| Literature DB >> 29451924 |
Hillary Klonoff-Cohen1, Ana Navarro2, Elizabeth A Klonoff3.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Every day 43 children are newly diagnosed with cancer. Fortunately, almost 90% of these childhood cancer patients will survive. However, 60-90% of these survivors will experience late effects, health problems that occur months or years after treatment has ended. Late effects could occur as a result of the disease, its treatment, and patient-related factors. The two main objectives of this research are to: 1) Examine the existence of all web-based resources for childhood cancer survivors with acute lymphocytic leukemia which focus on medical and psychological aspects of late effects, and 2) Create an innovative website specifically designed to fill this void.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 29451924 PMCID: PMC5815604 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0193141
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Categorization of specific late effects.
| Involved system | Specific late effects |
|---|---|
| Bone marrow | Anemia, polycythemia, leukopenia, marrow hypocellularity, neutropenia, thrombocytopenia, thrombocytosis, other |
| Skin | Alopecia, atrophy, fibrosis, nail changes, vitiligo, other |
| Obesity | Obesity (based on BMI), other |
| Ear | Hearing loss, otitis externa, otitis media, tinnitus, other |
| Eye | Cataract, dry eye syndrome, glaucoma, retinopathy, uveitis, vitreous hemorrhage, other |
| Cardiovascular | Cardiac arrhythmia, cardiomyopathy, congestive heart failure, hypertension, hypotension, ventricular dysfunction, other |
| Lung | Paranasal sinus infection, pneumonitis, pulmonary dysfunction, pulmonary fibrosis, other |
| Gastrointestinal | Bowel obstruction, colitis, dental abnormalities, chronic enterocolitis, constipation, fecal incontinence, hepatic dysfunction, ileus, malabsorption, mucositis, other |
| Kidney | Hematuria, hemorrhagic cystitis, incontinence, proteinuria, renal insufficiency, renal tubular disorder, other |
| Neurologic | Ataxia, cerebrovascular ischemia, cognitive disturbance, dizziness, hydrocephalus, leukoencephalopathy, memory impairment, mood alteration, neuropathy (cranial, motor or sensory), phrenic nerve dysfunction, seizures, speech impairment, tremor, other |
| Musculoskeletal | Fracture, limb discrepancy, musculoskeletal hypoplasia, osteonecrosis, osteopenia, osteoporosis, scoliosis, other |
| Thyroid | Hyperthyroidism, hypothyroidism, thyroid nodule, other |
| Growth | Growth deceleration, growth hormone deficiency, short stature, other |
| Sexual/puberty | Delayed puberty, gonadotrophin secretion abnormality, gynecomastia, primary gonadal failure, premature menopause, infertility, irregular menses, precocious puberty, other |
| Metabolic | Adrenal insufficiency, dyslipidemia, glucose intolerance, hypocalcemia, hypercalcemia, other |
Current websites on late effects in childhood cancer survivors.
| Patient, Parent/Family, Community and Friends | Pediatric Cancer Patients and Survivors | English, Spanish | No specific information on disparities in pediatric cancer. | "After Treatment" section consists of various physical complications/side effects, financial and healthcare navigation) | Emotional health as well as risk factors, signs and symptoms, resources for general support and definitions | Several links for other organizational sites, support groups, manual for helping create a follow-up plan | Pleasing format with green color scheme, pictures, print outs available. Four main headings by treatment phase and links by interested party on the right. Drop down menus for age and cancer type when entering a heading. | |
| Health care Professionals providing care to survivors of pediatric malignancies | Childhood, adolescent, and young adult cancer survivors | English, some portions translated in French, and Spanish | None | Introduction to problems associated with the heart, dental, endocrine, GI, immune, neurological, pulmonary, and reproductive health after cancer treatment. Includes types of cancer treatment associated with the problem, risk factors for developing problems, precautions and monitoring. | Emotional issues | Several resource links on screening recommendations, and general information on diet and physical activity, education, and payment information for healthcare after completing cancer treatment. | This is not set up as a traditional website. Rather it is resource guide for professionals consisting of a short summary with multiple links on different topics which are downloadable. | |
| Lay Individuals, Professionals (nurses primarily) | All cancers, all ages, though predominantly adults | English, Spanish | One fact found on prevalence rates. | Brief information in "Resources for Young Adults" section (basic facts, financial, clinical, etc.) | "Coping" heading with caregiver information, hospice/bereavement, support (support groups, reading room, art gallery, spirituality and inspiration, humor, holiday survival guide) | "Resources for Young Adults"—some overlap with adult information, but few brief facts about childhood cancers, web chat, annual summit information, clinical nurse information, external links (printable) | Format- plain, white background and text with few images. A lot of text, which is cumbersome at times. Set of associated links for each topic area, which is useful. | |
