We report on the synthesis and structure-property relations of a novel, dual-responsive organometallic poly(ionic liquid) (PIL), consisting of a poly(ferrocenylsilane) backbone of alternating redox-active, silane-bridged ferrocene units and tetraalkylphosphonium sulfonate moieties in the side groups. This PIL is redox responsive due to the presence of ferrocene in the backbone and also exhibits a lower critical solution temperature (LCST)-type thermal responsive behavior. The LCST phase transition originates from the interaction between water molecules and the ionic substituents and shows a concentration-dependent, tunable transition temperature in aqueous solution. The PIL's LCST-type transition temperature can also be influenced by varying the redox state of ferrocene in the polymer main chain. As the polymer can be readily cross-linked and is easily converted into hydrogels, it represents a new dual-responsive materials platform. Interestingly, the as-formed hydrogels display an unusual, strongly hysteretic volume-phase transition indicating useful thermal memory properties. By employing the dispersing abilities of this cationic PIL, CNT-hydrogel composites were successfully prepared. These hybrid conductive composite hydrogels showed bi-stable states and tunable resistance in heating-cooling cycles.
We report on the synthesis and structure-property relations of a novel, dual-responsive organometallic poly(ionic liquid) (PIL), consisting of a poly(ferrocenylsilane) backbone of alternating redox-active, silane-bridged ferrocene units and tetraalkylphosphonium sulfonate moieties in the side groups. This PIL is redox responsive due to the presence of ferrocene in the backbone and also exhibits a lower critical solution temperature (LCST)-type thermal responsive behavior. The LCST phase transition originates from the interaction between water molecules and the ionic substituents and shows a concentration-dependent, tunable transition temperature in aqueous solution. The PIL's LCST-type transition temperature can also be influenced by varying the redox state of ferrocene in the polymer main chain. As the polymer can be readily cross-linked and is easily converted into hydrogels, it represents a new dual-responsive materials platform. Interestingly, the as-formed hydrogels display an unusual, strongly hysteretic volume-phase transition indicating useful thermal memory properties. By employing the dispersing abilities of this cationic PIL, CNT-hydrogel composites were successfully prepared. These hybrid conductive composite hydrogels showed bi-stable states and tunable resistance in heating-cooling cycles.
Stimuli-responsive
or “smart” soft materials have
raised considerable attention due to their ability to spontaneously
respond to external environmental variations,[1−3] such as changes
in temperature, pH, solvent, pressure, and magnetic or electric fields,
showing promising potential applications in sensing,[4] gating materials,[5] actuators,
and molecular devices.[6] Thus, design and
synthesis of stimuli-responsive, multi-functional materials have received
distinguished attention in polymer chemistry and materials science.[7−9]Polymers with lower critical solution temperature (LCST)-type
behavior
are an important subclass of “smart” materials that
exhibit a reversible conformation transition between coil and globule,
stimulated by a thermal trigger. Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)
(PNIPAM) and its polyamide analogues are well-known examples.[10,11] They are usually electrostatically neutral or weakly charged in
aqueous solution. Poly(ionic liquid)s (PILs) bearing a quaternary
phosphoniumsulfonate ion pair, obtained by the direct polymerization
of corresponding monomers, were introduced recently as strong polyelectrolytes,
broadening the design scope of thermo-responsive “smart”
materials, with promising applications in desalination, selective
absorption, responsive hydrogels, dispersants, and stabilizers.[12−17]Poly(ferrocenylsilane)s (PFSs), composed of alternating ferrocene
and silane units along the main chain, are a fascinating class of
redox-active organometallic polymers featuring a high density of redox
centers and excellent processability.[18−21] The post-polymerization modification
method is often employed in polymer synthesis to endow the macromolecules
with designer properties and diverse functionalities.[22−24] In previous works, a variety of post-functionalized PFSs have been
designed and prepared by substituting different side groups, e.g.,
acrylate, imidazolium, azide, and poly(ethylene glycol) chains, yielding
innovative functional organometallic polymer materials with desirable
properties.[25−30]In this paper, we demonstrate that the conjugation of thermo-responsive
ionic liquid moieties with organometallic polymer backbones by post-polymerization
modification would offer interesting opportunities for the synthesis
and applications of tailor-made, “smart” soft materials
with unexpected responsive behavior. By using this strategy, we introduce
novel dual-responsive PILs based on redox-active poly(ferrocenylsilane)s.
