Recent insights into mitochondrial targeting strategies in liver transplantation.

Ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury in liver transplantation can disrupt the normal activity of mitochondria in the hepatic parenchyma. This potential dysfunction of mitochondria after I/R injury could be responsible for the initial poor graft function or primary nonfunction observed after liver transplantation. Thus, determining the mechanisms that lead to human hepatic mitochondrial dysfunction might contribute to improving the outcome of liver transplantation. Furthermore, early identification of novel prognostic factors involved in I/R injury could serve as a key endpoint to predict the outcome of liver grafts and also to promote the early adoption of novel strategies that protect against I/R injury. Here, we briefly review recent advances in the study of mitochondrial dysfunction and I/R injury, particularly in relation to liver transplantation. Next, we highlight various pharmacological therapeutic strategies that could be applied, and discuss their relationship to relevant mitochondrion-related processes and targets. Lastly, we note that although considerable progress has been made in our understanding of I/R injury and mitochondrial dysfunction, further investigation is required to elucidate the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying these processes, thereby identifying biomarkers that can help in evaluating donor organs.

Introduction

Ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury is a multifactorial process by which cellular damage is initiated in organs during hypoxia, after which cells are then stressed by restoration of oxygen delivery and rebalancing of pH. This phenomenon is a major factor underlying the injury that occurs in liver surgery, mostly during liver transplantation (LT), and remains a source of major complications affecting perioperative morbidity and mortality. Consequently, it is critical to clarify the molecular mechanisms and regulatory processes involved in organ damage after I/R injury, a complex process that comprises a cascade of events that promote inflammation and tissue damage, including energy loss, generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), release of cytokines and chemokines, and, finally, activation of immune cells 1-5.

In I/R injury, one of the most notable features is the deterioration of mitochondrial function coupled with subsequent adjustment of energy metabolism. During ischemia, the absence of oxygen leads to cessation of oxidative phosphorylation (which plays a crucial role in energy production), heightened generation of ROS, and initiation of apoptosis 6.

Currently, to treat patients with end-stage liver diseases or irreversible tumors of hepatic origin, LT is an established therapeutic regimen. However, an obstacle to LT is related to the lack of a donor pool; consequently, the mortality rate among LT waiting-list patients has been estimated to exceed 20%. This shortage has encouraged the adoption of extended criteria for selecting donor organs; however, these organs are particularly susceptible to I/R injury 7-9. In LT, functional and structural damage caused to donor organs by the process of cold preservation/warm reperfusion are major problems, and these can result in a non-functional graft or primary graft dysfunction 10, 11.

To understand liver damage caused by I/R injury, characterizing mitochondrial activity after I/R is critical. The early identification of the cellular and molecular changes that occur might allow the adoption of new strategies that protect against I/R injury, and thus help maintain mitochondrial function and liver energy balance.

Liver Transplantation

LT has developed over the past six decades from an experimental procedure to the standard of care for patients with end-stage liver disease. In LT, the long‑term outcome has been improved as a result of advances in surgical techniques, the subsequent immunosuppressive regimens, in donor liver selection, and in postoperative care. However, during the past few decades, the number of patients awaiting an organ for transplantation has increased 7, 12, 13, and this has necessitated the extension of the criteria for organ donation and the use of marginal donors previously considered inadequate for LT (e.g. allowing for an increase in the age considered suitable for donors, the use of organs after prolonged cold ischemia, or donation after cardiac death or hepatic steatosis) 14. Notably, the risk of primary graft nonfunction after the transplant of fatty donor organs is markedly higher than that after non-steatotic grafts (60% vs 5%).

Severe macrovesicular steatosis (> 60%) has been linked with > 60% risk of primary nonfunction after transplantation, and this has been calculated to be responsible for the rejection of 25% of donor livers 15, 16. As a consequence of the shortage of donors, the MELD score (Model for End-Stage Liver Disease score) was adopted in 2002. The MELD score is used to predict the 3-month mortality from the patient's liver disease, and it was adopted worldwide to help select patients from the recipient waiting list that should receive specific donor organs 17. Selection of the correct donor, particularly in living donor LT, is critical to increase the survival of the graft and the recipient 18.

