Kunyuan Xu1, Chun Che Lin1,2, Xiaobin Xie3, Andries Meijerink1. 1. Condensed Matter and Interfaces, Debye Institute for Nanomaterials Science, Utrecht University, 3508 TA Utrecht, The Netherlands. 2. Institute of Organic and Polymeric Materials, National Taipei University of Technology, Taipei 106, Taiwan. 3. Soft Condensed Matter, Debye Institute for Nanomaterials Science, Utrecht University, 3584 CC Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Abstract
There has been a growing interest in applying CsPbX3 (X = Cl, Br, I) nanocrystals (NCs) for optoelectronic application. However, research on doping of this new class of promising NCs with optically active and/or magnetic transition metal ions is still limited. Here we report a facile room temperature method for Mn2+ doping into CsPbCl3 NCs. By addition of a small amount of concentrated HCl acid to a clear solution containing Mn2+, Cs+, and Pb2+ precursors, Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs with strong orange luminescence of Mn2+ at ∼600 nm are obtained. Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs show the characteristic cubic phase structure very similar to the undoped counterpart, indicating that the nucleation and growth mechanism are not significantly modified for the doping concentrations realized (0.1 at. % - 2.1 at. %). To enhance the Mn2+ emission intensity and to improve the stability of the doped NCs, isocrystalline shell growth was applied. Growth of an undoped CsPbCl3 shell greatly enhanced the emission intensity of Mn2+ and resulted in lengthening the radiative lifetime of the Mn2+ emission to 1.4 ms. The core-shell NCs also show superior thermal stability and no thermal degradation up to at least 110 °C, which is important in applications.
There has been a growing interest in applying CsPbX3 (X = Cl, Br, I) nanocrystals (NCs) for optoelectronic application. However, research on doping of this new class of promising NCs with optically active and/or magnetic transition metal ions is still limited. Here we report a facile room temperature method for Mn2+ doping into CsPbCl3 NCs. By addition of a small amount of concentrated HCl acid to a clear solution containing Mn2+, Cs+, and Pb2+ precursors, Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs with strong orange luminescence of Mn2+ at ∼600 nm are obtained. Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs show the characteristic cubic phase structure very similar to the undoped counterpart, indicating that the nucleation and growth mechanism are not significantly modified for the doping concentrations realized (0.1 at. % - 2.1 at. %). To enhance the Mn2+ emission intensity and to improve the stability of the doped NCs, isocrystalline shell growth was applied. Growth of an undoped CsPbCl3 shell greatly enhanced the emission intensity of Mn2+ and resulted in lengthening the radiative lifetime of the Mn2+ emission to 1.4 ms. The core-shell NCs also show superior thermal stability and no thermal degradation up to at least 110 °C, which is important in applications.
Doping
transition metals (i.e., Mn2+, Ni2+, Co2+) in nanoparticles has received significant research
interest.[1−4] Fascinating new properties (e.g., optical and magnetic) can be introduced
by intentional incorporating dopant ions into nanoparticles. Mn2+-doped II–VI (CdSe, CdS, ZnSe) quantum dots (QDs),
as a representative, have been studied extensively in recent years.[5−7] The intense luminescence of Mn2+ combined with the large
absorption cross section of QDs make these Mn2+-doped II–VI
quantum dots promising for a wide range of applications.[8−11] For example, luminescent Mn2+-doped ZnSe QDs show emission
that is detuned from the QDs’ absorption, making these highly
luminescent QDs promising for application in solar cells.[11] In addition, another interesting aspect of Mn2+-doped QDs is their unique magneto-optical behavior resulting
from interaction of photogenerated charge carriers in the QDs with
the high magnetic moment of Mn2+ (3d5) ions.[12,13]Recently, all-inorganic CsPbX3 (X = Cl, Br, I)
perovskite
nanocrystals have emerged as a very promising group of materials with
nearly unity quantum yield in a broad spectral range covering the
visible spectrum.[14−17] Particular attention is presently given to new synthesis routes
for this group of materials aimed at a better control of their optical
properties (emission color, efficiency) as well as the chemical and
temperature stability.[18−21] A promising avenue to improve control over the optical properties
is doping these NCs with luminescent ions, but so far studies on doping
of lead halideperovskite NCs with optically active ions are limited.
