Ricky Bell1, Catherine Smith2, Leigh Hale2, Geoffrey Kira3, Steve Tumilty2. 1. Division of Health Sciences, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand. Electronic address: bodyhealthnz@xtra.co.nz. 2. Division of Health Sciences, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand. 3. School of Sport and Exercise, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Obesity is a progressive global phenomenon that is disparately prevalent amongst Indigenous populations. While there is a growing body of literature investigating the extrinsic contributors to obesity, there is a lack of evidence to elucidate intrinsic drivers in the context of an Indigenous population. METHODS: Qualitative research theory, inclusive of Indigenous knowledge systems, was applied to the narratives of 15 Indigenous (Māori) people aged between 18 and 65 to contextualise their understandings of obesity. RESULTS: Thematic analysis of the interview data revealed four intrinsic determinants for obesity expression that specifically relate to Indigenous peoples: (1) relationships and social connectedness; (2) holistic health including spiritual beliefs and cultural practices (Indigenous worldview); (3) historical trauma and the impacts of colonisation; and (4) the biomedical model of caloric restriction, diet and exercise were culturally insensitive, non-relatable, and were not significant drivers for engagement in healthier lifestyles. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: Similar to non-Indigenous populations, Indigenous understandings of obesity are multi-factorial. What was unique about the findings of this study were insights into the importance of relational aspects and connectedness to each other and the environment, as determinants for obesity expression. This suggests that the current individualistic approaches of western medicine to obesity management are not culturally aligned with Indigenous peoples ways of being. Adopting an ontology of connectedness may represent a more culturally centred approach, and help build epistemological resilience to mitigate rising obesity incidence in Indigenous populations.
BACKGROUND:Obesity is a progressive global phenomenon that is disparately prevalent amongst Indigenous populations. While there is a growing body of literature investigating the extrinsic contributors to obesity, there is a lack of evidence to elucidate intrinsic drivers in the context of an Indigenous population. METHODS: Qualitative research theory, inclusive of Indigenous knowledge systems, was applied to the narratives of 15 Indigenous (Māori) people aged between 18 and 65 to contextualise their understandings of obesity. RESULTS: Thematic analysis of the interview data revealed four intrinsic determinants for obesity expression that specifically relate to Indigenous peoples: (1) relationships and social connectedness; (2) holistic health including spiritual beliefs and cultural practices (Indigenous worldview); (3) historical trauma and the impacts of colonisation; and (4) the biomedical model of caloric restriction, diet and exercise were culturally insensitive, non-relatable, and were not significant drivers for engagement in healthier lifestyles. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: Similar to non-Indigenous populations, Indigenous understandings of obesity are multi-factorial. What was unique about the findings of this study were insights into the importance of relational aspects and connectedness to each other and the environment, as determinants for obesity expression. This suggests that the current individualistic approaches of western medicine to obesity management are not culturally aligned with Indigenous peoples ways of being. Adopting an ontology of connectedness may represent a more culturally centred approach, and help build epistemological resilience to mitigate rising obesity incidence in Indigenous populations.
Authors: Athira Rohit; Leisa McCarthy; Shiree Mack; Bronwyn Silver; Sabella Turner; Louise A Baur; Karla Canuto; John Boffa; Dana Dabelea; Katherine A Sauder; Louise Maple-Brown; Renae Kirkham Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2021-08-31 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Alana Gall; Kate Anderson; Kirsten Howard; Abbey Diaz; Alexandra King; Esther Willing; Michele Connolly; Daniel Lindsay; Gail Garvey Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2021-05-28 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Lisa G Rosas; Jan J Vasquez; Haley K Hedlin; Fei Fei Qin; Nan Lv; Lan Xiao; Adrian Kendrick; Dawn Atencio; Randall S Stafford Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2020-01-30 Impact factor: 3.295