Richard Saw1, Caroline F Finch2, David Samra3, Peter Baquie1, Tanusha Cardoso4, Danielle Hope5, John W Orchard6. 1. Olympic Park Sports Medicine Centre, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. 2. Australian Collaboration for Research into Injury in Sport and Its Prevention, Federation University Australia, Ballarat, Victoria, Australia. 3. The Stadium Sports Medicine Clinic, Sydney, New South Walesm Australia. 4. Alphington Sports Medicine Clinic, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. 5. Peak Sports Medicine Clinic, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. 6. School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Abstract
CONTEXT: The nature of Australian rules football (Australian football) predisposes both unique and common injuries compared with those sustained in other football codes. The game involves a combination of tackling, kicking, high-speed running (more than other football codes), and jumping. Two decades of injury surveillance has identified common injuries at the professional level (Australian Football League [AFL]). OBJECTIVE: To provide an overview of injuries in Australian rules football, including injury rates, patterns, and mechanisms across all levels of play. STUDY DESIGN: A narrative review of AFL injuries, football injury epidemiology, and biomechanical and physiological attributes of relevant injuries. RESULTS: The overall injury incidence in the 2015 season was 41.7 injuries per club per season, with a prevalence of 156.2 missed games per club per season. Lower limb injuries are most prevalent, with hamstring strains accounting for 19.1 missed games per club per season. Hamstring strains relate to the volume of high-speed running required in addition to at times having to collect the ball while running in a position of hip flexion and knee extension. Anterior cruciate ligament injuries are also prevalent and can result from contact and noncontact incidents. In the upper limb, shoulder sprains and dislocations account for 11.5 missed games per club per season and largely resulted from tackling and contact. Concussion is less common in AFL than other tackling sports but remains an important injury, which has notably become more prevalent in recent years, theorized to be due to a more conservative approach to management. Although there are less injury surveillance data for non-AFL players (women, community-level, children), many of these injuries appear to also be common across all levels of play. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: An understanding of injury profiles and mechanisms in Australian football is crucial in identifying methods to reduce injury risk and prepare players for the demands of the game.
CONTEXT: The nature of Australian rules football (Australian football) predisposes both unique and common injuries compared with those sustained in other football codes. The game involves a combination of tackling, kicking, high-speed running (more than other football codes), and jumping. Two decades of injury surveillance has identified common injuries at the professional level (Australian Football League [AFL]). OBJECTIVE: To provide an overview of injuries in Australian rules football, including injury rates, patterns, and mechanisms across all levels of play. STUDY DESIGN: A narrative review of AFL injuries, football injury epidemiology, and biomechanical and physiological attributes of relevant injuries. RESULTS: The overall injury incidence in the 2015 season was 41.7 injuries per club per season, with a prevalence of 156.2 missed games per club per season. Lower limb injuries are most prevalent, with hamstring strains accounting for 19.1 missed games per club per season. Hamstring strains relate to the volume of high-speed running required in addition to at times having to collect the ball while running in a position of hip flexion and knee extension. Anterior cruciate ligament injuries are also prevalent and can result from contact and noncontact incidents. In the upper limb, shoulder sprains and dislocations account for 11.5 missed games per club per season and largely resulted from tackling and contact. Concussion is less common in AFL than other tackling sports but remains an important injury, which has notably become more prevalent in recent years, theorized to be due to a more conservative approach to management. Although there are less injury surveillance data for non-AFL players (women, community-level, children), many of these injuries appear to also be common across all levels of play. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: An understanding of injury profiles and mechanisms in Australian football is crucial in identifying methods to reduce injury risk and prepare players for the demands of the game.
Australian rules football (Australian football) is a unique code of football played
widely in Australia. It attracts participants from across a broad level, from children
to the community to the national professional competition known as the Australian
Football League (AFL). Across Australia, the number participating in Australian football
is estimated to exceed 1.2 million, including almost 320,000 female participants.[3] Female football play has been growing rapidly, with a 25% increase from 2014 from 2015.[3]Australian football is a contact, winter sport played on natural grass with an oval ball
made of leather. There are 18 players on the field plus 4 additional players on the
bench (with 90 allowed rotations per match at the AFL level). Most playing fields are
also used for cricket in the summer and are larger than those used by other football
codes, varying from 135 to 185 m in length and 110 to 155 m in width.[4] The sport requires a mix of endurance and high-speed running, kicking,
ball-handling skills, and tackling (Figure 1).