Two recent papers reveal the possibility of doping Mn2+ with CsPbCl3 NCs at elevated temperature (180 °C)
via a hot-injection method.[22,23] Here, we report an
alternative synthesis method allowing successful synthesis of Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs at room temperature. Creating
a high chemical potential for Mn2+ in solution by mixing
a reactive Mn2+ precursor with a Cs+ and Pb2+ precursor in toluene, followed by the addition of a small
amount of HCl acid, results in Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs showing intense yellow/orange emission. A thermodynamically
controlled doping mechanism is proposed to explain the doping process.
In a next step, an undoped CsPbCl3 shell is grown which
greatly enhances the luminescence quantum yield and stability of the
doped CsPbCl3:Mn2+ NCs.
Experimental Section
Chemicals
All the chemicals were
obtained from Sigma-Aldrich and used as received without further purification.
The chemicals’ specifications are CsAc (cesium acetate, 99.9%),
PbAc2·3H2O (lead acetate, 99.99%), MnAc2·4H2O (manganese acetate, 99.9%), and HCl
acid (hydrochloric, 37 wt % in water).
Synthesis
of Mn2+-Doped CsPbCl3 NCs
Equimolar
amount of the acetatesCsAc and PbAc2 with a variable amount
of MnAc2 were stirred in
5 mL of toluene at room temperature (∼293 K) under N2 atmosphere. Oleic acid (OA) and oleylamine (OLAM) were chosen as
ligands. A colorless clear solution was achieved after ∼15
min of stirring. Subsequently, the HCl acid in water was added under
vigorous stirring. A white suspension formed, and the suspension was
centrifuged at low speed (1500 rpm) to remove large particles, agglomerates,
and acid residues (water). The larger particles precipitated at the
bottom of the vial. The supernatant which contains the NCs was collected
and stored at 0 °C for 15 min followed by centrifuging, now at
a higher speed (3500 rpm) to precipitate the NCs. After removing the
supernatant, the NCs were redissolved in 3 mL of toluene and centrifuged
again at low temperature (0 °C). The supernatant was discarded
and followed by addition of 1 mL of toluene, resulting in a stable
colloidal dispersion of Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs.In a typical synthesis, 0.1 mmol of CsAc, 0.1 mmol of PbAc2·3H2O, and 0.005 mmol of MnAc2 (5
at. %) were mixed in 5 mL of toluene and stirred with 0.045 mL of
OA and 0.075 mL OLAM to get a clear solution. Concentrated HCl acid
(0.1 mL) was injected under vigorous stirring. The successful doping
of CsPbCl3 NCs was evidenced by the observation of the
characteristic emission of Mn2+ under excitation with a
365 nm UV lamp. The average chemical yield is around 70% and was determined
by weighing the final reaction product and comparing this to the expected
weight for 0.1 mmol of the product.
Shell
Growth
For growth of an undoped
CsPbCl3 shell around the Mn2+-doped NCs, a coating
precursor solution was prepared by dissolving 0.01 mmol of CsAc and
PbAc2 in 5 mL of toluene with 0.01 mL of OA and OLAM. Separately,
a clear crude solution of NCs was made by redissolving dried Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs (∼0.01 mmol) and oleylammonium
chloride (∼0.01 mmol) in 1 mL of toluene. To this crude solution,
the coating precursor solution was slowly added. To achieve different
shell thicknesses, the amount of coating solution was increased from
0 to 0.3 mL with the increment of 0.05 mL.
Characterization
A variety of techniques
was used to characterize the doped CsPbCl3 NCs and to investigate
the doping process. To determine the crystal structure and phase purity,
X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns were recorded by using a PW 1729
Philips diffractometer, operating at 40 kV and 20 mA and using Cu
Kα radiation (λ = 1.5418 Å). For XRD analysis, the
sample plates were prepared by evaporating the NCs films on the silicon
wafer. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images were made with
a FEI TECNAI T12, operating at 120 kV and a Talos F200X, operating
at 200 kV. The samples for TEM imaging were prepared by dipping a
carbon-coated copper mesh TEM grid into a toluene solution of NCs.
