Ledibabari Mildred Ngaage1, Georgette Oni2, Rudolph Buntic3, Charles M Malata2,4,5, Gregory Buncke3. 1. School of Clinical Medicine, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom. 2. Department of Plastic Surgery Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, United Kingdom. 3. Department of Microsurgery, Buncke Clinic, San Francisco. 4. Cambridge Breast Unit, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, United Kingdom. 5. Anglia Ruskin University, School of Medicine, Cambridge & Chelmsford, United Kingdom.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Traumatic amputation of one or more digits can have a serious detrimental effect on social and economic standings which can be mitigated by successful replantation. Little has been recorded on preoperative management before replantation and how this affects the outcomes of the replanted digit. METHODS: A retrospective cohort study was conducted and data collected over an 18-month period. Three protocols for preoperative management were examined: minimal (basic wound management), complete Buncke (anticoagulation, dry dressing on amputate placed on indirect ice and absence of a digital block), and incomplete (any two or three criteria from complete Buncke in addition to the minimal) protocols. Data was collected on survival rate, secondary operations, and complication rate. Function was defined by sensation, range of movement, and strength. RESULTS: Seventy four of 177 digits were replanted with an overall survival rate of 86.5%. The rates for minimal, incomplete, and complete protocols were 95%, 87%, and 91%, respectively, and not significantly different. The complication rate was significantly different between the complete (20%) and minimal (60%) protocols (p = 0.0484). Differences in sensation and grip strength were statistically significant between protocols (p = 0.0465 and p = 0.0430, respectively). Anticoagulation, no digital block and dry gauze all showed reduced complication rates in comparison to their counterparts. CONCLUSIONS: The Buncke protocol, which includes anticoagulation, no digital block, and dry gauze, was found to significantly reduce the complication rate which suggests that it prevents compromise of tissue integrity. Significant differences were found between protocols for sensation and grip strength. A higher-powered study is needed to investigate the effects of preoperative management on complication rates and functional outcomes. Thieme Medical Publishers 333 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY 10001, USA.
BACKGROUND:Traumatic amputation of one or more digits can have a serious detrimental effect on social and economic standings which can be mitigated by successful replantation. Little has been recorded on preoperative management before replantation and how this affects the outcomes of the replanted digit. METHODS: A retrospective cohort study was conducted and data collected over an 18-month period. Three protocols for preoperative management were examined: minimal (basic wound management), complete Buncke (anticoagulation, dry dressing on amputate placed on indirect ice and absence of a digital block), and incomplete (any two or three criteria from complete Buncke in addition to the minimal) protocols. Data was collected on survival rate, secondary operations, and complication rate. Function was defined by sensation, range of movement, and strength. RESULTS: Seventy four of 177 digits were replanted with an overall survival rate of 86.5%. The rates for minimal, incomplete, and complete protocols were 95%, 87%, and 91%, respectively, and not significantly different. The complication rate was significantly different between the complete (20%) and minimal (60%) protocols (p = 0.0484). Differences in sensation and grip strength were statistically significant between protocols (p = 0.0465 and p = 0.0430, respectively). Anticoagulation, no digital block and dry gauze all showed reduced complication rates in comparison to their counterparts. CONCLUSIONS: The Buncke protocol, which includes anticoagulation, no digital block, and dry gauze, was found to significantly reduce the complication rate which suggests that it prevents compromise of tissue integrity. Significant differences were found between protocols for sensation and grip strength. A higher-powered study is needed to investigate the effects of preoperative management on complication rates and functional outcomes. Thieme Medical Publishers 333 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY 10001, USA.
Authors: Kayla R Rizzo; Michael D Eckhoff; Gilberto A Gonzalez; Shawn Diamond; Leon Nesti; John C Dunn Journal: Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open Date: 2022-09-14