Figure 1.
Overview of professional men’s Australian football.[2]
Overview of professional men’s Australian football.[2]In the AFL, 18 men’s teams compete weekly across a season that lasts 22 rounds, with 4
additional weeks of finals. Clubs had an average of 45.4 players on their player lists
in 2015.[1] Until recently, the national level has been predominantly played by men, but the
AFL launched a semiprofessional, national-level, female competition in 2017 with 8 teams.[3]As with all other football codes, there is a risk of injury associated with participation
in the sport. While many injuries may be somewhat preventable with implementation of
suitable strategies, performance factors tend to drive injury rates upward.[46] To inform such efforts, it is first important to understand both the common and
unique injuries associated with the sport.[22] The purpose of this review was to draw upon 2 decades of published injury
surveillance data at the professional level to provide an overview of injuries of
particular relevance to AFL players. This was supplemented with what is known about
injuries across other competition levels from a variety of published sources.
Methods
A literature search was conducted using the SPORTDiscus, MEDLINE, and Google Scholar
databases to find relevant articles pertaining to AFL injuries, football injury
epidemiology, and biomechanical and physiological attributes of relevant injuries.
Injury data pertaining to football codes were also sought from injury and annual
reports published by respective sport organizations. Narrative review methods were
used to synthesize data.
Injury Surveillance in Australian Football
Professional/AFL
The AFL has publicly released an annual injury report covering its national elite
male competition since 1996, with 100% compliance since 1997.[53] The AFL is believed to be the first professional football code to publish
an annual injury report for its entire professional league.[53] Player contracts include consent for players’ injury records to be used
anonymously for research purposes, including injury surveillance. At times, the
AFL Research Board commissions specific injury-focused studies (eg, anterior
cruciate ligament [ACL] and soft tissue injury audits) using these data;
however, for this to occur, the players must provide further consent.[56]The AFL has defined injury as any physical or medical condition
that cause a player to be unavailable for a match in the regular season or finals.[53] This definition is used to create uniformity across clubs and allow
reliable comparison, negating observational bias. AFL clubs are required to
record why any player is not playing for that week, and if injured, record the
diagnosis using the Orchard sports injury classifications system
(OSICS).[56,58] These data do not delineate between training and match
injuries, as it was thought that due to the high proportion of overuse injuries
this would be problematic.[52]The overall injury incidence for the 2015 season was 41.7 injuries per club per season,[1] equivalent to just under 1 injury per player. This has been fairly
consistent over time, ranging from 37.6 (1993) to 48.1 (1997) since records
began.In the AFL Injury Survey, injury prevalence is defined as the
number of missed games per club per season. It is recognized that this is not
the traditional epidemiological definition of prevalence, but it has been used
for 2 decades as the AFL’s preferred measure of time missed through injury. The
injury prevalence in the AFL for 2015 was 156.2 missed games per club per
season, and this has ranged from 116.3 (1994) to 158.1 (2013) since records
began. The game has evolved, with more high-speed running and increased size of
players, causing higher injury rates despite improved conditioning and injury
prevention practices.[46]The most prevalent injuries in the AFL are hamstring strains (19.1 missed
games/club/season in 2015), ACL injuries (16.7 missed games/club/season),
shoulder sprains and dislocations (11.5 missed games/club/season), leg and foot
stress fractures (8.6 missed games/club/season), and ankle sprains or joint
injuries (7.2 missed games/club/season) (Table 1 in the Appendix, available in the online version of this article).[1] Shoulder sprains and dislocations refer to the glenohumeral joint
specifically, as acromioclavicular (AC) joint and clavicle pathology are
categorized separately and cause fewer missed matches (AC joint injuries, 0.4;
clavicle fractures, 0.1). Groin strains and osteitis pubis was previously the
second-most common injury, with a prevalence of 17.5 in 2007; however, this had
fallen to 7.1 in 2015, potentially related to a shift toward hip-related
pathologies being diagnosed more frequently and possibly improved conditioning
programs and management. Other leg/foot/ankle injuries had a prevalence of 14.0
in 2015; however, this was unusually high and thought to be a reflection of an
interpretation/classification issue rather than a change in injury patterns.[1]The mean time lost per injury for the common AFL injuries is outlined in
Table 2 in the Appendix. However, these data should be
interpreted with caution, as the AFL Injury Survey only includes injuries that
result in missed matches. For example, the mean number of missed matches for
ankle sprains will be artificially high because those that do not cause any
missed matches are excluded. In addition, if a significant injury (eg, shoulder
dislocation requiring surgery) occurs late in the season, the player may miss
fewer matches because they are able to recover during the off-season.