The excess liquid was evaporated under vacuum. Elemental analysis
was used to determine the Mn/Pb elemental ratio using a PerkinElmer
Optima 8300 inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometer
(ICP-OES). To this end, samples were dissolved in concentrated HCl
acid overnight, followed by dilution with 5% HNO3 acid.Absorption spectra were obtained with a double beam PerkinElmer
Lambda 950 UV/vis/IR spectrophotometer. Luminescence (emission and
excitation) spectra and photoluminescence (PL) decay curves were measured
using an Edinburgh Instruments FLS920 spectrofluorometer equipped
with a 450 W xenon lamp as excitation source and a 0.22 m double grating
monochromator for excitation (Bentham DTMS300, 1200 lines/mm grating,
blazed at 300 nm for excitation). Emission spectra (380–700
nm) were recorded with a single 0.22 m monochromator (500 nm blazed
grating), and the emitted light was detected by a Hamamatsu R928 photomultiplier
tube (PMT). Decay curves of the Mn2+ emission were recorded
in the same setup using the third harmonic of a 10 Hz pulsed Nd:YAG
laser as the excitation source (pulse width: 10 ns, λex = 355 nm) and a Hamamatsu R928 photomultiplier tube (PMT) for light
detection. The samples for optical analysis were prepared by dissolving
the crude NCs mixture in toluene and transferring the solution to
the quartz cuvette.Photoluminescence quantum yield (PL QY)
determination was done
using Lumogen Red 305 with a PL QY 95% in toluene as a first reference.
With this reference, the PL QY of CsPbBr1.5 I1.5 nanocrystals (λem = 598 nm) was determined under
443 nm excitation. Next, the PL QY of Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs was determined by comparison with the second reference
(CsPbBr1.5 I1.5 nanocrystals) using 380 nm excitation.
The absorption coefficients of all the samples were carefully tuned
to the range 0.02–0.1.
Results
and Discussion
Synthesis and Luminescence
of CsPbCl3/Mn2+ NCs
To investigate
the formation of the
CsPbCl3 NCs, the reaction product was analyzed using a
variety of techniques to determine size, crystal structure, and chemical
composition. In Figure (a) the X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns for doped and undoped CsPbCl3 NCs are shown. The XRD pattern shows a number of diffraction
peaks at angles that are characteristic of the CsPbCl3 perovskite
structure. The positions for diffraction peaks calculated from the
unit cell parameters are marked by filled blue circles and match the
position observed. There is no difference between the XRD pattern
for the doped (nominal concentration: 10 at. % Mn, actual Mn2+ concentration ∼1 at. %) and undoped CsPbCl3 NCs.
The width of the peaks reflects a small crystallite size. However,
due to the close resemblance of diffraction peaks of the tetragonal
phase of CsPbCl3 and the cubic phase (Supporting Information, Figure S1) coupled with the broadness
of the diffraction peaks, further study is still needed to confirm
the phase of the product. To determine the size and size distribution,
TEM images were recorded. Figure (b) shows TEM images of CsPbCl3 NCs on a
TEM grid that was dipped into a NCs’ solution. On the grid,
areas with a high density of NCs are observed where the NCs are ordered.
It is believed that, during evaporation of the solvent, self-assembly
of the cubic CsPbCl3 NCs takes place, resulting in the
highly ordered pattern. From analysis of the size of NCs, the average
size (length of the edge of squares) was determined to be 7 nm. In Figure S2 the size distribution obtained from
the analysis of 100 NCs is shown (Supporting Information Figure S2 (C1)). For 7 nm CsPbCl3 NCs, weak quantum confinement
effects can be expected, as the exciton Bohr radius in CsPbCl3 is ∼2.5 nm.[14] Elemental
analysis was done to determine the actual Mn2+ concentration
in the NCs, as it is often observed that the fraction of dopant ions
incorporated is lower than the nominal concentration of dopants added
to the reaction mixture. A series of samples was prepared with different
nominal Mn2+ concentrations (5 at. % to 25 at. %, relative
to Pb2+). The Mn2+ concentrations in the CsPbCl3:Mn2+ NCs after careful washing were determined
with ICP-AES, and the results are shown in Table S1 of the Supporting Information. The concentration of
Mn2+ incorporated is about 10 times less than the concentration
in the reaction mixtures and seems to saturate around just above 2
at. % Mn2+ for the presently used synthesis protocol. The
fraction of dopant ions incorporated is typically much lower than
the nominal concentration added and is determined by kinetic and thermodynamic
effects, which are less favorable for incorporation of the chemically
different dopant ion than for the host cation.[24,25] For example, for Mn2+ incorporation in ZnSe NCs, the
actual Mn2+ concentration was found to be around 10% of
the Mn2+ concentration added and to saturate at 3 at. %
Mn2+.[26] Similar observations
have been reported for ZnS:Mn2+.[27] Extensive research on Mn2+ incorporation in CdSe QDs
has provided more insight into the role of both kinetic and thermodynamic
factors controlling dopant incorporation, and under extreme circumstances
(very high Mn2+ concentration in the presence of extra
host anions), concentrations of 30 at. % Mn2+ were realized.[28] It can be expected that with different synthesis
methods also for CsPbCl3 NCs, higher Mn2+ doping
levels are possible.
