Vichan Watthanakaiwan1,2, Manakorn Sukmak3, Kriengsak Hamarit2, Nongnid Kaolim3, Worawidh Wajjwalku1,3, Yuttamol Muangkram4. 1. Interdisciplinary Graduate Program in Genetic Engineering, The Graduate School, Kasetsart University, Bangkok, 10900, Thailand. 2. Entomology & Zoology Research Group, Plant Protection Research & Development Office, Department of Agriculture, Chatuchuk, Bangkok, 10900, Thailand. 3. Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kasetsart University, Kamphaeng Sean Campus, Nakhon Pathom, 73140, Thailand. 4. Graduate School of Life Sciences, Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu, Shiga 525-8577, Japan.
Abstract
Sarcocystis species are heteroxenous cyst-forming coccidian protozoan parasites with a wide host range, including rodents. In this study, Sarcocystis spp. samples were isolated from Bandicota indica, Rattus argentiventer, R. tiomanicus and R. norvegicus across five provinces of Thailand. Two major groups of Sarcocystis cysts were determined in this study: large and small cysts. By sequence comparisons and phylogenetic analyses based on the partial sequences of 28S ribosomal DNA, the large cysts showed the highest identity value (99%) with the S. zamani in GenBank database. While the small cysts could be divided into 2 groups of Sarcocystis: S. singaporensis and presupposed S. zuoi. The further analysis on 18S rDNA supported that the 2 isolates (S2 and B6 no.2) were as identified as S. singaporensis shared a high sequence identity with the S. singaporensis in GenBank database and the unidentified Sarcocystis (4 isolates, i.e., B6 no.10, B6 no.12, B10 no.4 and B10 no.7) showed 96.3-99.5% identity to S. zuoi as well as high distinct identity from others Sarcocystis spp. (≤93%). The result indicated that these four samples should be S. zuoi. In this study, we provided complete sequence of internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1), 5.8S rDNA and internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) of these three Sarcocystis species and our new primer set could be useful to study the evolution of Sarcocystis.
Sarcocystis species are heteroxenous cyst-forming coccidian protozoan parasites with a wide host range, including rodents. In this study, Sarcocystis spp. samples were isolated from Bandicota indica, Rattus argentiventer, R. tiomanicus and R. norvegicus across five provinces of Thailand. Two major groups of Sarcocystis cysts were determined in this study: large and small cysts. By sequence comparisons and phylogenetic analyses based on the partial sequences of 28S ribosomal DNA, the large cysts showed the highest identity value (99%) with the S. zamani in GenBank database. While the small cysts could be divided into 2 groups of Sarcocystis: S. singaporensis and presupposed S. zuoi. The further analysis on 18S rDNA supported that the 2 isolates (S2 and B6 no.2) were as identified as S. singaporensis shared a high sequence identity with the S. singaporensis in GenBank database and the unidentified Sarcocystis (4 isolates, i.e., B6 no.10, B6 no.12, B10 no.4 and B10 no.7) showed 96.3-99.5% identity to S. zuoi as well as high distinct identity from others Sarcocystis spp. (≤93%). The result indicated that these four samples should be S. zuoi. In this study, we provided complete sequence of internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1), 5.8S rDNA and internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) of these three Sarcocystis species and our new primer set could be useful to study the evolution of Sarcocystis.
Sarcocystis species are cyst-forming coccidia (Alveolata: Apicomplexa:
Coccidia) and have two host life cycles between the sexual and asexual stages (heteroxenous
life cycles), using the predator–prey relationship [1,
7]. During the sexual stage, sporocysts multiply in
the small intestine of the definitive host (predator) and are excreted in the definitive
host’s feces, and the asexual stage (sarcocysts) develops in the muscles of the intermediate
host [15]. S. zamani and S.
