Brett R Anderson1, Amelia S Wallace2, Kevin D Hill2, Brian C Gulack2, Roland Matsouaka2, Jeffrey P Jacobs2, Emile A Bacha2, Sherry A Glied2, Marshall L Jacobs2. 1. From the Division of Pediatric Cardiology, NewYork-Presbyterian/Morgan Stanley Children's Hospital, Columbia University Medical Center (B.R.A.); Duke Clinical Research Institute, Durham, NC (A.S.W.); Department of Pediatrics, Duke Clinical Research Institute (K.D.H.) and Department of Surgery (B.C.G.), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC; Department of Biostatistics and Bioinformatics, Duke University, Durham, NC (R.M.); Division of Cardiovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, Johns Hopkins All Children's Heart Institute, St. Petersburg, FL (J.P.J., M.L.J.); Division of Cardiac Surgery, Department of Surgery, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD (J.P.J., M.L.J.); Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY (E.A.B.); and The Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service, New York University (S.A.G.). bra2113@cumc.columbia.edu. 2. From the Division of Pediatric Cardiology, NewYork-Presbyterian/Morgan Stanley Children's Hospital, Columbia University Medical Center (B.R.A.); Duke Clinical Research Institute, Durham, NC (A.S.W.); Department of Pediatrics, Duke Clinical Research Institute (K.D.H.) and Department of Surgery (B.C.G.), Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC; Department of Biostatistics and Bioinformatics, Duke University, Durham, NC (R.M.); Division of Cardiovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, Johns Hopkins All Children's Heart Institute, St. Petersburg, FL (J.P.J., M.L.J.); Division of Cardiac Surgery, Department of Surgery, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD (J.P.J., M.L.J.); Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY (E.A.B.); and The Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service, New York University (S.A.G.).
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Surgeon experience concerns both families of children with congenital heart disease and medical providers. Relationships between surgeon seniority and patient outcomes are often assumed, yet there are little data. METHODS AND RESULTS: This national study used linked data from the American Medical Association Physician Masterfile and the Society of Thoracic Surgeons-Congenital Heart Surgery Database to examine associations between surgeon years since medical school and major morbidity/mortality for children undergoing cardiac surgery. Sensitivity analyses explored the effects of patient characteristics, institutional/surgeon volumes, and various measures of institutional surgeon team experience. In secondary analyses, major morbidity and mortality were examined as separate end points. We identified 206 congenital heart surgeons from 91 centers performing 62 851 index operations (2010-2014). Median time from school was 25 years (range 9-55 years). A major morbidity/mortality occurred in 11.5% of cases. In multivariable analyses, the odds of major morbidity/mortality were similar for early-career (<15 years from medical school, ≈<40 years old), midcareer (15-24 years, ≈40-50 years old), and senior surgeons (25-35 years, ≈50-60 years old). The odds of major morbidity/mortality were ≈25% higher for operations performed by very senior surgeons (35-55 years from school, ≈60-80 years old; n=9044 cases). Results were driven by differences in morbidity. In extensive sensitivity analyses, these effects remained constant. CONCLUSIONS: In this study of >200 congenital heart surgeons, we found patient outcomes for surgeons with the fewest years of experience to be comparable to those of their midcareer and senior colleagues, within the context of existing referral and support practices. Very senior surgeons had higher risk-adjusted odds of major morbidity/mortality. Contemporary approaches to training, referral, mentoring, surgical planning, and other support practices might contribute to the observed outcomes of junior congenital heart surgeons being comparable to those of more experienced colleagues. Understanding and disseminating these practices might benefit the medical community at large.