Redox- and thermo-responsive PILs are used as building blocks to construct “smart”
hydrogels which display surprising and interesting hysteretic volume-phase
transitions with unexpected bi-stable states at room temperature.
Results
and Discussion
Dual-Responsive PILs
As illustrated
in Scheme , tetraalkylphosphonium
side
groups are introduced to PFS by a simple quaternization reaction between
poly(ferrocenyl(3-iodopropyl) methylsilane) (PFS-I) and tri-n-butylphosphine (PBu3) in a mixture of THF and
DMSO, forming a new organometallic PIL, i.e., PFS-PBu3.
Iodide was exchanged with chloride or alkyl sulfonate counterions
by dialysis in the corresponding aqueous salt solution. The resulting
polymer was characterized by 1H NMR spectroscopy, indicating
the quantitative conversion of the iodopropyl groups of PFS-I into
tetraalkylphosphonium groups, as was evident from the complete disappearance
of the CH2-I signal in the 1H NMR spectrum at
δ = 3.2 ppm. After adequate dialysis, successful exchange of
the iodide counterions into pentanesulfonate (C5S) counterions
was also supported by 1H NMR spectroscopy, revealing the
signals typical of C5S with the expected integrals (Figure
S1, Supporting Information).
Scheme 1
Synthesis
of Dual-Responsive PILs from a Nucleophilic Substitution
Reaction
The counterion species
strongly influences the PFSpolyelectrolyte
properties in water due to the hydrophobicity−hydrophilicity
balance.[31,32] When PFS-PBu3 includes chloride
as the counterion, the polymer can be well dissolved in water. In
a recent report by Yuan and co-workers, a phosphonium-based cationic
PIL containing an alkyl sulfonate anion was found to undergo a LCST-type
phase transition in aqueous solutions.[14] Here, the new PIL with structural similarity, the PFS-PBu3 bearing C5S as counterion also displays a LCST-type phase
transition when the temperature is raised (Figure S2, Supporting Information). The aqueous polymer
solution of PFS-PBu3-C5S was transparent at
room temperature and gradually turned into a yellow opaque suspension
upon heating. The original transparent state of the solution could
be recovered upon cooling back to room temperature.The thermo-responsive
properties of PFS-PBu3-C5S in water as a function
of polymer concentration were studied first.
Turbidity experiments revealed sharp and tunable LCST phase transition
behavior of the PFS-PBu3-C5S in water (Figure a). The cloud point
temperature increased from 22 °C (8 wt%) to 49 °C (1 wt%)
upon gradual dilution (Figure b). In contrast to typical neutral thermo-responsive polymers,
e.g., PNIPAM, which exhibit a cloud point temperature within a rather
narrow range around 32 °C, the phase transition temperature of
most thermo-responsive PILs changes over a wide range depending on
polymer concentration and the type and concentration of additional
salts. This behavior is usually explained as a result of the structural
balance between the alkyl sulfonate counterion with a hydrophobic
hydrocarbon tail and the hydrophilic charged group.[33]
Figure 1
(a) Turbidity curves of PFS-PBu3-C5S in aqueous
solution at concentrations of 1, 2, 4, 6, and 8 wt%. (b) Cloud points
of PFS-PBu3-C5S in aqueous solution at different
concentrations. (c) DLS measurements of dual-responsive PIL in reduced
(1 wt% PFS-PBu3-Cl, 40 mM NaC5S with 60 mM NaCl)
and oxidized (1 wt% PFS-PBu3-Cl, 40 mM NaC5S
with 20 mM FeCl3) states. (d) Photographs of reduced and
oxidized PIL at 20 and 40 °C, respectively.