singaporensis use rodents of the genera Bandicota and
Rattus as intermediate hosts and snakes (Python
reticulatus) as definitive hosts [11, 17]. During the life cycle of S. zuoi,
Norway rats (R. norvegicus) are used as intermediate hosts and snakes
(Elaphe) as definitive hosts [1,
9]. Several species in this group, such as S.
neurona and S. canis, can cause systemic illness in many species
of animals [6], and S. nesbitti is a
causative agent of acute human muscular sarcocystosis in Malaysia [1, 2, 10].Basically, the identification of this genus has been based on the cyst morphology and the
molecular method or a combination of these methods [11,
15]. Phylogenetic analyses on the members of this
group have largely been based on nuclear ribosomal DNA (rDNA), such as the 18S rDNA and 28S
rDNA nucleotide sequences, to reconstruct the evolutionary relationship between the organisms
[13, 16, 17]. The 18S rDNA sequences are becoming possible to
improve and refine the current taxonomic system which is based mainly on phenotypic characters
[5], while the 28S rDNA helped to resolve some
relationships and confirm other postulated from the 18S rDNA analyses [13]. The internal transcribed spacer (ITS1 and ITS2) regions can be useful
for the identification and differentiation of closely related Sarcocystis
species, such as S. calchasi and S. columbae, which are
found in wood pigeons (Columba palumbus) [14, 16]. However, there are still a few
complete sequences of ITS1, 5.8S rDNA and ITS2 data in Sarcocystis spp.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In 2013 and 2014, a total of 15 wild rodents (Rodentia: Muridae) of the genera
Bandicota and Rattus were used in this study. Species
identification of rodents was performed by rodents’ specialist (Hamarit; personal
communication). All rodents examined were obtained as fresh carcasses from several farmers
in five provinces of Thailand (Table
1), because the rodents were considered as pest animals in farms. Sarcocysts
were isolated from the abdominal muscles or all striated muscles and investigated under a
light microscope (LM) (Olympus BX40, Tokyo, Japan) at the total magnification of 50×, 100×
and 400×, respectively. The observed sarcocysts were individually dissected, placed in
labeled 1.5 ml tubes and then kept frozen at −20°C until the DNA extraction
process. Total genomic DNA (gDNA) was extracted using the QIAmp DNA mini kit (Qiagen,
Hilden, Germany) according to the manufacturer’s tissue protocol recommendations. For the
polymerase chain reaction (PCR), we designed primers based on 28S rDNA nucleotide sequences
of S. zamani and S. singaporensis (AF237616 and AF237617)
from previous studies [13], and the primers of 18S
rDNA, ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2 and 28S rDNA (Table
2 and Fig. 1) were employed for the amplification of Sarcocystis species in this
study. Each PCR reaction mixture contained 3 µl of the gDNA template
solution, 10× HF buffer, 200 µM of dNTPs, 10 µM of each
primers and 1 U Phusion hotstart Taq DNA polymerase (Thermo Scientific,
Waltham, MA, U.S.A.). The PCR was performed in a Peltier thermal cycler machine (Bio-Rad,
Hercules, CA, U.S.A.), model PTC-200, the program of which was 98°C for 30 sec, followed by
40 cycles of 98°C for 30 sec, 60°C for 30 sec and 72°C for 90 sec, ending with a final
extension of 72°C for 5 min. The PCR products were purified using the Gel Elution Kit
(GeneMark, Taipei, Taiwan), according to the manufacturer’s protocol recommendations. The
PCR products were sent to First BASE laboratories, Shah Alam, Malaysia for sequencing. The
obtained sequences were aligned by Muscle in the MEGA 6 software [19] and edited to build a consensus sequence for each segment, using the
BioEdit version 7.0 [8]. The nucleotide sequences of
the Sarcocystis species (15 isolates) in this study were deposited in the
GenBank database with the following accession numbers: S. zamani:
KU244520–KU244528, S. singaporensis: KU341122–KU341123 and S.