Figure 1
Structure characterization of as-prepared undoped and
Mn-doped
CsPbCl3 NCs. (a) XRD pattern of undoped and doped samples.(b)
TEM image of Mn2+-doped (nominal concentration: 10 at.
%, actual concentration ∼1 at. %) CsPbCl3 NCs.
Structure characterization of as-prepared undoped and
Mn-doped
CsPbCl3 NCs. (a) XRD pattern of undoped and doped samples.(b)
TEM image of Mn2+-doped (nominal concentration: 10 at.
%, actual concentration ∼1 at. %) CsPbCl3 NCs.The optical properties of the
NCs were explored by recording emission
and excitation spectra for CsPbCl3 NCs doped with Mn2+. Figure shows the typical absorption, emission, and excitation spectra of
Mn2+-doped (10 at. %) CsPbCl3 NCs. In the emission
spectrum, two distinctive peaks can be seen, namely, a narrow peak
located at 405 nm with fwhm 11 nm and a broad band with a maximum
around 600 nm. The narrow band at 405 nm is assigned to the intrinsic
exciton emission of CsPbCl3 NCs while the broader emission
peak at 600 nm (fwhm: ∼100 nm) is assigned to a 3d5 intraconfigurational Mn2+ transition (4T1 → 6A1).[2,22,23] The excitation spectra both of the exciton
emission at 405 nm and of the Mn2+ emission at 600 nm very
closely follow the absorption spectrum. The spectra have a sharp onset
at 400 nm followed by a first maximum around 385 nm, a weak second
maximum around 360 nm, and a third maximum around 337 nm. The fine
structure observed is typical for nanoparticles where discrete energy
levels that emerge at the band edges give rise to discrete transitions
and fine structure in the absorption/excitation spectra. For the II–VI
(e.g., CdSe) and IV–VI (e.g PbSe) QDs, this fine structure
has been extensively investigated, and theoretical calculations on
peak positions and absorption strengths have been compared with experimental
spectra to gain insight into the energy level structures of the QDs.
For the perovskite NCs, energy level calculations explaining the fine
structure are in progress. The observation of the exciton absorption
peaks in the excitation spectrum of the Mn2+ emission provides
strong evidence for the incorporation of Mn2+ in the CsPbCl3 NCs. Clearly, exciton absorption by the CsPbCl3 NCs is followed by energy transfer to Mn2+ and bright
yellow/orange emission from the Mn2+ ions. The fact that
exciton to Mn2+ energy transfer is observed shows the successful
incorporation of Mn2+ in the CsPbCl3 NCs.
Figure 2
Absorption,
excitation, and emission spectra of Mn2+-doped (10 at.
% nominal concentration) CsPbCl3 NCs. The
inset shows a photograph of a vial with a colloidal dispersion of
undoped (left) and Mn-doped (right) CsPbCl3 sample under
excitation of 365 nm UV light. The Mn2+ concentration indicated
is the nominal concentration; the actual Mn2+ concentration
in the NCs is much lower (see Table S1 of the Supporting Information).
Absorption,
excitation, and emission spectra of Mn2+-doped (10 at.
% nominal concentration) CsPbCl3 NCs. The
inset shows a photograph of a vial with a colloidal dispersion of
undoped (left) and Mn-doped (right) CsPbCl3 sample under
excitation of 365 nm UV light. The Mn2+ concentration indicated
is the nominal concentration; the actual Mn2+ concentration
in the NCs is much lower (see Table S1 of the Supporting Information).It is interesting to investigate the incorporation mechanism
for
this room temperature synthesis. In the formation mechanism of NCs,
ligands play an important role. To investigate the role of the ligands,
we systematically varied the concentrations of both oleic acid (OA)
and oleylamine (OLAM). Surface passivation by ligands is crucial and
influences colloidal stability, quantum yield, and doping efficiency.