Comparison With Other Football Codes
The injury profile of Australian football tends to be more contact-orientated
than soccer but more noncontact-oriented than rugby union and related sports
(American football and rugby league).[52] This seems to reflect the less frequent and perhaps lower force of
tackling compared with rugby codes as well as the more open and dynamic nature
of Australian football, with larger playing fields, longer duration of matches
(mean match length, 120 minutes [20-minute quarters plus stoppage time]), and
more high-speed running. There is more continuous running in Australian football
than other codes where there are more regular breaks for tackling, with AFL
players running on average 13.20 km per match at a mean 7.23 km/h. This
includes, on average, 5 minutes 16 seconds at greater than 18 km/h.[70] By comparison, a study of elite European soccer players found they ran on
average 10.86 km per match, and 1 minute 24 seconds at greater than 18 km/h.[44] Professional rugby union players in England covered an average of 7.52 km
per match, including 300 m at greater than 20 km/h (different units).[41] In soccer, 87% of injuries affect the lower limbs, compared with 68% in
Australian football.
Other Levels of Play
There is no routine collection of injury data for any level of play other than at
the AFL. Although the rules are largely the same across all levels, at least in
adults, there is a slower speed of game and variation in skill level, which
contributes to different injury profiles in community and professional football.
Injury surveillance in the adult male community leagues and junior leagues has
been undertaken in a sample of clubs through specific research studies reported
in the peer-reviewed literature.[7,17,25,31,33,42,60,61] A recent review has
summarized the methods used in these studies.[25] These studies have generally used an injury definition encompassing both
medical treatment and time-loss injuries occurring during both matches and
training. The inclusion of either team-based or player-exposure measures have
enabled calculations of injury rates. There have also been published reports of
the profile of Australian football injuries treated in medical treatment
settings, such as hospitals, but such studies have not allowed calculation of
exposure-adjusted injury rates.[18] More recently, the first profile of injuries in female Australian
football players has been published from a compilation of the above sources[29] and the first survey of injured players.[27]
Lower Limb Injuries
Irrespective of the level of play, the lower limbs are the most commonly injured body
region. Almost all the community-level studies either did not collect or report
specific injury diagnoses, so it was not possible to summarize those studies to this
same level of detail. The exceptions were the amateur Australian football players,
for whom provisional injury diagnoses were coded according to the OSICS.[31] However, on a frequency basis, lower limb injuries account for 40% to 68% of
all injuries in adult male community players and 42% to 49% of all injuries in children.[25]Soft tissue injuries of the lower limb typically require less recovery time than bone
and joint injuries; however, their collective time burden for a club over a season
can be greater.[1] The burden of soft tissue injuries is complicated by the high incidence of
recurrent injuries and the prolonged recovery for recurrent injuries. Furthermore,
this high soft tissue load injury rate has been fairly refractory over time[1] despite advancement in imaging technology, improved anatomical and
pathological understanding, and improved sports science and medicine practices,
perhaps suggesting that game-related factors such as running loads are more relevant
than prevention strategies in affecting incidence.[20]
Strain Injuries
Hamstring
The incidence of hamstring strain injury is high across all football
codes[19,71]; however, it is the sport-specific demands that
contribute to the particularly high risk of this injury in Australian
football. Hamstring injuries were also the most common individual injury in
the single community-level surveillance study reporting diagnostic detail.[31] The substantial volume of high-speed running in the AFL[70] is a known risk factor for hamstring strain injuries.[16] Players also frequently collect the ball from the ground on the run
in the vulnerable position of trunk flexion, hip flexion, and knee extension
(Figure 2).[39] This is often completed under stress from an opponent at the moment
of ball collection, where the hamstring is particularly vulnerable to higher
grade (proximal biceps femoris intramuscular tendon) strains.
