Maha A H Ghanem1, Tarek A Moustafa2, Haidy M Megahed1, Naglaa Salama1, Sara A Ghitani3. 1. Department of Forensic Medicine and Clinical Toxicology, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Egypt. 2. Department of Orthopedic Surgery and Traumatology, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Egypt. 3. Department of Forensic Medicine and Clinical Toxicology, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Egypt. Electronic address: saraghitani14@gmail.com.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Lack of awareness and recognition of child maltreatment is the major reason behind underreporting. All victims often interact with the health care system for routine or emergency care. In several research works, non-accidental fractures are the second most common injury in maltreated children and it is represented up to one-third of cases. AIM OF THE STUDY: To determine the incidence of different types of accidental and non-accidental skeletal injuries among children, estimate the severity of injuries according to the modified injury severity score and to determine the degree of fractures either closed or opened (Gustiloe-Anderson open fracture classification). Moreover, identifying fractures resulting from child abuse and neglect. This aimed for early recognition of non-accidental nature of fractures in child maltreatment that can prevent further morbidity and mortality. PATIENTS AND METHOD: A descriptive study was carried out on all children (109) with skeletal injuries who were admitted to both Main Alexandria and El-Hadara Orthopedic and Traumatology University Hospitals during six months. History, physical examination and investigations were done for the patients. A detailed questionnaire was taken to diagnose child abuse and neglect. Gustiloe-Anderson open fracture classification was used to estimate the degree of open fractures. RESULTS: Out of 109 children, twelve cases (11%) were categorized as child maltreatment. One case was physical abuse, eight cases (7.3%) were child neglect and three cases (2.8%) were labour exploitation. Road traffic accidents (RTA) was the commonest cause of skeletal injuries followed by falling from height. Regarding falls, they included 4 cases of stair falls in neglected children and another four cases of falling from height (balcony/window). The remaining 36 cases of falls were accidental. The skeletal injuries were in the form of fractures in 99 cases, dislocation in two cases, both fracture and/or dislocation in three cases, and bone deformity from brachial plexus injury in five cases. Fractures of the lower limb (42.2%) and both bones of the forearm (35%) represented the highest incidence of skeletal injuries in children. 54.5% of fractures due to neglect were lower limb fractures due to falling from height. Ninety-nine cases were diagnosed as long bone fractures and classified as the following; eighty patients as closed fractures, six patients as open grade I fractures, three patients as open grade II fractures, three patients as open grade IIIA fractures, four patients as open grade IIIB fractures and three patients as open grade IIIC fractures. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION: Cases of neglect and child abuse represented 11% of all the studied cases, where neglect was the main cause. RTA and falling from height represented the most common cause of skeletal injury in children. Most fractures due to neglect were lower limb fractures resulting from falling from height. This demonstrates the need for early detection of neglect and child maltreatment aiming for early initiation of parental educational programs about child care and safety. Misinterpretation of skeletal injuries due to neglect or abuse can be avoided by proper training of orthopedic and traumatology staff on signs of child neglect and abuse.
BACKGROUND: Lack of awareness and recognition of child maltreatment is the major reason behind underreporting. All victims often interact with the health care system for routine or emergency care. In several research works, non-accidental fractures are the second most common injury in maltreated children and it is represented up to one-third of cases. AIM OF THE STUDY: To determine the incidence of different types of accidental and non-accidental skeletal injuries among children, estimate the severity of injuries according to the modified injury severity score and to determine the degree of fractures either closed or opened (Gustiloe-Anderson open fracture classification). Moreover, identifying fractures resulting from child abuse and neglect. This aimed for early recognition of non-accidental nature of fractures in child maltreatment that can prevent further morbidity and mortality. PATIENTS AND METHOD: A descriptive study was carried out on all children (109) with skeletal injuries who were admitted to both Main Alexandria and El-Hadara Orthopedic and Traumatology University Hospitals during six months. History, physical examination and investigations were done for the patients. A detailed questionnaire was taken to diagnose child abuse and neglect. Gustiloe-Anderson open fracture classification was used to estimate the degree of open fractures. RESULTS: Out of 109 children, twelve cases (11%) were categorized as child maltreatment. One case was physical abuse, eight cases (7.3%) were child neglect and three cases (2.8%) were labour exploitation. Road traffic accidents (RTA) was the commonest cause of skeletal injuries followed by falling from height. Regarding falls, they included 4 cases of stair falls in neglected children and another four cases of falling from height (balcony/window). The remaining 36 cases of falls were accidental. The skeletal injuries were in the form of fractures in 99 cases, dislocation in two cases, both fracture and/or dislocation in three cases, and bone deformity from brachial plexus injury in five cases. Fractures of the lower limb (42.2%) and both bones of the forearm (35%) represented the highest incidence of skeletal injuries in children. 54.5% of fractures due to neglect were lower limb fractures due to falling from height. Ninety-nine cases were diagnosed as long bone fractures and classified as the following; eighty patients as closed fractures, six patients as open grade I fractures, three patients as open grade II fractures, three patients as open grade IIIA fractures, four patients as open grade IIIB fractures and three patients as open grade IIIC fractures. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION: Cases of neglect and child abuse represented 11% of all the studied cases, where neglect was the main cause. RTA and falling from height represented the most common cause of skeletal injury in children. Most fractures due to neglect were lower limb fractures resulting from falling from height. This demonstrates the need for early detection of neglect and child maltreatment aiming for early initiation of parental educational programs about child care and safety. Misinterpretation of skeletal injuries due to neglect or abuse can be avoided by proper training of orthopedic and traumatology staff on signs of child neglect and abuse.
Authors: Ayman Hussain Jawadi; Mohammed Benmeakel; Moath Alkathiri; Maha A Almuneef; Winnie Philip; Manal Almuntaser Journal: Saudi J Med Med Sci Date: 2018-12-14