In the present case, a ligand combination of OA and OLAM is used.
This is essential to obtain a clear solution of the precursors (CsAc,
PbAc2, and MnAc2), which is important for achieving
a stable colloidal solution of NCs. Furthermore, the long chain amine
can play an important role in regulating the crystallization process
of the NCs, while the steric repulsion provided by oleic acid is integral
to preventing the irreversible coagulation. The presence of ligands
is crucial in forming a stable colloidal solution of NCs. However,
a stable bond between Mn2+ ions and ligands will hinder
the effective incorporation of Mn2+. These considerations
reflect the trade-off between colloidal stability and successful incorporation
of Mn2+ ions. To optimize the synthesis, the added volume
of OA was varied from 0.015 to 0.125 mL while keeping the added volume
of OLAM fixed at 0.015 mL, and the added OLAM volume was varied from
0.015 to 0.15 mL while keeping the volume of OA fixed at 0.045 mL.
The variations of the emission spectra as a function of OA or OLAM
volume are shown in Figure a and 3b. The results show a strong
dependence of the relative Mn2+ emission intensity, especially
on the OA concentrations. The relative intensity of the Mn2+ emission is expected to increase with Mn2+ concentration
in the CsPbCl3 NCs. The Mn2+ concentrations
were determined using ICP, and the results are collected in Table
S1 of the Supporting Information. Indeed,
the Mn2+ concentration shows the same trends as the Mn2+ emission intensity, which means that a decrease in the Mn2+ emission intensity can be explained by a lower concentration
on Mn2+ in the NC, except for the highest Mn2+ concentrations, where concentration quenching starts to play a role
(vide infra). For OA added volumes higher than 0.045 mL, a very rapid
decrease in the Mn2+ concentration is observed. The added
volume of OLAM also affects the relative intensity of the Mn2+ emission. For an OA volume of 0.045 mL, the highest relative Mn2+ emission intensity is observed for 0.075 mL of OLAM.
Figure 3
Emission spectrum
of as-prepared CsPbCl3:Mn2+ NCs samples formed
under different reaction conditions at 297 K.
All spectra are normalized to the absorption at 365 nm, which makes
a direct comparison of the efficiencies of the emission possible.
(a) PL emission spectrum as a function of OA volume (λex = 365 nm). (b) PL emission spectrum as a function of OLAM volume
(λex = 365 nm). (c) PL emission spectrum as a function
of HCl volume (λex = 365 nm). (d) Emission spectrum
of Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs with 5 at. % ∼
25 at. % Mn2+ in the reaction mixture. The Mn2+ concentrations indicated are nominal concentration; the actual Mn2+ concentration in the NCs is much lower and depends strongly
on the synthesis conditions (see Table S1 of the Supporting Information).
Emission spectrum
of as-prepared CsPbCl3:Mn2+ NCs samples formed
under different reaction conditions at 297 K.
All spectra are normalized to the absorption at 365 nm, which makes
a direct comparison of the efficiencies of the emission possible.
(a) PL emission spectrum as a function of OA volume (λex = 365 nm). (b) PL emission spectrum as a function of OLAM volume
(λex = 365 nm). (c) PL emission spectrum as a function
of HCl volume (λex = 365 nm). (d) Emission spectrum
of Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs with 5 at. % ∼
25 at. % Mn2+ in the reaction mixture. The Mn2+ concentrations indicated are nominal concentration; the actual Mn2+ concentration in the NCs is much lower and depends strongly
on the synthesis conditions (see Table S1 of the Supporting Information).To understand the variation in incorporation efficiency for
different
added OLAM/OA volumes, the doping mechanism needs to be considered.