Figure 2.
Picking up a ground ball on the run results in hip flexion and knee
extension (Source: Australian Football League).
Picking up a ground ball on the run results in hip flexion and knee
extension (Source: Australian Football League).The biceps femoris is the predominant affected muscle,[32] with frequent involvement of the intramuscular tendon.[8,10] Such
injuries have also recently been identified as the most common types of
subsequent injury in AFL players.[24]
Quadriceps
Quadriceps strain injuries occur predominantly in the rectus femoris of the
kicking leg.[8] As for hamstring strain injuries, tendon involvement is important to
consider for return-to-play planning.[12] Strain events in the other 3 quadriceps muscles do not cause as much
concern, as they tend to settle quickly.[12]
Calf
Calf strain injuries are less common, yet their prevalence/incidence has
increased over time. This may be attributed to the introduction of 1 bench
injury substitute in 2011, with 1 less player being freely available to
interchange (1 injury substitute plus 3 free interchange players, previously
4 interchange players and no substitute), although hamstring strains were
noted to drop concurrently.[1] The substitute was removed in 2016. Musculotendinous junction and
intramuscular tendon soleus injuries are more likely to result in missed games.[67] The gastrocnemius is less commonly involved in strain events in the AFL.[67]
Adductor
Adductor strain injuries (included in the hip and groin grouping in the AFL
Injury Survey) as a group are neither frequently encountered nor a cause for
long-term absence[1] compared with insertional tendinopathy at the pubic symphysis. This
possibly reflects the absence of kicking in the abducted foot position
relative to soccer and possibly the absence of intramuscular tendon
involvement.
Contusions
Contusions commonly occur to the lateral thigh (predominantly vastus lateralis
and intermedialis) and less often in the leg muscle groups.[43] While impact can arise from all hard surfaces or body parts, if the knee
and high speed are involved, the severity can be underestimated and result in a
more protracted or complicated outcome. Contusion and other soft tissue injuries
are very common in players from the community forms of the game.[25]
Joint/Ligament Injuries
Ankle Sprain
The AFL injury report details a 10-year mean of 8.9 games missed per club per
season from all ankle joint injuries. In 2015, there was a mean 2.3 new
ankle injuries causing 7.2 missed games per AFL club.[1] Undoubtedly, there are a significant number of low-grade ankle
injuries not resulting in missed matches that were not included in these
statistics.The majority of reported ankle sprains in both the AFL and community forms of
the game are lateral ankle sprains. Syndesmosis ankle sprains may be less
common than in other sports such as rugby union, where they are a large
cause of morbidity,[21] but they still represent a significant proportion of the overall
morbidity.Typical mechanisms of ankle sprains include marking contests, where a player
may land on another player’s foot, similar to other sports such as
basketball and netball, causing either an inversion injury or less commonly
an eversion and external rotation injury. A player’s foot could also become
trapped and twisted into eversion as the “pack” falls to the ground, but one
can also see how rugby union players would be more often exposed to a loaded
rotation mechanism with multiple players in scrums and tackles. Another
common mechanism is the player who has the foot planted and is rotating to
pass the ball while being tackled.
