Copper(I)-binding properties of de-coppering drugs for the treatment of Wilson disease. α-Lipoic acid as a potential anti-copper agent.

Wilson disease is an autosomal recessive genetic disorder caused by loss-of-function mutations in the P-type copper ATPase, ATP7B, which leads to toxic accumulation of copper mainly in the liver and brain. Wilson disease is treatable, primarily by copper-chelation therapy, which promotes copper excretion. Although several de-coppering drugs are currently available, their Cu(I)-binding affinities have not been quantitatively characterized. Here we determined the Cu(I)-binding affinities of five major de-coppering drugs - D-penicillamine, trientine, 2,3-dimercapto-1-propanol, meso-2,3-dimercaptosuccinate and tetrathiomolybdate - by exploring their ability to extract Cu(I) ions from two Cu(I)-binding proteins, the copper chaperone for cytochrome c oxidase, Cox17, and metallothionein. We report that the Cu(I)-binding affinity of these drugs varies by four orders of magnitude and correlates positively with the number of sulfur atoms in the drug molecule and negatively with the number of atoms separating two SH groups. Based on the analysis of structure-activity relationship and determined Cu(I)-binding affinity, we hypothesize that the endogenous biologically active substance, α-lipoic acid, may be suitable for the treatment of Wilson disease. Our hypothesis is supported by cell culture experiments where α-lipoic acid protected hepatic cells from copper toxicity. These results provide a basis for elaboration of new generation drugs that may provide better therapeutic outcomes.

Introduction

Wilson disease is characterized by loss-of-function mutations in a P-type copper ATPase, ATP7B, which is expressed mostly in liver[1,2]. The WD protein has dual roles, it is functioning in the transport of copper into the trans-Golgi network, for incorporation into the plasma protein ceruloplasmin[3,4], and into the bile, for excretion of excess cellular copper[5]. Defective ATP7B functioning is causing reduced incorporation of copper into ceruloplasmin and copper accumulation primarily in liver and in brain, leading to liver disorders and/or neuropsychiatric symptoms[6].

Unlike many other genetic disorders, Wilson disease is treatable, primarily by copper-chelation therapy, which promotes copper excretion. Several de-coppering drugs have been used for the treatment of Wilson disease, two of which have also been approved by the FDA. D-penicillamine (PA), the first orally administered copper-chelating agent available, was approved for therapeutic use in 1956[7]. PA induces copper excretion into urine[8]; however, it also has many adverse effects[9]. The second oral copper chelating drug, trientine (TR), was approved in 1982. TR also acts by enhancing urinary excretion of copper, however, it is better tolerated than PA[9,10]. In addition to these two major drugs, two other copper-chelating compounds have been used for treatment of Wilson disease in the past: an injectable drug, British anti-Lewisite (BAL or dimercaptopropanol), which was used in the UK in 1951[11] and dimercaptosuccinate (DMS), which has been used in China for half a century already[12]. In Western medicine, BAL and DMS are used primarily for the treatment of arsenic, mercury, and lead poisoning[13,14]. The fifth de-coppering drug selected for our study is tetrathiomolybdate (TTM), which was introduced in 1984 and was used in a limited number of patients with Wilson disease. Initial studies with ammonium TTM[15] and a recently completed Phase II clinical study with bis-choline TTM[16], demonstrate that TTM acts rapidly, resulting in improvements in copper control and this is accompanied by improved neurologic outcomes and stabilization of liver function, with a favorable safety profile[17].

De-coppering drugs should compete for copper ions with cellular Cu(I)-binding proteins, for which the Cu(I)-binding affinities are known[18]. However, the Cu(I)-binding affinities of de-coppering drugs, which are of fundamental importance for understanding their therapeutic action, are currently not known. In the current study, Cu(I)-binding affinities of de-coppering drugs were determined from their competition with two cellular Cu(I)-binding proteins, Cox17 and metallothionein (MT), which have different Cu(I)-binding affinities[18]. These proteins were reconstituted to form Cu1Cox17 and Cu10MT metalloforms and incubated with increasing concentrations of the de-coppering drugs. Demetallation of the copper proteins was monitored by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI MS)[18] and the copper-binding affinities were determined from dose-dependent demetallation curves. The absolute values for dissociation constants (Kd) of Cu(I)-drug complexes were obtained by comparing demetallation potencies of de-coppering drugs with those of copper chelators with known copper-binding affinities such as dithiotreitol (DTT) and diethyl dithiocarbamate (DETC). Analysis of structure-activity relationships suggested that an endogenous biologically active substance, α-lipoic acid (LA), may serve as a potential de-coppering drug. LA was able to protect hepatic cells from copper toxicity in vitro, which further supports its potential as an anti-copper agent.

