA in I. Primary, J. Secondary, K. Tertiary, L.
Graafian follicles (Thick arrows, ×200 and ×400 magnifications), M.
Mean percentage of follicles with necrotic cells in different groups. Alldata are presented as mean ± SD. a, b, c, d represent significant differences(P<0.01) between marked groups. Necrotic cells distribution per 300µm of the ovarian stroma in N. Control, O. Low dose PGN-exposed
(25 mg/kg), P. Medium dose PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg), and Q. highdose PGN-exposed groups. Red bars represent normal cells with intactmRNA, green bars present cellular DNA content and yellow bars mark
the connective tissue content of the ovaries. Decreased normal cells
with intact mRNA were seen in PGN-exposed groups.
The fluorescent staining for apoptosis was performed
as another possible mechanism for follicular atresia
(especially in lower doses). Observations revealed that
PGN at low (25 mg/kg) and medium (50 mg/kg) doses
causes increased apoptosis at both follicular and stromal
cells (Fig .3A-D). The Percentage of follicles with
apoptotic cells are presented in Figure 3E-I.
Fig.3
Apoptosis detection using terminal transferase and biotin-16-dUTP. A. Control, B. Low dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed (25 mg/kg), C. Medium dose
PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg), D. high dose PGN-exposed groups. The apoptotic cells are discernable through their red stained nuclei. Intensive cellular
apoptosis was seen in the low dose (25 mg/kg) PGN-exposed group, which is significantly decreased in the medium dose (50 mg/kg) and high dose (100
mg/kg) PGN-exposed groups (×200 magnification). Distribution of apoptotic cells per 2000 µm of ovarian tissue in E. Control, F. Low dose PGN-exposed (25
mg/kg), G. Medium dose PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg) and H. High dose PGN-exposed groups. Increased blue spots for apoptotic cells can be seen in the low
dose (25 mg/kg) PGN-exposed group versus the medium dose (50 mg/kg) and high dose (100 mg/kg) PGN-exposed groups, I. Mean percentage of follicles
with apoptotic cells in different groups. All data are presented as mean ± SD. a, b, c, d represent significant differences (P<0.01) between marked groups.
Cross section from ovaries. A. Control, B. Low dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed (25 mg/kg), C. Medium dose PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg), D. High dose
PGN-exposed groups. Significantly higher antral follicles distribution and active ovary were seen in the control group. PGN reduced the follicular growth
in a dose dependent manner. Note the small size (arrows) and antral (thick arrows) atretic follicles in the cortex region of PGN-exposed groups, E. Normal
primary, F. Early secondary, G. Late secondary, H. Tertiary, I. Graafian follicles are presented in figures, J. Missing oocyte in atretic primary follicle, K.
Centrifugal nuclei (CN) and luteinized granulosa cells (LGs) in atretic early secondary follicle, L. Disappeared oocyte (DO) associated with necrosis of
granulosa cells (GCN) in atretic late secondary follicle, M. Cytoplasmic vacoulation (CV) of oocyte in atretic tertiary follicle, N. Cumulus cells abnormality
(CCs) in atretic graafian follicle (H&E staining, ×200 and ×400 magnifications), O. Mean changes of primordial and primary, P. Secondary and antral follicles
total count per ovary, and Q. Percentage of atretic primordial and primary (P&P), and secondary and antral (S&A) follicles per ovary in different groups. All
data are presented as mean ± SD. Different letters represent significant (P<0.05) differences between marked groups.Fluorescent staining for mRNA damage. A. Control, B. Low
dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed (25 mg/kg), C. Medium dose PGN-
exposed (50 mg/kg), D. High dose PGN-exposed groups. Cross
sections from PGN-exposed groups show dose dependent enhancementin the distribution of ovarian and follicular necrotic cells, E. Normal
cells with intact mRNA content (red stained and marked with arrows)
in intact primary, F. Secondary, G. Tertiary, H. Graafian follicles.
However, the follicles in the right hand column are demonstrate
mRNA damage in atretic follicles, exhibiting necrotic cells with faintstained yellowish red RNA in I. Primary, J. Secondary, K. Tertiary, L.
Graafian follicles (Thick arrows, ×200 and ×400 magnifications), M.