zuoi: KU341118–KU341121. Phylogenetic relationship was calculated by using three
different methods, including neighbor-joining (NJ), maximum parsimony (MP) and maximum
likelihood (ML). The phylogenetic trees were constructed and selected the best model using
Find Best DNA Model test performed via MEGA 6 software [19]. The Hasegawa-Kishino-Yano model was used for ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2 full length
region. For 18S rDNA and 28S rDNA, partial sequences were performed using the Kimura
2-parameter distance model and Tamura 3-parameter, respectively. The three phylogenetic
trees were tested using 1,000 bootstrap replicates, and the sequences of Toxoplasma
gondii (X75429) and Besnoitia besnoiti (DQ227419) were used as
the out group.
Table 1.
The Sarcocystis spp. isolates used in this study
Species
Accession no.
Voucher no.
Country
Sampling location
Locality coordinating
Size of the cyst
Intermediate host
S. zamani
KU244520
B23 no.3
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 0543833 1207973
Large cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
KU244521
BJ no.1
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 054090 1212120
Large cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
KU244522
DOA02
Thailand
Krasaesin, Songkhla
47N 649220 844496
Large cyst
Rattus argentiventer
KU244523
DOA05
Thailand
Krasaesin, Songkhla
47N 649220 844496
Large cyst
Rattus argentiventer
KU244524
no.1
Thailand
Hua Hin, PraChuap Khiri Khan
47P 604044 1389620
Large cyst
Bandicota indica
KU244525
no.2
Thailand
Hua Hin, PraChuap Khiri Khan
47P 604044 1389620
Large cyst
Bandicota indica
KU244526
no.15
Thailand
BanMi, Lopburi
47P 659640 1669000
Large cyst
Rattus argentiventer
KU244527
no. 13.2a)
Thailand
Bangkhen, Bangkok
47P 672509 1534355
Large cyst
Rattus norvegicus
KU244528
R.t
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 0543090 1212120
Large cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
S. zuoi
KU341120
B10 no.4
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 0542724 1210951
Small cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
KU341119
B6 no.12
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 0543038 1210361
Small cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
KU341121
B10 no.7
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 0542724 1210951
Small cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
KU341118
B6 no.10
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 0543038 1210361
Small cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
S. singaporensis
KU341122
S2
Thailand
Hua Hin, PraChuap Khiri Khan
47P 604044 1389620
Small cyst
Bandicota indica
KU341123
B6 no.2
Thailand
TaaSae, Chumphon
47P 0543038 1210361
Small cyst
Rattus tiomanicus
a) Samples maintained in our laboratory, Entomology & Zoology Research Group,
Plant Protection Research & Development Office, Department of Agriculture,
Chatuchuk, Bangkok, Thailand.
Table 2.
PCR forward (F) and reverse (R) primers used to amplify various DNA regions in
this study
Regions
Primer name
Sequences 5′ to 3′
T (°C)a)
Reference
18S rDNA
18S-Fw
AGC CAT GCA TGT CTA AGT ATA AG (23 bp)
60
Modified from [20]
1471-Rw
TAT CCC CAT CAC GAT GCA TAC (21 bp)
60
Modified from [20]
18S-3 (1251) w
GTT AAC GAA CGA GAC CTT AAC C (22 bp)
60
This study
zam-1717w
GTG AAC CTT AAC ACC TAG AGG AAG GA (26 bp)
76
This study (for S. zamani)
ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2
sar 5.8-1w
CAA TGG ATG TCT TGG CTC GCG CAA (24 bp)
68
This study
sar 5.8-2w
C AAA GAC ACT GAA ACA GAC GTG CTG (25 bp)
68
This study
zam-1870w
TCT CCG TTG CCG CCA GGA ACG TGA GAC (27 bp)
78
This study (for S. zamani)
28S rDNA
28S-1 (001) w
TAC CCG CTG AAC TTA AGC ATA TTA T (25 bp)
64
This study
28S-4 (290) w
TTT GCG CTC AAA TCC CGA TGA A (22 bp)
60
This study
28S-2 (1880) w
CTA GAG ACT GTT CCA CGC AGG CTT A (25 bp)
64
This study
a) T refers to annealing temperature,Yang et al. [20] .