Anterior Cruciate Ligament
The incidence of ACL injuries over the previous 2 decades is 0.7 per AFL club
per season.[1,56,58] The incidence decreased from the 1990s to 2012,[58] possibly due to improved strength and conditioning practices and
changes in ground preparation aimed to reduce shoe-surface traction
injuries.[53,54] ACL injuries typically occur early in the playing
season and preseason training,[54,55] with 2014 being an
unexplained anomaly to this trend.[56]ACL injuries are expensive, both in terms of treatment costs and missed matches.[35] They are treated surgically, with a mean return to play of 10 to 12 months.[48] Hence, AFL players are unlikely to return to play in the same playing
season.[54,65]Australia has the highest incidence of ACL reconstructions per 100,000
person-years as compared with other Western countries, and in Australia, at
the population level, Australian football has the second-highest incidence
of ACL injuries per participant after skiing.[35] A greater incidence of ACL injuries in the AFL occurs in warmer
regions,[1,49,55] a finding consistent with European soccer.[66] This is hypothesized to be due to the higher traction forces
encountered playing on warm season grasses.[50,59] Injury risk has also
been demonstrated to be related to ground hardness in community football.[64]Noncontact mechanisms account for 56% of ACL ruptures in Australian football.[9] Side-stepping and landing on an extended knee appear to be the most
common mechanisms of noncontact ACL injuries in the league, as identified on
video analysis.[9] Risk factors include speed and change of direction, knee instability,
angle of landing, and studded boots increasing friction with the ground.[65] A recent randomized controlled trial has demonstrated that targeted
exercise training programs for community Australian football can reduce the
risk of knee injury by up to 50% and the risk of all lower limb injury by 22%.[26]Female athletes are at greater risk of ACL rupture than males, with a 2- to
3-fold increase observed in other football codes.[27] Data do not currently exist for this cohort in Australian football;
however, the Women’s Injury Surveillance Extension (FootyWISE) was
established to address this gap.[27] The first analysis of injury data in women players was not able to
confirm an excess of ACL ruptures because of a low number of reported
injuries.[27,29]
Posterior Cruciate Ligament
Posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) injuries have earned the colloquial label
“ruckman’s curse” due to their prevalence in AFL ruckmen. Opposing ruckmen
jump to contest the ball when it is bounced up or thrown in at a stoppage in play.[57] The 2 opposing ruckmen will usually run at each other while the ball
is in flight, potentially colliding with a flexed knee. The most widely
reported mechanism of PCL injury is a fall on the flexed knee with the foot
in plantar flexion or direct force blow to the anterior tibia[63]; however, a ruckman can also collide with a flexed knee while
“rucking.”Because of a spike in PCL ruptures in ruckmen,[57] the center circle rule was developed in 2005, which led to the
creation of a 10-meter outer circle that the ruckmen had to start in at a
center bounce. The rule change was aimed at decreasing the run-up distance
and acceleration, which would then translate into decreasing impact forces.[51] A cohort study in 2009 demonstrated that the rule change was
successful in reducing the overall ruck-related PCL injuries in general and
those due to the center bounce mechanism.[51,55,57] A further rule change
was introduced in 2013 to increase the separation of ruckmen at stoppages;
however, the efficacy of this rule cannot yet be established.[51] The reduction in ground hardness could be a possible confounder in
decreased injury rates due to non-ruck-related mechanisms.[45]The incidence of PCL injuries for the latest 2015 AFL injury surveillance
data was 0.5 new injuries, in keeping with historically low averages since
the introduction of the center circle rule.[1]
Upper Limb Injuries
The upper limb is the second-most common body region of injuries in Australian
football in children, with 18% to 22% of all injuries, compared with 13% to 27% of
injuries in adult male community players.[25] Such injuries are also common in female players.[27] Upper limb injuries are more commonly reported in treatment-based data
collections than in club surveillance in community football because of their nature
(commonly involving the wrist, fingers, and hands) and immediate assessment needs.[17]
Shoulder
Shoulder injuries in all forms of Australian football occur due to the
contact/collision nature of the sport. Glenohumeral instability has the greatest
incidence and time lost to injury (1.0 to 1.8 new injuries/club/year resulting
in 7.1 to 21.1 missed games/club/season).[1] Recurrence rates are typically between 9% and 15% but have been much
higher (54% in 2014).[1]The first injury pattern relates to the contested overhead mark (mean, 11.4 per
AFL club/game).[2] This action involves the arm being placed in full abduction and at the
limit of shoulder external rotation during an attempt to catch/mark the ball
against an opponent who is attempting to disrupt the mark, usually by punching
or knocking the ball away concurrently. Unique to Australian football is the
height at which this can occur, which is greater than other codes because of the
allowed technique of jumping onto another player to increase elevation. This
mechanism can result in hyperexternal rotation of the abducted arm, with
resultant glenohumeral joint anterior instability injury patterns.The second injury pattern involves players competing for the ball while at ground
level, even lying on the ground. This can occur when a player in the prone
position reaches forward into full flexion and external rotation toward the ball
and another player impacts on the posterior aspect of the scapula or shoulder,
forcing the arm into hyperflexion/external rotation, also creating anterior
instability.Third, glenohumeral instability may result after a tackle. While tackling is more
prevalent in other football codes (eg, the mean number per club per game in the
Australian National Rugby League in 2016 was 326[47]), it is also a prominent feature of AFL, with a mean 69.6 tackles per
game in 2016.[2] Tackling a player head-on with the arm abducted at 90° risks anterior
dislocation force similar to that seen in other tackling sports. In Australian
football, the lack of an offside rule means players can be tackled from any
direction, and tackles more often occur by chasing a player down rather than
head-on. This frequently leaves the arms of the tackled player free. A tackle
that takes the player to the ground in this way can result in forced abduction
and external rotation and a greater likelihood of glenohumeral instability
injury compared with rugby, in which the arms are often pinned to the player and
resultant impact results more frequently in an AC joint injury.Preventative/protective taping and bracing of the shoulder is less effective in
Australian football players than in other tackling football codes, as every
player in the team is required to be able to freely reach overhead repetitively
during the game. Taping is commonly used in Australian football players;
however, the effect is largely proprioceptive rather than providing structural restraint.[5]Posterior instability injuries in Australian football mimic those of other
football codes, caused by a direct anterior impact to the shoulder or the player
either falling onto the elbow or fending off another player with the shoulder
forward flexed and resultant posteriorly directed forces applied to the joint.
