| Literature DB >> 29334939 |
J C Faivre1,2,3, J E Bibault4,5,6, A Bellesoeur7,8, J Salleron9, M Wack10, J Biau4,11,12, M Cervellera4,13, G Janoray4,14, T Leroy4,15, N Lescut4,16, V Martin4,17,18, S Molina4,19, B Pichon4,20, C Teyssier4,16, S Thureau21,22, J J Mazeron23,24, H Roché25,26, S Culine27,28.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Little information is currently available concerning young medical students desire to pursue a career in oncology, or their career expectations.Entities:
Keywords: Career mobility; Education; Internship and residency; Neoplasms; Research; Training
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 29334939 PMCID: PMC5769332 DOI: 10.1186/s12909-018-1117-2
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Med Educ ISSN: 1472-6920 Impact factor: 2.463
Fig. 1Medical and research curricula in France. Footnotes: PACES: [Première Année Commune des Etudes de Santé]: First Common Year for Health Studies. An end-of-year examination obligatory for the continuation of medical studies. DFGSM and DFASM: [Diplômes de Formations Générales ou Approfondies en Sciences Médicales]: Diplomas of General or Advanced Training in Medical Sciences. ECN: [Epreuves Classantes Nationales]. Students can enrol in national ranking exams (called ECN) and choose according to their ranking position a specialty and an assigned health region in which to complete their internship. Residency: Access to a career in oncology in France is possible with two types of diploma: the DES for a duration of 5 years with three options: radiation oncology, medical oncology or onco-haematology; and the DESC. The DES diploma qualifies practitioners and confers exclusive practice. The DESC in oncology is open to holders of the various DESs in medical or surgical specialities, certifies specific additional training in oncology, and confers limited practice of cancerology in the field of the initial DES (pulmonology, hepato-gastroenterology, etc.). Post-residency: Residents usually complete their training with a post-residency position to hone their skills and develop professional autonomy
Baseline characteristics of the respondents
| Characteristics | % (n/N) |
|---|---|
| Male | 47.8 (241/504) |
| Status | |
| Intern | 80.4 (406/505) |
| Assistant Professor | 16.0 (81/505) |
| Hospital Assistant Specialist | 3.6 (18/505) |
| Specialities | |
| DES in Oncology | 60.2 (304/505) |
| medical oncology option | 20.8 (105/505) |
| radiation oncology option | 36.0 (182/505) |
| haematology/oncology option | 3.4 (17/505) |
| Other DES in the DESC in Cancerology | 39.8 (201/505) |
| Family situation | |
| Couple | 70.3 (353/502) |
| Spouse’s socio-professional category | |
| Doctor | 47.2 (167/354) |
| Manager, professional | 28.8 (102/354) |
| Intermediate professional | 9.0 (32/354) |
| Craftsperson, merchant, | 1.4 (5/354) |
| Employee | 5.9 (21/354) |
| Labourer | 0.0 (0/354) |
| Student | 6.2 (22/354) |
| Looking for employment | 1.4 (5/354) |
| Child(ren) | 20.5 (103/503) |
Determining factors in the decision to practice oncology
| Total | DES | Radiation oncology | Onco-haematology | Medical oncology | Other | Overall p | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cross-sectional nature | 70.8 (357) | 74.7 (227) | 73.1 (133) | 64.7 (11) | 62.9 (66) | 35.5 (71) | 0.05 |
| Depth and variety of human relations | 56.3 (284) | 65.8 (200) | 57.1 (104) | 76.5 (13) | 79.0 (83) | 42.0 (82) | |
| Multi-profession and multi-disciplinary field of work | 50.2 (253) | 59.9 (182) | 57.7 (105) | 64.7 (11) | 62.9 (66) | 35.5 (71) | |
| Clinical | 49.6 (250) | 44.1 (134) | 38.5 (70) | 52.9 (9) | 52.4 (55) | 58.0 (116) | |
