Sandeep K Padamati1, Davide Angelone1,2, Apparao Draksharapu1, Gloria Primi1, David J Martin3, Moniek Tromp3, Marcel Swart2,4, Wesley R Browne1. 1. Molecular Inorganic Chemistry, Stratingh Institute for Chemistry, Faculty of Science and Engineering, University of Groningen , Nijenborgh 4, 9747AG, Groningen, The Netherlands. 2. IQCC & Departament de Química, Universitat de Girona , Campus Montilivi (Ciències), 17003 Girona, Spain. 3. Sustainable Materials Characterisation, Van't Hoff Institute for Molecular Sciences, University of Amsterdam , Science Park 904, 1098 XH Amsterdam, The Netherlands. 4. ICREA, Pg. Lluís Companys 23, 08010 Barcelona, Spain.
Abstract
A reactive high-valent dinuclear nickel(IV) oxido bridged complex is reported that can be formed at room temperature by reaction of [(L)2Ni(II)2(μ-X)3]X (X = Cl or Br) with NaOCl in methanol or acetonitrile (where L = 1,4,7-trimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane). The unusual Ni(IV) oxido species is stabilized within a dinuclear tris-μ-oxido-bridged structure as [(L)2Ni(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+. Its structure and its reactivity with organic substrates are demonstrated through a combination of UV-vis absorption, resonance Raman, 1H NMR, EPR, and X-ray absorption (near-edge) spectroscopy, ESI mass spectrometry, and DFT methods. The identification of a Ni(IV)-O species opens opportunities to control the reactivity of NaOCl for selective oxidations.
A reactive high-valent dinuclear nickel(IV) oxido bridged complex is reported that can be formed at room temperature by reaction of [(L)2Ni(II)2(μ-X)3]X (X = Cl or Br) with NaOCl in methanol or acetonitrile (where L = 1,4,7-trimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane). The unusual Ni(IV) oxido species is stabilized within a dinuclear tris-μ-oxido-bridged structure as [(L)2Ni(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+. Its structure and its reactivity with organic substrates are demonstrated through a combination of UV-vis absorption, resonance Raman, 1H NMR, EPR, and X-ray absorption (near-edge) spectroscopy, ESI mass spectrometry, and DFT methods. The identification of a Ni(IV)-O species opens opportunities to control the reactivity of NaOCl for selective oxidations.
Metalloenzymes are
central to the functioning of biological systems,
especially in oxidative transformations and protection against reactive
oxygen species.[1] Fe-, Cu-, and Mn-dependent
metalloenzymes have been studied extensively and have stimulated the
design and synthesis of structural and functional model complexes,
especially in the search for synthetic analogues of reactive bioinorganic
intermediates.[2] Recently, attention has
turned to synthetic nickel-based complexes due to both enzymes such
as NOD (nickel oxide dismutase)[3] and their
potential in the activation of small molecules, including H2O2,[4] mCPBA,[5] and NaOCl.[6] In the latter case,
such complexes open the possibility to achieve selective alkane chlorination
and alkane and alkene oxygenation.Recently, several high-valent
(Ni(III)[4,7] and
Ni(IV)[6c,8]) intermediates were identified spectroscopically.
In contrast to organometallic Ni(IV) complexes,[8] the formation of Ni(III) and, more so, Ni(IV) oxido complexes,
although inferred, is controversial due to the implications of the
oxo-wall premise.[9] Nevertheless, several
Ni(II) and Ni(III) oxido or peroxido complexes, formed with O2 and H2O2, have been characterized already
at low temperature.[24−27]Here we show that a novel room-temperature-stable dinuclear
Ni(IV)
oxido complex (3), [(L)2Ni(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+ (where L = 1,4,7-trimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane),
can be generated by reaction of the Ni(II) complexes (1, 2) with NaOCl (Scheme ). The high oxidation state of 3 is stabilized
by the tris-μ-oxido-bridged dinuclear structure. Furthermore,
the reactivity of 3 toward direct C–H oxidation
of organic substrates is demonstrated.
