| Literature DB >> 29486707 |
S Gasser1, H Reichenspurner2, E Girdauskas2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Myxomatous mitral valve prolapse is a common cardiac abnormality. Morbus Barlow is characterized by excess myxomatous leaflet tissue, bileaflet prolapse or billowing, chordae elongation and annular dilatation with or without calcification. Extensive myxoid degeneration with destruction of the normal three-layered leaflet tissue architecture is observed histologically in such patients. Autosomal dominant inheritance with an age and sex-dependent expression has long been recognised. This review explores the current understanding of the genetics of bileaflet prolapse, with a focus on genetic analysis and the role for echocardiographical screening of the first degree relatives of affected patients.Entities:
Keywords: Barlow’s disease; Bileaflet mitral valve genetic analysis; Bileaflet prolapse; Morbus Barlow; Myxomatous valve disease and myxomatous mitral valve
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2018 PMID: 29486707 PMCID: PMC5830049 DOI: 10.1186/s12872-018-0755-y
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Cardiovasc Disord ISSN: 1471-2261 Impact factor: 2.298
Fig. 1Trial enrollment showing the number of publications examining patients with myxomatous mitral valve disease who underwent genetic screening and echocardiography or surgery up to 09/2017. Patients with syndromic MVP were excluded. Thus, 7 papers were included in the further analysis
Gives an overview of study designs and methods
| Disse et al. [ | Freed et al. [ | Nesta et al. [ | Monteleone et al. [ | Hagler et al. [ | Thalji et al. [ | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No° of pedigrees included | 4 | 1 | 1 | 1 | – | – |
| No° of individuals included | 64 | 41 | 46 | n/a (> 300) | 48 | 22 |
| Underlying disease | MMVD (in probands during surgery, in relatives by echo) | Mitral valve prolapse | Mitral valve prolapse | Co-existent myxomatous valvular dystrophy and hemophilia A | MMVD (during surgery) | MMVD (during surgery) |
| Exclusion criteria | n/a | (1) Marfan’s syndrome; (2) Genetical linkage to MMVP1 | (1) Marfan’s syndrome /other CTD (2) genetical linkage to MMVP 1 or 2 | (1) Marfan‘s and Ehlers-Danlos syndromes | (1) Marfan’s- syndome, Loeys-Dietz, osteogenesis imperfecta | n/a |
| Echochardiography | Transthoracic, blinded by two physicians | Transthoracic, blinded by two physicians | Transthoracic | Transthoracic, blinded by two physicians | n/a | – |
| Echocardiographic inclusion criteria | 1)Thickness > 5 mm + leaflet displacement > 8 mm + annular displacement | MVP > 2 mm | 1)Classic: | Leaflet thickness > 4 mm | Severe mitral valve regurgitation | – |
| Genetic analysis + Gene expression | Genescan and Genotyper | Linkage and Genehunter, linkage to MMVP1 excluded | SLINK, linkage to MMVP1 + 2 excluded | Linkage analysis | TaqMan gene expression assay | qRT-PCR + Immunhistochemistry |
No° of pedigrees and individuals tested are displayed. Underlying valve disease for each gene defect/ study is shown. Study design (e.g. double-blinded echocardiography, method used for genotyping) as well as in- and exclusion criteria are described
m male, MVP mitral valve prolapse, n/a not available, f female, MVR mitral valve regurgitation, No° number, AML anterior mitral leaflet, MMVP myxomatous mitral valve prolapse, PML posterior mitral leaflet, qRT-PCR quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction
Fig. 2Shows the severity of mitral regurgitation in affected patients (i.e. positive genetic testing) with gene defect “MMVP1”
Fig. 3Shows the severity of mitral regurgitation in affected patients (i.e. positive genetic testing) with gene defect “MMVP 2”
Fig. 4Shows the severity of mitral regurgitation in affected patients (i.e. positive genetic testing) with gene defect “MMVP 3”
Fig. 5The pie chart shows grade of MR from the studies examining the X-linked mode of inheritance. The cumulative data of all 92 screened patients (i.e., echocardiography + genetic analysis) is displayed. Data of genetically affected patients is not provided
