Literature DB >> 28985748

Correction to: Trends in use of and complications from intrauterine contraceptive devices and tubal ligation or occlusion.

Brandon Howard1, ElizaBeth Grubb2, Maureen J Lage3, Boxiong Tang4.   

Abstract

Entities:  

Year:  2017        PMID: 28985748      PMCID: PMC5629804          DOI: 10.1186/s12978-017-0386-2

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Reprod Health        ISSN: 1742-4755            Impact factor:   3.223


× No keyword cloud information.
As result of a query from a reader, the authors reviewed the data in Table 2 of the original article [1] and found a number of errors in the prior construction of this data table. A formatting error has also been noticed in Table 1.
Table 2

Complications and side effects associated with IUD insertion and tubal sterilization over time

Copper IUDLNG IUDTubal Sterilization
Complications/Side Effectn (%)n (%)n (%)
Amenorrhea (ICD-9 626.0)
 Total (2006–2011)2385 (8.99)ab 9077 (7.53)ac 9410 (11.06)bc
 2006308 (8.92)941 (7.82)1638 (11.00)
 2007381 (10.02)1278 (7.61)1614 (10.93)
 2008412 (9.21)1873 (7.72)1700 (11.59)
 2009448 (9.20)1845 (7.44)1658 (11.14)
 2010452 (8.62)1518 (7.36)1429 (10.73)
 2011384 (8.20)1622 (7.36)1371 (10.92)
 P Value0.07750.41910.2768
Anemia (ICD-9 280.xx)
 Total (2006–2011)595 (2.24)b 2832 (2.35)c 2823 (3.32)bc
 200667 (1.94)279 (2.32)435 (2.92)
 200778 (2.05)386 (2.30)433 (2.93)
 2008106 (2.37)538 (2.22)492 (3.35)
 2009119 (2.44)600 (2.42)513 (3.45)
 2010135 (2.57)512 (2.48)481 (3.61)
 201190 (1.92)517 (2.35)469 (3.73)
 P Value0.14960.52430.0001
Dysmenorrhea (ICD-9 625.3)
 Total (2006–2011)723 (2.73)ab 3909 (3.24)ac 3678 (4.32)bc
 200690 (2.61)378 (3.14)587 (3.94)
 200785 (2.24)566 (3.37)591 (4.00)
 2008132 (2.95)723 (2.98)598 (4.08)
 2009139 (2.86)807 (3.25)647 (4.35)
 2010137 (2.61)692 (3.35)649 (4.87)
 2011140 (2.99)743 (3.37)606 (4.82)
 P Value0.63880.1234<0.0001
Heavy Menstrual Bleeding (ICD-9 626.2)
 Total (2006–2011)1370 (5.16)ab 10,204 (8.46)ac 11,381 (13.38)bc
 2006204 (5.91)1048 (8.71)1687 (11.33)
 2007198 (5.21)1406 (8.37)1750 (11.85)
 2008224 (5.01)1846 (7.60)1922 (13.10)
 2009256 (5.26)1992 (8.03)2045 (13.74)
 2010261 (4.98)1881 (9.11)2006 (15.07)
 2011227 (4.85)2031 (9.22)1971 (15.69)
 P Value0.3527<0.0001<0.0001
Infection (ICD-9 998.5×)
 Total (2006–2011)15 (0.06)88 (0.07)c 24 (0.03)c
 20064 (0.12)12 (0.10)2 (0.01)
 20071 (0.03)14 (0.08)2 (0.01)
 20086 (0.13)15 (0.06)7 (0.05)
 20092 (0.04)25 (0.10)4 (0.03)
 20100 (0.00)14 (0.07)4 (0.03)
 20112 (0.04)8 (0.04)5 (0.04)
 P Value0.05430.12550.4301
Menorrhagia (ICD-9 627.0)
 Total (2006–2011)53 (0.20)ab 528 (0.44)ac 640 (0.75)bc
 200612 (0.35)48 (0.40)88 (0.59)
 20076 (0.16)58 (0.35)94 (0.64)
 200811 (0.25)84 (0.35)92 (0.63)
 200912 (0.25)89 (0.36)119 (0.80)
 20108 (0.15)121 (0.59)121 (0.91)
 20114 (0.09)128 (0.58)126 (1.00)
 P Value0.1181<0.0001<0.0001
Ovarian Cyst (ICD-9 620.2)
 Total (2006–2011)1157 (4.36)ab 6340 (5.26)ac 6063 (7.13)bc
 2006140 (4.05)539 (4.48)1045 (7.02)
 2007155 (4.08)786 (4.68)990 (6.70)
 2008211 (4.72)1268 (5.22)1076 (7.34)
 2009209 (4.29)1400 (5.64)1039 (6.98)
 2010223 (4.25)1142 (5.53)1003 (7.53)
 2011219 (4.68)1205 (5.47)910 (7.25)
 P Value0.5197<0.00010.0975
Pelvic Inflammatory Disease (ICD-9 614.xx-616.xx)
 Total (2006–2011)93 (0.35)334 (0.28)c 319 (0.37)c
 200613 (0.38)40 (0.33)64 (0.43)
 200712 (0.32)53 (0.32)66 (0.45)
 200823 (0.51)74 (0.30)69 (0.47)
 200915 (0.31)60 (0.24)54 (0.36)
 201012 (0.23)49 (0.24)41 (0.31)
 201118 (0.38)58 (0.26)25 (0.20)
 P Value0.2820.37270.02
Pelvic Pain (ICD-9 625.9, 789.00)
 Total (2006–2011)3222 (12.15)ab 13,891 (11.52)ac 11,750 (13.81)bc
 2006384 (11.12)1395 (11.60)1987 (13.35)
 2007466 (12.25)1915 (11.41)1997 (13.52)
 2008519 (11.60)2729 (11.24)1976 (13.47)
 2009627 (12.88)2897 (11.68)2117 (14.23)
 2010661 (12.60)2419 (11.72)1881 (14.13)
 2011565 (12.07)2536 (11.51)1792 (14.27)
 P Value0.14490.6170.0593
Perforation of Uterine Wall (ICD-9 621.8, 665.3)
 Total (2006–2011)412 (1.55)ab 1558 (1.29)ac 555 (0.65)bc
 200640 (1.16)142 (1.18)57 (0.38)
 200751 (1.34)176 (1.05)76 (0.51)
 200848 (1.07)301 (1.24)91 (0.62)
 200988 (1.81)319 (1.29)119 (0.80)
 201098 (1.87)307 (1.49)103 (0.77)
 201187 (1.86)313 (1.42)109 (0.87)
 P Value0.00140.0023<0.0001