(a) Turbidity curves of PFS-PBu3-C5S in aqueous
solution at concentrations of 1, 2, 4, 6, and 8 wt%. (b) Cloud points
of PFS-PBu3-C5S in aqueous solution at different
concentrations. (c) DLS measurements of dual-responsive PIL in reduced
(1 wt% PFS-PBu3-Cl, 40 mM NaC5S with 60 mM NaCl)
and oxidized (1 wt% PFS-PBu3-Cl, 40 mM NaC5S
with 20 mM FeCl3) states. (d) Photographs of reduced and
oxidized PIL at 20 and 40 °C, respectively.Due to the presence of the ferrocene units in the PFS main
chain,
the corresponding organometallic PILs display redox-responsive behavior.
The polymer shows a reversible color change from amber to dark green
upon oxidation (Figure d). The reduced PFS exhibits an absorbance peak at 450 nm, corresponding
to a characteristic d-d electronic transition (Figure S3a, Supporting Information). After oxidation, a new
peak at 635 nm appears due to the formation of ferrocenium cations.
Regarding the redox behavior, typical double wave-shaped voltammetry
signals, representative of PFSs were observed (Figure S3b, Supporting Information) demonstrating redox-responsiveness
originating from ferrocene in the polymer main chain and electronic
pπ–dπ coupling between neighboring ferrocene units
via Si bridges.[34,35]The excess positive charge
along the PFS main chain from chemical
or electrochemical oxidation increases the overall hydrophilicity,
which results in a redox-switchable thermo-responsive behavior. As
shown in Figure d,
the solution of neutral, or reduced, polymer turned turbid upon elevating
the temperature, while the oxidized polymer remains clear upon heating,
i.e., the LCST phase transition is absent. In order to explain this
redox-switchable behavior, temperature-dependent dynamic light scattering
(DLS) experiments were conducted on samples with constant polymer
concentration (Figure c). The counterion species and their concentration were carefully
controlled to remain identical in both reduced and oxidized samples,
ruling out the influence of the counterion composition. The values
of the hydrodynamic radii of the polymer particles in aqueous solution
are displayed in Figure c. At room temperature, the solution contains molecularly dissolved
polymer chains with some very small residual fraction of aggregates
with diameter <100 nm. Upon heating, the primary soluble aggregates
slightly grow at lower temperatures and suddenly jump-increase in
size at 29 °C, while the chain dimensions of the oxidized state
sample remain essentially unchanged. This transition is confirmed
by turbidity measurements (Figure S4, Supporting Information), illustrating that the LCST of PFS-PBu3 is significantly influenced by the redox state of the PFS main chain.
During oxidation, the polymer main chains become positively charged
and the backbones are highly strained due to the increased Kuhn length
and segment elasticity,[36−38] which inhibits the torsion and
rotation of the side groups that would promote aggregate forming.
The hydrophilicity of the polymer backbones also increases with oxidation,
influencing the hydrophobicity–hydrophilicity balance in the
aqueous polymer system. The combined action of these effects suppresses
the LCST transition.
Dual-Responsive PIL-Based Hydrogel
Acrylate or acrylamide
moieties allow rapid and quantitative uniform cross-linking under
mild conditions by thiol-Michael addition reactions.[25]N-[3-(Dimethylamino)propyl] methacrylamide
(DMAPMA) was introduced to the PFS backbone to obtain a cross-linkable
dual-responsive polymer prior to the addition of PBu3 (Figure a and Experimental Methods). Defined quantities of DMAPMA (0.45,
0.25, 0.15, and 0.08 in repeat unit molar ratio) were incorporated
by reaction of PFS-I with this methacrylamide.
Figure 2
(a) Schematic representation
of cross-linkable PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3. (b) Photographs of PFS-based
dual-responsive hydrogels formed
by using a 4-arm PEG-thiol cross-linker. (c) Hydrogel composition
(H1–H7) based on PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 and 4-arm PEG-thiol cross-linker with different cross-linking
degree (x) and DMAPMA/PBu3 ratio ((x + y):z).