Mean percentage of follicles with necrotic cells in different groups. Alldata are presented as mean ± SD. a, b, c, d represent significant differences(P<0.01) between marked groups. Necrotic cells distribution per 300µm of the ovarian stroma in N. Control, O. Low dose PGN-exposed
(25 mg/kg), P. Medium dose PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg), and Q. highdose PGN-exposed groups. Red bars represent normal cells with intactmRNA, green bars present cellular DNA content and yellow bars mark
the connective tissue content of the ovaries. Decreased normal cells
with intact mRNA were seen in PGN-exposed groups.
Pulegone affected ovarian angiogenesis
The IHC staining for CD31 was performed and ovarian
angiogenesis was estimated in all groups. Observations
showed that PGN, in a dose dependent manner, reduced
ovarian vascularization. The animals in the high dose
(100 mg/kg) PGN group exhibited significantly (P<0.05)
reduced vascular distribution per m of the ovarian
cortex and medulla. The vasculature enclosed within the
theca layer of the antral follicles significantly diminished
in the PGN-exposed group. The stromal angiogenesis in
the cortex region was investigated in order to evaluate
the preantral follicles vascular support. The animals
in PGN-receiving groups showed decreased vascular
distribution per m of the cortical region and manifested
reduced angiogenesis adjacent to the preantral follicles
(Fig .4A-G).
Fig.4
Immunohistochemical assessment of angiogenesis and vascular distribution. A. Control, B. The high dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed
group. Cross section of the ovary from the PGN-exposed group represents a significant reduction in vascular distribution, C. Physiologic stromal
vascularization is marked in the intact secondary follicles (arrows), D. Which is significantly decreased in cross a section from the PGN-exposed
group, E. Angiogenesis in the theca layer of intact antral follicles, which are not developed in the theca layer (arrows) of F. Atretic antral follicles
(Immunohistochemical staining for CD31, ×200 and ×400 magnifications), and G. Effect of PGN on mean average of 1-5 µm and 5-10 µm vessels
distribution per one m of the ovarian tissue, all data are presented as mean ± SD. a, b, c, d represent significant differences (p<0.05) between groups.
Apoptosis detection using terminal transferase and biotin-16-dUTP. A. Control, B. Low dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed (25 mg/kg), C. Medium dose
PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg), D. high dose PGN-exposed groups. The apoptotic cells are discernable through their red stained nuclei. Intensive cellular
apoptosis was seen in the low dose (25 mg/kg) PGN-exposed group, which is significantly decreased in the medium dose (50 mg/kg) and high dose (100
mg/kg) PGN-exposed groups (×200 magnification). Distribution of apoptotic cells per 2000 µm of ovarian tissue in E. Control, F. Low dose PGN-exposed (25
mg/kg), G. Medium dose PGN-exposed (50 mg/kg) and H. High dose PGN-exposed groups. Increased blue spots for apoptotic cells can be seen in the low
dose (25 mg/kg) PGN-exposed group versus the medium dose (50 mg/kg) and high dose (100 mg/kg) PGN-exposed groups, I. Mean percentage of follicles
with apoptotic cells in different groups. All data are presented as mean ± SD. a, b, c, d represent significant differences (P<0.01) between marked groups.
Pulegone altered expression of apoptosis relating genes
The p53 and Bcl-2 mRNA levels were evaluated
using RT-PCR analyses. The animals in the low (25
mg/kg) and medium (50 mg/kg) doses of PGN groups
showed the highest p53 mRNA levels, respectively.
This situation was faint in the high dose (100 mg/
kg) PGN group. More analyses for Bcl-2 exhibited
a contrary pattern. The low (25 mg/kg) and medium
(50 mg/kg) doses of PGN resulted in a significant
(P<0.05) reduction in Bcl-2 mRNA levels. No band
for the mRNA of Bcl-2 was revealed in the high dose
(100 mg/kg) PGN group. However, the animals in the
control group showed remarkably (P<0.05) higher
Bcl-2 and significantly (P<0.05) lower p53 mRNAs in
comparison to PGN-receiving animals (Fig .5A, B).
