| Literature DB >> 29619242 |
Jan Pringle1, Lawrence Doi1, Divya Jindal-Snape2, Ruth Jepson1, John McAteer1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Experimentation is a natural part of adolescent maturation. In conjunction with increased exposure to behaviours such as alcohol or substance use, and the potentially intensified influence of peer groups, unhealthy behaviour patterns may develop as part of this experimentation. However, the adolescent years also provide considerable opportunity for behaviour to be shaped in positive ways that may improve immediate and longer term health outcomes. A systematic review carried out by the authors concluded that physiological changes during adolescence need to be considered when designing or implementing interventions, due to their influence on health behaviours. The aim of the study is to demonstrate how the six steps in quality intervention development (6SQuID) framework can be used, in conjunction with research or review findings, to inform the development of pilot or feasibility studies. Using the synthesised findings from our adolescent systematic review, we sought to illustrate how adolescent interventions might be designed to target specific health behaviours and augment positive adolescent health outcomes.Entities:
Keywords: Adolescence; Health behaviour; Intervention development; Intervention implementation
Year: 2018 PMID: 29619242 PMCID: PMC5879600 DOI: 10.1186/s40814-018-0259-7
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Pilot Feasibility Stud ISSN: 2055-5784
The 6SQuID process
| 6SQuID steps | Details |
|---|---|
| Step 1: define and understand the problem | Clarify the problem, using the existing research. Establish how the issues are socially and spatially situated, including any immediate or underlying influences. Diagrams may help at this point |
| Step 2: clarify which causal or contextual factors are malleable and have greatest scope for change | Identify the factors that shape the problem and have the greatest scope to be changed. Diagrammatic representation in step 1 may help to establish the most effective intervention point(s) in causal pathways |
| Step 3: identify how to bring about change: the change mechanism | Articulate the theory of change and mechanism(s) for incorporation into the intervention |
| Step 4: identify how to deliver the change mechanism | Investigate the means and options for delivering the intervention, as well as target groups and context |
| Step 5: test and refine on a small scale | Identify a means of testing the intervention in an appropriate setting, for a small sample of the target group(s), as detailed in step 4 |
| Step 6: collect sufficient evidence of effectiveness to justify rigorous implementation or evaluation | Gather evidence that the intervention has worked as intended in the small scale, in order to warrant larger scale application. This may include critically examining any unintended/detrimental effects |
Summarised from Wight et al. 2016
Review findings and implementation considerations
| Adolescent physiological factors | Key points from systematic review results | Implementation considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Neurological decision-making ability | • When adolescents are in situations that involve a high level of emotion (e.g. times of great excitement), they are less likely to spend time considering the (potentially risky) consequences | • Interventions to support adolescents, and those who care for them, can raise awareness of this likelihood and help adolescents to identify that their ‘gut’, or immediate reaction, in such situations may put them at risk |
| Reward processing | • Reward processing develops across adolescence | • Interventions to support adolescents should encourage the rewards that healthy behaviours can give (for example being more active and looking/feeling healthier as a result) |
| • In situations where adolescents need to concentrate intensely (for example when playing computer games), they may be more likely to accept an immediate reward without considering the consequences (for example they may be more likely to eat an unhealthy snack and lose their appetite for more nutritious food) | • An understanding of this likelihood may be helpful for both adolescents and those who care for them. | |
| Age and stage | • Many new experiences that children encounter as they develop through adolescence can impact on future health (for example, smoking) | • It is important that early interventions, at a younger age, explain the potential consequences (good or bad) in a supportive way. This early approach may help adolescents make healthier choices at a later stage (for example, turning down an offer of a cigarette for the first time) |
| • Younger adolescents may be less able to stop acting on impulse, due to the developing (neurological) maturation processes | • Interventions that focus on controlling impulsive action may be better suited to older adolescents | |
