Jeannette Brodbeck1, Eva Fassbinder2, Ulrich Schweiger2, Antje Fehr2, Christina Späth2, Jan Philipp Klein3. 1. Department of Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland. 2. Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Lübeck University, Lübeck, Germany. 3. Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Lübeck University, Lübeck, Germany. Electronic address: philipp.klein@uksh.de.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Types of maltreatment often co-occur and it is unclear how maltreatment patterns impact on comorbidity in depressed patients. METHODS: We analysed associations of maltreatment patterns with a broad range of comorbidities assessed with diagnostic interviews in 311 treatment-seeking depressed outpatients. RESULTS: Latent class analyses identified a "no maltreatment class" (39%), a "mild to moderate abuse and neglect class" (34%), a "severe abuse and neglect class" (14%) and a "severe neglect class" (13%). We found a dose-response association for the first three classes with comorbid disorders, a general psychopathology factor and an interpersonal insecurity factor. Patients in the "severe abuse and neglect" class had increased odds ratios (OR) of suffering from an anxiety disorder (OR 3.58), PTSD (OR 7.09), Borderline personality disorder (OR 7.97) and suicidality (OR 10.04) compared to those without child maltreatment. Patients in the "severe neglect" class did not have a higher risk for comorbidity than those in the "no maltreatment" class. LIMITATIONS: Class sizes in the "severe abuse and neglect" and the "severe neglect" classes were small and findings should be replicated with other clinical and population samples. CONCLUSIONS: A higher severity rather than the constellation of types of child abuse and neglect was associated with more comorbid disorders. An exception were patients reporting solely severe emotional and physical neglect who had a similar risk for comorbidity as patients without a history of child maltreatment. This may be associated with distinct learning experiences and may inform treatment decisions.
BACKGROUND: Types of maltreatment often co-occur and it is unclear how maltreatment patterns impact on comorbidity in depressedpatients. METHODS: We analysed associations of maltreatment patterns with a broad range of comorbidities assessed with diagnostic interviews in 311 treatment-seeking depressed outpatients. RESULTS: Latent class analyses identified a "no maltreatment class" (39%), a "mild to moderate abuse and neglect class" (34%), a "severe abuse and neglect class" (14%) and a "severe neglect class" (13%). We found a dose-response association for the first three classes with comorbid disorders, a general psychopathology factor and an interpersonal insecurity factor. Patients in the "severe abuse and neglect" class had increased odds ratios (OR) of suffering from an anxiety disorder (OR 3.58), PTSD (OR 7.09), Borderline personality disorder (OR 7.97) and suicidality (OR 10.04) compared to those without child maltreatment. Patients in the "severe neglect" class did not have a higher risk for comorbidity than those in the "no maltreatment" class. LIMITATIONS: Class sizes in the "severe abuse and neglect" and the "severe neglect" classes were small and findings should be replicated with other clinical and population samples. CONCLUSIONS: A higher severity rather than the constellation of types of childabuse and neglect was associated with more comorbid disorders. An exception were patients reporting solely severe emotional and physical neglect who had a similar risk for comorbidity as patients without a history of child maltreatment. This may be associated with distinct learning experiences and may inform treatment decisions.
Authors: Anja Schaich; Nele Assmann; Sandra Köhne; Daniel Alvarez-Fischer; Stefan Borgwardt; Ulrich Schweiger; Jan Philipp Klein; Eva Faßbinder Journal: Eur J Psychotraumatol Date: 2021-08-13
Authors: Anna L Westermair; Anne M Stoll; Wiebke Greggersen; Kai G Kahl; Michael Hüppe; Ulrich Schweiger Journal: Front Psychiatry Date: 2018-05-23 Impact factor: 4.157
Authors: Bach Xuan Tran; Thang Van Pham; Giang Hai Ha; Anh Toan Ngo; Long Hoang Nguyen; Thuc Thi Minh Vu; Ha Ngoc Do; Vu Nguyen; Anh Tuan Le Nguyen; Tung Thanh Tran; Nu Thi Truong; Vuong Quan Hoang; Tung Manh Ho; Nhue Van Dam; Thu Trang Vuong; Hung Quang Nguyen; Huong Thi Le; Hoa Thi Do; Mackenzie Moir; Yoko Shimpuku; Meghnath Dhimal; Shalini Subash Arya; Tu Huu Nguyen; Suraj Bhattarai; Carl A Latkin; Cyrus S H Ho; Roger C M Ho Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2018-07-10 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Jolien Rijlaarsdam; Charlotte A M Cecil; J Marieke Buil; Pol A C van Lier; Edward D Barker Journal: Res Child Adolesc Psychopathol Date: 2021-01-22
Authors: Jolien Rijlaarsdam; Edward D Barker; Chiara Caserini; M Elisabeth Koopman-Verhoeff; Rosa H Mulder; Janine F Felix; Charlotte A M Cecil Journal: J Psychiatr Res Date: 2021-05-28 Impact factor: 4.791