Elizabeth Chuang1, Noa Hashai2, Michele Buonora3, Jonathan Gabison3, Benjamin Kligler4, M Diane McKee5. 1. 1 Department of Family and Social Medicine, Palliative Care Service, Montefiore Medical Center/Albert Einstein College of Medicine , Bronx, NY. 2. 2 Karolinska Institutet Medical School , Solna, Sweden . 3. 3 Albert Einstein College of Medicine , Bronx, NY. 4. 4 Coordinating Center for Integrative Health , U.S. Veterans Health Administration, Washinton, District of Columbia. 5. 5 Department of Family and Social Medicine, Albert Einstein College of Medicine , Bronx, NY.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Chronic pain is prevalent, burdensome, and costly, and there are ethnic and racial disparities in treatment. Acupuncture is effective and safe, but access is limited. Group acupuncture can decrease cost and increase capacity by decreasing clinic space needs and increasing patient volume per acupuncturist; however, the effectiveness and patient acceptability of group and individual session acupuncture have never been directly compared. DESIGN: The Acupuncture Approaches to Decrease Disparities in Pain Treatment (AADDOPT-2) study is a randomized comparative effectiveness trial of acupuncture for chronic pain. Semistructured in-depth interviews were conducted with a subset of patients enrolled in the trial. SETTINGS/LOCATION: Outpatient clinics in an urban, low income area serving a primarily black and Hispanic population. SUBJECTS: Qualitative interviews were conducted with 46 patients; 23 in each arm of the AADDOPT-2 study. INTERVENTIONS: Patients were randomized to receive either individual acupuncture or acupuncture delivered in a small group. OUTCOME MEASURES: Transcripts of the interviews were analyzed using an inductive thematic framework to explore and compare the patient experience in group and individual settings. RESULTS: Patients in both study arms valued the pain relief, improved quality of life, and relaxation experienced during acupuncture. Privacy and mixed-sex groups were cited as a concern by a minority of patients; however, most of those randomized to the group setting noted that these concerns abated after initiating treatment. Differences between arms included the depth of the relationship with the acupuncturist and misgivings related to the treatment space. Group dynamics varied; some groups fostered a supportive, therapeutic interaction, while others were more reserved. CONCLUSIONS: Patients in both arms valued their acupuncture experience. Participants described both positive and negative aspects of the group setting.
OBJECTIVES: Chronic pain is prevalent, burdensome, and costly, and there are ethnic and racial disparities in treatment. Acupuncture is effective and safe, but access is limited. Group acupuncture can decrease cost and increase capacity by decreasing clinic space needs and increasing patient volume per acupuncturist; however, the effectiveness and patient acceptability of group and individual session acupuncture have never been directly compared. DESIGN: The Acupuncture Approaches to Decrease Disparities in Pain Treatment (AADDOPT-2) study is a randomized comparative effectiveness trial of acupuncture for chronic pain. Semistructured in-depth interviews were conducted with a subset of patients enrolled in the trial. SETTINGS/LOCATION: Outpatient clinics in an urban, low income area serving a primarily black and Hispanic population. SUBJECTS: Qualitative interviews were conducted with 46 patients; 23 in each arm of the AADDOPT-2 study. INTERVENTIONS: Patients were randomized to receive either individual acupuncture or acupuncture delivered in a small group. OUTCOME MEASURES: Transcripts of the interviews were analyzed using an inductive thematic framework to explore and compare the patient experience in group and individual settings. RESULTS: Patients in both study arms valued the pain relief, improved quality of life, and relaxation experienced during acupuncture. Privacy and mixed-sex groups were cited as a concern by a minority of patients; however, most of those randomized to the group setting noted that these concerns abated after initiating treatment. Differences between arms included the depth of the relationship with the acupuncturist and misgivings related to the treatment space. Group dynamics varied; some groups fostered a supportive, therapeutic interaction, while others were more reserved. CONCLUSIONS: Patients in both arms valued their acupuncture experience. Participants described both positive and negative aspects of the group setting.
Authors: Brian M Berman; Lixing Lao; Patricia Langenberg; Wen Lin Lee; Adele M K Gilpin; Marc C Hochberg Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2004-12-21 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: C Witt; B Brinkhaus; S Jena; K Linde; A Streng; S Wagenpfeil; J Hummelsberger; H U Walther; D Melchart; S N Willich Journal: Lancet Date: 2005 Jul 9-15 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Claudia M Witt; Susanne Jena; Benno Brinkhaus; Bodo Liecker; Karl Wegscheider; Stefan N Willich Journal: Pain Date: 2006-06-14 Impact factor: 6.961
Authors: Ian Chen; James Kurz; Mark Pasanen; Charles Faselis; Mukta Panda; Lisa J Staton; Jane O'Rorke; Madhusudan Menon; Inginia Genao; JoAnn Wood; Alex J Mechaber; Eric Rosenberg; Tim Carey; Diane Calleson; Sam Cykert Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2005-07 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: M Diane McKee; Benjamin Kligler; Arthur E Blank; Jason Fletcher; Anne Jeffres; William Casalaina; Francesca Biryukov Journal: J Altern Complement Med Date: 2012-08-06 Impact factor: 2.579
Authors: Kevin T Liou; Tony K W Hung; Salimah H Meghani; Andrew S Epstein; Q Susan Li; Sally A D Romero; Roger B Cohen; Jun J Mao Journal: Pain Med Date: 2019-10-01 Impact factor: 3.750
Authors: Sheila N Garland; Kelly Trevino; Kevin T Liou; Philip Gehrman; Eugenie Spiguel; Jodi MacLeod; Desirée A H Walker; Betsy Glosik; Christina Seluzicki; Frances K Barg; Jun J Mao Journal: J Cancer Surviv Date: 2021-02-19 Impact factor: 4.442
Authors: Erica Nicole Reed; Jessa Landmann; Devesh Oberoi; Katherine-Ann L Piedalue; Peter Faris; Linda E Carlson Journal: Evid Based Complement Alternat Med Date: 2020-04-13 Impact factor: 2.629
Authors: M Diane McKee; Arya Nielsen; Belinda Anderson; Elizabeth Chuang; Mariel Connolly; Qi Gao; Eric N Gil; Claudia Lechuga; Mimi Kim; Huma Naqvi; Benjamin Kligler Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2020-02-19 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Belinda J Anderson; Paul Meissner; Donna M Mah; Arya Nielsen; Steffany Moonaz; M Diane McKee; Benjamin Kligler; Mirta Milanes; Hernidia Guerra; Raymond Teets Journal: J Altern Complement Med Date: 2021-03-15 Impact factor: 2.579