Given the present reaction conditions, the doping resembles diffusion
doping that was recently shown to be effective in incorporating Mn2+ in CdSe.[29] This doping process
is largely thermodynamically controlled. Dopant incorporation is driven
by a high chemical potential of the dopant in solution which will
be further internalized from the surface layer and subsequently diffuses
inward. In our synthesis, metal acetate salts are the initial metal
precursors. When metal acetate salts are dissolved in toluene with
oleic acid and oleylamine, acetate ligands will be replaced by oleate
ligands and form dissolvable metal-oleate complexes. Initially, after
addition of the hydrochloric acid, the carboxylate groups of the oleate
ligand are protonated, which results in a massive increase in the
concentration of active metal monomers. Consequently, the chemical
potential of metal ions (e.g., Cs+, Pb2+, Mn2+) in bulk solution is substantially increased and provides
a strong driving force for the crystallization of CsPbCl3. In the presence of excess Cl– (from the addition
of concentrated HCl) a Cl– surface layer allows
for binding of Mn2+ to the surface, followed by inward
diffusion. Given that there is an activation energy for inward diffusion,
the Mn2+ incorporation is expected to be slow at room temperature
and the Mn2+ concentration in the surface layer can be
expected to be higher than in the core of the NCs.Second, since
the doping and crystallization process are initiated
by protonation of metal-oleate complex, it is expected that H+ ions are of prime importance to determine PL properties.
The influence of varying volume of HCl added is depicted in Figure c. A strong increase
in the Mn2+ emission intensity is observed when the volume
of HCl acid increases from 0.01 to 0.1 mL. Increasing the concentration
of H+ will facilitate the formation of reactive metal monomer,
resulting in a higher chemical potential difference of metal ions
in solution and nanocrystals. In addition, the higher Cl– concentration will result in surface adsorption of Cl–, and adsorption of Mn2+ at the Cl– rich
surface will be followed by internalization of Mn2+ through
cation diffusion. Thus, excess Cl– will decrease
the chemical potential of dopant ions in the host lattice, enlarging
the driving force for Mn2+ incorporation. Again, similar
observations were made for Mn2+ diffusion doping of CdSe,
where the anion (Se2–) concentration in solution
was shown to be crucial for successful Mn2+ doping.[29] With further increase of the amount of HCl acid,
the emission intensity of Mn2+ decreases. The reduction
of Mn2+ emission intensity suggests that H2O
from halide acid may affect the incorporation of Mn2+ while
also the chemical stability of the NCs may be reduced at the highest
HCl concentrations. The optimum concentration (under the presently
optimized reaction conditions) is 0.10 mL of concentrated HCl.Based on the observations discussed above, the optimized synthesis
conditions for further NCs synthesis are HCl: 0.1 mL, OA: 0.045 mL,
and OLAM: 0.075 mL. The observation of Mn2+ emission indicates
that energy transfer from the exciton to Mn2+ ions occurs.
However, it still cannot rule out the possibility that a large fraction
of the Mn2+ ions are only surface bound and not (statistically)
incorporated in the nanocrystal lattice. The fact that for a 1–2
at. % Mn2+ content (on average 30–60 Mn2+ ions per CsPbCl3 NC) exciton emission is still observed
indicates that energy transfer to Mn2+ is not highly efficient.
For Mn2+ in the center of the NC, where the exciton wave
function has the higher amplitude, more efficient energy transfer
is expected. The observation of exciton emission indicates that the
concentration of Mn2+ is relatively higher closer to the
surface of the NC, where the overlap with the exciton wavelengths
is weaker. The relative intensity of the exciton emission is observed
to vary between samples that were prepared under identical conditions
and is also affected by the washing procedure. The trends observed
in Figure are however
reproducible and provide information on the optimum conditions for
Mn2+ incorporation for the present synthesis protocol.In order to further internalize surface bound dopant ions, surface
passivation by isocrystalline core–shell (ICS) growth was adopted.
Several reports have confirmed that solution epitaxial growth of additional
layers of host material can efficiently internalize surface-bound
dopant ions, hence enhancing the relative intensity of dopant emission.[30−32] For growing a CsPbCl3-shell layer, 0.01 mmol of the purified
Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs was redispersed in 1
mL of toluene. This was followed by slow addition of a specific volume
of a solution consisting of Pb2+ and Cs+ precursors
for overgrowth with a CsPbCl3 shell under vigorous stirring.
The samples obtained after additional shell growth will be referred
to as Cx (x represents sample number,
C1 is the original NCs without any modification, higher numbers correspond
to a thicker shell). Figure presents the evolution of PL QY of an as-prepared sample
with that of NCs with different isocrystalline shell thicknesses.
The details of PL QY determination can be found in the Experimental Section. As can be seen from Figure , a general trend of an increase
in PL QY of the Mn2+ emission is observed with increasing
shell thickness. The highest PL quantum yield is measured for sample
C7. The high PL QY (39%) reflects successful incorporation of surface
bound Mn2+ ions by overgrowth of a CsPbCl3 shell.