Scheme 1
Formation of 3 from 1 and NaOCl
Complex 3 is obtained within seconds of addition
of
near stoichiometric amounts of NaOCl to [(L)2Ni(II)2(μ-X)3]X·(H2O) (where X = Cl (1) or Br (2), n = 5 or 7)[10] in methanol
or acetonitrile at room temperature. The structure of 3 was elucidated through a combination of UV–vis absorption
and resonance Raman spectroscopy and ESI mass spectrometry, supported
by isotope labeling, crossover experiments, and DFT methods.
Results
and Discussion
Complexes 1 and 2 were prepared by methods
analogous to those reported earlier (see SI for details).[10] The Raman spectra of 1 in the solid state (Figure S1) and in solution (i.e., methanol, acetonitrile, Figure S2) indicate that the complexes retain their structure;
that is, the ligand (L) remains bound to Ni(II) upon dissolution.
However, ESI mass spectrometry indicates that 1 can form
mononuclear complexes with three (176.3 m/z: 4 [(L)Ni(II)(CH3CN)3)]2+) or two acetonitrile ligands (155.9 m/z: 5, ([(L)Ni(II)(CH3CN)2)]2+) by substitution of the chlorido ligands (Figure S3). Indeed, mixtures of 1 and 2 show rapid exchange of Cl– and
Br– ligands (Figure S4). The 1H NMR spectrum of 1 in acetonitrile
shows paramagnetically shifted and broadened signals at ca. 60, 90,
and 120 ppm (Figure S5), and its UV–vis
absorption spectrum in methanol and acetonitrile (Figure S6) shows bands at 384, 635, and 1014 nm. The DFT data
(vide infra) indicate antiferromagnetically coupled Ni(II) ions in 1 and 2, consistent with observations by Wieghardt
et al.[11] The C3-symmetric DFT structure for both 1 and 2 is in excellent agreement with the X-ray structure,[11] with differences of ca. 0.01–0.02 Å
between DFT and X-ray for Ni–N, Ni–Cl/Br, and Ni–Ni
distances (Table S1). The antiferromagnetically
coupled state lies lowest in energy (including COSMO solvation[12] and ZORA[13] relativistic
effects, Table S2),[14,15] in excellent agreement with experiment.[11] In this state, the locally spin-polarized triplet (S = 1) Ni(II) ions couple antiferromagnetically (AFM) to reach overall
an open-shell singlet state. As a result, spin-up spin-density is
observed around one Ni and spin-down around the other (Figure ). This AFM state is only 0.3
kcal·mol–1 lower than the ferromagnetically
(FM) coupled (S = 2) state (see SI section 7 for the corresponding spin-density plot). Both
states would be consistent with the paramagnetic 1H NMR
shifts (vide supra), but the AFM state is found to be slightly lower
by both theory and experiment. The diamagnetic closed-shell singlet
state, in which the Ni(II) ions are now locally in a closed-shell
(S = 0) state, is higher in energy than the AFM state
by 37.7 kcal·mol–1 (1) and 35.0
kcal·mol–1 (2). Finally, also
an overall intermediate spin state (S = 1) was obtained,
25.5 kcal·mol–1 (1) and 23.4 kcal·mol–1 (2) higher in energy than the AFM state,
where spin-density corresponding to the single occupation of an antibonding
d orbital was observed on both Ni ions. Finally, the
experimental NMR and UV–vis absorption spectra of the AFM state
are similar to those of related Ni(II) complexes (Figure S7).[16]
Figure 1
Spin-density plot (S12g/TZ2P)
for (antiferromagnetically coupled) 1 with spin-up spin-density
shown in blue (around Nia, left) and spin-down spin-density
in red (around Nib,
right).
