Shawn Walker1, Mandie Scamell2, Pam Parker3. 1. City, University of London, Centre for Maternal and Child Health Research, Northampton Square, London EC1 V0HB, UK; King's College London, Florence Nightingale Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, London SE1 8WA, UK. Electronic address: Shawn.Walker@kcl.ac.uk. 2. City, University of London, Centre for Maternal and Child Health Research, Northampton Square, London EC1 V0HB, UK. 3. City, University of London, Learning Enhancement and Development, Northampton Square, London EC1 V0HB, UK.
Abstract
PROBLEM: Research suggests that the skill and experience of the attendant significantly affect the outcomes of vaginal breech births, yet practitioner experience levels are minimal within many contemporary maternity care systems. BACKGROUND: Due to minimal experience and cultural resistance, few practitioners offer vaginal breech birth, and many practice guidelines and training programmes recommend delivery techniques requiring supine maternal position. Fewer practitioners have skills to support physiological breech birth, involving active maternal movement and choice of birthing position, including upright postures such as kneeling, standing, squatting, or on a birth stool. How professionals learn complex skills contrary to those taught in their local practice settings is unclear. QUESTION: How do professionals develop competence and expertise in physiological breech birth? METHODS: Nine midwives and five obstetricians with experience facilitating upright physiological breech births participated in semi-structured interviews. Data were analysed iteratively using constructivist grounded theory methods to develop an empirical theory of physiological breech skill acquisition. RESULTS: Among the participants in this research, the deliberate acquisition of competence in physiological breech birth included stages of affinity with physiological birth, critical awareness, intention, identity and responsibility. Expert practitioners operating across local and national boundaries guided less experienced practitioners. DISCUSSION: The results depict a specialist learning model which could be formalised in sympathetic training programmes, and evaluated. It may also be relevant to developing competence in other specialist/expert roles and innovative practices. CONCLUSION: Deliberate development of local communities of practice may support professionals to acquire elusive breech skills in a sustainable way.
PROBLEM: Research suggests that the skill and experience of the attendant significantly affect the outcomes of vaginal breech births, yet practitioner experience levels are minimal within many contemporary maternity care systems. BACKGROUND: Due to minimal experience and cultural resistance, few practitioners offer vaginal breech birth, and many practice guidelines and training programmes recommend delivery techniques requiring supine maternal position. Fewer practitioners have skills to support physiological breech birth, involving active maternal movement and choice of birthing position, including upright postures such as kneeling, standing, squatting, or on a birth stool. How professionals learn complex skills contrary to those taught in their local practice settings is unclear. QUESTION: How do professionals develop competence and expertise in physiological breech birth? METHODS: Nine midwives and five obstetricians with experience facilitating upright physiological breech births participated in semi-structured interviews. Data were analysed iteratively using constructivist grounded theory methods to develop an empirical theory of physiological breech skill acquisition. RESULTS: Among the participants in this research, the deliberate acquisition of competence in physiological breech birth included stages of affinity with physiological birth, critical awareness, intention, identity and responsibility. Expert practitioners operating across local and national boundaries guided less experienced practitioners. DISCUSSION: The results depict a specialist learning model which could be formalised in sympathetic training programmes, and evaluated. It may also be relevant to developing competence in other specialist/expert roles and innovative practices. CONCLUSION: Deliberate development of local communities of practice may support professionals to acquire elusive breech skills in a sustainable way.