Methods

Reagents

Chemical reagents: PA, TR, BAL, DMS, LA, ammonium TTM, diethylammonium DETC were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich, DTT (ultrapure) from USB Corporation, DLA from Santa Cruz Biotechnology. Bischoline TTM (WTX101) was provided by Wilson Therapeutics AB. Rabbit apo-MT2A was purchased from Bestenbalt LLC and apo-Cox173S-S was produced as described previously[19]. Recombinant human Cu,Zn-SOD was purchased from Biovision Inc. All solutions were prepared immediately before the experiments in 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH 7.3 buffer in the absence of organic solvents. To avoid oxidation of DTT and proteins, the buffer was saturated with argon.

Reconstitution of proteins with Cu(I) ions

Lyophilized apo-Cox17 was dissolved in 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH 7.3 containing 50 µM DTT and metallated at 1 µM concentration with one equivalent of Cu(I)–DTT complex in the presence of 50 µM DTT. Cu10MT2 was reconstituted in the presence of 10 mM DTT from 3 µM apo-MT2 dissolved in 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH 7.3 by addition of 10-fold excess of Cu(I)–DTT. The stock solution of Cu(I)–DTT complex was prepared by dissolving Cu(II)-acetate at 1.3 mM concentration in argon-saturated 20 mM ammonium acetate containing 10 mM DTT at pH 7.3.

ESI-MS settings and determination of copper-binding affinities

DTT is suitable for applications in ESI MS as being a nonionic compound it does not suppress the ionization efficiency of proteins during ESI-MS substantially, which enables detection of protein peaks even if ligand is present in millimolar concentrations. The Cu(I)-binding affinity of DDT has been studied extensively[18,20], and was therefore used as a standard for determination of Cu(I)-binding affinities of DETC, PA, TR, TTM, BAL and DMS. It should be mentioned that DTT is air sensitive and its Cu(I)-binding affinity depends on pH of solution[20]. Therefore all experiments with DTT have been conducted in oxygen-free argon-saturated solutions at pH = 7.3, where the Cu(I)-binding affinity has reliably been determined (Kd = 5.01 × 10−16 M)[20]. Since DETC, PA, TR TTM and DMS are ionic compounds, they lead to ionic suppression of protein peaks in ESI MS spectra. However, ionic suppression is low at submillimolar concentrations and presumably similar for all protein peaks. In a standard experiment, the reconstituted protein was incubated with increasing concentrations of copper chelators for 1 min and samples were injected into the electrospray ion source of an Agilent Technology 6540 UHD Accurate-Mass Q-TOF MS instrument (Agilent) by a syringe pump at 7 μL/min. ESI-MS spectra were recorded for 10 min in the m/z region from 100 to 3,000 Da using the following instrument parameters: capillary voltage = 3500 V, drying gas = 4 l/min, drying gas temperature 100 °C, nebulizer 15 psig, skimmer voltage = 65 V. ESI MS spectral composition was stabilized after 5 min of monitoring time and spectra between 8–10 min were averaged for further analysis. Obtained ESI MS spectra were deconvoluted using the Mass Hunter software (Agilent). The fractional content of metallated protein forms was calculated from the integrated peak areas for metallated and nonmetallated protein forms. C50 values for compounds have been calculated by fitting the dose-dependent demetallation curve to the simple 1:1 binding isotherm (in case of Cu1Cox17) or Hill equation (in case of Cu10MT). Kd values for the Cu(I)-protein complexes at pH 7.3, 20 mM ammonium acetate, and 25 °C were determined using previously determined Kd values for protein-Cu(I) complexes[18] and the re-estimated apparent Kd for the Cu(I)–DTT complex of 5.01 × 10−16 M[20]. Kd values for PA, TR, BAL, DMS and TTM, were determined by the ability of these ligands to extract Cu(I) ions from Cu1Cox17 or Cu10MT in comparison with DTT (in case of Cu1Cox17) or DETC (in case of Cu10MT) respectively as described above.