| Young Adult Cancer Patients and Survivors | Pediatric Cancer Pts and Survivors | English | No direct information but does have an advocacy thread. | Few articles and news feed with some information. Many of the articles are primarily shared personal information or gathered from the public domain and posted. | It is an online cancer support network. Some general information on well-being through personal information, but little specific psychological info. | Many social media resources, both internal and external, including an internal social community. "Cancertainment section". Retreats for survivors, including couple retreats. (printable information). "Welcome to Our World" kit to help with healthcare providers. Financial information and resources for assistance, including scholarship and grant information. | Format- fairly simple with white background and black and red headings and text. Multimedia built into site with online community, videos, blog, and links to Facebook and a Twitter feed. | |
| Young Adult Cancer Patients and Survivors | Pediatric Cancer Pts and Survivors | English | Young adults as an underserved population and provide statistics in a report for approx. 2 pages. No other sociodemographic disparity information. | Have a section on education for YA cancer patients and survivors but not many facts about late effects. Do call for advocacy and development of follow-up care for survivors and that is part of their mission. Have various videos and testimonials that have personal information on this topic. | Also has support network resources, and general information about need for support. Little to no specific psychological information. Support information often advocacy related, such as patient decision-making help. | Several external links for support network sites, general cancer information sites, and specific to their alliances (LIVESTRONG, etc.). Videos produced by the foundation and available. Preventative education modules for schools, prevention facts, and prevention links. Activity links such as "Cancer to 5K" and other donor/survivor events. University outreach section, including scholarship information. | Pleasing format with yellow, white, and blue color scheme, pictures of survivors and events, videos, twitter feed and Facebook link, print outs available. Well laid-out in organization and not overwhelming amounts of text. | |
| Lay Individuals—cancer patients | Long-term cancer survivors (much info geared toward adult survivors of childhood cancer) | English | None available. | Information given via links to books, articles, and websites. Also have brief information by topic provided under "Quick Info/FAQ" link, and much of it is related to late effects (e.g., basic info, health advocacy tips, links to follow-up care plans, etc.). | Very little information. There are references to available information (e.g., 1–2 articles) | "Reading List" link with information for books, articles, and websites for helpful information. Also includes a "How To" section on researching information. Health care provider list by state of clinics that treat long-term survivors. Listserv, survivor stories, | Very plain in layout. Able to navigate easily. | |
| Communities, Families, Cancer Pt's and survivors, Advocates | Pediatric Cancer Pts and Survivors | English | None found. | Have a section in the "Information" table on Late Effects with several links to topics within the site and also external links to organizations and articles. | Have a "Support" heading, which includes financial information and resources, "Remembered Forever" section, bereavement (just links to outside groups) and approximately one page of information on the topic psychological and emotional. This has information for local affiliates who may have face-to-face support groups, online support group links, and brief information on potential referral sources if counseling is wanted. | Very cool iCancer app for keeping your medical care organized. Local affiliates who provide services and help to families. A helpful book for parents and teachers about education and childhood cancer pts. "Advocacy" heading with several links to advocacy organizations, information on how to write your officials, current and past information about legislation, and research-based info. Also have "Awareness" heading with resources for events, organizations for promoting awareness, both internal and external to the group. Information and links for kids and teens, as well as information and links for siblings. Books, newsletters, websites for more information. | Pleasing format with very clean and concise look. Another yellow, blue and white background website. Headings are across the top and when highlighted have drop down menu trees for further information headings. Cool peel-back feature at the top, right hand corner for sponsoring or donating for an event. Homepage has an inspiring video for the annual awareness/celebration of tree-lighting. Also have icons to link to their Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube accounts. | |
