Tracy Flanagan1, Amy Alabaster2, Brigid McCaw3, Nicole Stoller2, Carey Watson4, Kelly C Young-Wolff2. 1. 1 The Permanente Medical Group, Regional Offices, Kaiser Permanente Northern California , Oakland, California. 2. 2 Division of Research, Kaiser Permanente Northern California , Oakland, California. 3. 3 Family Violence Prevention Program, Kaiser Permanente Northern California , Oakland, California. 4. 4 Obstetrics and Gynecology, Kaiser Permanente Antioch Medical Center , Antioch, California.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are common among pregnant women and contribute to increased risk for negative perinatal outcomes, yet few clinicians screen prenatal patients for ACEs. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the feasibility and acceptability of screening for ACEs in standard prenatal care. METHODS: We evaluated a 4-month pilot (March 2016-June 2016) to screen pregnant women (at ∼14-23 weeks of gestation) for ACEs and resiliency in two Kaiser Permanente Northern California medical centers (N = 480). We examined the acceptability of the screening to patients through telephone surveys (N = 210) and to clinicians through surveys and focus groups (N = 26). RESULTS: Most eligible patients (78%) were screened. Patients who received the screening were significantly more likely to be non-Hispanic White, Asian, or of "Other" or "Unknown" race/ethnicity than African American or Hispanic race/ethnicity (p = 0.02). Among those screened, 88% completed the questionnaires; 54% reported 0 ACEs, 28% reported 1-2 ACEs, and 18% reported ≥3 ACEs. Most patients were somewhat or very comfortable completing the questionnaires (91%) and discussing ACEs with their clinician (93%), and strongly or somewhat strongly agreed that clinicians should ask their prenatal patients about ACEs (85%). Clinicians reported significant pre- to postpilot increases in comfort discussing ACEs, providing education, and offering resources (ps < 0.01). Clinicians' willingness to screen for ACEs was contingent on adequate training, streamlined workflows, inclusion of resilience screening, and availability of mental health, parenting, and social work resources. CONCLUSION: ACEs screening as part of standard prenatal care is feasible and generally acceptable to patients. Women's health clinicians are willing to screen patients for ACEs when appropriately trained and adequate behavioral health referral resources are available.
INTRODUCTION: Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are common among pregnant women and contribute to increased risk for negative perinatal outcomes, yet few clinicians screen prenatal patients for ACEs. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the feasibility and acceptability of screening for ACEs in standard prenatal care. METHODS: We evaluated a 4-month pilot (March 2016-June 2016) to screen pregnant women (at ∼14-23 weeks of gestation) for ACEs and resiliency in two Kaiser Permanente Northern California medical centers (N = 480). We examined the acceptability of the screening to patients through telephone surveys (N = 210) and to clinicians through surveys and focus groups (N = 26). RESULTS: Most eligible patients (78%) were screened. Patients who received the screening were significantly more likely to be non-Hispanic White, Asian, or of "Other" or "Unknown" race/ethnicity than African American or Hispanic race/ethnicity (p = 0.02). Among those screened, 88% completed the questionnaires; 54% reported 0 ACEs, 28% reported 1-2 ACEs, and 18% reported ≥3 ACEs. Most patients were somewhat or very comfortable completing the questionnaires (91%) and discussing ACEs with their clinician (93%), and strongly or somewhat strongly agreed that clinicians should ask their prenatal patients about ACEs (85%). Clinicians reported significant pre- to postpilot increases in comfort discussing ACEs, providing education, and offering resources (ps < 0.01). Clinicians' willingness to screen for ACEs was contingent on adequate training, streamlined workflows, inclusion of resilience screening, and availability of mental health, parenting, and social work resources. CONCLUSION: ACEs screening as part of standard prenatal care is feasible and generally acceptable to patients. Women's health clinicians are willing to screen patients for ACEs when appropriately trained and adequate behavioral health referral resources are available.
Authors: Peter F Cronholm; Christine M Forke; Roy Wade; Megan H Bair-Merritt; Martha Davis; Mary Harkins-Schwarz; Lee M Pachter; Joel A Fein Journal: Am J Prev Med Date: 2015-09 Impact factor: 5.043
Authors: Nicolas Berthelot; Karin Ensink; Odette Bernazzani; Lina Normandin; Patrick Luyten; Peter Fonagy Journal: Infant Ment Health J Date: 2015-02-18
Authors: Shanta R Dube; Vincent J Felitti; Maxia Dong; Daniel P Chapman; Wayne H Giles; Robert F Anda Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2003-03 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Kelly C Young-Wolff; Varada Sarovar; Stacy A Sterling; Amy Leibowitz; Brigid McCaw; Charles B Hare; Michael J Silverberg; Derek D Satre Journal: AIDS Care Date: 2019-03-19
Authors: Carey Watson; Julia Wei; Nicole Varnado; Normelena Rios; Tracy Flanagan; Amy Alabaster; Mary Staunton; Stacy A Sterling; Erica P Gunderson; Kelly C Young-Wolff Journal: J Womens Health (Larchmt) Date: 2021-02-04 Impact factor: 2.681