Fig. 1.
Primers map of the 18S rDNA partial sequence, ITS1-5.8S-ITS2 complete sequence, 28S
rDNA partial sequence. The map has roughly been draw to scale. The primers positions
were indicated based on KU244520 Sarcocystis zamani (isolated B23
no.3) length 4,748 bp. *Primer zam-1717w and zam-1870w were specifically used for
nucleotides sequencing of S. zamani.
a) Samples maintained in our laboratory, Entomology & Zoology Research Group,
Plant Protection Research & Development Office, Department of Agriculture,
Chatuchuk, Bangkok, Thailand.a) T refers to annealing temperature,Yang et al. [20] .Primers map of the 18S rDNA partial sequence, ITS1-5.8S-ITS2 complete sequence, 28S
rDNA partial sequence. The map has roughly been draw to scale. The primers positions
were indicated based on KU244520 Sarcocystis zamani (isolated B23
no.3) length 4,748 bp. *Primer zam-1717w and zam-1870w were specifically used for
nucleotides sequencing of S. zamani.
RESULTS
By LM, two major groups of Sarcocystis cysts were determined in this
study: large and small cysts (Table 1). The
morphology of large cysts (N=9) looks like grains of rice with thin and delicate wall, and
they could be seen by the naked eye. Microscopic examination proved those of large cysts
that were similar to S. zamani [3].
The small cysts showed two types of sarcocysts; the first type (N=2) had thick wall cysts
and fine surface villi. These microscope findings suggest that the characteristics of the
tissue cysts were similar to those of S. singaporensis, in accordance with
the previous studies [3]. The second type of small
cysts (N=4) had thin wall cyst isolated from four isolations of R.
tiomanicus. Microscopically, they were determined as an unidentified species of
Sarcocystis spp., and the cyst surface was distinguished from that of
S. singaporensis.Both of the small cysts were smaller than those of S. zamani and difficult
to be seen with the naked eye. In this study, the phylogenetic tree construction based on
partial 18S rDNA, 28S rDNA and full-length ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2, sequences of sarcocysts
isolated from 14 wild rodents and 1 laboratory rat in Thailand [N=15] can be separated into
three groups (groups A–C) under NJ, ML and MP criteria (Figs. 2, 3, 4). These three Sarcocystis species from fifteen isolates in this
study (S. zamani, S. singaporensis and S.
zuoi) used rodent and snake as intermediate and definitive hosts, respectively.
The PCR product length of 18S rDNA and 28S rDNA was approximately 1.4 and 1.5 kb,
respectively. The PCR product of ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2 region was found three sizes in
S. zamani (approximately 560, 890 and 1,000 bp) and two sizes in
S. zuoi and S. singaporensis (estimated 1.0 and 1.3 kb,
respectively). The phylogenetic tree inferred with the partial sequences of 28S rDNA was
reconstructed using the NJ method supported an identical tree to that of the ML and MP
analyses. Groups A to C were placed in the reptile/mammal life cycle (used snake/rodent as
definitive and intermediate hosts, respectively) and were within these three groups (A–C)
with high bootstrap values identified and categorized based on the differences on morphology
of cysts: S. zamani group (group A: large cysts), S. zuoi
group (group B: small thin wall cysts) and S. singaporensis group (group C:
small thick wall cysts and surface villi) (Fig.