Spin-density plot (S12g/TZ2P)
for (antiferromagnetically coupled) 1 with spin-up spin-density
shown in blue (around Nia, left) and spin-down spin-density
in red (around Nib,
right).Addition of NaOCl to 1 or 2 in methanol
or in acetonitrile leads to a rapid increase in absorbance at 363
and 612 nm due to formation of 3 (Figure ). In methanol, the visible absorption band
decreases with a t1/2 of ca. 50 s at 20
°C (Figure S8), and the absorption
spectrum after 20 min is similar to the initial spectrum, with only
a minor shift from 388 to 378 nm (Figure ). Notably, the rate of decay of 3 in methanol was substantially lower than the rate of the direct
reaction of NaOCl with methanol in the absence of 1 (Figure S8), indicating that the formation of 3 competes with oxidation of methanol by NaOCl and that 3 is less reactive in the oxidation of methanol than NaOCl.
Figure 2
UV–vis
absorption spectrum of 1 (3.5 mM) in
methanol before (black) and after (red 6 s, blue 48 s, green 463 s)
addition of 11 equiv of NaOCl(aq) at 293 K. Inset: Expansion of the
NIR region. The data indicate that for 3 ε612 nm > 715 M–1·cm–1.
UV–vis
absorption spectrum of 1 (3.5 mM) in
methanol before (black) and after (red 6 s, blue 48 s, green 463 s)
addition of 11 equiv of NaOCl(aq) at 293 K. Inset: Expansion of the
NIR region. The data indicate that for 3 ε612 nm > 715 M–1·cm–1.In both the presence and absence
of 1, near-quantitative
(cf. NaOCl) oxidation of methanol to formaldehyde occurs (1.5:1, Figure S9), indicating that although at least
2 equiv of NaOCl are consumed in forming 3 from 1, these oxidation equivalents are still available for subsequent
oxidation of methanol. Further additions of NaOCl in the presence
of 1 resulted in the reappearance of the 612 nm absorption
(Figure S10), confirming the integrity
of the catalyst under reaction conditions. Similar changes were observed
with NaOBr (Figure S11), which indicates
that the same intermediate is formed with both oxidants (vide infra).
Addition of H2O2 or purging with O2 (Figures S12 and S13) did not result
in the appearance of 3.Intermediate 3 forms upon addition of NaOCl to 1 also in acetonitrile
(absorbance band at 612 nm), but persists
for a substantially longer time period than in methanol, with a t1/2 of ca. 10 min at 20 °C and over 6 h
at −15 °C (Figures S14 and S15), enabling characterization by resonance Raman spectroscopy, XANES,
XES, and ESI mass spectrometry and reactivity with other substrates
to be studied (vide infra). The maximum transient absorbance at 612
nm was obtained with 3–4 equiv of NaOCl (Figure S16) and is accompanied by an increase in oxidation
state as confirmed by XANES and XES (Figure and Figure S17).
Figure 3
(Top) Ni K XANES before (blue) and after (yellow) addition of 4
equiv of NaOCl to 1 (30 mM) in acetonitrile. (Bottom)
Ni K edge XANES for structures 1, 3, and 3a, simulated using FEFF9.0[18] using
coordinates available from DFT-optimized structures (see the SI).