Demetallation of Cu,Zn-SOD with TTM

Commercial lyophilized Cu,pan class="Chemical">Zn-SOD was dissolved in argon-saturated 20 mM ammonium acetate pH 7.3 to the final concentration of 5 µM, and injected at different time points into an Agilent Technology 6540 UHD Accurate-Mass Q-TOF MS instrument by a syringe pump at 7 μL/min. ESI-MS spectra were recorded for 10 min in the m/z region from 500 to 3,000 Da using the instrument parameters presented above. ESI MS spectrum of the sample exposed two peaks: Cu,Zn-SOD and partially demetallated Zn-SOD (Fig. S9A). Following incubation of the sample with 10 µM ammonium TTM, there was a time-dependent shift in intensities of the peaks, whereas peak of Cu,Zn-SOD disappeared and peak of apo-SOD appeared in the spectrum (Fig. S9A). Spectral changes could be interpreted with extraction of Cu(I) and Zn(II) ions from Cu,Zn-SOD and Zn-SOD and formation of Cu-SOD and apo-SOD. The demetallation process occurred with a half-life of 23 ± 14 min (Fig. S9B).

Cell culture

Huh7 heical">patocyte derived cellular carcinoma cell line were cultured in Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium (DMEM, Gibco) supplemented with 10% Fetal Bovine Serum (FBS, Gibco) and 50 U/ml penicillin, 50 µg/ml streptomycin solution (PAA) in an incubator at 37 °C and 5% CO2. The medium was changed every 2–3 days and cells were split using Trypsin-EDTA solution (Gibco).

Cell viability measured by WST-1

The effects of CuCl2 on the cells were determined using the cell viability assay WST-1 (Roche). WST-1 assay allows colorimetric measurement of cell viability due to reduction of tetrazolium salts to water-soluble formazan by viable cells. 105 cells were seeded in triplicates in a 96 well plate and cultivated for 24 h. Various concentration (0–100 µM) of CuCl2 were added and the measurements were performed 24 hours after cells treatment. The experiments with no CuCl2 added were used as a negative control. 5 µl/well of WST-1 reagent was added to 100 µl of cell culture medium, incubated at 37 °C for 2 h and absorbance was measured at 450 nm using TECAN Genios Pro microplate reader. For LA testing, cells in triplicates were preincubated with various concentrations (0–100 µM) of LA (dissolved in ethanol) for 24 h and medium was changed to fresh medium, containing 50 µM of CuCl2 and various concentrations (0–100 µM) of LA. Cell viability was determined after 24 h incubation with WST-1 test. Experiments were performed twice.

Results and Discussion

Demetallation of Cu1Cox17 by the de-coppering drugs

All de-coppering drugs were able to depan class="Chemical">metallate Cu1Cox17; however, it occurred at different concentrations with different drugs. Demetallation potency of compounds was defined as the concentration where 50% of Cu1Cox17 was demetallated and was denoted as C50. PA and TR extracted Cu(I) from Cu1Cox17 at millimolar concentrations with the corresponding C50(PA) = 1.47 mM (Figs 1A and S1) and C50(TR) = 1.08 mM (Figs 1B and S1). BAL extracted Cu(I) from Cu1Cox17 at micromolar concentrations with C50(BAL) = 9.38 μM (Figs 1C and S3). DMS and TTM showed very low C50 values: C50(DMS) = 3.14 μM (Figs 1E and S4) and the C50(TTM) was less than 1 μM (Figs 1F and S5). C50 values were determined also for reference compounds, DTT (C50[DTT] = 3.10 mM) (Fig. S6) and DETC (C50[DETC] = 5.28 μM) (Fig. S7). Based on the linear relationship between C50 and Kd values and the known Kd value for DTT[20], we calculated the Kd values for studied compounds and the results are presented in Table 1. As an example we present here the mathematics for calculation of Kd value for DETC. DETC was 587 times more effective Cu(I) chelator than DTT (C50[DTT] / C50[DETC] = 587), which is in line with earlier results obtained with a different ESI-MS setup[18]. Consequently the Kd for Cu(I)-DETC complex should also be 587 times lower as that for DTT and therefore Kd(DETC) = 5.01 × 10−16 / 587 = 8.53 × 10−19 M.