(a) Schematic representation
of cross-linkable PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3. (b) Photographs of PFS-based
dual-responsive hydrogels formed
by using a 4-arm PEG-thiol cross-linker. (c) Hydrogel composition
(H1–H7) based on PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 and 4-arm PEG-thiol cross-linker with different cross-linking
degree (x) and DMAPMA/PBu3 ratio ((x + y):z).Reaction between PFS-I and DMAPMA was proved by
FTIR and 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy (Figures
S5, S6, and S7, Supporting Information).
Because of the presence
of DMAPMA, the organometallic polymers can be transformed into dual-responsive
PIL networks. Hydrogels were prepared from PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 and 4-arm PEG-thiol with a pentaerythritol core by the rapid and
quantitative thiol-Michael addition reaction under mild conditions
(Figure b,c). Subsequently,
the hydrogels obtained were characterized.The water content
in the hydrogels was determined to be 95 wt%
for H3. The mechanical properties of H1, H2, and H3 were evaluated by dynamic mechanical
measurements, indicating the elastic nature of the hydrogel networks.
The storage modulus did not depend on the frequency in the employed
frequency range between 0.06 and 60 rad/s (Figure S8, Supporting Information). The mechanical data
obtained show that the hydrogels can be considered as “hard
gels” (G′> 1 kPa) according to Hvidt’s
classification.[39,40]Similar to the phase transition
of non-cross-linked PFS-PBu3 in aqueous solution, the hydrogels
obtained from the organometallic
PILs also show LCST-type thermo-responsive behavior. The transition
temperature could be tuned by varying the cross-linking degree (CD)
and the choice of the counterion species in the hydrogel, which influence
the hydrophobicity−hydrophilicity balance in the systems
(Figure ). For the
hydrogel with C5S counterions, the transition temperature
increases from 42 °C (8% CD) to above 50 °C (15% CD). For
the specimen with the highest cross-link density (25%) the transition
became very broad, thus no clear LCST could be defined. However, it
is clear that further shifts of the LCST value with increasing CD
takes place. We postulate that the shape of the volume-phase transition
is sharper at lower CD, resulting from the higher degree of motional
freedom of network chains between cross-link junctions for lower CD
values.[41]
Figure 3
Volume-phase transition of hydrogel H4 (25% CD), H5 (15% CD), and H6 (8% CD) in 5 mM NaC5S and NaC6S aqueous solutions.
Midpoint of volume-phase
transition: 51 °C (H5 in NaC5S), 42 °C
(H6 in NaC5S); 34 °C (H5 in NaC6S), 29 °C (H6 in NaC6S).
Volume-phase transition of hydrogel H4 (25% CD), H5 (15% CD), and H6 (8% CD) in 5 mM NaC5S and NaC6S aqueous solutions.
Midpoint of volume-phase
transition: 51 °C (H5 in NaC5S), 42 °C
(H6 in NaC5S); 34 °C (H5 in NaC6S), 29 °C (H6 in NaC6S).The length of the carbon chain
in the counterion is another factor
that influences the LCST behavior of the PILs.[14] When using hexanesulfonate (C6S) as the counterion,
the hydrogel shows a similar trend in the transition behavior, while
the values of the transition temperature decrease to 29 °C (at
8% CD) and 34 °C (at 15% CD) at the same sulfonate concentration.
(We note that for 25% CD the transition is also broad, similar to
C5S.) We conclude that by carefully choosing the counterion
species and the cross-linking degree, the transition behavior of the
PFS-PIL hydrogels could be fine-tuned in a wide range of temperatures.The hydrogels could also be reversibly oxidized and reduced both
chemically and electrochemically. Figure a captures the variations of the relative
diameter of disk-shaped specimens of hydrogel H3 in their
reduced and oxidized states. The dimensional changes of representative
reduced, as well as oxidized, specimens are shown on the photographs
in Figure b. The reduced
and oxidized samples display the typical color change characteristic
for PFS upon changing its redox state (Figure b). The dimensional changes upon heating
from 20 to 70 °C are also visible, while the extent of the shrinkage
of the oxidized sample is substantially smaller upon heating. Quantitative
data for dimensional variations (Figure a) capture this difference. At room temperature,
the swelling ratio of the orange-color hydrogel had a value of 19,
while the value for the oxidized (dark green) specimen was 45. This
difference in volumetric swelling ratio indicates a variation of the
overall polarity of the gel, which changes during the redox reaction.[25,42]
Figure 4
Dimensional
variations of the reduced and oxidized hydrogels vs
temperature. (a) Variation of the relative size of the reduced and
oxidized hydrogel H3 in 45 mM NaC5S aqueous
solution (heating rate: 0.1 °C min–1). Hydrogel H3 was oxidized in 45 mM NaC5S and 40 mM FeCl3, then equilibrated in 45 mM NaC5S aqueous solution
before measurements. (b) Photographs of the reduced (top) and oxidized
(bottom) hydrogel H3 upon heating and cooling.
