| Literature DB >> 28674685 |
Michael Silvey1, Leonardo R Brandão2.
Abstract
Congenital heart disease (CHD) is a common condition in the pediatric population, affecting up to 1% of all live births (i.e., around 40,000 newborns/year in the United States). Although CHD does have a wide range of severity, by the age of 5 years approximately 80% of patients will require at least one surgical intervention to achieve a complete/palliative cardiac repair. Today, in light of their much-improved surgical survival, the care of these patients focuses on morbidity prevention and/or treatment. One such morbidity has been the increased frequency of thrombotic occlusions [e.g., cardioembolic arterial ischemic strokes; arterial, cardiac, and/or newly created shunt thrombosis; venous thromboembolism (VTE)]. Patients with CHD are at high risk of developing thrombosis due to the disruption of blood flow, CHD-related coagulopathy, inflammation, and/or platelet activation secondary to extracorporeal circulation support required during open-heart surgery or as a bridge to recovery, which can increase thrombus formation. In this article, we will discuss how the coagulation system is altered in patients with CHD in regard to the patient's anatomy, procedures they undergo to correct their congenital heart defect, and other risk factors that may increase their thrombotic risk, focusing on VTE. We will also discuss the most recently published reports pertaining to guidelines on prophylaxis and treatment of VTE in this population. Finally, we will briefly address the long-term VTE outcomes for patients with CHD.Entities:
Keywords: congenital heart disease; congenital heart disease and thrombosis; venous thromboembolism; venous thromboembolism prophylaxis; venous thromboembolism risk factors; venous thromboembolism treatment
Year: 2017 PMID: 28674685 PMCID: PMC5476169 DOI: 10.3389/fped.2017.00146
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Pediatr ISSN: 2296-2360 Impact factor: 3.418
Published literature regarding thrombosis risk factors and outcomes in CHD patients.
| Reference | Study design | Prospective/retrospective | Number of patients | Main VTE findings | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Faraoni ( | Database review of CHD patients | Retrospective | 27,492 | Thrombotic complications in 3.9% of surgical CHD patients; younger age, single-ventricle physiology associated with increased risk | Retrospective; no access to pt charts, data could be missed or miscoded, causality not established |
| Manlhiot et al. ( | Cohort of CHD patients who developed thrombosis and outcomes | Retrospective | 192 | Serious complications occurred with 17–24% of thrombi, 13% of patients had bleeding complications | Retrospective, no standardized follow-up, unable to assess for thrombophilia, asymptomatic thrombus not identified |
| Jensen et al. ( | Cross-sectional study examining pulmonary and cerebral thrombosis | Prospective | 98 | Prevalence of cerebral and pulmonary thrombosis: 47 and 31% | Unable to determine when the thrombotic event occurred, small sample size |
| Emani et al. ( | Single-ventricle physiology cohort | Retrospective | 512 | 51 patients developed thrombosis (10%); patients with thrombosis had longer ICU and hospital stays, single-ventricle physiology and CBP were risk factors | Retrospective, small number of patients, small number of thrombotic events |
| Wessel et al. ( | Multicenter, randomized double-blind, placebo controlled study examining clopidogrel in CHD patients | Prospective | 906 | Clopidogrel did not reduce mortality or shunt-related morbidity | Heterogeneity of the patient population, could not compare Aspirin + clopidogrel vs. clopidogrel alone, difficulty to diagnose shunt thrombosis |
| Idorn ( | Population-based study of Fontan patients | Retrospective for prevalence, prospective for laboratory testing | 210 | Thromboembolic prevalence was 8.1%, no evidence of hypercoagulability in the patient groups | Blood samples not taken at the time of thrombotic event, could not establish reference ranges for coagulation tests |
| Manlhiot ( | Cross-sectional study of patients undergoing cardiac surgery | Retrospective | 357 | Thrombotic incidence was 40 and 28% after initial palliation and superior cavopulmonary connection, thromboprophylaxis with enoxaparin was associated with a reduced risk of thrombotic complications, thrombosis was associated with increased mortality | Retrospective, no control group |
