Design of Reduction Process of SnO2 by CH4 for Efficient Sn Recovery.

We design a novel method for the CH4 reduction of SnO2 for the efficient recovery of Sn from SnO2 through a study combining theory and experiment. The atomic-level process of CH4-SnO2 interaction and temperature-dependent reduction behavior of SnO2 were studied with a combination of a multi-scale computational method of thermodynamic simulations and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. We found that CH4 was a highly efficient and a versatile reducing agent, as the total reducing power of CH4 originates from the carbon and hydrogen of CH4, which sequentially reduce SnO2. Moreover, as a result of the CH4 reduction of SnO2, a mixture of CO and H2 was produced as a gas-phase product (syngas). The relative molar ratio of the produced gas-phase product was controllable by the reduction temperature and the amount of supplied CH4. The laboratory-scale experimental study confirmed that CH4 actively reduces SnO2, producing 99.34% high-purity Sn and H2 and CO. Our results present a novel method for an efficient, green, and economical recycling strategy for Sn with economic value added that is held by the co-produced clean energy source (syngas).

Introduction

Recovering (extracting) metallic elements from ores has occurred throughout human history[1-5]. Advanced copper and iron smelting technology was required for the development of civilization in history[1-5]. However, although dry- or hydro-smelting technologies are currently used as a core technology in industry, many of these technologies are not green or environmentally friendly[6-13]. The most common dry-smelting or reduction of ores by carbon and flux typically byproduces CO2 and slag at high temperatures[13-15]. In addition, electrolytic smelting or refining of low-quality metal sources is not cost-effective and produces highly corrosive liquid wastes[6-10,16,17]. During the development of human civilization over the past thousands of years, the most easily mineable and accessible high purity ores have been used first due to economic efficiency. The relative depletion of most economically accessible and mineable ores naturally accompanies the accumulation of used metal wastes; many of these wastes are not appropriately recycled.

Sn (Tin) is a highly demanded industrial material[18-22] that is important for the production of electronics[23-26], sensors[27-30], glasses[31-33], and displays[23,34,35]. The industrial demand of Sn is expected to gradually increase in the near future[20-22] as Sn plays as a central role in Pb-free solder[36,37] and transparent electrode[23,34,35]. The current London metal exchange market price of Sn is approximately $19,900/metric ton as of July 2017[38], which is more than 3 and 10 times more expensive than Cu and Al, respectively[38]. However, currently, only approximately 30% of the annual industrially consumed Sn is being recovered worldwide[39], meaning that the remaining 70% of the Sn used is excluded from the recycling process and is eventually wasted. In principle, recovering a metallic element from used metals (wastes and scraps) requires a similar process to the initial ore smelting. To recover high-purity metal from used metal wastes, a combined smelting-electrolytic refining process is typically required, making the recovery process economically nonadvantageous[6,7,9,10,12,13,16]. Such a complicated recovery process weakens the economic driving force for the recovery of metals, such as Sn, which is consumed heavily worldwide.

Hydrogen or methane have been utilized as a reducing agent for metal oxides[40-47]. For example, methane reduction (MR)[41,46] or hydrogen reduction of ZnO[44,48] was proposed to overcome environmental or economical disadvantages of conventional dry-smelting or recovery techniques. To the best of our knowledge, there are few previous reports on the MR of SnO2. Eroglu and coworkers thermodynamically studied and experimentally demonstrated the feasibility of MR of SnO2 method[42]. They also utilized methane as a reducing agent of various metal oxides[43,45,49] confirming the strong reducing power of methane. However, detailed atomic scale understanding of MR of SnO2, which is necessary for optimization of the MR reduction method, is scarce.