Dimensional
variations of the reduced and oxidized hydrogels vs
temperature. (a) Variation of the relative size of the reduced and
oxidized hydrogel H3 in 45 mM NaC5S aqueous
solution (heating rate: 0.1 °C min–1). Hydrogel H3 was oxidized in 45 mM NaC5S and 40 mM FeCl3, then equilibrated in 45 mM NaC5S aqueous solution
before measurements. (b) Photographs of the reduced (top) and oxidized
(bottom) hydrogel H3 upon heating and cooling.We note that, due to the presence
of the oxidized ferrocenium moieties,
the polycation chain acquired additional positive charge from the
oxidation that increased the hydrophilicity of the chain, which weakened
the volume change.
Hysteretic Behavior of PFS PIL-Based Hydrogels
In addition
to the redox-switchable thermo-responsive volume-phase behavior, surprisingly,
the neutral, or reduced, PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 hydrogel exhibits
a strongly hysteretic volume-phase transition and shows long-lived
bi-stable states at room temperature (Figure a). Hysteresis is an interesting phenomenon,
displaying output that depends on both present and past input. Usually
occurring in ferromagnetic and ferroelectric materials, hysteresis
has also been found in the soft matter field, especially in stimuli-responsive
soft materials.[43−52] For example, PNIPAM has hysteretic differences between heating and
cooling of about 5 °C.[11] Previous
reports often considered the hysteretic volume-phase transitions as
problematic because it affects signal reproducibility in many conventional
applications.[43] This behavior was also
shown to be short-lived and fades as time passes.[44,45] Such hysteretic volume-phase transitions in soft materials could
be utilized for example in memory devices, where multiple states of
the material can exist, preserving information on physical history
in a single environment.[46−51] Few examples of pH-responsive polymer gels with hysteretic volume-phase
transitions and strong bi-stability can be found in literature.[43,46] The organometallic PIL hydrogel presented here provides a unique
example of a thermo-responsive hysteretic system.
Figure 5
(a) Photographs of the
shrinking and swelling of the PFS PIL-based
hydrogel in a heating–cooling cycle, showing thermal hysteresis
behavior and bi-stable states at 25 °C (H7, stable
for more than 5 days). (b) Hysteresis loops of PFS PIL-based hydrogel H5, H7 in 5 mM NaC6S aqueous solution
(heating and cooling rates: 0.1 °C min–1), T1, T2: volume-phase
transition temperature in the heating–cooling cycle. T: “coercivity”
temperature. (c) Schematic illustration of the hydrogel sample’s
free energy at high temperature (③), room temperature (②
and ④), and low temperature (①). The coexistence is
stable in the local energy minimum at T2 < T < T1.