2). The tree topology of S. zamani group from our samples (N=9) was
placed in the same cluster as group A and could also be divided into two sub-clusters, i.e.,
i) seven samples (KU244520-KU244523 and KU244526-KU244528) which were isolated from three
different Rattus spp. and ii) two samples (KU244524-KU244525) which were
isolated from B. indica, that shared the highest identity value (99%) with
the S. zamani sequence (GenBank AF237616). The six small cyst samples were
classified into two groups (B and C). The two small cysts, isolates S2 (KU341122) and B6
no.2 (KU341123), were placed in group C with the S. singaporensis sequence
in the GenBank database (AF237617). While the four isolates, B10 no.4 (KU341120), B6 no.12
(KU341119), B6 no.10 (KU341118) and B10 no.7 (KU341121), from R. tiomanicus
in this study were placed in group B. When the four isolates from R.
tiomanicus (group B) were compared with S. zamani (group A) and
S. singaporensis (group C), the sequences identities were found to be
90.3–91.8% and 87.2–91.7%, respectively. Thus, the results show that the four
Sarcocystis isolates from R. tiomanicus have significant
genetic differences in the 28S rDNA sequence and can be separated from the S.
zamani and S. singaporensis species. A total of 15 isolates in
this study were phylogenetically fallen into three clades (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2.
Phylogenetic tree of Sarcocystis spp. based on 28S rDNA partial
sequences (1 kb) with related sequences obtained from GenBank database, reconstructed
using NJ/ML/MP method. The group (A–C) of Sarcocystis species is
identified as reptile/mammal life cycles. Bootstrap support (1,000 replicates) shows
at each node following three different methods, respectively, and the bootstrap values
below 70% are not shown. Scale bar is according to the branch length and rooted on
Toxoplasma gondii (X75429) and Besnoitia besnoiti
(DQ227419). *This isolation obtained from Sprague Dawley rat that was routinely used
in laboratory of entomology & Zoology Research Group, Plant Protection Research
& Development Office, Department of Agriculture, Thailand (personal
communication).
Fig. 3.
Phylogenetic tree of Sarcocystis spp. based on 18S rDNA partial
sequences (800 bp) and related sequences obtained from GenBank database, reconstructed
using NJ/ML/MP method. The group (A–C) of Sarcocystis species is
identified as reptile/mammal life cycles. Subgroup (BI, BII and CI, CII) was
classified by their diversity within species level. Bootstrap support (1,000
replicates) shows at each node following three different methods, respectively, and
the bootstrap values below 70% are not shown. Scale bar is according to the branch
length and rooted on Toxoplasma gondii (X75429) and Besnoitia
besnoiti (DQ227419). *This isolation obtained from Sprague Dawley rat
routinely used in laboratory of Entomology & Zoology Research Group, Plant
Protection Research & Development Office, Department of Agriculture, Thailand
(personal communication). (?) These species were previously reported as reptile/mammal
life cycles, but are genetically placed in mammal/mammal life cycles cluster.
Fig. 4.
Phylogenetic tree of Sarcocystis spp. based on 18S rDNA partial
sequences, internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1)-5.8S rDNA-internal transcribed
spacer 2 (ITS2) complete sequences and 28S rDNA partial sequences (3.7 kb) with
related sequences from GenBank database and reconstructed using NJ/ML/MP method. The
group (A–C) of Sarcocystis species is identified as reptile/mammal
life cycles. Bootstrap support (1,000 replicates) shows at each node following three
different methods, respectively, and the bootstrap values below 70% are not shown.
Scale bar is according to the branch length and rooted on Toxoplasma
gondii (X75429) and Besnoitia besnoiti (DQ227419). *This
isolation obtained from Sprague Dawley rat routinely used in laboratory of Entomology
& Zoology Research Group, Plant Protection Research & Development Office,
Department of Agriculture, Thailand (personal communication).