Diagnosing pre-existing liver disease is a crucial part of donor organ evaluation, and histopathological examination plays an essential role in this analysis and in the assessment of the donor liver. However, despite efforts to improve the quality of the donor liver pool, some of the LT patients will develop initial poor function and primary nonfunction 19, 20.

Currently, the three most common indications for LT are hepatocellular carcinoma, hepatitis C virus infection, and alcoholic cirrhosis. In this regard, other indications are also used, such as those for acute fulminant liver failure (e.g. acute acetaminophen overdose, mushroom poisoning, fulminant hepatitis A or B infection, Wilson's disease, acute Budd-Chiari syndrome, or failed LT), cholestatic liver disease (e.g. primary biliary cirrhosis), and metabolic disorders (e.g. α-1-antitrypsin deficiency, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease) 21, 22.

In LT, the outcome is potently affected by liver preservation, which is one of the most critical component steps of LT 23. The standard practice of liver preservation involves the use of preservation solutions at low temperatures (2-4 °C) under static, cool preservation conditions. In the 1980s, Belzer and Southard designed the University of Wisconsin (UW) solution, which is probably the most commonly used static preservation solution employed under hypothermic conditions, wherein the organ is perfused with cool preservation solution and held on ice; this has become the prevalent method for liver allograft preservation. The UW solution features an intracellular-type electrolyte composition, and to prevent tissue edema, the solution contains three inhibitory molecules: lactobionate, raffinose, and colloidal hydroxyethyl starch 24. Conversely, in the histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) solution, whose potassium concentration is slightly lower than that of the UW solution, the main impairment molecule is the amino acid histidine, and the HTK solution does not contain a colloid 25. Another preservation solution, Celsior, which was developed in early 1990, contains histidine, a low concentration of glutathione, and incorporates lactobionate and mannitol as inhibitors. Celsior and the HTK solution are considerably less viscous than the UW solution 26.

Lastly, in clinical LT, the application of ex vivo machine preservation/perfusion is currently under investigation, and various temperatures (hypothermia or normothermia) and diverse preservation solutions are being tested. The development of new techniques will likely lead to an alteration in the manner in which organs are perfused, preserved, and transported 27-29.

Ischemia/Reperfusion

I/R injury induces damage to a hypoxic organ after oxygen delivery is restored, and this might occur in several clinical situations, such as trauma, hemorrhage, shock, thermal injury, transplantation, and certain types of liver surgery. In contrast to the ischemia under such clinical conditions, cold ischemia is exclusively related to the transplant setting.

The specific period of cold ischemia (used to reduce metabolic activities of the graft) begins when a donor graft is harvested using a cold perfusion solution and ends after the tissue reaches the physiological temperature during the implantation procedures. The cold ischemia process is followed by a period of warm ischemia, which ends with the completion of surgical anastomosis after blood-flow restoration 30, 31. Inevitably, this step is responsible for the major part of the LT injury and the development of graft failure that is coupled with considerable morbidity and mortality in patients 32 (Figure 1).

Figure 1

Schematic timeline of the liver transplantation phases of I/R injury.

The cellular and molecular mechanisms of I/R injury are poorly understood; however, the injury is recognized to affect hepatocytes and biliary epithelial cells. The I/R injury caused by cold ischemia and warm ischemia can produce common and specific effects on various subsets of cells. For example, sinusoidal endothelial cells are more susceptible to the effects of cold preservation than are hepatic parenchymal cells. In the remaining viable endothelial cells, the expression of adhesion molecules is affected, and this accentuates the I/R injury (Figure 2).

Figure 2

I/R injury caused by cold ischemia and warm ischemia can produce common and specific effects on various subsets of cells. For example, sinusoidal endothelial cells are more susceptible than hepatic parenchymal cells to the effects of cold preservation, and the reperfusion phase amplifies the ischemic injury with the preferential involvement of the hepatic parenchymal cells; A- space of Disse; B- sinusoid; C- sinusoidal endothelial cells (with fenestrae); D- biliary canaliculus; E- Stellate cell; F- Kupffer cell; H- hepatocyte; N- nucleus.

Conversely, in the reperfusion phase, ischemic injury can be amplified with the preferential involvement of hepatocytes. During this period, the generation of ROS causes nonspecific oxidative damage to lipids, proteins, and DNA 33.