(Top) Ni K XANES before (blue) and after (yellow) addition of 4
equiv of NaOCl to 1 (30 mM) in acetonitrile. (Bottom)
Ni K edge XANES for structures 1, 3, and 3a, simulated using FEFF9.0[18] using
coordinates available from DFT-optimized structures (see the SI).The Ni K edge X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES)
as well
as the X-ray emission (XES) spectra were recorded for 1 (30 mM) in acetonitrile before and after addition of NaOCl. Spectra
were acquired over 5 min after addition when the concentration of 3 (generated from 1) was substantial, although
Ni(II) species are present also. The Ni K edge XANES spectra of both 1 and the mixture of species formed after addition of NaOCl
show a nondescript edge, i.e., no significant pre- edge features,
which indicates a near-octahedral, six-coordinated, geometry around
the Ni center for all species present (consistent with the structures 1, 3, and 3a).The edge position
is a function of the ligands present and geometry
as well as oxidation state, and hence a direct conclusion based on
XANES alone cannot be drawn. For example, for purely oxidic Ni systems,
an energy shift of about 1.8 eV per oxidation state is reported, with
a much lower shift for sulfur-based systems.[17] A conclusive statement as to the oxidation state requires the availability
of a series of reference compounds with similar ligands and geometries
(data for closely related structures are not yet available in the
literature).The energy shift of about 2 eV observed in the
experimental spectra
is consistent with an increase in oxidation state, but it will also
reflect the change from chlorido to oxido ligands. Furthermore, the
mixture of species available (including Ni(II)) reduces the magnitude
of the observed shift and complicates interpretation.The simulated
XANES for complexes 1, 3, and 3a are displayed in Figure .[18] All XANES
spectra have only a pre-edge feature at low energy and an otherwise
featureless edge, consistent with six-coordinated geometries. A clear
difference in the spectra of the Ni(II) 1 of 5 eV with
the Ni(III) 3a and Ni(IV) 3a species is
calculated, i.e., upon oxidation and change of ligands from Cl to
O. It is, however, also clear that XANES data will not allow for distinguishing
the Ni(III) and Ni(IV) species, i.e., complexes 3 and 3a. Furthermore, the Ni K edge XANES of 1 undergoes
only a few electronvolts shift in the presence of NaOCl and not the
full 5 eV shift, as it is a mixture of Ni(II) and nickel in higher
oxidation states, resulting in only an average shift, i.e., between
2 and 3 eV, reflecting an overall average increase in oxidation state.
The XES data at the Kβ1,3 edge also display an overall
shift of a few electronvolts; however, the emission lines are sensitive
to both oxidation state and ligand type also.The three broad
signals in the 1H NMR spectrum of 1 in acetonitrile
decrease upon addition of NaOCl, suggesting
the formation of a diamagnetic species, and then recover concomitant
with the increase and decrease in absorbance at 612 nm (Figure S18). Samples flash frozen to 77 K at
any time, however, did not indicate the presence of a mononuclear
Ni(III) species by X-band EPR spectroscopy.Generation of 3 by electrochemical oxidation of 1 was explored
also. The cyclic voltammetry of 1 shows irreversible
redox waves at 1.52, 1.35, and 1.05 V and an
irreversible redox wave at 0.58 V on the return cycle. At higher scan
rates (up to 10 V s–1) the initial oxidation wave
at 1.05 V shows some evidence of chemical reversibility; however,
the shifts in Ip,a (which are corrected
for IRu) indicate that the oxidation is electrochemically
irreversible also (Figure S19). Addition
of NaOCl to 1 results (after 2 min) in a shift in the
oxidation wave to 1.16 V, indicative of ligand exchange, e.g., CH3CN replacing Cl–. It should be noted, however,
that the redox chemistry of NaOCl, concentration polarization, and
the likely complex series of dis- and comproportionation reactions
between 1 and 3 preclude the observation
of a redox wave assignable to 3. One hour after addition
of NaOCl, a further shift is observed, indicating ligand exchange