Phylogenetic tree of Sarcocystis spp. based on 28S rDNA partial
sequences (1 kb) with related sequences obtained from GenBank database, reconstructed
using NJ/ML/MP method. The group (A–C) of Sarcocystis species is
identified as reptile/mammal life cycles. Bootstrap support (1,000 replicates) shows
at each node following three different methods, respectively, and the bootstrap values
below 70% are not shown. Scale bar is according to the branch length and rooted on
Toxoplasma gondii (X75429) and Besnoitia besnoiti
(DQ227419). *This isolation obtained from Sprague Dawley rat that was routinely used
in laboratory of entomology & Zoology Research Group, Plant Protection Research
& Development Office, Department of Agriculture, Thailand (personal
communication).Phylogenetic tree of Sarcocystis spp. based on 18S rDNA partial
sequences (800 bp) and related sequences obtained from GenBank database, reconstructed
using NJ/ML/MP method. The group (A–C) of Sarcocystis species is
identified as reptile/mammal life cycles. Subgroup (BI, BII and CI, CII) was
classified by their diversity within species level. Bootstrap support (1,000
replicates) shows at each node following three different methods, respectively, and
the bootstrap values below 70% are not shown. Scale bar is according to the branch
length and rooted on Toxoplasma gondii (X75429) and Besnoitia
besnoiti (DQ227419). *This isolation obtained from Sprague Dawley rat
routinely used in laboratory of Entomology & Zoology Research Group, Plant
Protection Research & Development Office, Department of Agriculture, Thailand
(personal communication). (?) These species were previously reported as reptile/mammal
life cycles, but are genetically placed in mammal/mammal life cycles cluster.Phylogenetic tree of Sarcocystis spp. based on 18S rDNA partial
sequences, internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1)-5.8S rDNA-internal transcribed
spacer 2 (ITS2) complete sequences and 28S rDNA partial sequences (3.7 kb) with
related sequences from GenBank database and reconstructed using NJ/ML/MP method. The
group (A–C) of Sarcocystis species is identified as reptile/mammal
life cycles. Bootstrap support (1,000 replicates) shows at each node following three
different methods, respectively, and the bootstrap values below 70% are not shown.
Scale bar is according to the branch length and rooted on Toxoplasma
gondii (X75429) and Besnoitia besnoiti (DQ227419). *This
isolation obtained from Sprague Dawley rat routinely used in laboratory of Entomology
& Zoology Research Group, Plant Protection Research & Development Office,
Department of Agriculture, Thailand (personal communication).In the phylogenetic analysis based on the partial 18S rDNA sequences (Fig. 3), all isolates of S. zamani in this study (KU244520-KU244528) were
placed in the group A as well as unidentified Sarcocystis species isolated
from the reticulated python (Braghammerus reticulatus) (KC878485) with
97.8–98.6% identity. Group B is divided into two subgroups (BI and BII). Subgroup BI can be
separated into two clusters based on the bootstrap values, consisted of the four isolates
(KU341118–KU341121) from R. tiomanicus and S. zuoi
sequences in the GenBank (JQ029112 and JQ029113) from the king rat snake (Elaphe
carinata) in China [9], LC054267 from the
beauty snake (Elaphe taeniura) in Japan [1], and KC878487 and KC878488 from the Malayan keeled rat snake (Ptyas
carinata) in Malaysia. Subgroup BII was identified as S.
clethrionomyelaphis which comprised of Sarcocystis sp.
(KC201639) from the green tree python (Morelia viridis) and S.
clethrionomyelaphis (KP057504) from the beauty snake (E.
taeniura). The four isolates from R. tiomanicus in this study
(KU341118–KU341121) were located in the same group as S. zuoi, JQ029112 and
JQ029113 and closely related with other S. zuoi sequences in the GenBank
database. Sequences identity value of the four isolates (KU341118–KU341121) in this study
and S. zuoi sequences in GenBank database accounted for 96.3–99.5%, also
showed a distinct identity from others Sarcocystis spp. (93% or less).
