| Literature DB >> 28877199 |
Naga Siva Kumar Gunda1, Saumyadeb Dasgupta1, Sushanta K Mitra1.
Abstract
We have developed a new litmus paper test (DipTest) for detecting Escherichia coli (E. coli) in water samples by performing enzymatic reactions directly on the porous paper substrate. The paper strip consists of a long narrow piece of cellulose blotting paper coated with chemoattractant (at bottom edge), wax hydrophobic barrier (at the top edge), and custom formulated chemical reagents (at reaction zone immediately below the wax hydrophobic barrier). When the paper strip is dipped in water, E. coli in the water sample is attracted toward the paper strip due to a chemotaxic mechanism followed by the ascent along the paper strip toward the reaction zone due to a capillary wicking mechanism, and finally the capillary motion is arrested at the top edge of the paper strip by the hydrophobic barrier. The E. coli concentrated at the reaction zone of the paper strip will react with custom formulated chemical reagents to produce a pinkish-red color. Such a color change on the paper strip when dipped into water samples indicates the presence of E. coli contamination in potable water. The performance of the DipTest device has been checked with different known concentrations of E. coli contaminated water samples using different dip and wait times. The DipTest device has also been tested with different interfering bacteria and chemical contaminants. It has been observed that the different interfering contaminants do not have any impact on the DipTest, and it can become a potential solution for screening water samples for E. coli contamination at the point of source.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2017 PMID: 28877199 PMCID: PMC5587108 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0183234
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Existing paper based test strips for the detection of E. coli.
The commercial product is denoted by “*”.
| Product/reference | Method | Sample Preparation | Specificity | Concentration (CFU/mL) | Time | Temperature | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hossain et al. [ | Paper strip coated with chromogenic substrate using silica gels and tested with pre-concentrated bacteria | Yes (pre-concentrated using antibody-coated immune-magnetic nanoparticles) | Yes | 5 to 106 | 30 min to 8 hr | Room temperature | Yes/No |
| Ma et al. [ | Paper strips fabricated by drawing the patterns with wax pencil and screen printing method. Immunoassay method is applied for detection | Yes | Yes | 10 to 106 | 55 min | Not mentioned | Yes/No |
| Water Safe* from Silver Lake Research Corporation (Azusa, CA, USA) | Lateral flow test: antigen—antibody interaction on paper strip | No | No | Not mentioned | 15 min | Room temperature | Yes/No |
| DipTest (similar to litmus paper) | Paper strip coated with chemoattractant and enzymatic substrate | No | Yes | 200 to 105 | 75 min to 3 hr | Room temperature | Yes/No |
Fig 1Schematic of the DipTest device.
Fig 2Comparison of the DipTest device between (a) tested with DI water at room temperature (inset shows the scanning electron microscope (SEM) image of porous paper matrix) (b) tested with E. coli contaminated water (2 × 104 CFU/mL) at room temperature.
It is to be noted that the appearance of color on the used DipTest device represents the presence of E. coli.
Fig 3Development of pinkish red color on the DipTest device after 2 hrs based on the concentrations of E. coli (CFU/mL).
The control strip is with DI water, which shows no color.
Fig 4Comparison of DipTest wait (response) times for the appearance of the pinkish red color with respect to various dip times.
The plot is shown for various known concentrations of E. coli spiked water samples.
DipTest results for 40 different water samples used in this work.
| Category | Sample No. | Contents in Water Samples | DipTest |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | No Color | ||
| 2 | No color | ||
| 3 | No color | ||
| 4 | ATCC11229, | Color produced | |
| 5 | ATCC11229, | Color produced | |
| 6 | ATCC11229, | Color produced | |
| 7 | ATCC 11229, | Color produced (low intensity) | |
| 8 | Sodium fluoride | No color | |
| 9 | Sodium nitrate | No color | |
| 10 | Iron Chloride hexahydrate (EMD) | No color (paper strip turned yellowish) | |
| 11 | Ammonia persulfate | No color (paper strip turned light yellowish) | |
| 12 | Sodium sulfate | No color | |
| 13 | Sodium bromide | No color | |
| 14 | Sodium iodide | No color | |
| 15 | Sodium phosphate | No color | |
| 16 | Ferric chloride, hexahydrate (Sigma) | No color (yellowish) | |
| 17 | Sodium chloride | No color | |
| 18 | Calcium propionate | No color | |
| 19 | Potassium hydroxide | No color | |
| 20 | Fluoride solution (1ppm) | No color | |
| 21 | Fluoride solution (10ppm) | No color | |
| 22 | Cadmium | No color | |
| 23 | Lead | No color | |
| 24 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and sodium fluoride | Color produced | |
| 25 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and sodium nitrate | Color produced | |
| 26 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and iron chloride hexahydrate (EMD) | Color produced | |
| 27 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and ammonia persulfate | Color produced (high intensity) | |
| 28 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and sodium sulfate | Color produced | |
| 29 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and sodium bromide | Color produced | |
| 30 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and sodium iodide | Color produced | |
| 31 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and sodium phosphate | Color produced | |
| 32 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and Ferric chloride, hexahydrate (Sigma) | Color produced | |
| 33 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and sodium chloride | Color produced | |
| 34 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and calcium propionate | Color produced | |
| 35 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and potassium hydroxide | Color produced | |
| 36 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and fluoride solution (1ppm) | Color produced | |
| 37 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and fluoride solution (10ppm) | Color produced | |
| 38 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and cadmium | Color produced | |
| 39 | ATCC 11229, E.coli K-12, and lead | Color produced (low intensity) | |
| 40 | DI water without bacteria and chemical contaminants | No Color |
Fig 5Representation of the use of DipTest device to test the water sample for the presence of E. coli bacteria.