Two distinct phases follow reperfusion: an early phase that lasts for the first 2 h after reperfusion; and a late phase that extends from 6 to 48 h after reperfusion.

The early phase is characterized by the activation of immune cells and oxidative stress. In the initial stages, the activation of Kupffer cells leads to ROS generation, which causes moderate hepatocellular injury. This oxidative damage is then increased as a consequence of the release of several proinflammatory chemokines and cytokines (e.g. tumor necrosis factor (TNF)‑α, and interleukin (IL)-12 and IL-1β), and this promotes and amplifies the later secondary inflammatory phase 34, 35.

The occurrence of the late phase is mediated by neutrophils, whose involvement depends on the chemokines released in the early stage. These neutrophils release proteases and other cytotoxic enzymes (e.g. collagenase, elastase, cathepsin G, and heparanase) that act within cellular membranes and on matrix components, thereby promoting cellular degradation 36, 37.

Mitochondrial Activity and I/R

Mitochondrial activity is involved in the I/R process, and the change in in this parameter might be critical for I/R injury. The most crucial change induced by I/R injury is related to the deterioration of mitochondrial function and the consequent alteration in energy metabolism.

In cold ischemia, oxygen deprivation and metabolite reduction lead to a reduction in the natural function of the mitochondrial respiratory chain and in ATP synthesis; this results in failure of ATP-dependent enzymes and a concomitant rise in ADP, AMP, and Pi concentrations, coupled with the consequent disturbances in membrane ion translocation and cytoskeletal disruption. During this period, any ATP that is produced is used to preserve the mitochondrial membrane potential, and the ATP yield from glycolysis is insufficient 36,37.

During ischemia, an increase in the intracellular concentrations of H+, Na+, and Ca2+ causes mitochondrial dysfunction. This increase in Na+ is associated with ATP depletion, which inhibits Na+/K+ ATPases. The increased Na+ concentration promotes Ca2+ influx through the Na+-Ca2+ exchanger, which is responsible for the irreversible cell injury that occurs. The intracellular Ca2+ increase associated with Ca2+-ATPase failure mainly affects sinusoidal endothelial cells 38.

The source of ROS generation during hepatic I/R remains unclear; however, it might involve complexes I and III of the electron transport chain or possibly xanthine/xanthine oxidase. ROS promote the peroxidation of the components of the phospholipids (unsaturated fatty acids) of the inner mitochondrial membrane, and this disrupts the electron flow through the electron transport chain. Moreover, during the reperfusion phase, the damage caused to mitochondrial lipids and proteins enhances ROS generation. If the tissue damage occurs for only a short time, mitochondria can repair themselves and continue to generate ATP; however, if a critical period is exceeded, mitochondrial recovery is not possible 39.

During mitochondrial damage, once mitochondrial permeability transition (MPT) has been permanently initiated, the mitochondrial inner membrane collapses, which enables solutes with a molecular mass of up to 1.5 kDa to cross the inner membrane. MPT promotes the release of certain apoptotic factors (such as cytochrome c) from the mitochondrial intermembrane space into the cytosol through channels formed by Bax (a proapoptotic Bcl-2 family member). After I/R, the predominant type of cell death is necrosis, but the onset of MPT can induce apoptosis in the ischemic liver 4, 40-42. MPT is a common pathway leading to both types of cell death after I/R: necrosis and either apoptosis or necroptosis.

Damaged mitochondria are cleared through the selective autophagy process of mitophagy, a catabolic pathway that favors cell survival by preserving energy levels and preventing the accumulation of damaged mitochondria and cytotoxic mitochondrial subproducts 43, 44. At least two types of mitophagy exist: the phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase-dependent and -independent types 45. In normoxia or short ischemia, the demand for mitophagy is negligible because only a few mitochondria are damaged. By contrast, in prolonged ischemia and reperfusion, the increase in Ca2+ and ROS levels induce numerous damaged mitochondria, which must be rapidly removed via mitophagy to prevent autophagy failure caused by the increase in the number of injured mitochondria 46.