| Cancer Patients and Health Professionals | Cancer Patients and Survivors | English | None found. | Fertility being a specific late effect. They do have a section on fertility information specifically for pediatric cancer pts and survivors (2–3 pages, by gender). | They have a link to the LIVESTRONG site where there are resources for support and some information, but nothing specific about psychological effects. It is embedded in some of the information in a general way. | Have a guide for fertility information and resources, which includes resources for finding healthcare, CAM therapies, fertility preservation, etc. by zip code and you can read about the providers and services. Also, have cancer centers of excellence for fertility. Have a risk and options calculator by cancer type and treatment, which shows the risk of developing infertility. One of their major purposes is to help people find financial resources to help with fertility preservation, such as adoption services, sperm and egg preservation, etc. Also, have resources for health professionals, including information, fast facts print outs, options to present about the topic, and research from the field. There is also a "kit" available to help facilitate cryogenic freezing and a link to the website for the kit. They also have the standard resources page with links to organizations and readings about fertility and cancer. | Basic format, easy to follow with major headings listed on the left and tabs on the right for resources guide, calculators, and "kit". Easily navigated and tools are easy to use as well. The resource guide is laid out very well and lots of searching terms available. | |
| Cancer survivors, families (very driven toward pt education and advocacy) | All cancer types, all ages | English, Spanish, and toolbox is available in Spanish audio, transcripts in Chinese | None found. | Not specific information for pediatric late effects, but some general information about late effects of blood cancers. | Have a good amount of information on the emotional aspects of cancer, including case examples and information about talking to your healthcare provider about these topics. Part of the audio and pdf toolkit in "Special Topics". Have information about intimacy as well in the larger section. | Award-winning audio cancer survivor toolkit (available direct from site, downloadable on iTunes, and CD purchase), with a facilitators manual available for healthcare professionals to download for free. A resources guide for a condensed version in a brochure form of the toolkit. Lots of great tips and tools to advocate for your healthcare as a survivor. A few survivor testimonies available too. Searchable resource guide with drop-down menus for location, cancer type, issue, etc. Also an advocacy toolkit. | Nicely laid out and easy to navigate. Have cross-links to topics so that you can get there multiple ways by related topics, or through the homepage headings. Accessible pdf's and audio files, as well as a few video files. Not very many graphics or intriguing visual aspects, but straight forward and clean. | |
| Cancer patients and survivors, families, and scientists and professionals | Leukemia and Lymphoma cancer patients and survivors | English and Spanish | None found. | Have some information about survivorship and late effects in general with links out to guidelines for care and more information. Not many specifics, and mostly links out. | Have a section on "How to help your child cope", (1pg) also how to talk to your child about leukemia/lymphoma, and sibling and parent coping (1pg'ers). | Have links to several resource guides about survivorship and guidelines for treatment of late effects. Advocacy resources such as action alerts and email-writing tools to your congress person, and a toolbox for advocates. Information for financial assistance, finding support, getting information, a discussion board, have an information center call-in, a new dx peer support program, and information that is printable (like fact sheets, etc.). | Has a lot of information and feels a bit overwhelming and crowded in format. Not too difficult to navigate, but a big contrast to something like the Ulman Foundation which provides a lot of info but has less going on so it "appears" easier to navigate. | |
| Lay Persons- Cancer pts and families | All cancers, all ages | English | None found. | None specifically. | This is a support line for all people with cancer. Open to anyone to call in and get support for any stage of treatment and/or survivorship. Open from 8–4:30pm MST. | It is a resource, but also will help those who call in attain resources that they may need for treatment. | It is part of a larger hospital site. Very brief page of information, mostly text, with bullet points. | |
| Parent/Family, cancer survivors | childhood cancer survivors | English | None available. | Discusses the causes of late effects and provides detailed examples of common late effects experienced by childhood cancer survivors. | Have a section titled, "Dealing with uncertainty", but other than this section does not go into much detail on the psychological effects. | At the bottom of the page, there is a box where viewers can go to for more information on the topic. It is subdivided into three different tabs, "For parents, for kids, and for teens", providing relevant information for that age group. | Very plain layout, but it is easy to navigate. There is a lot of information provided in the three pages, yet very few pictures. | |
| Childhood cancer survivors, parent/family | childhood cancer survivors | English | None found | There is a tab under the "Survivorship" section titled, "Late Effects After Treatment Tool". This is a resource where cancer survivors can either input information on their own personal cancer diagnosis/treatment and receive information on late effects specific to them, or choose to not to put in specific information on their treatment and instead have an assessment on their medical concerns. The LEATT takes less than 10 minutes to complete and describes potential late effects specific to the patient, symptoms to watch for, and recommendations/prevention tips to look out for. | In the Survivorship section, there is a tab that provides information for both patients and parents. One of the categories viewers can click on in both is titled, "Emotional Information". It discusses the types of emotions survivors may face, how to deal with stress and anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, how to deal with depression, and information about attending a support group. | There is an entire section titled, "Education and Resources “that directs patients and parents to publications, conferences, webinars, helpful links, the late effects after treatment tool, links for long term follow up clinics, special education information, educational articles and cancer facts. | Plain layout with a white background and blue headings. It is very well organized and easy to follow with the main categories at the top. Instead of having to scroll through an entire section for the information you are looking for, the category is subdivided at the top with the different headings discussed. | |