abcChi square pairwise comparisons between groups with the same superscript, p < 0.05. The pairwise comparisons were done for the total for each complication/side effect across years 2006–2011 and not for the individual years

Table 1

Rate of IUD insertion and tubal sterilization over time

Copper IUDLNG IUDTubal Sterilization
YearTotal Nn (%)n (%)n (%)
20061,907,7483454 (0.18)12,028 (0.63)14,887 (0.78)
 Age 15 to 19 y293,35452 (0.02)216 (0.07)38 (0.01)
 Age 20 to 24 y220,950330 (0.15)1257 (0.57)451 (0.20)
 Age 25 to 34 y566,1521735 (0.31)6230 (1.10)6642 (1.17)
 Age 35 to 45 y827,2921337 (0.16)4325 (0.52)7756 (0.94)
20071,940,3013803 (0.20)16,789 (0.87)14,769 (0.76)
 Age 15 to 19 y299,59979 (0.03)416 (0.14)42 (0.01)
 Age 20 to 24 y224,324403 (0.18)1813 (0.81)444 (0.20)
 Age 25 to 34 y583,9551964 (0.34)8533 (1.46)6471 (1.11)
 Age 35 to 45 y832,4231357 (0.16)6027 (0.72)7812 (0.94)
20082,001,7394474 (0.22)24,276 (1.21)14,667 (0.73)
 Age 15 to 19 y308,311102 (0.03)690 (0.22)21 (0.01)
 Age 20 to 24 y237,192455 (0.19)2845 (1.2)410 (0.17)
 Age 25 to 34 y615,5372368 (0.38)12,545 (2.04)6473 (1.05)
 Age 35 to 45 y840,6991549 (0.18)8196 (0.97)7763 (0.92)
20092,016,9164868 (0.24)24,811 (1.23)14,881 (0.74)
 Age 15 to 19 y312,43193 (0.03)777 (0.25)37 (0.01)
 Age 20 to 24 y237,723460 (0.19)2920 (1.23)394 (0.17)
 Age 25 to 34 y625,3232578 (0.41)12,614 (2.02)6232 (1.00)
 Age 35 to 45 y841,4391737 (0.21)8500 (1.01)8218 (0.98)
20101,870,6755246 (0.28)20,639 (1.10)13,313 (0.71)
 Age 15 to 19 y289,736142 (0.05)677 (0.23)37 (0.01)
 Age 20 to 24 y222,812551 (0.25)2101 (0.94)243 (0.11)
 Age 25 to 34 y574,7022782 (0.48)10,316 (1.8)5485 (0.95)
 Age 35 to 45 y783,4251771 (0.23)7545 (0.96)7548 (0.96)
20111,909,3164682 (0.25)22,035 (1.15)12,560 (0.66)
 Age 15 to 19 y295,377116 (0.04)762 (0.26)24 (0.01)
 Age 20 to 24 y265,891601 (0.23)2648 (1.00)280 (0.11)
 Age 25 to 34 y575,7292451 (0.43)10,694 (1.86)5102 (0.89)
 Age 35 to 45 y772,3191514 (0.20)7931 (1.03)7154 (0.93)
P Value for Trend Over Time in the Overall Population<0.0001<0.0001<0.0001
Rate of IUD insertion and tubal sterilization over time The correct version of Table 1 and Table 2 is published in this erratum. Complications and side effects associated with IUD insertion and tubal sterilization over time abcChi square pairwise comparisons between groups with the same superscript, p < 0.05. The pairwise comparisons were done for the total for each complication/side effect across years 2006–2011 and not for the individual years
  1 in total

1.  Trends in use of and complications from intrauterine contraceptive devices and tubal ligation or occlusion.

Authors:  Brandon Howard; ElizaBeth Grubb; Maureen J Lage; Boxiong Tang
Journal:  Reprod Health       Date:  2017-06-08       Impact factor: 3.223

  1 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.