In this work, considering the findings of previous studies and combining the widely applied methane dry reforming (CH4 + CO2 → 2CO + 2H2)[50-53] and the conventional reduction of Sn oxides by carbon (SnOx + C → Sn + COx), we study a novel, environmentally friendly MR method of SnO2. We hypothesized that carbon and hydrogen from methane independently and actively reduce SnO2, making the reduction process highly efficient. Moreover, because our MR method utilizes methane and SnO2 as a reducer and an oxidizer, respectively, the final gas-phase product naturally involves H2 and CO. The mixture of H2 and CO, syngas, can be utilized as a feedstock for further Fisher-Tropsch synthesis[50-53] improving the economic accessibility of our method. Thermodynamic simulations confirmed the availability of the MR of SnO2 and deduced the optimal operation conditions for efficient Sn recovery and syngas (H2 + CO) production. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations revealed the atomic-level understanding of the process. Subsequent experiments demonstrated that the MR method is very promising for economic and environmentally friendly Sn recovery from SnOx-containing industrial wastes.

Results

Theoretical prediction of CH4 reduction of SnO2

Figure 1a and b present the equilibrium concentrations of the mixture for a kmole of SnO2 and n∙CH4 (n = 0~5, continuously increasing by a step of 0.01 kmole) at 1000 °C as a function of the amount of supplied CH4. These diagrams were designed to phenomenologically describe the continuous reduction process that occurs inside the reduction furnace in which a certain amount of SnO2 is exposed to a stream of CH4. In the early phase of reduction, as the amount of supplied CH4 increases, SnO2 was gradually reduced to SnO rather than completely reduced to Sn. At less than R = 0.21 (), all the decreasing amount of SnO2 was reduced to SnO (Fig. 1a). In this early phase, the main gas-phase product was H2O.

Figure 1

Theoretical prediction of the MR of SnO2. (a,b) Equilibrium concentration of the mixture of one kmole of SnO2 and n∙CH4 (n = 0~5, continuously increasing by a step of 0.01 kmole) at 1000 °C as a function of the amount of supplied CH4. (a) , (b) between CH4 and the pre-produced gas-phase products occur as the R ratio exceeds 0.62. (c) Temperature dependent reaction energies of two sets of mixtures of gas-phase molecules. The red solid symbols represent the reaction Gibbs free energy, ΔGr, for H2O + CO2 + 2CH4 → 5H2 + 3CO. The gas phase reaction becomes thermodynamically driven at above 632 °C. (d) Temperature dependent equilibrium relative concentration of a SnO2-CH4 mixture. The initial R value was set to 2.0. Theoretical maximum recovery of Sn was achieved at approximately 550 °C. Although the solid-state reduction of SnO2 to Sn was completed at 550 °C, the relative concentration of the gas-phase products varies as a function of temperature and converges at approximately 1000 °C.

As the amount of supplied CH4 exceeded R = 0.21, SnO2 and SnO both began to decreased producing the fully reduced metallic Sn (Fig. 1a). At an equilibrium condition, the supplied SnO2 can be completely reduced to metallic Sn at R = 0.62. Interestingly, even up to R = 0.62, H2O was the main gas-phase product. At R = 0.62, almost half the total supplied oxygen content from SnO2 was taken up by hydrogen (H2O), and the other half formed CO2 and CO. In the early phase of reduction at less than R = 0.62, the hydrogen and carbon from CH4 were independently acting as reducing agents. The solid-state reduction of SnO2 to SnO and Sn by CH4 was completed at R = 0.62. Up to this point, the amount of SnO2 and SnO was gradually decreasing and was finally reduced to metallic Sn.

As the R ratio exceeded 0.62, the gas-phase reactions occurred between the excess CH4 and the pre-existing H2, CO, O2, and H2O in an oxygen-depleted condition (Fig. 1b). All the oxygen from the SnO2 was already consumed by the hydrogen or carbon. The temperature dependent reaction Gibbs free energy, ΔGr, estimated for the reaction H2O + CO2 + 2CH4 → 5H2 + 3CO, show that ΔGr becomes negative over at above 632 °C (Fig. 1c). A negative ΔGr predicts that if CH4 is continuously supplied to the system over the equilibrium amount for complete solid-state SnO2 reduction to Sn (R = 0.62), the formation of H2 and CO becomes thermodynamically preferred at high temperature. As a result of this gas-phase reaction, a mixture of pre-existing CO2 and H2O and excessively supplied CH4 was converted to H2 and CO at a high temperature (1,000 °C) (Fig. 1b and c).