to form a Ni(II) complex similar to 4 (Figure S20). Notably the voltammetry and spectroelectrochemistry
were not affected substantially by the addition of water and NaCl
(i.e., at concentrations present under reaction conditions).The spectroelectrochemistry of 1 in acetonitrile shows
that oxidation at 1.2 V leads to essentially no change in the UV absorption
(Figure S21a). On the second cycle the
redox wave is shifted to >1.58 V; again relatively little change
in
absorbance is observed, and after reduction below 0.86 V only minor
shifts in absorbance at ca. 300 nm are observed, consistent with ligand
exchange (Figure S21b). Bulk electrolysis
of 1 shows an increase in absorption at 344 nm; however,
the EPR spectrum (X-band 77 K) of this sample was silent, and hence
oxidation leads to ligand exchange to a Ni(II) complex with a more
positive redox potential rather than formation of a Ni(III) or Ni(IV)
complex.Attempts to isolate 3 by flash precipitation
with
KPF6 yielded the mononuclear Ni(II) compound [(L)Ni(II)(CH3CN)3]2+ (4) instead, reported
earlier by Tak et al. as the B(Ph)4– salt,[16] in which the chlorido ligands are replaced by
acetonitrile ligands to form a mononuclear complex (see the SI and Scheme ). Notably, addition of NaOCl to 4 in
acetonitrile results in the same visible absorption spectrum as obtained
with 1 (Figure S23), indicating
that the formation of 3 is not dependent on the initial
form of the LNi(II) complex (with Cl–/Br–/CH3CN) and is consistent with the rapid equilibration
of these species in solution. Furthermore, addition of NaOCl (4–10
equiv) to a 1:1 mixture of NiCl2 and the ligand (L) in
acetonitrile results in the appearance of the bands at λmax 363 and 612 nm (Figure S24),
consistent with a maximum 50% conversion to 3. In the
absence of ligand (i.e., only NiCl2·6H2O) the band at 612 nm was not observed (Figure
S25).
Scheme 2
Formation of 3 from 1 and
NaOCl and Subsequent
Decay to 4 in Acetonitrile
In earlier reports,[6] the presence
of
acetic acid was necessary for the formation of high-valent nickel
complexes with NaOCl. Addition of acetic acid (4.5 equiv) to 3 in acetonitrile (generated by addition of 4.5 equiv of NaOCl
to 1 (0.9 mM)) did not affect the absorbance at 612 nm
significantly (Figure S26a). In contrast,
addition of acetic acid (4.5 equiv) prior to addition of NaOCl to 1 (0.9 mM) precluded the appearance of the 612 nm band and
hence formation of 3 (Figure S26b).[19]The ESI mass spectra of 1 in acetonitrile show signals
(m/z) assignable to [Ni(II)(L)(CH3CN)2]2+ (155.9 m/z), [Ni(II)(L)(CH3CN)3]2+ (176.3 m/z), [Ni(II)(L) (Cl)]+ (264.1 m/z), and [Ni(II)2(L)2(Cl)3]+ (565.2 m/z) (Figure S27). The spectrum obtained from a solution containing 3 shows an additional strong signal at 253.3 m/z with an isotope distribution consistent with two Ni centers
(Figure S28), regardless of whether it
was generated with NaOBr or NaOCl and with 2 in place
of 1 (Figures S29–S33). Notably, however, the signal increased by 3 m/z units with Na18OCl (Figure S31). The m/z signal
at 253.3 is therefore consistent with structures such as the peroxy-bridged 3a,[20] [(L)2Ni(III)2(μ-O)(μ-O-O)]2+, the mono-μ-oxo-bis-terminal-oxo 3b, [(L)-(O)=Ni(IV)-O-Ni(IV)=(O)-L]2+, and the tri-μ-oxido-bridged 3, [((L)2Ni(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+ (Scheme ), with the latter
structure 3 favored on the basis of Raman spectroscopy
(vide infra) and DFT.[21]
Scheme 3
Structures (3, 3a, 3b) Consistent
with ESI Mass Spectral Data and Calculated Driving Forces for Their
Formation from 1
All possible spin states were explored by DFT methods
for 3, 3a, and 3b. As expected
for the
d6 Ni(IV) ions in 3, the lowest energy[15] state corresponds to locally closed-shell singlet
(S = 0) Ni(IV) ions. For consistency, we explored
the possibility of other spin states and found several higher lying
spin states, where, for example, the Ni(IV) ions had locally a triplet
(S = 1) state that coupled to form overall a quintet
(S = 2) state. However, these other spin states are
>27 kcal·mol–1 higher in energy (see Table S2) and will not be discussed any further.
