Priya S Dhawan1, Danielle Leong1, Lisa Tapsell1, Amaal J Starling1, Steven L Galetta1, Laura J Balcer1, Trenton L Overall1, Jennifer S Adler1, Rashmi B Halker-Singh1, Bert B Vargas1, David Dodick1. 1. Department of Neurology (PSD, LT, AJS, TLO, RBH-S, BBV, DD), Mayo Clinic Arizona, Phoenix; King-Devick Test, Inc. (DL), Oakbrook Terrace, IL; Departments of Neurology (SLG, LJB), Ophthalmology (SLG, LJB), and Population Health (LJB), New York University Langone Medical Center, New York; Departments of Neurology (SLG, LJB) and Biostatistics and Epidemiology (LJB), University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia; and University of Arizona (JSA), Scottsdale.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Sports concussion has an annual incidence of approximately 3.8 million. Over half go unreported and a substantial number may be asymptomatic. A rapid, cost-effective, and reliable tool that facilitates diagnosis of concussion is needed. The King-Devick (K-D) test is a vision-based tool of rapid number naming for assessment of concussion. In this study, we evaluated the utility of the K-D test in real time for identification of symptomatic concussion in youth athletes and to determine if similar impairment (subclinical concussion) exists in youth athletes without an obvious head injury or symptoms. METHODS: Youth hockey players underwent K-D testing preseason, postseason, and immediately after suspected concussion. Additional testing was performed in a subgroup of nonconcussed athletes immediately before and after a game to determine effects of fatigue on K-D scores. RESULTS: Among 141 players tested, 20 had clinically diagnosed concussion. All 20 had immediate postconcussion K-D times >5 seconds from baseline (average 7.3 seconds) and all but 2 had worse postseason scores (46.4 seconds vs 52.4 seconds, p < 0.05, Wilcoxon signed rank test). Nonconcussed athletes saw minimal improvement postseason (43.9 seconds vs 42.1 seconds, p < 0.05) and 51 nonconcussed players assessed before and after a game revealed no significant time change as a result of fatigue. CONCLUSIONS: Rapid number naming using the K-D test accurately identifies real-time, symptomatic concussion in youth athletes. Scores in concussed players may remain abnormal over time. Athletes should undergo preseason and postseason K-D testing, with additional evaluation real time to inform the assessment of suspected concussion. CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE: This study provides Class III evidence that the K-D test accurately identifies real-time concussions in youth athletes.
BACKGROUND: Sports concussion has an annual incidence of approximately 3.8 million. Over half go unreported and a substantial number may be asymptomatic. A rapid, cost-effective, and reliable tool that facilitates diagnosis of concussion is needed. The King-Devick (K-D) test is a vision-based tool of rapid number naming for assessment of concussion. In this study, we evaluated the utility of the K-D test in real time for identification of symptomatic concussion in youth athletes and to determine if similar impairment (subclinical concussion) exists in youth athletes without an obvious head injury or symptoms. METHODS: Youth hockey players underwent K-D testing preseason, postseason, and immediately after suspected concussion. Additional testing was performed in a subgroup of nonconcussed athletes immediately before and after a game to determine effects of fatigue on K-D scores. RESULTS: Among 141 players tested, 20 had clinically diagnosed concussion. All 20 had immediate postconcussion K-D times >5 seconds from baseline (average 7.3 seconds) and all but 2 had worse postseason scores (46.4 seconds vs 52.4 seconds, p < 0.05, Wilcoxon signed rank test). Nonconcussed athletes saw minimal improvement postseason (43.9 seconds vs 42.1 seconds, p < 0.05) and 51 nonconcussed players assessed before and after a game revealed no significant time change as a result of fatigue. CONCLUSIONS: Rapid number naming using the K-D test accurately identifies real-time, symptomatic concussion in youth athletes. Scores in concussed players may remain abnormal over time. Athletes should undergo preseason and postseason K-D testing, with additional evaluation real time to inform the assessment of suspected concussion. CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE: This study provides Class III evidence that the K-D test accurately identifies real-time concussions in youth athletes.
Authors: Kevin M Guskiewicz; Michael McCrea; Stephen W Marshall; Robert C Cantu; Christopher Randolph; William Barr; James A Onate; James P Kelly Journal: JAMA Date: 2003-11-19 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: B L Plassman; R J Havlik; D C Steffens; M J Helms; T N Newman; D Drosdick; C Phillips; B A Gau; K A Welsh-Bohmer; J R Burke; J M Guralnik; J C Breitner Journal: Neurology Date: 2000-10-24 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Marcus H Heitger; Richard D Jones; A D Macleod; Deborah L Snell; Chris M Frampton; Tim J Anderson Journal: Brain Date: 2009-07-16 Impact factor: 13.501
Authors: Patricia R Roby; Kristina B Metzger; Catherine C McDonald; Daniel J Corwin; Colin M Huber; Declan A Patton; Susan S Margulies; Matthew F Grady; Christina L Master; Kristy B Arbogast Journal: Phys Sportsmed Date: 2021-09-21 Impact factor: 2.241