Mitochondrial Targeting Strategies against I/R Injury in Liver Transplantation

I/R is a multifactorial process and the animal models used to study it have limitations; thus, most of the animal studies on I/R have not translated to human trials 4. In the literature, multiple therapeutic strategies against hepatic I/R injury have been reported. Furthermore, numerous experimental investigations have suggested that the use of various drugs (synthetic and natural derivatives) could prevent or reduce the injury related to I/R; however, despite these efforts, no 'optimal' drug has been identified to date. Nevertheless, the strong implication of mitochondrial involvement in I/R injury justifies a careful analysis of various available therapeutic options in relation to their effects on mitochondrial function. Diverse therapeutic approaches have been attempted thus far, including those involving the storage process (cold storage, machine perfusion), manual conditioning, and multiple pharmacological conditioning. These approaches can promote a reduction in I/R injury, which indicates the importance of the relationship between mitochondrial activity and the mitigation of I/R injury.

With regard to the aforementioned relationship, the most important mitochondrion-related processes and targets are the following: (1) MPT onset, (2) calcium channel inhibition, (3) autophagy, (4) antioxidants, (5) nitric oxide (NO), (6) TNF-α, (7) apoptosis, and (8) nucleic acids as drugs (Figure 3).

Figure 3

Mitochondrion-related processes and targets

MPT is a phenomenon involved in calcium signaling and cell destruction. A previous study showed that MPT inhibition with cyclosporine A reduced mitochondrial ROS production in response to calcium 47. Moreover, Mg2+, acidic pH, and trifluoperazine were shown to prevent the opening of permeability transition pores; whereas calcium, inorganic phosphate, alkaline pH, and ROS were shown to promote the onset of MPT 48.

Mitochondrial Ca2+ accumulation and overloading are responsible for the cell abnormality associated with I/R injury. In one study, pretreatment with the calcium-channel blocker amlodipine restored cellular normality and counteracted the alteration in mitochondrial enzymes induced by I/R injury 49. In another study, the calcium-channel inhibitor, 2-aminoethoxydiphenyl borate, prevented Ca2+ overloading, cytochrome c release, and cell death during I/R 50.

Mitochondrial autophagy can play a protective role in liver I/R injury 51. Heme oxygenase-1 can prevent liver I/R injury by suppressing inflammation and eliciting an antiapoptotic response, and inhibition of this enzyme reduced autophagy and upregulated apoptosis 52. Furthermore, autophagy inhibition aggravated starvation-induced ROS accumulation, which contributed to hepatocyte necrosis 53.

The deleterious effects produced by ROS could potentially be reduced using antioxidants. For example, mangafodipir trisodium, a powerful antioxidant, exerts a protective effect when administrated to the donor before organ harvesting 54. Furthermore, herbal antioxidants, such as green tea catechins, tetrandrine, quercetin, and trans-resveratrol can efficiently reduce I/R injury and could act directly as antioxidants and indirectly through the activation of Nrf2 55-57. Another example is glutathione, a crucial molecule in the cell's defense against oxidative stress, and N-acetylcysteine, a glutathione precursor, might help to maintain or replenish hepatic glutathione stores 58. Pretreatment with N-acetylcysteine can improve glutathione homeostasis, enhance ATP regeneration, and increase survival 59.

Mitochondria reduce nitrite to NO, and this is usually sufficient to inactivate redox-active iron ions. NO is a signaling mediator involved in numerous cellular activities, such as the regulation of microcirculation and the inhibition of caspase activity in apoptosis pathways 60. Nitrite protects against I/R injury and improves mitochondrial function by inhibiting the iron-mediated oxidative reactions that occur as a consequence of the release of iron ions during hypoxia 61. During liver I/R injury, the protective effects of NO, including the potentiation of hepatic ATP levels, reduce oxidative damage and alleviate the adverse effects of endothelin. However, the safe therapeutic window of NO is limited because large amounts of NO can damage liver tissue 62, 63.

TNF-α is a proinflammatory cytokine that plays a major role in hepatocyte apoptosis and triggers apoptotic liver damage. In mitochondria, TNF-α induces the formation of MPT pores, the release of cytochrome c, and the activation of caspases 64-66. In animal models, TNF-α induces apoptotic liver injury only when hepatocyte-specific transcription is inhibited, whereas in the absence of this inhibition, it protects against liver damage. Thus, TNF-α preconditioning with low doses of TNF-α or the blockade of TNF-α action (e.g. with anti-TNF-α antibodies) prevents hepatocellular apoptosis and liver injury 67.