Posterior dislocation is far less common than anterior dislocation[62] and appears to present more commonly with subluxation symptoms rather
than frank dislocations.Clavicular and AC joint injury patterns in Australian football mimic those seen
in other contact sports such as rugby, with direct impact during a tackle or
with the player falling to the ground with the arm by the side and a direct
lateral impact to the shoulder.[11] No shoulder padding is worn. In Australian football, “bumping”
(deliberately impacting an opposing player with the hip and shoulder) is a legal
means of dispossessing a player with the ball and can also result in impact
injury to the shoulder. Whereas AC joint injury is the most common shoulder
injury in rugby,[34] glenohumeral instability is more common than AC joint injury in the AFL.[1]
Concussion
Concussion in the AFL appears less common than in head-on tackling sports such as
rugby union, with 6 per 1000 player-hours in Australian football compared with 13.4
in rugby union.[1,21] Both statistics include all concussions, regardless of whether
they resulted in missed matches. By contrast, statistics from the annual AFL Injury
Survey only includes injuries causing missed matches. The AFL Injury Survey
incidence of concussion (new injuries/AFL club/season) has increased over the past
decade, from 0.3 in 2006 to 1.5 in 2015,[1] particularly since 2011, when a rule was introduced that players could not
return in a match after suffering a concussion.[51]The prevalence of concussion in the AFL (missed games/AFL club/season) has also
increased, with a notable spike from 1.6 in 2014 to 4.2 in 2015. However, the 2014
and 2015 surveys suggest that the increase in observed rates of concussion and
missed time may be a reflection of better recognition and increasingly conservative
approaches toward concussions, with players being more likely to miss a game, as
opposed to a recent true increase in prevalence.[1,56]Concussion rates have also been reported in community forms of the game. In an adult
male league, they accounted for 19% of all head/neck/orofacial injuries.[6] In a secondary analysis of data from a randomized controlled trial,
concussion rates in community football were 4.9 per 1000 game-hours.[36] An analysis of hospital admissions data over a 9-year period prior to
mid-2011 reported a relatively stable rate of concussion-related admissions from
Australian football, with a mean 80.3 cases per 100,000 participants aged 15+ years.[23] In a survey of injured female players, concussion was ranked as the most
commonly reported worst injury by 33% of survey respondents.[27]The nature of Australian football places players at risk of concussion from unique
mechanisms during play. Opponents can tackle players from any angle, and since there
are 36 players on the ground at any time, there is a considerable risk of accidental
collision. The rules of the game aim to protect players from being struck in the
head; however, head contact still does occur both within and outside the rules of
the game.[4] In a study involving male adults from community leagues in 2 states, 63% of
the concussions were sustained within game rules.[30]Examples of at-risk plays include a player jumping for the ball and being punched in
the back of the head by a player trying to “spoil” the ball who misjudges (or
maliciously judges) their approach. Players may try to jump and mark a ball while
running backward, which puts them at risk of hitting the back of their head on the
pitch from a significant height or colliding with an opposition player. Players who
are running to tackle a player with the ball may be “bumped” by opposition players
who may deliberately obstruct them if they are within 5 meters of the player with
the ball. A “bump” is similar to a block in American football (which is legal in
this code) or a shoulder charge in the rugby codes (which is now illegal in both
rugby codes). A player who is tackled is often “wrapped up” with the ball to secure
a free kick. Therefore, players and coaches have adopted a tackling style that
involves tackling a player around their arms, which leaves the head unprotected
(Figure 3).