Figure 1d shows the temperature dependent equilibrium composition map of a mixture of SnO2 and CH4 with R = 2.0. This R value was the critical point where the gas-phase reaction described in Fig. 1c was almost completed. The MR of SnO2 begins at approximately 300 °C. In the temperature range between 300 °C and 550 °C, the sequential solid-state reduction of SnO2 to SnO and Sn was completed. As predicted in Fig. 1a and b, the amount of H2O, CO2, and solid-state carbon produced were rapidly increased in this temperature range. At greater than 550 °C, the gas-phase reaction described in Fig. 1c drives a redistribution of the gas-phase products. Because R = 2.0 is generally the condition with excess CH4, a mixture of CH4, H2O, and CO2 naturally transforms to H2 and CO. Moreover, solid-state carbon began to appear even in the initial phase of the solid-state reduction process due to the presence of excess CH4 in the reduction system. However, this carbon was also decreasing at temperatures greater than 550 °C at which the solid-state reduction is completed and the gas-phase reaction begins. At approximately 1000 °C, the entire gas-phase product was transformed to a mixture of H2 and CO, increasing the H2/CO ratio up to 2.15.

The molecular level process of SnO2-CH4 interaction was studied using DFT calculations. The DFT-calculated binding processes of CH4 on the (100) and (110) facets of the rutile-SnO2 show that SnO2 dissociatively binds CH4, producing a lattice oxygen-bound methyl group (O-CH3 *) and a surface hydroxyl (-OH*) (S0 of Fig. 2a and b).

Figure 2

Energetics of SnO2 reduction by surface-bound CH4. (a) SnO2 (100) surface. (b) SnO2 (110) surface. On both SnO2 facets, formation of H2O was energetically preferred to H2. The red arrows present the preferred reaction pathway. E ad(CH4) represents the adsorption energy of CH4 on the SnO2 surfaces. ΔE of each step represents the energetic state of the current state relative to the previous state. For example, ΔE = 0.51 eV of S1 in (a) means that 0.51 eV of energy is required for CH3 dissociation from S0 to S1.

On SnO2(100) surface (Fig. 2a), the energetics shows that the direct production of H2O from O-CH3 * and –OH* is highly endothermic (ΔE = 1.23 eV) and requires high energy barrier (ΔE b1 = 1.52 eV, a panel below the S0 of Fig. 2a). Oh the other hand, further dehydrogenation of O-CH3 * coupled with the formation of additional -OH* is more energetically preferred (S1 of Fig. 2a, ΔE = 0.51 eV and ΔE b2 = 1.02 eV). We found that, from two separated –OH* groups, the formation of H2O molecule is energetically preferred (S2 of Fig. 2) to the H2 formation (see a panel below S1 of Fig. 2a, ΔE = 1.83 eV) which is again highly endothermic. The desorption of water from the S2 requires only 0.37 eV (see S3 of Fig. 2a). However, further dehydrogenation of O-CH2 * group is endothermic and requires high barrier of 1.12 eV (S4 of Fig. 2a, ΔE b3 = 1.12 eV). Once a O-CH2 * acetylene group is dissociated, H2O and CO or CO2 production follows. Particularly, the preferred formation of H2O is thermodynamically and kinetically favored to the formation of H2, confirming the trend in Fig. 1a. Another interesting feature is that a CO molecule was spontaneously formed upon dehydrogenation of a O-CH* group, as presented in S4 and S5 of Fig. 2a. We also found that this CO molecule directly attacks the surface and be transformed to CO2 with ΔE of −1.61 eV (S7, Fig. 2a). The processes presented in S5 to S7 suggest that solid carbon could directly reduce SnO2. However, as the case of carbon coking generally observed in CH4 reforming catalysis[50-53], sudden deposition of solid carbon may block the surface of SnO2. However, considering that solid carbon would float on the surface of reduced molten Sn, coking would not be a severe issue in MR of SnO2.