As a consequence of I/R injury, the mitochondrial respiratory chain is disrupted, and this can lead to ATP loss and initiation of apoptosis through caspase activation and cytochrome c release. Cyclosporine A treatment could serve as a promising adjunct therapeutic approach, because cyclosporine A limits the activation of the apoptotic machinery by inhibiting MPT 68. Moreover, supplementation with dibutyryl-cAMP could promote the inhibition of mitochondrial apoptosis by stimulating the cAMP second-messenger signaling pathway and subsequently reducing the release of cytochrome c into the cytosol 69.

Current data indicate that circulating microRNAs could serve as non-invasive biomarkers because of their association with liver diseases and liver injury. Farid et al. demonstrated that serum levels of microRNAs (e.g., miR-122) increased before an elevation of transaminase levels 70. This could represent a critical finding because the currently used biochemical blood parameters related to liver disease/injury and dysfunction are nonspecific 71.

Some studies relate the role of mitochondria with the genetic regulation by RNA interference72-75(Figure 4).

Figure 4

Interaction between the regulation of gene expression by RNA interference due to the presence of pre-mature (pre-miRNA) and mature (miRNA) microRNAs and the mitochondria system

The use of nucleic acids as drugs represents the ultimate therapy 76. RNA interference (RNAi) is a biological process in which RNA molecules neutralize targeted mRNA molecules by inhibiting gene expression or translation. Several options are available for synthetic and expressed RNAi. The most commonly used form of synthetic RNAi involves the use of small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), which occur naturally in the cytoplasm or are synthesized outside and then introduced into the cell. Intraportal administration of siRNAs targeting caspase-8 and caspase-3 promoted a reduction in lesions induced in the liver by warm I/R via RNAi-mediated inhibition of the expression of caspase-8 and caspase-3, which are both components of the apoptotic process 77. Other RNAi therapies that have been applied to prevent I/R injury targeted IL-1β/nuclear factor kappa B (NF- κB) (transcription-related factors), Fas cell surface death receptor (Fas) and acid sphingomyelinase (ASMase) (apoptosis), and adiponectin (oxidative stress)78-80. Recent advances in nanomedicine have led to progress in the design of RNA/DNA drug-delivery systems, such as the development of a multifunctional envelope-type nano device that can control intracellular trafficking in specific cells in vivo and enables drug targeting to the mitochondrial system 81, 82. MITO-Porter is a specific delivery system to mitochondria that allows the introduction of macromolecules cargoes into mitochondria. To date, this system was used to delivery antisense oligo-RNA with functional effect on mitochondria83, 84.

One of the therapeutic approaches that has attracted the most attention recently is the use of machine perfusion. The first randomized controlled trial comparing normothermic machine perfusion with cold storage revealed that machine perfusion is safe and can preserve liver function outside the body for 24 h. Moreover, using this technique, liver function can be assessed, including bile production and clearance of lactic acidosis 85. In the future, it is believed that it should be possible to assess specific miRNAs during organ preservation to evaluate the potential liver injury related to the I/R process and the RNAi that might be active during normothermic preservation or the reperfusion phase.

Conclusions and Future Perspectives

Although considerable effort has been devoted to studying I/R injury, the molecular and cellular mechanisms involved in this process remain incompletely determined and require further investigation.

In evaluating the quality of donor organs for LT, a critical aspect could be the identification of biomarkers. For example, microRNAs have been established as key posttranscriptional regulators in the liver, and could be used in LT as valuable biomarkers and potential therapeutic targets.

To improve the outcome of the LT, pharmacological agents could be added to the preservation solutions used for the donor liver. Although this has been extensively investigated using animal models, few clinical trials have been conducted, because most of these studies were conducted in unrealistic conditions without the potential to be translated for clinical use 86.

The development of new mitochondrial drug delivery systems could be helpful to use some of these mitochondrial targets directly into the mitochondria 87.

Nowadays, the most promisor's mitochondrion-related targets are the antioxidant agents or caspase inhibitors, which are being studied in Phase II trials 88.

Lastly, because I/R injury is a multifactorial process, it will probably be necessary to perform studies to assess the results of treatment with emergent pharmacological drugs that act on multiple therapeutic targets. Translational research could represent a solution to increase the donor liver pool and improve the outcome of LT 89, 90.