Fig.5
Effect of pulegone (PGN) on p53, Bcl-2 and Cyp19 mRNA levels in ovarian tissue as well as serum levels of estrogen and progesterone: the mRNA
levels of A. p53, B. Bcl-2, C. Cyp19 and Gapdh were evaluated by semi-quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), the density
of mRNA bands for p53, Bcl-2 and Cyp19 was measured by densitometry and normalized to Gapdh mRNA expression level. Results were expressed as
integrated density values (IDV) of p53, Bcl-2 and Cyp19 mRNA levels, and D. Effect of PGN on serum levels of estrogen and progesterone, all data are
presented as mean ± SD. a,b,c,d represent significant differences (p<0.05) between groups.
Pulegone reduced Cyp19 mRNA levels and affected
serum concentrations of estrogen and progesterone
The RT-PCR analysis showed that PGN at doses of 25
mg/kg significantly (P<0.05) increased Cyp19 mRNA
levels versus the control group. However, the mRNA
levels of Cyp19 were significantly (p<0.05) decreased in
medium (50 mg/kg) and high (100 mg/kg) doses of PGN
groups (Fig .5C). Biochemical analysis showed that PGN,
in a dose dependent manner, reduces the serum levels
of estrogen and progesterone in comparison to control
animals (Fig .5D).Immunohistochemical assessment of angiogenesis and vascular distribution. A. Control, B. The high dose pulegone (PGN)-exposed
group. Cross section of the ovary from the PGN-exposed group represents a significant reduction in vascular distribution, C. Physiologic stromal
vascularization is marked in the intact secondary follicles (arrows), D. Which is significantly decreased in cross a section from the PGN-exposed
group, E. Angiogenesis in the theca layer of intact antral follicles, which are not developed in the theca layer (arrows) of F. Atretic antral follicles
(Immunohistochemical staining for CD31, ×200 and ×400 magnifications), and G. Effect of PGN on mean average of 1-5 µm and 5-10 µm vessels
distribution per one m of the ovarian tissue, all data are presented as mean ± SD. a, b, c, d represent significant differences (p<0.05) between groups.Effect of pulegone (PGN) on p53, Bcl-2 and Cyp19 mRNA levels in ovarian tissue as well as serum levels of estrogen and progesterone: the mRNA
levels of A. p53, B. Bcl-2, C. Cyp19 and Gapdh were evaluated by semi-quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), the density
of mRNA bands for p53, Bcl-2 and Cyp19 was measured by densitometry and normalized to Gapdh mRNA expression level. Results were expressed as
integrated density values (IDV) of p53, Bcl-2 and Cyp19 mRNA levels, and D. Effect of PGN on serum levels of estrogen and progesterone, all data are
presented as mean ± SD. a,b,c,d represent significant differences (p<0.05) between groups.
Pulegone affected ERα and ERβ expression
The ERα and ERβ proteins and the mRNA levels were
estimated using IHC staining and RT-PCR analysis,
respectively. Observations showed that, the mRNA level
of ERα significantly (P<0.05) increased in the low dose (25
mg/kg) PGN-receiving animals versus those in the control,
medium and high dose PGN groups. However, in a dose
dependent manner, the mRNA level of ERα significantly
(P<0.05) decreased in the medium (50 mg/kg) and high
dose (100 mg/kg) groups. IHC staining demonstrated that
the follicular cells of intact antral follicles and stromal
cells of the ovaries (in control groups) exhibited ERα
that was remarkably decreased in atretic follicles of the
same stage (Fig .6A, B). More analyses for ERβ showed
that PGN causes decreased expression of ERβ mRNA.
Accordingly, the distribution of ERβ-positive cells was
significantly (P<0.05) decreased in stromal cells enclosed
to the preantral follicles. Moreover, the GCs and theca
cells of antral follicles showed decreased ERβ protein
compared to those in intact antral follicles (Fig .6C, D).
Fig.6
Effect of pulegone (PGN) on ERα and ERß proteins (see brown chromogen) and mRNA levels. A. Intact secondary (preantral) follicle with ERa expressionlevels in granulosa cells, which is significantly diminished in atretic secondary follicles. Normal graafian follicle with intensive ERα expression. Note reduceddistribution of ERα positive cells in atretic graafian follicles (×400 magnification), B. mRNA levels of Erα and Gapdh were evaluated by semi-quantitative
reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), the Erα density measured by densitometry and normalized to Gapdh mRNA expression, C.
