| Literature DB >> 28877663 |
Steve Lefever1,2,3,4, Filip Pattyn5,6, Bram De Wilde5,7,8, Frauke Coppieters5,9, Sarah De Keulenaer5,10, Jan Hellemans5,11, Jo Vandesompele5,9,7,8.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Although the sequencing landscape is rapidly evolving and sequencing costs are continuously decreasing, whole genome sequencing is still too expensive for use on a routine basis. Targeted resequencing of only the regions of interest decreases both costs and the complexity of the downstream data-analysis. Various target enrichment strategies are available, but none of them obtain the degree of coverage uniformity, flexibility and specificity of PCR-based enrichment. On the other hand, the biggest limitation of target enrichment by PCR is the need to design large numbers of partially overlapping assays to cover the target.Entities:
Keywords: PCR assay; Primer design; Sanger sequencing; Targeted resequencing; Variant confirmation next generation sequencing
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2017 PMID: 28877663 PMCID: PMC5588703 DOI: 10.1186/s12859-017-1809-3
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Bioinformatics ISSN: 1471-2105 Impact factor: 3.169
Fig. 1PrimerXL targeted resequencing PCR design pipeline. Schematic representation of the primerXL pipeline functionality. Tasks performed by the parent process are marked in yellow, tasks executed by the child processes in green and blue. The design criteria relaxation cascade is shown in blue. Following retrieval of the sequence of interest (and adjustment of the amplicon size range for small regions), SNPs and secondary structures are masked. Next Primer3-based primer design is initiated and a SNP- and secondary structure analysis is performed on each resulting assay to remove assays harboring these features in their primer annealing sites. If a successful primer pair remains after specificity assessment, the next target region is processed or the design is terminated. On the other hand, if no successful assays remain, design parameters are relaxed (specificity-, SNP- and secondary structure analysis stringency, GC content, amplicon length, …) and primer design is attempted once again. If all parameters have already been relaxed to their fullest extent without the generation of a successful primer pair, the design process is terminated
Fig. 2Amplicon and sequencing statistics. Graphical representation of the amplicon and sequencing statistics of four sequencing projects. a Target coverage efficiency, b Distribution of the amplicon sequence, c Schematic displaying the different on- and off-target portions of an amplicon, d Cumulative distribution of the amplicon length, e Cumulative distribution of the Cq values (amplicons of Project 2 were tested by regular PCR), f Cumulative distribution of the end-point fluorescence and g Cumulative distribution of the sequencing coverage
PrimerXL feature overview in function of pipeline version
| Version | Relaxation cascade | Dynamic target adjustment |
|---|---|---|
| 0.8 | ||
| 0.9 | V | |
| 1.0 | V | V |
Differences in primerXL features between the various versions used in this study. The term “dynamic target adjustment” refers to the ability of primerXL to automatically adjust the amplicon size range for smaller exons, thus reducing the amount of intronic near-target sequence
Projects statistics overview
| Amplicon design | PCR | Sequencing | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Target size | # amplicons | Total amplicon sequence | Exonic (on-target) | Intronic (on-target) | Intronic (near-target) | F-primer | R primer | Assays tested | Failed (No amplification) | Multiple bands | Assays sequenced | No reads | % bp within 2 × mean coverage | |
| Project 1 | 83 Kb | 625 | 185 Kb | 108 Kb (58.1%) | 22 Kb (11.7%) | 56 Kb (30.2%) | 13 Kb | 13 Kb | 626 | 17 (2.7%) | NA | 569 | 8 (1.4%) | 70% |
| Project 2 | 157 Kb | 723 | 281 Kb | 167 Kb (59.3%) | 27 Kb (9.7%) | 87 Kb (31.0%) | 15 Kb | 15 Kb | 638 | 6 (0.9%) | 79 (12.4%) | NA | NA | NA |
| Project 3 | 67 Kb | 375 | 137 Kb | 77 Kb (56.2%) | 14 Kb (9.9%) | 47 Kb (33.9%) | 8 Kb | 8 Kb | 375 | 0 (0.0%) | NA | 375 | 18 (5%) | 59% |
| Project 4 | 98 Kb | 625 | 182 Kb | 102 Kb (56.1%) | 29 Kb (15.7%) | 51 Kb (28.2%) | 13 Kb | 13 Kb | 625 | 8 (1.3%) | NA | NA | NA | NA |
Details of the different projects showing the design target coverage, success rate when testing the assays on (q)PCR and sequence coverage
Fig. 3Targeted resequencing assay statistics. Graphical representation of the targeted resequencing assay statistics for five genes (SACS, SETX, APTX, ANO10, CYP27A1) designed using three primer design tools (primerXL, Optimus Primer and Illumina DesignStudio): a Target coverage efficiency, b Distribution of the amplicon sequence and percentage of amplicons harbouring SNPs (c) or secondary structures d in primer annealing sites