(a) Photographs of the
shrinking and swelling of the PFS PIL-based
hydrogel in a heating–cooling cycle, showing thermal hysteresis
behavior and bi-stable states at 25 °C (H7, stable
for more than 5 days). (b) Hysteresis loops of PFS PIL-based hydrogel H5, H7 in 5 mM NaC6S aqueous solution
(heating and cooling rates: 0.1 °C min–1), T1, T2: volume-phase
transition temperature in the heating–cooling cycle. T: “coercivity”
temperature. (c) Schematic illustration of the hydrogel sample’s
free energy at high temperature (③), room temperature (②
and ④), and low temperature (①). The coexistence is
stable in the local energy minimum at T2 < T < T1.In order to assess the hysteretic
behavior, the size of the hydrogel
was recorded during a relatively slow heating–cooling cycle
using a rate of 0.1 °C min–1. The relative
size vs temperature curves obtained for two hydrogels are displayed
in Figure b. In the
heating curve, the size decreased significantly between 25 and 50
°C and remained constant at temperatures T >
50 °C. In the cooling curve, the relative size showed a clear
hysteresis, as the size of the hydrogel remained almost constant until
25 °C. With further cooling, the hydrogel swelled sharply. By
keeping the samples at 5 °C overnight, the hydrogel could be
recovered to its original size. This strong and unexpected hysteresis
was shown to be persistent as the hydrogels with history information
at states ② and ④ (Figure a) were stable for at least 5 days at room
temperature (25 °C).The absence of hysteresis (less than
3 °C) in uncross-linked
polymer solution (Figure S9, Supporting Information) implies a quick dissociation of the PIL aggregates into individual
polymer chains. The hysteretic behavior of the hydrogel originates
from the constrained nature of the polymer network and the concentration-dependent
thermo-responsive phase transition as observed for uncross-linked
polymer solution. Multiple phases can coexist in the gel if each corresponds
to a local minimum in free energy (Figure c).[48,53] The swollen hydrogel
at low temperature has a swelling ratio around 100 before heating,
and thus a higher LCST. With the size decreasing, the local polymer
concentration in the hydrogel matrix increases during shrinking, which
results in a lowering of the LCST. In other words, the dehydration
process of the hydrogel provides a positive feedback and promotes
the lowering of the LCST value. Once the hydrogel reaches its final
shrunken state at high temperature, its LCST will be reduced due to
its low swelling ratio (∼10). There is also a positive feedback
related to the dehydration during the swelling process upon cooling.In our experiments, two transition temperature values, T1 and T2, can be
estimated from the midpoints of the volume-phase transitions in the
heating–cooling cycle, respectively (Figure b). A “coercivity” temperature, Tc = |T1 – T2|, has been introduced here to define the magnitude
of residual temperature needed in the heating–cooling cycle
to bring the hydrogel back to the original state. The “coercivity”
temperatures for hydrogel H5 and H7 are
both approximately 20 °C covering the room temperature region.
Once temperature crosses T1 or T2, the hydrogel can reach its final shrunken,
or swollen, state even at the constant temperature as a result of
the diminished coexistence phase and shifted energy minimum.
Bi-stable
CNT-Hydrogel Composites
By combining with
other functional materials, the applications of “smart”
hydrogels can be extended. Here we demonstrate some application potential
related to the ionic liquid nature of our starting polymers. PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 is a powerful dispersant, as are other cationic PILs reported.[54−56] We selected carbon nanotubes as conductive filler to be dispersed,
due to their frequently utilized applications in electronic or sensing
devices. Figure a
illustrates that CNTs are successfully suspended in aqueous solution
with the aid of PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 after 30 min of ultrasound
treatment in an ice bath. The macroscopic homogeneous solution was
stable for more than ten months (Figure S10, Supporting Information), while the CNTs without the dispersing PIL precipitated
in water completely overnight. The stabilizing effect is believed
to come from a cation−π electron interaction between
the substituted phosphonium/ammonium groups and the CNTs surface (Figure
S11, Supporting Information).[56,57]
Figure 6
(a)
Photograph of an aqueous dispersion of CNTs (10 mg/mL) with
and without PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 (5 mg/mL) taken 3 days after
ultrasonication treatment. (b) Bi-stable PFS-PEG/CNT hybrid hydrogels
at room temperature (top: after cooling treatment, bottom: after heating
treatment). (c) An on–off LED switch showing the hybrid hydrogel
exhibiting different resistance values at swollen (top) and shrunken
(bottom) states. (d) Relative size of PFS-PEG/CNT hybrid hydrogel
vs heating and cooling cycles.