| Childhood cancer survivors but geared towards surviving cancer in general. For example, if you survive breast cancer and liver cancer the same links are applicable to both of those cancers if you are an adult. | All cancer types, all ages | English | None found | There are two sections under the "For Children" page on the website titled “Late Effects of Childhood Cancer" and "Managing Late Effects of Childhood Cancer." The Late Effects section gives a list of the causes of late effects and a brief description of each type of late effect. The late effects included range from emotional and learning troubles to physical setbacks such as dental and digestive issues. The Managing Late Effects section goes through what to do before, during and after treatment as well as coping and lowering late effects. For example, before treatment includes a list of questions the patients should ask their doctors while the after section includes checkups and screening tests at follow-up clinics. | In the Managing Late Effects section there is a brief description of learning and memory problems as well as emotional troubles that patients may deal with. The information in this section includes that patients may have anxiety, depression, and fear of recurrence. It also includes that patients with memory and learning problems may need referrals school programs or state and county social services. In the "Coping with Cancer" tab there are managing emotions, talking with friends and family, and finding support and information that includes information on how to find counseling and support groups. However, this section is not specifically for childhood cancer survivors and applied to all cancer survivors. | Under the Coping with Cancer tab there is a section titled "Finding Support and Information" that has a subheading "Cancer Specific Resources" that allows users to enter in the cancer they are looking for and the results bring up Cancer Groups and Foundations. For example, upon entering Childhood Cancer into this area, the groups and foundations presented included 21 different childhood cancer foundations with links to their websites and a phone number to contact. Some examples of the foundations are Locks of Love and the Make-a-Wish Foundation. | The appearance of this website is not very exciting. It is plain white with yellow headings and blue text. I found this website very difficult to navigate. All the information pertaining to one type of cancer could not be found in the same area. For example, for childhood cancer there one link but it does not include the resources for Late Effects or Emotional/Psychological Help. That information is in a completely different part of the website. However, this part does include statistics (how many children get and die from childhood cancer), overviews, risk factors, prevention, clinical research, symptoms and signs of childhood cancer. | |
| Parents and loved ones of a childhood cancer survivor | The entire website is for all cancer types and all ages but this specific page is for childhood cancer. | English | The only information found was the difference in treatment effects on sexual development and fertility based on gender. | Late Effects is an entire section for the | The psychological information they include on this page is under two different sections. The first is Brain, which has information about learning disabilities and cognitive impairments. Under the Emotional Issues heading, the information included regards dealing with physical changes, worries about the cancer returning, feelings of resentment, concerns about being treated differently, and concerns about dating, family life, etc. This section does not offer solutions to these issues, it only states that childhood cancer survivors may experience them. | The resources this website offers are pages with more information which include: Fertility and Women with Cancer, Fertility and Men with Cancer, Second Cancers caused by cancer treatment, Cancer information on the internet, Children Diagnosed with Cancer (include subcategories of Dealing with Diagnosis, Financial Issues, Understanding the Health Care System, and Returning to School), and When you're child's treatment ends: A guide for families. In addition to these pages, the website also offers links to other national organizations and specific websites for children and teens to reach out to others. | The format of this page is very formal and unpleasant. The font is black and there is not very much color added to the different headings. There is one picture at the top but it does not seem to be specific to this page and you cannot see everyone's face in the picture. I think the sections on this page should be separated to completely different pages because there is too much information crowding in one area. |