An almost identical reduction process was observed on SnO2(110) (Fig. 2b). The notable difference is that the first O-CH3 * dehydrogenation on SnO2(110) is relatively slow compared to that on SnO2(100). Dissociation of a O-CH2 * described in S3 and S4 is energetically and kinetically similar with that on SnO2(100). Most importantly, SnO2(110) surface provides the easier H2O desorption pathways as presented in S2 and S3 (ΔE = 0.11 eV) and S5 and S6 (ΔE = 0.13 eV). Because several high-index facets could coexist on the surface of SnO2 particles or powders, we believe that our DFT-generated SnO2 reduction pathways would proceed in a bi-functional or a multi-functional manner: Dissociation of a O-CH3 * or a O-CH2 * groups and formation and desorption of H2O could occur in a different local area of SnO2.

From the molecular structure points, the carbon from CH4 cannot aggressively reduce SnO2 in the early phase of reduction. The hydrogen atoms of CH4 reduce Sn oxides first, and the carbon from CH4 subsequently reduces the Sn oxides.

CH4 reforming of CO2 (dry reforming, CH4 + CO2 → 2H2 + 2CO) and CH4 steam reforming (CH4 + H2O → 3H2 + CO) have been applied to produce a mixture of CO and H2, which is a feedstock for Fisher-Tropsch synthesis. In general, the molar ratio of H2 and CO in the CH4 reforming product gas varies between 1 (dry reforming) and 3 (steam reforming)[12,21,39,50]. In Fig. 1a, at less than R = 0.62, H2 and CO were minority gas-phase products. However, as SnO2 and SnO are consumed and the gas-phase reactions occur in oxygen-depleted condition between CH4 and pre-produced gas-phase molecules, the H2/CO ratio rapidly increases as a function of the amount of supplied CH4. The rapid increase of the H2/CO ratio is phenomenologically feasible because excess CH4 supplies H, which enters into the system. Moreover, the negative ΔGr also drives the release of H atoms from H2O molecules in the form of H2 molecules.

Typically, CH4 dry reforming operates at high temperatures above 500 °C and is catalyzed by the transition metal or novel metal catalysts[54,55]. It is not clear whether molten liquid Sn in our system catalyzes the reaction described in Fig. 1c. A recent report by Wetzel and coworkers showed that molten Sn facilitates the thermal dissociation of CH4 and thus the formation of solid-state carbon and H2 [56,57]. Considering that solid-state carbon and H2 were increasingly accumulating at greater than R = 2.0 (Fig. 1b), CH4 dissociation by molten Sn may be attributed to the rapid H2 and solid carbon formation.

Thermodynamic simulation results presented in Fig. 3 show that the rate of the gas phase reaction, H2O + CO2 + 2CH4 → 5H2 + 3CO, does not critically affected by the presence of metallic Sn (or molten Sn, Fig. 3a and b). On the other hand, the addition of metallic Sn promotes thermal decomposition of CH4 (Fig. 3c and d). At 550 °C, at which the solid-state reduction is completed, the amount of decomposed CH4 was increased by 19.8 % in the presence of metallic Sn. This result theoretically reproduces the recent experimental findings reported by Wetzel and coworkers[56,57].

Figure 3

Thermodynamic simulations of the Sn effect on the gas phase reactions. (a,b) Temperature dependent equilibrium concentration of gas phase species without Sn (a) and with Sn (b). The presence of metallic Sn does not significantly affect the transformation of H2O + CO2 + 2CH4 to 5H2 + 3CO. (c,d) Temperature dependent concentration of CH4 and decomposed products; H2 and C, without Sn (c) and with Sn (d). Metallic Sn accelerates thermal decomposition of CH4 into C and H2. The numbers in the parentheses represent the equilibrium concentration of CH4, C, and H2 at 550 °C, at which theoretical maximum recovery of Sn was achieved (see Fig. 1d).

Although the MR of SnO2 is not a catalytic reaction, a reasonable amount of the H2 and CO mixture was acquired as a byproduct as the R value exceeded 0.62. At approximately R = 2.0, H2O and CO2 in the system began to be depleted. All the oxygen in the system was taken by carbon-forming CO molecules, and the excess carbon from the CH4 was transformed to solid carbon. During this stage, the increasing H2 content in the system was entirely from the excess CH4.

