Victoria Porthé1, Ingrid Vargas1, Elena Ronda2, Davide Malmusi3, Lola Bosch4, M Luisa Vázquez5. 1. Grup de Recerca en Polítiques de Salut i Serveis Sanitaris (GRPSS), Servei d'Estudis i Prospectives en Polítiques de Salut, Consorci de Salut i Social de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain. 2. Departamento de Salud Pública, Universidad de Alicante, Alicante, Spain. 3. Direcció de Serveis de Salut, Ajuntament de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; CIBER Epidemiología y Salud Pública, Spain. 4. Unitat de Atenció al Ciutadà i Comunicació, Serveis de Salut Integrats del Baix Empordà, Palamós, Girona, Spain. 5. Grup de Recerca en Polítiques de Salut i Serveis Sanitaris (GRPSS), Servei d'Estudis i Prospectives en Polítiques de Salut, Consorci de Salut i Social de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain. Electronic address: mlvazquez@consorci.org.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To analyse changes in health professionals' and immigrant users' perceptions of the quality of care provided to the immigrant population during the crisis. METHODS: A qualitative descriptive-interpretative and exploratory study was conducted in two areas of Catalonia. Semi-structured individual interviews were used with a theoretical sample of medical (n=24) and administrative (n=10) professionals in primary care (PC) and secondary care (SC), and immigrant users (n=20). Thematic analysis was conducted and the results were triangulated. RESULTS: Problems related to technical and interpersonal quality emerged from the discourse of both professionals and immigrants. These problems were attributed to cutbacks during the economic crisis. Regarding technical quality, respondents reported an increase in erroneous or non-specific diagnoses, inappropriate use of diagnostic tests and non-specific treatments, due to reduction in consultation times as a result of cuts in human resources. With regard to interpersonal quality, professionals reported less empathy, and users also reported worse communication, due to changes in professionals' working conditions and users' attitudes. Finally, a reduction in the resolution capacity of the health services emerged: professionals described unnecessary repeated PC visits and limited responses in SC, while young immigrants reported an insufficient response to their health problems. CONCLUSION: The results indicate a deterioration in perceived technical and interpersonal quality during the economic crisis, due to cutbacks mainly in human resources. These changes affect the whole population, but especially immigrants.
OBJECTIVE: To analyse changes in health professionals' and immigrant users' perceptions of the quality of care provided to the immigrant population during the crisis. METHODS: A qualitative descriptive-interpretative and exploratory study was conducted in two areas of Catalonia. Semi-structured individual interviews were used with a theoretical sample of medical (n=24) and administrative (n=10) professionals in primary care (PC) and secondary care (SC), and immigrant users (n=20). Thematic analysis was conducted and the results were triangulated. RESULTS: Problems related to technical and interpersonal quality emerged from the discourse of both professionals and immigrants. These problems were attributed to cutbacks during the economic crisis. Regarding technical quality, respondents reported an increase in erroneous or non-specific diagnoses, inappropriate use of diagnostic tests and non-specific treatments, due to reduction in consultation times as a result of cuts in human resources. With regard to interpersonal quality, professionals reported less empathy, and users also reported worse communication, due to changes in professionals' working conditions and users' attitudes. Finally, a reduction in the resolution capacity of the health services emerged: professionals described unnecessary repeated PC visits and limited responses in SC, while young immigrants reported an insufficient response to their health problems. CONCLUSION: The results indicate a deterioration in perceived technical and interpersonal quality during the economic crisis, due to cutbacks mainly in human resources. These changes affect the whole population, but especially immigrants.
Keywords:
Calidad de la atención; Crisis económica; Economic crisis; Health policy; Health services; Inmigrantes; Migrants; Políticas sanitarias; Quality of health care; Servicios sanitarios
Authors: Shaun Bhatia; Nicole Olczyk; Leonard A Jason; Jose Alegre; Judith Fuentes-Llanos; Jesus Castro-Marrero Journal: Am J Soc Sci Humanit Date: 2019-12-19
Authors: Alina Pavlova; Clair X Y Wang; Anna L Boggiss; Anne O'Callaghan; Nathan S Consedine Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2021-09-20 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Mariko Nishikawa; Masaaki Yamanaka; Akira Shibanuma; Junko Kiriya; Masamine Jimba Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-10-07 Impact factor: 4.614
Authors: María Ángeles Pérez-Morente; Adelina Martín-Salvador; María Gázquez-López; Pedro Femia-Marzo; María Dolores Pozo-Cano; César Hueso-Montoro; Encarnación Martínez-García Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2020-04-05 Impact factor: 3.390