Successful growth of additional layers of CsPbCl3 is also
supported by a slight red shift of the exciton emission peak of CsPbCl3 NCs (Supporting Information Figure
S3). Additionally, the shape of the emission peak of CsPbCl3 NCs is largely unaffected without any broadening. This confirms
that the process of continued growth on existing CsPbCl3 NCs is dominant (Supporting Information, Figure S3). TEM images of samples C1 and C7 were shown in Figure S2 and reveal a clear increase of the
average size of NCs after shell coating (from 7 to 8.5 nm).
Figure 4
Effect of ICS
growth on the relative PL QY and integrated area
under the Mn2+ luminescence decay curves for Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs. Blue line: evolution of PL QY as a
function of shell thickness (λex = 380 nm). The inset
shows a photograph of samples C1 to C7 (left to right) under excitation
with a 365 nm UV lamp (Please note that the NCs concentration of each
sample is different, decreasing from left to right). Red line: Evolution
of integrated area under the Mn2+ emission decay curves
for samples C1 to C7 (λex = 355 nm, λem = 600 nm).
Effect of ICS
growth on the relative PL QY and integrated area
under the Mn2+ luminescence decay curves for Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs. Blue line: evolution of PL QY as a
function of shell thickness (λex = 380 nm). The inset
shows a photograph of samples C1 to C7 (left to right) under excitation
with a 365 nm UV lamp (Please note that the NCs concentration of each
sample is different, decreasing from left to right). Red line: Evolution
of integrated area under the Mn2+ emission decay curves
for samples C1 to C7 (λex = 355 nm, λem = 600 nm).Further evidence for
the beneficial influence of ICS growth on
the luminescence efficiency can be obtained from luminescence lifetime
measurements. Luminescence decay curves of the Mn2+ emission
are shown in Figure S4 of the Supporting Information. The Mn2+ emission decay curve of the as-prepared samples
does not show monoexponential decay behavior. A multiexponential fitting
has to be used, and a biexponential fit gives a reasonably good agreement,
with lifetimes of 0.15 and 0.78 ms. Upon overgrowth of an additional
CsPbCl3 shell, a clear lengthening of the decay lifetime
of the Mn2+ emission is observed. This is explained by
a reduction of Mn2+ ions close to surface quenching sites.
It is well-known that luminescent ions close to the surface experience
faster decay as a result of energy transfer to surface defects. This
results in a faster and also nonexponential decay, as the nonradiative
decay rate varies between luminescent ions at varying distances from
quenching sites. A transformation of the Mn2+ emission
decay curve from multiexponential to monoexponential is observed as
the undoped CsPbCl3 layer thickness increases. This is
consistent with efficient incorporation of Mn2+ ions by
additional shell growth, which effectively removes Mn2+ ions at the NC surface by overcoating with an undoped isocrystalline
CsPbCl3 shell. For the thickest CsPbCl3 shell,
a monoexponential decay curve with a 1.4 ms decay time is observed.
The 1.4 ms Mn2+ lifetime is the radiative lifetime and
is in the millisecond range that is expected for the spin- and parity-forbidden 4T1–6A1 transition
within the 3d5 configuration of Mn2+. The evolution
of integration area under the decay curve, which is a good indicator
for the relative PL QY, runs parallel to the PL QY determined by the
double reference method. The final PL QY of 40% is high and can possibly
be further improved by optimizing the synthesis conditions. The high
PL QY makes these Mn2+-doped NCs promising for application
as efficient emitters in optical devices.The thermal stability
of NCs is another issue, especially for applications
in high-power LEDs where on-chip phosphors reach temperatures between
150 and 200 °C. To gain insight on the quenching behavior of
NCs with different shell thicknesses at elevated temperature, the
thermal stabilities of C1–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 and C7–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 (both in toluene,
boiling point: 111 °C) were tested using a thermal cycling experiment.