| • Younger adolescents may respond better to interventions that focus on immediate rewards (for example, the immediate benefits of taking exercise, such as glowing skin, feeling energised). In contrast, older adolescents may be better able to see the longer term outcomes and anticipate those benefits (for example, having good muscle tone as a result of regular exercise) | • Interventions that are responsive to and implemented in an |
Fig. 1Factors for consideration in relation to adolescent intervention development
6SQuID step 2: causal and contextual factors that have scope for change and step 4: how to deliver the change mechanism
| 6SQuID step | Health behaviours | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Substance use | Sleep | Sexual behaviour | Physical activity | Eating behaviour | |
| Step 2: clarify which causal or contextual factors are malleable and have greatest scope for change | Positive peer influences and family/social networks can offer a protective effect, and this knowledge can be incorporated into and encouraged within interventions, both at an early stage and as adolescents mature | School schedules may benefit from later start times, if feasible. Ensuring that adolescents themselves, parents, and teachers understand adolescent sleep issues is important; limited late evening screen use and consistent sleep patterns can be promoted | Information may need to be matched to stage of readiness to receive and/or stage of maturity rather than simply age related. Earlier maturation of girls is a factor. | Physical activity (PA) programmes may need to be altered to take account of gender and body image issues, especially during periods of rapid physical change in adolescence. | Information regarding healthy eating needs to be embedded in early education to ensure healthy patterns and understanding predate puberty; school policies regarding meal/snack consumption may be less easy to alter or implement, but ensuring adolescents, teachers, and parents are aware of the nutritional needs of adolescents, and healthy BMI perimeters, may assist. Stress coping strategies can be implemented to help reduce unhealthy eating tendencies linked to anxiety |
| Step 4: identify how to deliver the change mechanism | Interventions to promote healthy attitudes to substance use may be most effective when they involve peer and social groups throughout adolescence, but certainly starting at an early stage and for those who mature early | Educating adolescents, parents, and teachers about the changing needs of adolescents regarding sleep and sleep patterns may be an effective way of promoting understanding, and good ‘sleep health’ | Delivering sex and relationship education according to maturity, stage of readiness to receive, and with gender adaptations may help to target information in the best way and at the optimum time. | Interventions to promote physical activity in girls need to adapt to take account of changing bodies and self-consciousness and promote the benefits of being and looking healthy. This may be better targeted towards younger adolescents before reduced activity patterns are formed | Encouraging healthy eating behaviour and knowledge can be introduced pre-puberty and emphasised as bodily changes occur during puberty. Links with activity and sleep also need to be emphasised. Stress-coping strategies could be incorporated into life skills sessions |
| Delivery potential | Youth workers, teachers/teaching assistants, and healthcare workers (e.g. school nurses, GPS) are all well placed to deliver interventions. Parental support and reinforcement of messages may be particularly helpful in areas such as sleep and eating behaviour, especially where parents have had the opportunity to attend information or training sessions and/or contribute to intervention development | ||||
Fig. 2Target populations
Fig. 3Adolescent intervention delivery
6SQuID step 6: pilot intervention considerations
| Pilot considerations | Details |
|---|---|
| Study approvals | Applications made to, and approvals sought from, relevant ethics committee(s) and education board(s) |
| Sampling | Local schools identified. Head/lead teachers provided with information about the study, whom it would involve and how it would be carried out (e.g. details of time commitment, venue etc.) |
| Population | Teaching assistants do not generally have any formal teaching qualifications but may be vital to the support of pupils, especially in challenging situations. Training that is specific to adolescent development may be of benefit, particularly for those new to the role |
| Recruitment | Head teachers, who are agreeable to study conduct at their school, would be asked to pass study details to their teaching assistants. Those willing to take part would be asked to consider the study information and sign a consent form, which would then be given to the researchers. |
| Intervention | Aim: to improve knowledge and confidence in dealing with adolescents, through increased understanding of adolescent development. |
| Outcome measures | Participant levels of understanding and knowledge |
| Resource requirements | Study base: office for study team to operate from, including access to IT/PC, stationery, telephones etc. |
| Evaluation | Outcome evaluation: pre- and post-intervention ratings of levels of understanding, knowledge, confidence, and influence on future practice (from questionnaires) |