Group C (the S. singaporensis species) was clustered into two minor groups
(CI–CII). For the isolate S2 (KU341122) from the bandicoot rat, B. indica,
and B6 no.2 (KU341123) from the Malaysian wood rat, R. tiomanicus, in the
present study, the phylogenetic placement of these two isolates as inferred from figures as
18S rDNA (Fig. 3) and 28S rDNA (Fig. 4) sequences was placed in the group of S. singaporensis species from
the GenBank database (group C). Sequences identity of S. singaporensis in
this study (KU341122-KU341123) had 99.8 and 100% identity (data not shown) to the closet
sequences of S. singaporensis in the GenBank, AF434056 and AF434058,
respectively for 18S rDNA. While 28S rDNA sequence data of both isolates, KU341122-KU341123,
were 98.4 and 96.3% identical with S. singaporensis from GenBank (AF237617)
and were higher than compared with S. zamani (88.3–94.5 and 90.3–91.8%) and
S. zuoi (87.6–93.6% and 87.2–91.7%). The results of sequence homology
indicated that the two isolates, KU341122 and KU341123, were identified as S.
singaporensis. The two fragments of 18S rDNA sequences in the present study
(KU341122 and KU341123), were placed in CI subgroup and closely related with the CII
subgroup, where the five sequences in CII used the Malayan brown pit viper, (Ovophis
convictus) as definitive hosts [1].
Although our phylogenetic tree can divide our sequences into different subgroups (BI/BII and
CI/CII), but the certain taxon was not supported by high bootstrap value, indicating
ambiguity at subgroup level for each tree. Other Sarcocystis species
isolated from snake definitive host was comprised of S. nesbitti and
S. atheridis which be clustered with the mammal/mammal life cycle (e.g.
S. tenella, S. capracanis, S. cruzi,
S. gigantea, S. moulei, S. buffalonis
and S. hirsuta). Three Sarcocystis species, including
S. dispersa, S. albifronsi and
Sarcocystis sp. ex Columba livia, were placed in the
cluster bird/bird life cycle and can be divided into two subgroups based on the high
bootstrap values (Fig. 3).The trees obtained from the complete ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2, partial 18S rDNA and 28S rDNA
nucleotide sequences of S. zamani, S. zuoi and S.
singaporensis in this study were estimated at 4 kb in length, The different
constructed methods (NJ, ML and MP) mostly supported the same branching pattern for each
region. However, the differences of branching pattern can be observed between phylogenetic
trees from different gene. The sequence homology for intraspecies level in our studied was
98.6–99 , 83.2–98.1 and 95% for S. zamani, S. zuoi and S.
singaporensis, respectively (data not shown). Conversely, for interspecies level,
the sequence homology among three species was ≤80% identity (data not shown). The topology
of the phylogenetic tree divided the 15 isolates of Sarcocystis species in
this study into five clusters, seven isolates of S. zamani (KU244520,
KU244521-KU244522, KU244524-KU244526 and KU244528), two isolates of S.
zamani (KU244523, KU244527), one isolate of S. zuoi (KU341120),
three isolates of S. zuoi (KU341118-KU341119 and KU341121) and two isolates
of S. singaporensis (KU341122-KU341123), respectively (Fig. 4).
DISCUSSION
The identification and classification of Sarcocystis species have been
based on morphology and biological data [5, 11, 16, 18], such as details of cyst wall, villi, host
specificity and their molecular characteristics. Morphological characteristic of the cyst
wall and the life cycle are two key criteria of conventional classification for
Sarcocystis. In addition, the study of speciation by using molecular
markers, such as 18S rDNA and ITS1 regions, is more efficient and accurate to classify the
Sarcocystis species, and it can resolve some questions and differentiate
the closely related species of the Sarcocystidae.The present study based on partial sequence of the 28S rDNA sequences revealed that
S. zamani has a close relationship to the S.
singaporensis and S. zuoi groups, place in “reptile/mammal life
cycle” cluster and separate from the mammal/mammal and the bird/bird life cycle cluster
(Fig. 2) as well as described in a previous
study [1, 11].