For the d7 Ni(III) ions in 3a, the lowest
energy[15] state corresponds to a doublet
on each of the metals, which can be FM (S = 1) or
AFM (open-shell singlet) coupled. The latter open-shell singlet state
is lower in (Gibbs free) energy than the triplet by 2.1 kcal·mol–1, and 5.1 kcal·mol–1 lower
than the diamagnetic closed-shell singlet state. All other spin states
for 3a are >10 kcal·mol–1 higher
in (Gibbs free) energy. The lowest energy for the d6 Ni(IV)
ions in 3b corresponds to an AFM state, where each of
the Ni(IV) ions is found locally in a triplet (S =
1) state. The AFM state is lower than the FM state in 3b by 1.2 kcal·mol–1, with the other spin states
higher in energy by >10 kcal·mol–1.The geometrical parameters for compound 3, which although
isostructural to [(L)2Mn(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+,[22] are found to
be somewhat different. The most prominent feature in [(L)2Mn(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+ is a short
Mn(IV)–Mn(IV) distance of 2.30 Å, which is absent in 3, where the Ni(IV)–Ni(IV) is instead 2.46 Å;
the latter distance is more similar to the bis-μ-oxo variant
[L2MnIV2(O)2(μ-O)2] (2.62 Å).[22] Furthermore,
the NiIV–N distance of 2.02 Å in 3 is substantially shorter than in [(L)2Mn(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+ (2.11 Å). The NiIV–(μ-O) distance in 3 of 1.85 Å is
however similar to that in the MnIV analogue (1.82 Å).
Overall, the DFT structure for 3 and the X-ray structure
for [(L)2Mn(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+ are similar, which is apparent when superimposed (Figure S34).Raman spectra (λexc 532 nm) of 1 (3.5
mM) in acetonitrile (a) and with (b) 4.5 equiv of NaOBr, (c) 4.5 equiv
of Na16OCl, and (d) 4.5 equiv of Na18OCl. *Solvent
band. #Raman band from quartz.The Raman spectrum of 3, with excitation resonant
with the visible absorption band, shows enhanced Raman scattering
at 801, 631, and 521 cm–1 (Figure ), with only the band at 631 cm–1 (Δ[18O] = 32 cm–1) affected by
the use of Na18OCl. The bands are unaffected by use of
OBr– in place of OCl–. The DFT-calculated
Raman spectrum for [(L)2Ni(IV)2(μ-16/18O)3]2+ (3) shows a
penta-atomic symmetric stretching Ni–(O)3–Ni
mode at 638 cm–1, which shifted to 609 cm–1 upon isotope labeling (i.e., Δ[18O] = 29 cm–1, Figure S35). Mixed labeling
(i.e., varying ratios of 16O and 18O) experiments
show the series of four bands expected for the four isotopologues
and correspond well with the DFT-calculated shifts (Figure ).
Figure 5
Top: Calculated spectra
for 3 with various degrees
of 18O substitution (16O3 (blue), 16O218O (red), 16O18O2 (green), 18O3 (purple)). Bottom:
Resonance Raman spectra of 3 generated from 1 (4 mM) in methanol by addition of 4 equiv of NaOCl/H2O with (blue) 100% 16O, (red) 50% 18O, (green)
34% 18O, and (purple) 26% 18O.
Top: Calculated spectra
for 3 with various degrees
of 18O substitution (16O3 (blue), 16O218O (red), 16O18O2 (green), 18O3 (purple)). Bottom:
Resonance Raman spectra of 3 generated from 1 (4 mM) in methanol by addition of 4 equiv of NaOCl/H2O with (blue) 100% 16O, (red) 50% 18O, (green)
34% 18O, and (purple) 26% 18O.The band at 801 cm–1 corresponds to a symmetric
Ni–N stretching (calcd by DFT at 782 cm–1, at the same position upon 18O labeling), while the band
at 521 cm–1 involves mainly a combination of Ni–N
and Ni–O stretching (calcd by DFT at 517 cm–1 and at 516 cm–1 upon 18O labeling).