Immunohistochemical staining for ERß: ERß expression in intact early secondary, late secondary follicles (preantral), which is significantly decreased in atreticearly and late secondary follicles, (×400 magnification), and D. Effect of pulegone (PGN) on mRNA levels of Erß in ovarian tissue: mRNA levels of Erß and Gapdh were evaluated using semi-quantitative RT-PCR. The Erß density measured by densitometry and normalized to Gapdh mRNA expression level. Results were
expressed as integrated density values (IDV) of Erß mRNA level. a, b, c represent significant differences (p<0.05) between groups.
Effect of pulegone (PGN) on ERα and ERß proteins (see brown chromogen) and mRNA levels. A. Intact secondary (preantral) follicle with ERa expressionlevels in granulosa cells, which is significantly diminished in atretic secondary follicles. Normal graafian follicle with intensive ERα expression. Note reduceddistribution of ERα positive cells in atretic graafian follicles (×400 magnification), B. mRNA levels of Erα and Gapdh were evaluated by semi-quantitative
reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), the Erα density measured by densitometry and normalized to Gapdh mRNA expression, C.
Immunohistochemical staining for ERß: ERß expression in intact early secondary, late secondary follicles (preantral), which is significantly decreased in atreticearly and late secondary follicles, (×400 magnification), and D. Effect of pulegone (PGN) on mRNA levels of Erß in ovarian tissue: mRNA levels of Erß and Gapdh were evaluated using semi-quantitative RT-PCR. The Erß density measured by densitometry and normalized to Gapdh mRNA expression level. Results were
expressed as integrated density values (IDV) of Erß mRNA level. a, b, c represent significant differences (p<0.05) between groups.
Discussion
In the present study, we have analyzed IHC and RT-PCR
expression data to measure the expression of Erα and Erß
and defined that, PGN resulted in severe decrease in Erα
and Erß
expression at both the protein and mRNA levels.
We have also established low levels of transcription
for Cyp19 in PGN-exposed animals. Expression was
diminished in a dose dependent manner. Moreover, we
found that elevated p53 and decreased Bcl-2 expression
were both associated with enhanced follicular cell and
oocyte apoptosis/necrosis and consequently follicular
atresia. In order to clarify the exact mechanism(s) by
which PGN negatively impacts the ovaries, special
staining techniques were conducted to detect probable
cases of induced apoptosis and/or necrosis. We showed
that PGN more prominently at the low dose (25 mg/kg)
and with lower efficiency at the medium dose (50 mg/
kg) triggered apoptosis that triggered necrosis at the high
dose (100 mg/kg) of exposure. Finally, we found positive
correlation between reduced Cyp19 expression and
reduced estrogen biosynthesis.The cytochrome P450 (P450) enzymes family consists
of constitutive and inducible mono-oxygenase enzymes
that metabolize many lipophilic, biologically active
endogenous and xenobiotic substrates including, a large
number of therapeutic drugs and toxic environmental
chemicals (27-29). Actually, it has been reported that
Cyp19 oxidizes PGN to menthofuran (2). Considering the
direct involvement of Cyp19 in metabolizing PGN, we
can come to the conclusion that PGN treatment resulted
in compensatory expenditure of Cyp19, which in turn
affected biosynthesis of estrogen from androgens.
To uncover the relation and/or association between
Cyp19 and estrogen, it should be considered that in
ovaries, the key genes that are involved in encoding
the aromatase cytochrome P450 are co-expressed with
estrogen, suggesting estrogen-induced paracrine or
autocrine effects (30).
Early studies showed that at the early and late preantral
stages, follicles possess gonadotrophins that initiate
estrogen synthesis (31). Accordingly, the preovulatory
follicle has the highest intrafollicular levels of estradiol,
primarily due to the size of its GCs population and its
capacity for androgen aromatization. Although aromatase
activity is present in small antral follicles, estrogen
production at this stage of development is limited
by an inability to produce the androgen substrate for
aromatization to estrogen (32). The current study shows
that PGN, in a dose dependent way, enhances follicular
atresia and ovarian tissue necrosis. Therefore, it would
be more logic to conclude that, both reduced Cyp19expression and the associated atresia of preovulatory
follicles resulted in a remarkable reduction in estrogen
biosynthesis. Dose dependent reduction of serum estrogen
confirmed this hypothesis.