By monitoring the luminescence intensity of the Mn2+ emission
band for successive heating and cooling cycles, we studied the temperature
dependent luminescent behavior. The thermal cycling experiments were
conducted between 30 °C and 110 °C. Emission spectra was
taken every 10 °C under 365 nm illumination. During the measurement,
the temperature of the sample was gradually increased to 110 °C
and allowed to cool down to 30 °C. Both heating and cooling were
done in a controlled manner (heating and cooling rate: ∼10
°C/min).The temperature dependent luminescence characteristics
of C1–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 (no CsPbCl3 shell) and C7–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 (thickest
CsPbCl3 shell) are
plotted in Figure . Upon raising the temperature, the peak intensity of the uncoated
CsPbCl3:Mn2+ sample shows a continuous decrease
(Figure a, emission
spectra are shown in Figure S5), losing
nearly 50% of peak intensity at 110 °C.
Figure 5
Temperature dependent
PL behavior. (a) Peak emission intensity
of sample C1–Mn2+: CsPbCl3 NCs (no shell
overgrowth) and C7–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 NCs (overcoated)
as a function of temperature. (b) Temperature dependent emission spectra
for C7–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 NCs.
Temperature dependent
PL behavior. (a) Peak emission intensity
of sample C1–Mn2+: CsPbCl3 NCs (no shell
overgrowth) and C7–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 NCs (overcoated)
as a function of temperature. (b) Temperature dependent emission spectra
for C7–Mn2+:CsPbCl3 NCs.After the first heating cycle, the uncoated CsPbCl3:Mn2+ sample suffered an ∼15% permanent
peak intensity
loss (see Figure a).
A much superior temperature stability is observed for the emission
from the core–shell sample C7. A nearly constant PL intensity
is observed when temperature varies from 30 to 110 °C (see also Figure a and Figure S6). In fact, a small increase in emission
intensity is observed upon heating. This increase can be explained
by thermal annealing of defects. Defects reduce the emission intensity.
The nonequilibrium defect concentration, for example defects at the
interface between the core and isocrystalline shell, can be reduced
by annealing. A beneficial effect of annealing is generally observed
for (nano)crystalline luminescent materials and can explain the presently
observed increase in emission intensity during and after the heat
treatment. The superior thermal stability of the Mn2+ emission
for the CsPbCl3:Mn2+ after overgrowth with an
undoped CsPbCl3 shell is explained by efficient passivation
from thermally induced quenching sites located at the surface. Furthermore,
it is also interesting to note a small shift of the emission wavelength
of the Mn2+ emission during the heating cycle. As shown
in Figure b, the emission
shifts to higher energies (blue shift) when the temperature increases
from 30 to 110 °C, which is fully reversible upon cooling. The
reason for the temperature dependent emission wavelength is lattice
expansion at high temperature.[33] Lattice
expansion results in a larger Mn2+–ligand distance
and thus a smaller crystal field splitting. The 3d5 Tanabe–Sugano
diagram shows that the emission maximum shifts to higher energies
(shorter wavelengths) for stronger crystal fields. The stabilization
of the doped CsPbCl3 NCs is important for the applicability
of ICS growth.
Conclusions
In summary,
Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 perovskite
NCs were synthesized by a facile room temperature method. Following
addition of a small volume of concentrated HCl acid to a clear solution
containing Mn2+, Cs+, and Pb2+ precursors,
monodisperse Mn2+-doped CsPbCl3 NCs showing
bright orange Mn2+ emission were obtained. For the used
doping levels (up to 25 at. % relative to Pb), no substantial changes
of the NC size and shape were observed. Several important synthesis
parameters, e.g. ligand volume and ratio, HCl volume, and Mn2+ concentration, were optimized to achieve highly efficient Mn2+ emission. Overgrowth with an undoped CsPbCl3 shell
strongly improves the photoluminescence quantum yield of the Mn2+ emission (up to 40%) and also improves the thermal stability
(no thermal quenching up to 110 °C). Overall, the presently reported
room temperature synthesis method enables us to achieve highly luminescent
NCs and provides new insights in the development of new doping strategies
for perovskite NCs.
Authors: Steven C Erwin; Lijun Zu; Michael I Haftel; Alexander L Efros; Thomas A Kennedy; David J Norris Journal: Nature Date: 2005-07-07 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Stefan T Ochsenbein; Yong Feng; Kelly M Whitaker; Ekaterina Badaeva; William K Liu; Xiaosong Li; Daniel R Gamelin Journal: Nat Nanotechnol Date: 2009-08-16 Impact factor: 39.213
Authors: Donny Magana; Susanthri C Perera; Andrew G Harter; Naresh S Dalal; Geoffrey F Strouse Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2006-03-08 Impact factor: 15.419