Figure 1

Determination of the relative Cu(I)-binding affinity of de-coppering drugs in competition with Cu1Cox17. Fractional occupancy of Cu(I)-binding sites in Cox17 at different concentrations of PA (a), TR (b), BAL (c), DMS (d) and TTM (e) in a metal competition experiment. Conditions: Cox17 1 μM; 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH = 7.3, DTT 50 μM; T = 25 °C. Results of duplicate experiments are presented with different symbols. The solid line shows the fitting curve with hyperbolic equation (y = P1*(1 − [x/(P2 + x)]) + P3), where P2 = C50.

Table 1

Determination of Kd values for de-coppering drugs. The efficiency of de-coppering drugs to demetallate Cu1Cox17 and/or Cu10MT (C50) was in linear correlation with Kd values for Cu(I)-binding complexes (conditions: 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH 7.3, 25 °C).

Ligand	C50 (mM) for Cu1Cox17	Kd (M)
DTT	3.10 ± 0.26	5.01 × 10−16*
DETC	0.00528 ± 0.00032	8.53 × 10−19
PA	1.47 ± 0.33	2.38 × 10−16
TR	1.08 ± 0.13	1.74 × 10−16
BAL	0.00938 ± 0.00148	1.52 × 10−18
DMS	0.00314 ± 0.00041	5.07 × 10−19
TTM	<0.001	<1.6 × 10−19
DLA	0.498 ± 0.098	8.05 × 10−17
Ligand	C 50 (mM) for Cu 10 MT	K d (M)
DETC	0.772 ± 0.087	8.53 × 10−19
TTM	0.0211 ± 0.0014	2.32 × 10−20

*Taken from reference[20].

Determination of the relative Cu(I)-binding affinity of de-pan class="Chemical">coppering drugs in competition with Cu1Cox17. Fractional occupancy of Cu(I)-binding sites in Cox17 at different concentrations of PA (a), TR (b), BAL (c), DMS (d) and TTM (e) in a metal competition experiment. Conditions: Cox17 1 μM; 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH = 7.3, DTT 50 μM; T = 25 °C. Results of duplicate experiments are presented with different symbols. The solid line shows the fitting curve with hyperbolic equation (y = P1*(1 − [x/(P2 + x)]) + P3), where P2 = C50.

Determination of Kd values for de-coppering drugs. The efficiency of de-pan class="Chemical">coppering drugs to demetallate Cu1Cox17 and/or Cu10MT (C50) was in linear correlation with Kd values for Cu(I)-binding complexes (conditions: 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH 7.3, 25 °C).

Demetallation of Cu10MT by the de-coppering drugs

In the second series of experiments, we explored the ability of different de-coppering drugs to expan class="Gene">tract copper from Cu10MT, which has 42 times higher Cu(I)-binding affinity as compared to Cu1Cox17[18]. TTM demetallated Cu10MT at micromolar concentrations through a stepwise process. First, a complex Cu10MT-TTM was formed with 1:1 stoichiometry (Fig. 2A). Multiple peaks appeared at higher concentrations of TTM, indicative of the binding of a second, third and fourth TTM molecule to the complex and the simultaneous build-up of apo-MT (Fig. 2A). The binding of multiple TTM ions appeared to lead to the opening of Cu(I)-thiolate clusters and dissociation of Cu(I) ions from the protein. As dissociation of Cu(I)-thiolate clusters of Cu10MT occurred cooperatively we did not observe hyperbolic demetallation curves like in case of Cu1Cox17. By this reason fitting of the Cu10MT demetallation curves by the influence of TTM was performed by using the Hill equation[18]. A C50(TTM) value of 21.1 μM was obtained by taking into account all CuMT-TTM complexes (Fig. 2B). Both salts of TTM, ammonium and bis-choline TTM, behaved similarly in ESI-MS experiments. Earlier HPLC/ICP experiments have also demonstrated the binding of TTM to CuMT[21]; however, the exact composition of ternary complexes remained unclear.