On the other hand, it should be considered that estrogen
signals act via two forms of estrogen receptors as ERα
and ERß. Accordingly, previous reports showed that ER
knockout mice (ERKO) have the most severe ovarian
phenotype, in which follicles fail to mature or ovulate and
form hemorrhagic cysts, leading to infertility (33). In low
dose (25 mg/kg) PGN-exposed animals, the expression
of Erα and Erß increased both at the protein and the
mRNA levels, suggesting compensatory transcription/
biosynthesis of these receptors following a decrease in
estrogen. However, this situation was inversed at higher
doses (50 mg/kg and 100 mg/kg). Indeed, estrogen promotes
proliferation of GCs, oocyte development and provokes
follicles to escape from atresia and reach the preovulatory
stage via Erα and Erß
receptor signaling pathways (33, 34). Thus, reduced ERs expression associated with
decreased aromatization potentially resulted in severe
follicular atresia, suggesting a PGN-induced impact on
vital interactions between aromatization, estrogen levels
and ER signaling pathways.Over the last few years there has been increasing
evidence that expression of certain genes, such as p53
and Bcl-2, may affect the cellular response to an apoptotic
stimulus (22, 35). There is an inverse relationship between
Bcl-2 and p53. Accordingly, after cells have been exposed
to apoptotic stimuli, p53 (36) and Bcl-2 (22) are associated
positively and negatively with release of cytochrome C
from the mitochondria into the cytoplasm, respectively.
Indeed, p53 is known as a promoter for activating cell
death proteases and caspase III expression (37). However,
Bcl-2 is considered as an apoptosis inhibitor protooncogene,
which is involved in cell survival (22).Considering the point that GCs are the primary site for
apoptosis during follicular atresia, we aimed to estimate
the possible roles of p53 and Bcl-2 in PGN-exposed
ovaries. The RT-PCR analysis showed that PGN up-
regulated p53 expression and reduced Bcl-2 expression at
doses of 25 mg/kg and 50 mg/kg, suggesting an apoptotic
effect of PGN at these doses.Histological investigations for apoptosis confirmed these
alterations by revealing intensive apoptosis in low (25 mg/
kg) and medium dose (50 mg/kg) PGN-exposed ovaries.
Meanwhile, we failed to measure Bcl-2 mRNA in the
high dose (100 mg/kg) PGN-exposed group but RT-PCR
analysis illustrated decreased p53 expression. Therefore,
we considered the fact that PGN adversely affects ovarian
follicular growth through other mechanism(s). Special
fluorescent staining for mRNA damage in necrotic cells
was performed to uncover possible necrotic impacts of
PGN. Observations showed that, the ovaries from the
group exposed to the high dose (100 mg/kg) of PGN
exhibited severe necrosis, suggesting two different dose
dependent effects of PGN on the female reproductive
system.Our IHC staining for studying angiogenesis revealed
a significant reduction in ovarian angiogenesis in PGN-
exposed animals. Previous observations suggest the
potential for sex steroids to influence angiogenesis in
ovarian tissues (38). Estrogen stimulates endothelial cell
proliferation and migration in the ovarian tissue through
ERs, which are expressed by the endothelial cells (39).In line with this issue, early studies showed that,
estrogen induces the expression of vascular endothelial
growth factor in ovaries and uterine tissue (18, 38).
Thus, we can conclude that PGN adversely affects the
ovarian angiogenesis progression by down-regulating
estrogen biosynthesis associated with reduced ERs
expression. More biochemical analyses showed that, PGN
significantly diminished the serum levels of progesterone
versus the control group. With that in mind, the ovulation
and consequent corpora lutea formation positively
correlate with serum levels of progesterone, it would be
more logic to conclude that, the PGN-induced apoptosis
and necrosis negatively affects the survival of graafian
follicles, leading to lower ovulation and serum levels of
progesterone compared to control animals.
Conclusion
The PGN enhanced follicular atresia by multiple
mechanisms including; i. Reducing aromatization, ii.
Down-regulating estrogen synthesis, iii. Altering the
expression of Bcl-2 and p53, iv. Diminishing ERs (Erα
and Erß) expression, and v. Reducing angiogenesis.
Authors: Qing Lu; Gavin R Schnitzler; Kazutaka Ueda; Lakshmanan K Iyer; Olga I Diomede; Tiffany Andrade; Richard H Karas Journal: PLoS One Date: 2016-04-01 Impact factor: 3.240