Kirby Sainsbury1, Marta M Marques2. 1. Institute of Health and Society, Newcastle University, Baddiley-Clark Building, Richardson Rd, Newcastle Upon Tyne, NE2 4AX, UK. Electronic address: kirby.sainsbury@ncl.ac.uk. 2. Institute of Health and Society, Newcastle University, Baddiley-Clark Building, Richardson Rd, Newcastle Upon Tyne, NE2 4AX, UK; Centre for Behaviour Change, University College London, 1-19 Torrington Place, Fitzrovia, London, WC1E 7HB, UK. Electronic address: marta.marques@ucl.ac.uk.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Depressive symptoms are common in patients with coeliac disease (CD) and may represent a barrier to gluten free diet (GFD) adherence. The aims of this meta-analysis were: (1) to synthesise the evidence on the relationship between depression or depressive symptoms and degree of adherence to a GFD in patients with CD who are already attempting a GFD (i.e., post-diagnosis and onset of GFD), and (2) to summarise the direction of causation of any observed relationship. METHODS: A random effects meta-analysis of 8 cross-sectional studies (N = 1644) was conducted. Included studies measured self-reported depressive symptoms and GFD adherence using either a dietitian interview or validated self-report questionnaire that considered unintentional gluten consumption. RESULTS: There was a moderate association between poorer GFD adherence and greater depressive symptoms (r = 0.398, 95% CI = 0.321-0.469), with marked heterogeneity in the effects (I2 = 66.8%). A sensitivity analysis excluding studies with a moderate/high (k = 1) or unclear risk of bias (k = 1) did not change the results. CONCLUSION: The low number of studies meeting inclusion criteria limits the strength of the conclusions. Available evidence suggests there is an association between poorer GFD adherence and self-reported depressive symptoms; however, studies using longitudinal and prospective designs, and reliable measures, particularly for adherence, are needed to confirm this association. The direction of causation between depression and adherence remains unclear.
PURPOSE:Depressive symptoms are common in patients with coeliac disease (CD) and may represent a barrier to gluten free diet (GFD) adherence. The aims of this meta-analysis were: (1) to synthesise the evidence on the relationship between depression or depressive symptoms and degree of adherence to a GFD in patients with CD who are already attempting a GFD (i.e., post-diagnosis and onset of GFD), and (2) to summarise the direction of causation of any observed relationship. METHODS: A random effects meta-analysis of 8 cross-sectional studies (N = 1644) was conducted. Included studies measured self-reported depressive symptoms and GFD adherence using either a dietitian interview or validated self-report questionnaire that considered unintentional gluten consumption. RESULTS: There was a moderate association between poorer GFD adherence and greater depressive symptoms (r = 0.398, 95% CI = 0.321-0.469), with marked heterogeneity in the effects (I2 = 66.8%). A sensitivity analysis excluding studies with a moderate/high (k = 1) or unclear risk of bias (k = 1) did not change the results. CONCLUSION: The low number of studies meeting inclusion criteria limits the strength of the conclusions. Available evidence suggests there is an association between poorer GFD adherence and self-reported depressive symptoms; however, studies using longitudinal and prospective designs, and reliable measures, particularly for adherence, are needed to confirm this association. The direction of causation between depression and adherence remains unclear.
Authors: Andrew M Joelson; Marilyn G Geller; Haley M Zylberberg; Peter H R Green; Benjamin Lebwohl Journal: Nutrients Date: 2018-04-26 Impact factor: 5.717