| Hanson et al. ( | Observational study for VTE risk factors in critically ill CHD patients | Prospective | 1,070 | VTE incidence was 3.8% with 37% of VTEs being CVC-related; VTE was associated with single-ventricle physiology, and more CVC days | Heterogeneity of the patient population, no screening of VTE |
| Tzanetos et al. ( | Observational study for predictors of thrombosis in single-ventricle physiology patients | Prospective | 16 | Perioperative thrombus incidence was 31%, thrombus associated with longer CPB times, poor ventricular function, and lower antithrombin and tissue plasminogen activator antigen levels | Small sample size, no control group, no long-term follow-up data, unequal distribution of patients among surgical intervention groups |
| Monagle et al. ( | Multicenter, randomized trial comparing ASA vs. heparin/warfarin for primary prophylaxis | Prospective | 111 | No difference between the ASA vs. heparin/warfarin arms | Poor recruitment leading to less than optimal number of patients |
| Manlhiot et al. ( | Single center, cohort study of CHD patients | Retrospective | 1,361 | VTE incidence was 11%, VTE associated with increased number of ICU and hospital days, cardiac arrest, and higher mortality | Retrospective, possible incomplete medical records, unable to prove causality between VTE and morbidity/mortality |
| Kim ( | Cohort study of CHD patients | Retrospective | 200 | VTE occurred in 13 patients (6.5%), mostly happening within 1 year after the Fontan procedure | Retrospective, small sample size |
| Hanslik ( | Cohort study of CHD patients | Prospective | 90 | VTE was detected in 25 patients (28%), all VTEs occurred in the right jugular vein | Possible overestimation of sensitivity of diagnostic tests, follow-up monitoring not done |
| Li et al. ( | Multicenter non-randomized, observational study examining aspirin efficacy in lowering risk of death and shunt thrombosis | Prospective | 1,004 | Patients on ASA with lower risk of shunt thrombosis and death | Non-randomized, observational, no other antiplatelet or anticoagulation given, shunt characteristics not related to shunt thrombosis |
| Cholette ( | Observational study of neonates undergoing cardiac surgery | Prospective | 22 | 5/22 (23%) patients had evidence of thrombosis, C-RP elevation was the only predictor of thrombosis development | Small sample size |
| Kaulitz ( | Cohort of patients undergoing total cavopulmonary anastomosis | Retrospective | 142 | 10 patients (7%) suffered thrombotic events, 8 patients with VTE, and 2 patients with stroke | Retrospective, small number of patients |
| Gurgey ( | Review of CHD patients with thrombosis and thrombophilic factors | Retrospective | 28 | Overall frequency of Factor V Leiden and prothrombin Gene mutation was 22%, 5 patients had the FVL gene mutation and 1 pt had the prothrombin gene mutation | Retrospective, no control group, small sample size |
| Seipelt ( | Cohort study of CHD patients | Retrospective | 101 | Thrombotic events happened in 13/85 hospital survivors (15.3%) | Retrospective, small number of patients |
| Jacobs ( | Survey of patients who underwent Fontan procedure and aspirin use | Retrospective | 72 | No thrombotic event was documented (0%) | Retrospective, no control group, small number of patients |
| Coon et al. ( | Echocardiogram findings in Fontan patients | Retrospective | 592 | Thrombosis prevalence 8.8% | Retrospective, various time intervals until imaging was performed |
| Petaja et al. ( | Single center, cohort study of CHD patients | Retrospective | 1,499 | Central venous thrombosis incidence was 1.1%; mortality associated with central venous thrombosis was 40% | Retrospective |
| Petaja et al. ( | Single center cohort study of CHD patients | Retrospective | 10 | 3 patients who developed thrombosis had decreased antithrombin or protein C levels and elevated plasminogen activator inhibitor levels | Retrospective, small sample size |
| Rosenthal ( | Cohort study of patients undergoing the Fontan procedure | Retrospective | 70 | 14 patients (20%) developed thromboembolism with 12/14 thrombi located in the venous circulation | Retrospective, small number of patients |
CHD, congenital heart disease; VTE, venous thromboembolism; ASA, aspirin; ICU, intensive care unit; CPB, cardiopulmonary bypass; C-RP, C-reactive protein; CVC, central venous catheter.