Figure 3.
Wrapping up arms in a tackle can leave a player’s head unprotected (Source:
Australian Football League).
Wrapping up arms in a tackle can leave a player’s head unprotected (Source:
Australian Football League).There can be a large size differential between players who are valuable to their team
in different roles. Smaller, faster players are often utilized to pick up the ball
when it goes to the ground while larger players are important for the aerial
contests. Therefore, not only is a large size differential a risk to smaller
players, but these smaller players are more often trying to pick up the ball from
the ground while running fast such that their head is vulnerable to impact. Players
must show a duty of care to other players who are bending to pick up the ball, and
avoid any contact above the neck (Figure 4),[4] which can be difficult if a player puts their head in a low or vulnerable
position.
Figure 4.
The “no bump zone” (Source: Australian Football League).
The “no bump zone” (Source: Australian Football League).In accordance with the 2012 Zurich consensus guidelines,[40] the current policy of the AFL mandates off-field assessment whenever
concussion is suspected. This requires a player to be removed from play and rested
for a period of 10 minutes before a multimodal Standardized Concussion Assessment
Tool (SCAT 3) is completed. An additional tool for clinical assessment and diagnosis
of concussion is video replay footage, which is instantly available. Observable
clinical signs of concussion have been shown to be highly correlated with concussion
diagnosis, with good to excellent interrater reliability (among experienced
clinicians) for observable clinical signs of concussion.[13,38] No signs had both a high
sensitivity and specificity for concussion, emphasizing the need for multimodal
clinical assessment. These guidelines work well for the professional form of the
game but, as has been reportedly the case for many other sports, compliance with
concussion guidelines is hard to achieve in the community forms of the sport, and
there are many challenges to overcome to ensure they are consistently
implemented.[15,36,68,69]
Fatal Injuries
While death is not common during Australian football participation, insurance claims
in community-level Australian football over a 10-year period from 2004 to 2013 found
18 of these deaths occurring during football matches or training, and 16 of those
were in players. The most common causes of on-field death were cardiac and
unconfirmed causes.[28] Of the unconfirmed causes, many were listed as “collapsed,” so it is
suspected that the number of cardiac causes may be underestimated. Within the
limitations of the study, no contact-related or other physical injury deaths were
identified in the Australian football players. A 2-year study of injury-related
hospitalizations, which overlapped the same period, identified 2 in-hospital deaths
related to match play.[37]
Conclusion
Two decades of injury surveillance in the AFL has provided valuable insight into
injury patterns. The most prevalent injuries, and hence most costly from a time-loss
perspective, are hamstring strains, ACL ruptures, and glenohumeral dislocations.
Common injuries in the AFL can be attributed to the nature of the game, which
includes contesting for a ball and tackling/being tackled from all directions, plus
more high-speed running that other football codes. At the community level, there are
no directly comparable data with the AFL; however, the most common injuries appear
to be similar. Factors such as sports ground conditions, availability of sports
medicine professionals at games, and formal implementation of safety practices may
influence injury profiles at the community level.
Authors: Caroline F Finch; Dara M Twomey; Lauren V Fortington; Tim L A Doyle; Bruce C Elliott; Muhammad Akram; David G Lloyd Journal: Inj Prev Date: 2015-09-23 Impact factor: 2.399
Authors: Therese M Leahy; Ian C Kenny; Mark J Campbell; Giles D Warrington; Roisin Cahalan; Andrew J Harrison; Mark Lyons; Liam G Glynn; Kieran O'Sullivan; Helen Purtill; Thomas M Comyns Journal: Orthop J Sports Med Date: 2021-08-31
Authors: Austin G Wynn; Andrew P Collins; Elizabeth Nguyen; Eric Sales; Harrison Youmans; Daryl C Osbahr; Ibrahim Zeini; Michelle Henne Journal: Cureus Date: 2021-11-18