All of the vibrations of the normal modes are available in the SI. The modes observed for 3 are
similar in energy to those of the isostructural complex [(L)2Mn(IV)2(μ-O)3]2+, which shows
a Mn–(O)3–Mn stretch at 701 cm–1 (Δ18O = 33 cm–1).[23] Furthermore, the spectrum is similar to that
reported by Riordan and co-workers for [((PhTttBu)Ni(III))2(μ-O)2], with a band at 585 cm–1 (Δ[18O] = 30 cm–1),[24] and by Fukuzumi and co-workers for [(L′Ni(III))2(μ-O)2]2+, where L′ = N,N-bis[2-(2-pyridyl)ethyl]-2-phenylethylamine, with a band
at 612 cm–1 (Δ[18O] = 32 cm–1).[25] The higher Raman shift
for 3 is consistent with an increase in the oxidation
state from III to IV.The Ni–O–O–Ni stretching
modes in 3a are expected at higher wavenumbers compared
to Ni–O–Ni
modes; see, for example, the O–O stretch vibrations reported
by Riordan and co-workers ([(Ni(tmc))2(μ-O-O)] at
778 cm–1; Δ[18O] = 43 cm–1)[26] and Gade and co-workers ([(Ni(iso-pmbox))2(μ-O-O)] at 742 cm–1; Δ[18O] = 36 cm–1).[27] This conclusion is supported by the DFT-calculated IR spectrum for 3a (Figure S36), which shows an
O–O stretching band (Δ[18O] in parentheses)
at 892 (841) cm–1, a Ni–N stretching mode
at 768 (768) cm–1, and Ni–O bending/stretching
modes at 663 (633), 601 (594), 585 (571), and 536 (516) cm–1. Of these modes, the 663 and 768 cm–1 modes are
strongly IR active. Therefore, given that in the present system only
the band at 631 cm–1 is affected by the use of 18OCl– and that the DFT-calculated IR spectrum
of 3a (Figure S36) indicates
bands at ca. 660 and 770 cm–1 only and not a band
at ca. 801 cm–1, the peroxy species can be discarded.
The same is true for 3b, which shows terminal-oxo Ni–O
stretches at 742 cm–1 (shifting to 718 cm–1 upon 18O labeling, i.e., Δ18O = 24 cm–1), 700 cm–1 (Δ18O = 28 cm–1), and 689 cm–1 (Δ18O = 26 cm–1); the Ni–(μ-O)–Ni
stretch is found at 653 cm–1 (Δ18O = 17 cm–1). No bands are observed around 521
cm–1, and all bands show significant isotope effects.