(a)
Photograph of an aqueous dispersion of CNTs (10 mg/mL) with
and without PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 (5 mg/mL) taken 3 days after
ultrasonication treatment. (b) Bi-stable PFS-PEG/CNT hybrid hydrogels
at room temperature (top: after cooling treatment, bottom: after heating
treatment). (c) An on–off LED switch showing the hybrid hydrogel
exhibiting different resistance values at swollen (top) and shrunken
(bottom) states. (d) Relative size of PFS-PEG/CNT hybrid hydrogel
vs heating and cooling cycles.PFS-PEG-based conductive hydrogels can be fabricated using
our
PILs loaded with CNTs. For practical applications, the resistance
of the hydrogel, which depends on CNT concentration, can be controlled
by the volume change that accompanies the LCST behavior of the hydrogel.
As we demonstrate here, PFS-PEG/CNT hybrid hydrogels can show bi-stable
states and tunable resistance upon heating and cooling. The amount
of CNTs in the CNT-hydrogel composite was calculated to be 2 and 11
wt%, respectively, for swollen and shrunk hydrogels. Figure b shows a stable size change
of swollen and shrunk hydrogels that exhibit two different resistance
values (approximately 80 and 10 kΩ). The increase in resistance
of the swollen hydrogel is due to an expanded CNT-hydrogel network,
which leads to a reduction in the total number of conduction paths.[58] In this proof-of-concept experiment, a piece
of a PFS-PEG-based conductive hydrogel disk was placed between two
parallel ITO substrates and connected to a red light emitting diode
(LED) and a DC power supply with an output voltage of 2 V via an external
electrical circuit. The volume-phase transition is well reproducible,
as demonstrated by the four heating–cooling cycles captured
in Figure d. The on/off
state of the LED controlled by the different resistance of the piece
of the hydrogel at room temperature is illustrated in Figure c, demonstrating the bi-stable
behavior.
Conclusions
In conclusion, by using
a post-polymerization modification method,
a dual-responsive organometallic polymerPFS-PBu3 was synthesized
using iodopropyl-substituted starting polymers. Tri-n-butylphosphine and alkanesulfonate anions were introduced to the
side groups of PFS, yielding PILs with LCST-type behavior. The values
of the LCST transition temperature could be tuned by the redox state
of the polymer, the concentration, and the choice of the compensating
anions. By means of thiol-Michael addition cross-linking chemistry,
the PILs were covalently connected to obtain hydrogels. These gels
showed redox-switchable shrinking and swelling in response to thermal
stimuli. The PFS-PEG hydrogel exhibited a strongly hysteretic volume-phase
transition with a “coercivity” temperature of around
20 °C and showed bi-stable states at room temperature. In feasibility
experiments the polymers were used as dispersant for CNTs and as building
blocks for hybrid conducting hydrogels with CNTs. Potential applications
showing a thermal memory character were illustrated by LED switching
based on the variable resistance of the CNT-hydrogel composite. This
new class of PIL and PIL-based hydrogels is expected to open new opportunities
in the field of functional soft materials.
Experimental
Methods
Materials
Poly(ferrocenyl(3-iodopropyl)methylsilane)
(PFS-I, Mw = 3.12 × 105 g/mol, Mn = 1.56 × 105 g/mol, Mw/Mn = 2.0) was prepared according to established procedures.[31] Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and tetrahydrofuran
(THF) were obtained from Biosolve. Tri-n-butylphosphine
(PBu3), dimethylaminopropyl methacrylamide (DMAPMA), 1-hexylamine,
and multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs, 6–13 nm × 2.5–20
μm) were obtained from Aldrich and used without further purification.
Polyethylene glycol-tetrathiol (4-arm PEG-thiol, pentaerythritol core, Mn = 5000 g mol–1) was purchased
from JenKem Technology, USA. Sodium 1-pentanesulfonate (NaC5S) and sodium 1-hexanesulfonate (NaC6S) were supplied
by TCI, Belgium. Milli-Q water was used in all experiments.