Fig. 6Prolapse localization of all affected patients is shown. Patients were considered to be affected either if surgery was performed due to valve regurgitation and myxomatous changes were confirmed by histological examination or if mitral valve prolapse with leaflet displacement of one or both leaflets ≥ 2 mm and leaflet thickening were present in echocardiography
Fig. 7gives an overview of prolapse localization in all patients screened, including relatives of affected patients
Provides a detailed overview about known genetic findings in MMVD
| Disse et al. [ | Freed et al. [ | Nesta et al. [ | Monteleone et al. [ | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Underlying disease | MMVD | MVP | MVP | Myxomatous valvular dystrophy + hemophilia type A |
| No° of included individuals (echocardiography + genetics) | 64 | 28 (11 m, 17f) | 43 | 92 |
| Mean age (years) | 49 | 34 | 55 | 32 |
| Affected individuals (positive in genetic testing) (%) | 25 (39%) | 12 (43%) | 9 (21%) | 21 (23%) |
| MR present | 23 | 10 (3 m,7f) | 9 (5 m,4f) | 38 (14 m, 24f) |
| - Trace to mild | 15 (11 m, 4f) | 8 (3 m, 5f) | 7 (4 m, 3f) | 20 (0 m, 20f) |
| - Moderate | 3 (2 m, 1f) | 0 | 1 (f) | 16 (12 m, 4f) |
| - Severe | 5 (3 m, 2f) | 2 (0 m, 2f) | 1 (m) | 2 (2 m,0f) |
| Individuals with MVP | 25 (39%) (16 m,9f) | 12 (43%) | 9 (21%) | 21 (23%) |
| Prolapse localisation | ||||
| - AML | 10 | 0 | 0 | 16 (12 m, 4f) |
| - PML | 5 | 7 (3 m, 4f) | 1(f) | 9 (8 m, 1f) |
| - Bileaflet | 10 | 5 (1 m, 4f) | 8 (5 m, 3f) | n/a |
| Mean LVEF in MVP patients | n/a | 65.5% | 63.7% | 69 + 8% m / 72 + 6% f |
| Chromosome | 16 | 11 | 13 | X |
| Locus | 16p12.1.-p11.2 | 11p15.4 | 13.q31.3-q32.1 | Xq28 |
| Name of Gene | MMVP 1 | MMVP 2 | MMVP 3 | XMVD |
| Mode of inheritance | Autosomal dominant | Autosomal dominant (incomplete penetrance) | Autosomal dominant | X-linked |
It gives an overview of number of patients screened in each study, patients affected (i.e. positive genetic testing result), genetic mode of inheritance and gene locus. Grade of MR and localization of leaflet prolapse display phenotype and penetrance for each gene
MR mitral regurgitation, m male, f female, MVP mitral valve prolapse, AML anterior mitral leaflet, PML posterior mitral leaflet, EF ejection fraction, No° number, n/a not available
Molecular pathways leading to MMVD discussed in the studies
| Hagler et al. [ | Thalji et al. [ | Geirsson et al. [ | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Underlying disease | Surgery due to myxomatous mitral valve disease, histological confirmation of myxomatous changes | Surgery due to myxomatous mitral valve disease | Surgery due to myxomatous mitral valve disease |
| No° of mitral valves | 48 | 22 | 49 |
| Individuals with myxomatous valves | 24 (50%) | 11 (50%) | 26 (53%) |
| Echocardiographical findings | Severe mitral regurgitation: | n/a | Severe mitral regurgitation in 26 diseased patients, not more than mild MVR in 23 non-diseased patients |
| Control group | Visually normal mitral valves from cardiac transplant recipients | Visually normal mitral valves from transplant patients | organ/tissue donors and explanted hearts of transplant recipients without abnormalities of mitral valve |
| Affected signalling protein | TGF-ß2-; BMP-; WNT/ß-catenin activation | TGF-ß, increased phosphorylation of SMAD2/3, increased oxidative stress | TGF-ß |
Myxomatous valves were obtained through surgical excision of patients with myxomatous changes confirmed by histological examination. Cardiac transplant recipients with visually normal mitral valves formed the control groups. Five different signalling proteins as well as increased oxidative were found to play a role in development of MMVD
No° number, MMVD myxomatous mitral valve disease, n/a not available, MVR mitral valve regurgitation, TGF-ß transforming growth factor beta, BMP bone morphogenetic protein