Since these 3 species used snakes as definitive hosts, thus our finding indicated that the
Sarcocystis species in this group are snake-transmitted species.Our phylogenetic tree based on partial sequence of the 18S rDNA sequence revealed the four
isolates (KU341118–KU341121) from R. tiomanicus are closely related to
S. zuoi (JQ029112 and JQ029113) isolated from king rat snake (E.
carinata) (Fig.
3). They were placed in S. zuoi group with high
identity value (96.3–99.5%) and demonstrated clearly different from S.
zamani and S. singaporensis, indicating that these four isolates
may be S. zuoi species. So far, the 18S rDNA sequence data have favored the
co-evolution of Sarcocystis species in snakes, with a definitive host
rather than intermediate host [5]. Therefore, our
study hypothesized that the Elaphe or Ptyas snake may be
the definitive host of the four isolates from R. tiomanicus in this study.
For S. singaporensis (group C), our analysis found high genetic divergent
among this species and can divide into two subgroups (CI-CII; Fig. 3). S. singaporensis has been considered as
highly pathogenic caused lethal death in rat and widely dispersed across Southeast Asia. The
intermediate host included Rattus and Bandicota species as
well as this study. Many studies reported that python was the natural definitive host [11, 17]. In
addition, the viper (O. convictus) was considered as a definitive host of
S. singaporensis according to Abe, 2015 [1] and clustered in the “CII” subgroup (Fig.
3). Although, the bootstrap value (73/74/86) provided low clustering supported
divergence between “CI” and “CII”, however, accordance with previous studies [11, 17], can be
implied that S. singaporensis within the “CI” subgroup and two isolates in
this study (KU341122 and KU341123), used a python as a definitive host.The phylogenetic analyses based on the partial 18S rDNA sequences (Fig. 3) demonstrated that S. nesbitti (KC878477) and
S. atheridis (AF120114) were placed in the same cluster of
Sarcocystis species that have mammal/mammal life cycle. However,
S. nesbitti and S. atheridis were considered to use
snake as a definitive host [1, 11], indicating that the phylogenetic position of the
Sarcocystis species did not correlate with their definitive hosts/life
cycle, according to the previous studies [18].The phylogenetic tree construction using 18S rDNA, 28S rDNA partial sequences and ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2 full-length sequences region, can be divided into 4 subgroups, among the 13
isolates of S. zamani and S. zuoi (Fig. 4). To date, the ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2 region was considered to
evolve much faster than other rDNA regions [4, 12]. Thus, the phylogenetic analyses based on ITS1-5.8S
rDNA-ITS2 sequences would be useful for distinguishing among the same species or sub-species
level better than the more slowly evolving, such as 18S rDNA and 28S rDNA region, and are
better to use among different species level. In conclusion, this study is the first report
on the molecular characteristics of the full-length ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2, partial 18S and 28S
rDNA nucleotide sequences of S. zamani, S. zuoi and
S. singaporensis in the GenBank database and to reveal the genetic
diversity of the three species distributed in Thailand. However, the definitive host
(snakes) was not verified for S. zuoi species in this study. In further
studies, more feces samples of wild snakes containing sporocysts should be collected, and
the transmission experiment must be conducted to clarify the definitive host of S.
zuoi and other Sarcocystis species in Thailand. Therefore, not
only the analysis sequences in one region gene, but also the comparison in other regions are
insufficient for the classification of Sarcocystis species. Nevertheless,
further sampling from a broader geographic area in Thailand and combined data will clarify
the question of genetic variation and genetic diversity in this species. The benefits
derived from this study can be helpful for further research of Sarcocystis
species in snake definitive hosts and application for classification to prevent protozoa
infection in both human and animals.
Authors: Mercedes Fernández-Escobar; Javier Millán; Andrea D Chirife; Luis Miguel Ortega-Mora; Rafael Calero-Bernal Journal: Parasitol Res Date: 2020-06-25 Impact factor: 2.289