Characterization
Methods
1H NMR and 13C NMR spectra
were acquired with a Bruker Avance III (400
MHz) instrument at 400.1 and 100.6 MHz, respectively.Fourier
transform infrared (FTIR) spectra were recorded with a Bruker ALPHA
spectrometer on dried samples.Turbidity measurements were conducted
with a custom built photometer
equipped with a 10 mW HeNe laser (633 nm), a photodiode amplifier
and a hand-held digital multimeter; transmittance at 25 °C was
defined as 100%, and the healting–cooling rate was 1 °C
min–1.Using dynamic light scattering (DLS),
hydrodynamic radii were measured
on a Zetasizer Nano Series (Malvern, Worcestershire, United Kindom).Rheological experiments were carried out with a UDS 200 rheometer
(Anton Paar) using parallel plates (25 mm diameter, gap 0.8 mm) configuration
at 25 °C in the oscillatory mode.The swelling ratio (by
weight) was calculated as follows: (Wh – Wd)/Wd, where Wh and Wd were the hydrated and dry sample weights,
respectively. The hydrogels were allowed to equilibrate in Milli-Q
water for 24 h until a constant weight was reached. Surface water
was carefully wiped off before weighing.Cyclic voltammetry
(CV) measurements were performed with an Autolab
PGSTAT 32 instrument. The conventional three-electrode system used
included a working electrode (ITO glass substrate), a Ag/AgCl reference
electrode, and a Pt counter electrode.
Synthesis of PFS-PBu3-Cl
Tri-n-butylphosphine (750 μL,
3.0 mmol) and DMSO (6 mL) were added
to a solution of PFS-I (0.4 g, 1.0 mmol) in THF (12 mL). The mixture
was then stirred at room temperature for 24 h. After removing the
THF by a flow of N2, the mixture was transferred to a Spectra/Por
4 dialysis hose (MWCO 12000–14000 g mol–1) and dialyzed against 0.1 M NaCl (3 × 1 L) and Milli-Q water
(3 × 1 L). Concentration of the salt-free polyelectrolyte solution
by a flow of N2 produced PFS-PBu3-Cl as orange
flakes.
Synthesis of PFS-PBu3-C5S
PFS-PBu3-Cl aqueous solution was dialyzed against 0.1 M NaC5S (3 × 1 L) and Milli-Q water (3 × 1 L). Concentration
of the salt-free polyelectrolyte solution by a flow of N2 produced PFS-PBu3-C5S as orange flakes.
Synthesis of
PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3-Cl
DMAPMA with
required molar ratio was added to a solution of PFS-I (0.2 g, 0.5
mmol) in THF (8 mL) and DMSO (4 mL). The reaction mixture was subsequently
stirred at room temperature for 1 day. Tri-n-butylphosphine
(750 μL, 3 mmol) and additional THF (4 mL) were added to the
mixture for the next reaction at room temperature, which proceeded
for 1 day. The rest of the THF was removed by a N2 flow,
and the resulting mixture was dialyzed against 0.1 M NaCl (3 ×
1 L) and Milli-Q water (3 × 1 L).
Hydrogel Formation
PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 with
C5S or C6S counterions, and 4-arm PEG-thiol
were mixed at the required ratio in water (500 μL) in a vial
or mold. The concentration of PFS-PEG was 5 wt% in the mixture. 1-Hexylamine
(10 μL) was added as the catalyst. The time to form a gel (gelation
time) was estimated to be 2 h at room temperature.
Dispersion
of CNTs
CNT dispersion was accomplished
by the following procedure. CNTs (15.0–25.0 mg) were added
to Milli-Q water (10.0 mL) containing PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 (20.0
mg). The mixture was ultrasonicated in an ice bath for 30 min. The
dispersion was concentrated under a flow of N2 and then
ready for preparing hydrogels.
CNT-Hydrogel Composite
Formation
The conductive hydrogel
was prepared in two steps. First, well-dispersed high concentration
CNT suspensions with PFS-DMAPMA-PBu3 as dispersant were
obtained under a flow of N2 after ultrasonication. Second,
the PEG cross-linker 4-arm PEG-thiol and 1-hexylamine were mixed in
the CNT suspensions. The concentration of CNTs was 8 wt% in the pre-gel
mixture. After 12 h cross-linking at 40 °C, a black conductive
hydrogel was obtained.