Experimental confirmation of CH4 reduction of SnO2

To verify the feasibility of the theoretically proposed concept of the MR of SnO2, we constructed a laboratory-scale experimental reduction furnace (Figure S1) with continuously flowing CH4 over the exposed SnO2 powders. Figure 3a and b show the before and after images of an aluminum boat initially loaded with 25 g of SnO2 and reduced at 1000 °C with supplied CH4. Ar-balanced CH4 gas continuously flowed through a quartz tube furnace for a total reduction time of 1 hour (flow rate of CH4: 250 sccm). Inevitably, a large portion of supplied CH4 bypasses SnO2 powders, being decomposed eventually into C and H2. Of course, an industrially applicable furnace should be designed to minimize the amount of bypassing CH4.

The presence of a glittering metallic phase in Fig. 3b shows that SnO2 was reduced to metallic Sn. An XRD analysis confirmed that initial SnO2 was reduced to crystalline β-Sn (Fig. 4c). A data set tabulated in Table 1 shows the high purity of the Sn reduced by CH4. It is remarkable that almost 80% of the supplied Sn was recovered (Fig. 4) even in the test batch experiment. Additionally, the reduced Sn had a high purity of 99.34% (ICP-analyzed). The concentration of the gas phase products shows a high H2/CO ratio of 5.99, which exceeds the theoretical maximum of conventional CH4 reforming (Table 2). As we mentioned above, thermally decomposed bypassing CH4 contributes to the high H2/CO ratio. The thermodynamically predicted H2/CO ratio in our reaction condition is about 2.30, which is close to that of convenient syngas for fuel production[58].

Figure 4

Experimental results of the CH4 reduction of SnO2. Photos of unreduced SnO2 powder (a) and CH4 reduced SnO2 (b). (c) and (d) show XRD spectra of unreduced SnO2 and reduced SnO2, respectively. XRD pattern in (d) demonstrates a typical case of β-Sn. The recovery rate of Sn was 79.9 %.

Table 1

ICP-analyzed composition of the reduced Sn.

Element	Sn	Sb	As	Cu	Fe
Composition (at %)	99.34	0.13	0.001	0.49	0.04

Table 2

Molecular concentration of the gas-phase product from the CH4 reduction of SnO2 analyzed using gas chromatographya.

Molecule	H2 b	COb	CO2	CH4
Concentration (%)	83.9	14.0	1.7	0.4

aH2O was not analyzed.

bH2/CO = 5.99.

Discussion

Development of an environmentally friendly and economically accessible reduction technology for low-quality used metal wastes is key for the sustainable use of limited resources. The MR of SnO2 method is environmentally and economically novel compared to the conventional dry- and wet-reduction methods, as the MR of SnO2 does not involve the use of solid reducing agents and liquid-phase acidic electrolytes. The efficiency of the MR of SnO2 was theoretically proposed and experimentally verified. Moreover, because the MR of SnO2 occurs at the solid-gas phase interface, the reaction can be more effective than solid-solid interactions of conventional dry reduction.

CH4 is a quite efficient and versatile reducing agent because the carbon and hydrogen of CH4 sequentially reduce SnO2 and produce various gas-phase products. This versatility of CH4 is highly beneficial for practical uses because the two most representative reducing agents, hydrogen and carbon, contribute to the total reducing power of CH4.

The theoretical interpretation predicts that as a result of a gas-phase reaction between excess CH4 and pre-produced H2O and CO2, the carbon and hydrogen in the reduction system are eventually transferred to CO and H2. Our theory-experimental combination study found that the H2/CO ratio in the gas-phase product is adjustable by controlling the amount of supplied CH4 and the temperature. Gas-phase reactions between initial gas-phase products of SnO2 and CH4 interaction should be considered for optimization of H2/CO ratio. The economic value added of the MR of SnO2 increases as long as syngas is producible as a byproduct. Industrially attractable quality of syngas could be produced through further optimization of the reaction temperature, total reaction time, and supplied SnO2/CH4 ratio.