BACKGROUND: Surgeon experience concerns both families of children with congenital heart disease and medical providers. Relationships between surgeon seniority and patient outcomes are often assumed, yet there are little data. METHODS AND RESULTS: This national study used linked data from the American Medical Association Physician Masterfile and the Society of Thoracic Surgeons-Congenital Heart Surgery Database to examine associations between surgeon years since medical school and major morbidity/mortality for children undergoing cardiac surgery. Sensitivity analyses explored the effects of patient characteristics, institutional/surgeon volumes, and various measures of institutional surgeon team experience. In secondary analyses, major morbidity and mortality were examined as separate end points. We identified 206 congenital heart surgeons from 91 centers performing 62 851 index operations (2010-2014). Median time from school was 25 years (range 9-55 years). A major morbidity/mortality occurred in 11.5% of cases. In multivariable analyses, the odds of major morbidity/mortality were similar for early-career (<15 years from medical school, ≈<40 years old), midcareer (15-24 years, ≈40-50 years old), and senior surgeons (25-35 years, ≈50-60 years old). The odds of major morbidity/mortality were ≈25% higher for operations performed by very senior surgeons (35-55 years from school, ≈60-80 years old; n=9044 cases). Results were driven by differences in morbidity. In extensive sensitivity analyses, these effects remained constant. CONCLUSIONS: In this study of >200 congenital heart surgeons, we found patient outcomes for surgeons with the fewest years of experience to be comparable to those of their midcareer and senior colleagues, within the context of existing referral and support practices. Very senior surgeons had higher risk-adjusted odds of major morbidity/mortality. Contemporary approaches to training, referral, mentoring, surgical planning, and other support practices might contribute to the observed outcomes of junior congenital heart surgeons being comparable to those of more experienced colleagues. Understanding and disseminating these practices might benefit the medical community at large.
Authors: Leigh A Neumayer; Atul A Gawande; Jia Wang; Anita Giobbie-Hurder; Kamal M F Itani; Robert J Fitzgibbons; Domenic Reda; Olga Jonasson Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2005-09 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: Jeffrey P Jacobs; John E Mayer; Constantine Mavroudis; Sean M O'Brien; Erle H Austin; Sara K Pasquali; Kevin D Hill; Xia He; David M Overman; James D St Louis; Tara Karamlou; Christian Pizarro; Jennifer C Hirsch-Romano; Donna McDonald; Jane M Han; Rachel S Dokholyan; Christo I Tchervenkov; Francois Lacour-Gayet; Carl L Backer; Charles D Fraser; James S Tweddell; Martin J Elliott; Hal Walters; Richard A Jonas; Richard L Prager; David M Shahian; Marshall L Jacobs Journal: Ann Thorac Surg Date: 2016-03 Impact factor: 4.330
Authors: Brett R Anderson; Adam J Ciarleglio; David J Cohen; Wyman W Lai; Matthew Neidell; Matthew Hall; Sherry A Glied; Emile A Bacha Journal: Cardiol Young Date: 2015-07-14 Impact factor: 1.093
Authors: Brett R Anderson; S Ram Kumar; Danielle Gottlieb-Sen; Matthew H Liava'a; Kevin D Hill; Jeffrey P Jacobs; Francis X Moga; David M Overman; Jane W Newburger; Sherry A Glied; Emile A Bacha Journal: World J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg Date: 2019-03
Authors: Rachel R Kelz; Morgan M Sellers; Bijan A Niknam; James E Sharpe; Paul R Rosenbaum; Alexander S Hill; Hong Zhou; Lauren L Hochman; Karl Y Bilimoria; Kamal Itani; Patrick S Romano; Jeffrey H Silber Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2021-02-01 Impact factor: 13.787
Authors: Yeongin Jung; Kihun Kim; Sang Tae Choi; Jin Mo Kang; Noo Ree Cho; Dai Sik Ko; Yun Hak Kim Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2022-07-04 Impact factor: 4.996
Authors: Jo Wray; Deborah Ridout; Alison Jones; Peter Davis; Paul Wellman; Warren Rodrigues; Emma Hudson; Victor Tsang; Christina Pagel; Katherine L Brown Journal: Ann Thorac Surg Date: 2020-11-27 Impact factor: 4.330