Figure 2

Determination of the relative Cu(I)-binding affinity of TTM and DETC in competition with Cu10MT. ESI-MS spectra of Cu10MT in the presence of 1 μM–20 μM TTM (a) and 0.1–7 mM DETC (c). Conditions: MT 3 μM; 20 mM ammonium acetate, pH = 7.3, DTT 10 mM; T = 25 °C. Ions with a charge state + 5 are shown; numbers on the peaks denote the metal stoichiometry of the complex. Number of asterisks denotes number of TTM molecules in the complex. Fractional occupancy of Cu(I)-binding sites in MT at different concentrations of TTM (b) and DETC (d) in a metal competition experiment. Results of duplicate experiments are presented with different symbols. The solid line shows the fitting curve with Hill equation (y = START + (END − START) * x^n / (K^n + x^n)), where K = C50.

DETC also extracted Cu(I) from Cu10MT (Fig. 2C) at millimolar concentrations and the corresponding C50(DETC) was equal to 0.77 mM (Fig. 2D). Other de-coppering drugs were unable to demetallate Cu10MT up to millimolar concentrations. Based on the linear relationship between C50 and Kd values and the known Kd value for DETC (see Table 1), the Kd value for TTM was calculated (Kd = 2.32 × 10−20 M) and inserted into Table 1. The absolute value of Kd for Cu10MT of 4.1 × 10−16 M was first determined in 2010[18] based on the absolute value of available Kd for the Cu(I)-DTT complex known at that time. Subsequently, the Kd for the Cu(I)-DTT complex has been corrected from 7.94 × 10−12 M[22] to 5.01 × 10−16 M (pH 7.3)[20]. Based on the corrected absolute dissociation constant for Cu(I)-DTT complex, the corrected Kd for Cu10MT was calculated to be 2.59 × 10−20 M. TTM had almost equal copper-binding affinity (Kd = 2.32 × 10−20 M) to that of MT. Indeed, TTM can form a 1:1 TTM-Cu10MT complex at concentrations equimolar to MT, whereas at higher concentrations (from 5 to 30 μM) it can extract Cu(I) ions from Cu10MT (Fig. 2A).

Clinical implications of demetallation by de-coppering drugs

The obtained information can be applied to the clinical context. For a sustainable treatment effect in pan class="Disease">Wilson disease, de-coppering drugs must extract copper from intracellular copper stores, which have, however, different Cu(I)-binding affinities. MT has a high affinity for Cu(I) ions and only one de-coppering drug studied, TTM, had the ability to demetallate Cu10MT at low micromolar concentrations. For estimation of the physiological concentration of TTM, we used data from oncology patients where TTM 180 mg/day resulted in Cmax of 5.7 µM[23]. At such concentrations, TTM can partially demetallate CuMT, which most probably forms the basis of its fast and efficient therapeutic action.

MT has one of the highest copper-binding affinities among cellular Cu(I) proteins[18] and TTM may therefore extract copper also from several other essential copper proteins. Other cellular copper chaperones and copper transporters have copper-binding affinities similar to that of Cox17[18] and most probably they can also be demetallated by TTM. Intracellular copper enzymes Cu,Zn-SOD (antioxidative defense) and mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase (mitochondrial electron transfer) have copper-binding affinities comparable to that of MT[18]. However, the dissociation of metal ions from the active sites of these enzymes is very slow[18], which might protect them from fast demetallation by TTM. It has been shown that TTM does not inhibit mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase activity in hepatic mitochondrial preparations at concentrations up to 100 µM even after 16-h incubation[24], strongly suggesting that TTM cannot demetallate cytochrome c oxidase. Nevertheless, in the same study, TTM inhibited Cu,Zn-SOD in a time-dependent manner[24]. Our data confirm that 10 µM TTM can extract copper from 5 µM Cu,Zn-SOD with a half-life of 23 min (Fig. S8). Thus, treatment with high doses of TTM may demetallate Cu,Zn-SOD, which should be taken into account in refinement of therapeutic doses for TTM.