| Technical level | 44.0 (222) | 46.4 (141) | 67.0 (122) | 11. 8 (2) | 16.2 (17) | 40.5 (81) | |
| ECN ranking | 41.9 (211) | 44.1 (134) | 50.0 (91) | 23.5 (4) | 37.1 (39) | 38.5 (77) | 0.03 |
| Research | 35.9 (181) | 37.8 (115) | 26.9 (49) | 58.8 (10) | 53.3 (56) | 33.0 (66) | |
| Work-life balance | 35.7 (180) | 50.7 (154) | 65.9 (120) | 5.9 (1) | 31.4 (33) | 13.0 (26) | |
| Geographic ties | 20.6 (104) | 18.1 (55) | 18.7 (34) | 17.6 (3) | 17.1 (18) | 24.5 (49) | 0.39 |
| Personalized medicine | 19.2 (97) | 20.4 (62) | 12.6 (23) | 35.3 (6) | 31.4 (33) | 17.5 (35) | |
| Family ties | 19.0 (96) | 16.1 (49) | 15.9 (29) | 17.6 (3) | 16.2 (17) | 23.5 (47) | 0.29 |
| Working conditions | 17.7 (89) | 23.4 (71) | 34.1 (62) | 5.9 (1) | 7.6 (8) | 9.0 (18) | |
| Remuneration | 12.5 (63) | 19.1 (58) | 26.9 (49) | 0 (0) | 8.6 (9) | 2.5 (5) |
ECN (Epreuves Classantes Nationales). Overall p = overall comparisons between the four groups (Radiation oncology, Onco-haematology, Medical oncology and Other DES)
Career expectations of the respondents
| Career expectations | % (n/N) |
|---|---|
| Career in a public university hospital centre or a cancer centre that does not involve teaching or research | 48.3 (244/505) |
| Career as a doctor/professor | 39.0 (197/505) |
| Career in a general hospital | 35.0 (177/505) |
| Career in a private hospital | 34.3 (173/505) |
| Career in the health care industry | 2.4 (12/505) |
The respondents concerns for the future
| Total | DES Oncology % (n)0 | Radiation | Onco-haematology % (n)0 | Medical oncology % (n) | Others | Overall p | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Workload too heavy | 52.8 (237) | 50.4 (136) | 46.2 (74) | 52.9 (9) | 57.0 (53) | 56.4 (101) | 0.23 |
| Shortage of openings | 40.8 (183) | 42.2 (114) | 41.2 (66) | 52.9 (9) | 41.9 (39) | 38.5 (69) | 0.69 |
| Lack of work-life balance | 33.4 (150) | 27.4 (74) | 26.2 (42) | 58.8 (10) | 23.7 (22) | 42.5 (76) | p < 0.001 |
| Insufficient income | 24.5 (110) | 22.6 (61) | 17.5 (28) | 17.6 (3) | 32.3 (30) | 27.4 (49) | 0.04 |
| Not what I want to do | 24.1 (108) | 25.6 (69) | 25.0 (40) | 17.6 (3) | 28.0 (26) | 21.8 (39) | 0.66 |
| Uncertainty surrounding freedom of establishment | 20.5 (92) | 22.2 (60) | 28.8 (46) | 0 (0) | 15.1 (14) | 17.9 (32) | p < 0.001 |
| Shortage of openings for spouse | 16.9 (76) | 18.1 (49) | 20.6 (33) | 11.8 (2) | 15.1 (14) | 15.1 (27) | 0.51 |
| Professional isolation | 6.9 (31) | 9.6 (26) | 8.1 (13) | 11.8 (2) | 11.8 (11) | 2.8 (5) | 0.01 |
Overall p = overall comparisons between the four groups (Radiation oncology, Onco-haematology, Medical oncology and Other DES)
Determining factors in the decision to complete a Master’s degree in addition to the medical curriculum
| Total | DES Oncology | Radiation | Onco-haematology | Medical oncology | Others | Overall p | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Openness, curiosity, interest in research | 71.7 (119) | 70.2 (66) | 64.4 (29) | 50 (2) | 77.8 (35) | 73.6 (53) | 0.33 |
| Training complementary to research | 50.0 (83) | 41.5 (39) | 31.1 (14) | 25.0 (1) | 53.3 (24) | 61.1 (44) | 0.008 |
| Career in a university hospital | 47.0 (78) | 45.7 (43) | 57.8 (26) | 50.0 (2) | 33.3 (15) | 48.6 (35) | 0.12 |
| Prerequisite for fellowship | 42.8 (71) | 37.2 (35) | 33.3 (15) | 75.0 (3) | 37.8 (17) | 50.0 (36) | 0.14 |
| Expectation of a fellowship | 9.0 (15) | 9.6 (9) | 13.3 (6) | 0 (0) | 6.7 (3) | 8.3 (6) | 0.73 |
| Obligation for diploma | 7.8 (13) | 9.6 (9) | 8.9 (4) | 0 (0) | 11.1 (5) | 5.6 (4) | 0.64 |
Overall p = overall comparisons between the four groups (Radiation oncology, Onco-haematology, Medical oncology and other DES)