In this issue of Dementia & Neuropsychologia, the News and Views
section includes an article on the physician’s attitude and conduct when a patient
reaches the terminal phase of a severe and incurable illness. This situation, which
not rarely challenges physicians caring for patients with dementia or other chronic
diseases, is comprehensively analyzed in the article.[1] A recent Brazilian Federal Medical Council
resolution states that: “Doctors are permitted to limit or suspend procedures and
treatment which prolong life of patients in a terminal phase of a severe and
incurable illness, respecting the person’s will or that of their legal
representative”. Although this is very clear statement, Oselka and Oliveira also
included opinions of religious leaders and viewpoints of respected Brazilian
attorneys and jurists on end-of-life, to present a deep and objective analysis of
this complex matter.[1]
Informant questionnaire versus real performance
Another important aspect for clinical and even basic research is related to the
translation of scales originally designed and used in other countries with different
languages and cultures. This subject raises several controversial questions
regarding the methods of translation and adaptation, the need for validation, the
number of participants included in such validation studies, and so forth. In this
issue, Bressan and colleagues[2]
bring up another interesting issue regarding the use of an informant-based
questionnaire of functional activities (FAQ[3]). The results of the FAQ were compared with those based on
observations by the patients actually performing these activities in the
questionnaire. The authors found significant differences amongst the results,
showing that in their sample the informants tended to underestimate patients’
competency. Although these findings should be interpreted with caution and need
replication by other researchers, they are important because the FAQ has been used
by several epidemiologic studies in Latin America.[4-7] Commencing
in 1989, a World Health Organization cross-national project proposed the combined
use of a version of the FAQ and the Mini-Mental State Examination as a screening
tool for dementia.[5,8,9] Chile was
included as one of the six countries participating in this project, and the Chilean
version of the FAQ[5] was translated
into Portuguese and adapted for use in Brazil. It should be noted that the version
used by Bressan and colleagues was directly translated from the original FAQ, while
the cited Brazilian epidemiologic studies[4,6,7] have used the adapted version from that translated
in Chile.
First Brazilian Symposium of Frontotemporal Lobar Degeneration (FTLD)
Frontotemporal dementia, primary progressive aphasia and semantic dementia are the
main conditions included in this group of brain degenerative diseases. Initially
considered rare disorders, and also included in the group entitled “Non-Alzheimer
dementia”, FTLD has come to the fore over the last few years, after new and relevant
clinical and molecular biology findings have brought it center stage in the dementia
research field. As there are increasing numbers of Brazilian studies in FTLD, it was
felt appropriate to initiate regular meetings where researchers may liaise with each
other and with renowned colleagues from abroad. It is a privilege for Dementia
& Neuropsychologia to be able to publish the abstracts of the first
Symposium in this issue.
Authors: R Nitrini; P Caramelli; E Herrera; V S Bahia; L F Caixeta; M Radanovic; R Anghinah; H Charchat-Fichman; C S Porto; M T Carthery; A P J Hartmann; N Huang; J Smid; E P Lima; L T Takada; D Y Takahashi Journal: Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord Date: 2004 Oct-Dec Impact factor: 2.703
Authors: M Baldereschi; M P Amato; P Nencini; G Pracucci; A Lippi; L Amaducci; S Gauthier; L Beatty; P Quiroga; G Klassen Journal: Neurology Date: 1994-02 Impact factor: 9.910