The Kd values for PA and TR were 2.38 × 10−16 M and 1.74 × 10−16 M, respectively. Therapeutic doses of PA and TR (750–1500 mg/day[17]) are substantially higher than that for TTM. The current study suggests that PA and TR cannot effectively compete with CuMT at therapeutic concentrations (approximately 50–100 µM); however, they can partially compete with copper chaperones. At therapeutic concentrations, BAL and DMS effectively demetallated copper chaperones and only partially CuMT; however, the action of DMS is restricted mainly to the extracellular space since it is unable to cross biological membranes.

Structure-affinity relationship analysis and identification of new copper-binding drugs

The Cu(I)-binding affinity of the de-pan class="Chemical">coppering drugs studied varied by four orders of magnitude depending upon the molecular structure of the compounds. One can speculate that the number of sulfur-containing groups in the molecule, which are well adapted for the coordination of Cu(I) ions, is an important determinant of the binding affinity. Indeed, a positive correlation between the Cu(I)-binding affinities and the number of the S-atoms in the molecule (Fig. 3A) was observed: TTM, with four S-atoms, has the highest Cu(I)-binding affinity, and PA with only one S-atom has the lowest affinity. However, the Cu(I)-binding affinity of DTT is considerably different from that of BAL and DMS, although all these compounds carry two SH groups. Thus, not only the number, but also the position of the sulphur-containing groups appears to affect the Cu(I)-binding affinity of compounds. Indeed, the Cu(I)-binding affinity decreased substantially with increasing number of atoms between the sulfhydryl groups: TTM > BAL, DMS > DTT (Fig. 3B). This structure-affinity relationship explains why TTM has the highest Cu(I) affinity of all de-coppering agents studied and opens new perspectives for the rational design of new copper-binding drugs.

Figure 3

Structure-activity relationships. Correlation between the number of sulfur atoms in the molecule of copper chelators and their Cu(I)-binding affinity (a); correlation between the number of carbon atoms separating two SH groups in the molecule of copper chelators including DLA and their Cu(I)-binding affinity (b).

In order to test the validity of this structure-activity relationship and its applicability for design of new copper-binding drugs, we looked for biomolecules with three intercalating atoms between two SH groups and found that dihydrolipoic acid (DLA) fits these criteria. The experimental Cu(I)-binding affinity of DLA was equal to Kd = 8.05 × 10−17 M (Fig. S9, Table 1), which fits well the predicted relationship between logKd and the number of atoms between two SH groups, thus confirming the structure-activity relationship. The Cu(I)-binding affinity of DLA was 2 and 3 times higher than that of TR and PA respectively, however, the affinity was not high enough to directly decopper intracellular high-affinity Cu stores like Cu10MT when tested experimentally (data not shown). In vivo, DLA is formed from α-lipoic acid (LA) by reduction in a cellular environment. LA is a well-tolerated food supplement that is able to cross biological membranes. Considering its higher Cu(I)-binding affinity than that of chelators approved for the treatment of Wilson disease (PA, TR), good membrane and blood brain barrier permeability[25] as well as very good tolerability[26], we suggest that LA might be a suitable de-coppering drug for treatment of Wilson disease. Some exploratory attempts to use LA in Wilson disease have been reported[27,28], however, the potency of LA in the treatment of Wilson disease has not been explored in cellular experiments.

Effect of LA on cellular copper toxicity

To further explore the potential of LA as a de-coppering drug we performed preliminary experiments with Huh7 hepatic cell lines to test the putative protective effect of LA against copper toxicity. Similar experimental setup has been used earlier to demonstrate the protective effect of PA on copper toxicity exerted on hepatic cell lines[29,30]. The results in Fig. 4 demonstrate that copper is toxic to Huh7 cells with LD50 of approximately 30 μM of CuCl2 (Fig. 4a) and LA exerts a clear dose-dependent protective effect on toxicity of 50 μM CuCl2 (Fig. 4b). The protective effect on cellular level supports the potential therapeutic role of LA in treatment of Wilson disease, however, the full spectrum of therapeutic activities of LA should be evaluated in further cellular and animal studies.

Figure 4

Effect of LA on cellular copper toxicity. Viability of Huh7 cells determined by WST-1 assay after 24 h of exposure to CuCl2 (a). Viability of Huh7 cells after 24 h incubation with different concentrations of LA and additional treatment with 50 µM CuCl2 for next 24 h, measured with WST-1 test. Data are shown as mean ± SD.