Therefore, although the ESI mass spectral data could correspond also
to a peroxy-bridged (3a) or the mono-μ-oxo species
(3b), the most appropriate structural assignment for
the high-valent nickel species is 3 based on the vibrational
spectra.DFT calculations provide further support for this assignment
in
the thermochemistry of the reaction of 1 and 2 with NaOCl to form 3. Mass spectral data indicate that
the reactive intermediate 3 has the composition [(L)2Ni2O3]2+, and the absence
of EPR (X-band) signals at 77 K at any time suggests that mononuclear
Ni(III) complexes are not present to a significant extent. Hence,
geometry optimizations were performed with all spin multiplicities
for 1, 2, 3, and 3a, as well as possible mononuclear Ni(II) complexes, e.g., [(L)Ni(II)(CH3CN)3]2+ (4) and [(L)Ni(II)
(CH3CN)2]2+ (5) (Table S2). Antiferromagnetically coupled dinuclear
species were found as lowest energy for 1, 2, 3a, and 3b, while a closed-shell spin
state was found for 3 (vide supra); a high-spin Ni(II)
(S = 1) ground state was found for 4 and 5. The reactions of 1 with NaOCl to
form 3, 3a, or 3b (Scheme ) were calculated
to be exergonic by −92.5, −88.1, and −50.3 kcal·mol–1, respectively; hence, 3 is 4.46 kcal·mol–1 more stable than 3a and 42.2 kcal·mol–1 than 3b, in terms of Gibbs energy (in
electronic energy: 7.50 and 46.11 kcal·mol–1, respectively for 3a and 3b), Table S3.Further spectroscopic evidence
for the formation of 3, and not 3a or 3b, is obtained by mixed
labeling experiments. In these experiments we applied ratios of pure 16O (3:0), pure 18O (0:3), and 1:2/2:1 mixtures
of these, such that we would have four different distributions with
on average the incorporation of 0, 1, 2, and 3 labeled oxygens into
the complex. The observed isotope shifts observed in our Raman spectra
with these mixed labeling experiments match perfectly with the corresponding
DFT isotope shifts; that is, the 631 cm–1 peak (638
cm–1 DFT) shifts to 623 cm–1 (630
cm–1 DFT), to 613 cm–1 (622 cm–1 DFT), and finally to 599 (609 cm–1 DFT).Overall, the spectroscopic and computational data are
consistent
with the assignment of the intermediate as 3 ([(L)2Ni(IV)2(μ-16O)3]2+). The mechanism by which 3 forms from Ni(II)
complexes undoubtedly involves multiple elementary steps. However,
the coordination of OCl– to Ni(II) is expected to
be facile given the rapid exchange of Cl–, Br–, and CH3CN ligands. Heterolytic cleavage
of Ni(II)–O–Cl to form a transient intermediate Ni(IV)
species and Cl– is presumably followed by formation
of a (μ-O)3-bridged Ni(IV) dimer, which does not
show antiferromagnetic coupling, in contrast with the equivalent manganese
complex, but instead corresponds to diamagnetic closed-shell Ni(IV)
ions.Finally, although 3 undergoes rapid self-decay
in
methanol to yield formaldehyde, in acetonitrile it is relatively stable,
allowing for its reactivity with organic substrates to be assessed.
The addition of ca. 4 equiv of substrate (e.g., xanthene, 9,10-dihydroanthracene,
and fluorene) resulted in a complete loss of absorbance at 612 nm
within ca. 6 min (70, 150, and 350 s, respectively, Figure S37). At −15 °C, 3 is stable
for over 6 h (Figure S38),; however, addition
of 4 equiv of xanthene resulted in a rapid loss in absorbance at 612
nm (within ca. 275 s, Figure S39). Addition
of 50 equiv of fluorene to 3 resulted in the disappearance
of the signal at m/z 253.3 and a
recovery of the signals of 1 and 4 (Figure S40). Hence, although substrates react
directly with NaOCl, 3 engages in C–H oxidation
also (Figure S39).
Conclusions
Complex 3 represents the first example of a Ni(IV)-oxido-bridged
dimer. Its generation from NaOCl and subsequent reaction with organic
substrates opens up the possibility to use NaOCl as a terminal oxidant.
The intermediacy of a transition metal catalyst opens the possibility
of engaging in selective oxidations, thereby taming the reactivity
of this potent oxidant.
Authors: E I Solomon; T C Brunold; M I Davis; J N Kemsley; S K Lee; N Lehnert; F Neese; A J Skulan; Y S Yang; J Zhou Journal: Chem Rev Date: 2000-01-12 Impact factor: 60.622
Authors: Jorn D Steen; Stepan Stepanovic; Mahsa Parvizian; Johannes W de Boer; Ronald Hage; Juan Chen; Marcel Swart; Maja Gruden; Wesley R Browne Journal: Inorg Chem Date: 2019-10-18 Impact factor: 5.165