Does the Prostate Imaging-Reporting and Data System (PI-RADS) version 2 improve accuracy in reporting anterior lesions on multiparametric magnetic resonance imaging (mpMRI)?

INTRODUCTION: Multiparametric MRI (mpMRI) is useful in detecting anterior prostate tumours. Due to the location of anterior tumours, they are often diagnosed with a large size and may be suspicious for extra-prostatic extension (EPE). We aim to evaluate whether PI-RADS v2 is more accurate in assessing anterior prostate lesions identified on mpMRI compared to PI-RADS v1.
METHODS: Patients with anterior prostate lesions diagnosed on mpMRI who proceeded to a cognitive fusion transperineal prostate biopsy were identified. Each mpMRI was blinded and read by two experienced prostate MRI radiologists and assigned a PI-RADS v1 and PI-RADS v2 score, and the presence of EPE was estimated. Correlation was made with transperineal histopathology and, where relevant, radical prostatectomy histopathology. Concordance measures between PI-RADS v1 and PI-RADS v2, and between examiners of the same PI-RADS score were calculated using a weighted kappa.
RESULTS: Fifty-eight consecutive men were identified. Concordance between the examiners for PI-RADS v1 and for v2 showed substantial agreement (version 1: weighted kappa 0.71; version 2: weighted kappa 0.69). There was no difference in accuracy when using PI-RADS v1 or PI-RADS v2 to predict clinically significant cancer. There was poor correlation between EPE measured on mpMRI compared with EPE in radical prostatectomy histopathology.
CONCLUSION: PI-RADS v2 is reproducible between radiologists but does not have improved accuracy for diagnosing anterior tumours of the prostate when compared to PI-RADS v1. Multiparametric MRI is accurate at detecting anterior tumours with a sensitivity of 86-88%.