In addition, our preliminary calculations show that butane or propane also vigorously reduce SnO2. For instance, we found that propane completed the SnO2 reduction at around 400 °C. Considering that the MR of SnO2 was finished at 550 °C (see Fig. 1c), this preliminary data predicts that the propane reduction of SnO2 would be economically more effective than the MR of SnO2. If their reducing power is verified by experiment, more economically accessible liquid natural gas or liquid petroleum gas could be applied for the reduction of SnO2. As a first step, we are currently working on the optimization of the MR of SnO2 and the utilization of liquid natural gas for SnO2 reduction. The relevant results will be reported in due course.

Conclusions

We studied the mechanism of a novel MR of SnO2 which is a clean, environmentally friendly reduction method for SnO2. DFT calculations and thermodynamic simulations show that the carbon and hydrogen of CH4 bound to the surface of SnO2 independently and sequentially reduce SnO2. Various gas-phase products, such as H2O, CO, CO2, and H2, were produced from the early phase of reduction. The relative composition of the gas-phase product varies as a function of the amount of supplied CH4 and the temperature. In the early phase of the MR of SnO2 (low-temperature or less than R = 0.62 of supplied CH4), hydrogen acts as a dominant reducer. As the supplied CH4 increases, the carbon from CH4 aggressively takes the oxygen from H2O and CO2 forming CO. Hydrogen from CH4 and H2O is released as H2. The optimized operating condition of 1,000 °C and R = 2.0 was suggested from thermodynamic simulation data.

The reliability of this method was confirmed using an experimental batch test performed at 1,000 °C. The high recovery of our MR of SnO2 (approximately 80%) and the high purity (99.34%) of the reduced Sn demonstrate the novelty of our method.

Our results demonstrate a novel MR method for SnO2 as an efficient and green method for recovery of Sn from SnO2. In addition to the reduced metallic Sn, only several gas phase molecules and solid carbon were produced. The H2/CO ratio in the gas-phase product was controllable by the amount of CH4 supplied and the operating temperature. Our results open new avenues for the efficient and economic recovery of highly demanded metallic elements from complex oxide wastes, for example, the recovery of In and Sn from indium-tin oxide.

Methods

Thermodynamic simulations

Thermodynamic simulations were performed with the HSC 6.0 code (Outotec Research, www.hsc-chemistry.com). The relative thermodynamic stability of various Sn, C, O, and H chemical compounds was estimated at temperatures between 0 °C and 1,500 °C. For the initial equilibrium simulation, a mole of SnO2 was balanced with continuously increasing CH4 from 0 to 5 moles to clarify the effect of the SnO2/CH4 ratio (R) on the relative amount of the final products.

Density functional theory calculations

Quantum chemical DFT calculations were performed with the VASP code[59]. A 3 × 2 × 4 rutile (110) and a 2 × 3 × 5 (100) supercells were used for surface reaction calculations and the most bottom triple layer was fixed during the optimization to ensure the structural robustness of the slab models (refer to Figure S2 for supercell geometry). Electron exchange and correlation were modeled using the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE)[60] functional and the interaction between the ionic cores and the valence electrons was described with the projector augmented-wave method[61]. The valance-electron wave functions were expanded in the plane-wave basis set up to the energy cutoff of 400 eV. The convergence criteria for the electronic structure and the atomic geometry were 10−4 eV and 0.03 eV/Å, respectively.

Experimental procedure

A high purity SnO2 electrode, which was previously used in glass-producing electric furnaces[32], was acquired from Corning precision materials (Gumi, Korea). The average particle diameter of SnO2 powders was 135 μm (Figure S3). For the laboratory scale MR of SnO2 experiments, an alumina boat was loaded with 25 g of SnO2 powder and exposed to a stream of CH4 and Ar for 1 hour at 1000 °C. The CH4 flow rate was 250 sccm. The molar ratio of the total supplied CH4 was 1.85 to SnO2. The gas-phase concentration and composition of the reduced Sn was analyzed using gas chromatography (GC) and induced coupled plasma (ICP).

Data availability

The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Supplementary information