Diagnostic value of high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography examination in combination with anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide antibody testing in rheumatoid arthritis patients.

We studied the diagnostic value of high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography (HCDU) examination in combination with anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide (anti-CCP) antibody testing in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients with finger joint damage. From January 2015 to December 2015, 80 patients diagnosed with RA with finger joints damage were enrolled in this study. Patients were examined with HCDU. Serum anti-CCP antibody level was tested using ELISA, and results were compared with the healthy control group. Results obtained by ELISA demonstrated that the positive rate of anti-CCP antibodies was 73.8% in the study group, and 10% in the control group. The negative rate was 26.2% in the study group, and 90% in the control group. HCDU examination suggested that the predominantly affected joint by bone erosion of RA with finger joint damage was MCP3 (16.7%), followed by PIP3 (14.1%), MCP2 (13.5%) and PIP2 (12.8%). The slightest affected joint was thumb metacarpophalangeal joint, followed by thumb, little finger metacarpophalangeal joint and proximal interphalangeal joint. The sensitivity of diagnosis of RA with finger joints damage with both HCDU and CCP antibody examination showed a significantly lower level compared with examination with each one of the methods alone, while specificity showed a significantly higher level. Thus, a combination of HCDU examination and anti-CCP antibody testing can be considered useful to improve the early diagnostic rate of RA. HCDU examination is a sensitive, secure, atraumatic and easily-operated diagnostic method for early RA patients with finger joint damage. When combined with anti-CCP antibody testing, it will provide a better chance for RA patients, and give them hope for a better treatment and improved prognosis.

Introduction

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is an autoimmune disease, which might induce ankylosis, malformation, even loss of normal joint function (1). Early diagnosis is usually difficult due to atypical clinical features and the negative result of rheumatoid factor testing (2). Thus, the best time period for starting the treatment could be easily missed and as a result, patients could suffer irreversible joints damage leading to permanent disabilities (3). Therefore, a quick and accurate diagnosis of RA has been in the centre of attention (4,5).

In this study, we investigated the diagnostic value of high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography (HCDU) examination in combination with anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide (anti-CCP) antibody testing in RA patients with finger joint damage.

Materials and methods

General information

From January to December 2015, 80 patients (with 162 affected joints) who were diagnosed with RA with finger joint damage were enrolled for this study. There were 44 males and 36 females and the age range was from 21 to 68 years (average, 57.2±3.6 years). The disease courses ranged from 8 to 22 months (mean disease course, 25.6±2.2 months). All the patients met the 1987 American clinical diagnostic criteria (6). During the same period, 50 healthy individuals (100 joints) were enrolled in our control group. They were physically examined in the Yantai Yuhuangding Hospital (Shandong, China). There were 30 males and 20 females in the control group, aged 22 to 67 years (average, 56.5±3.3 years). Aomparison between general information in both groups did not reveal any significant differences.

Methods

HCDU examination and the serum anti-CCP antibody testing by ELISA were conducted. HCDU examinations were conducted as follows: Cross sections and different gestures of the articulationes digitorum manus were scanned with a transducer frequency of 12 MHz, using HCDU scanner (Shanghai Chuangxun Medical Equipments Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China). Serum CCP antibody tests using ELISA were conducted by strictly following the instructions provided by the CCP IgG test kit (Beijing Euroimmun Medical Diagnosis Technology Co., Ltd., Beijing, China).

Statistical analysis

SPSS 21.0 (IBM SPSS, Armonk, NY, USA) was used for data analysis. We applied t-test or Chi-square test for comparison between groups. P<0.05 was considered to indicate a statistically significant difference.

Results

Comparison of the anti-CCP antibody testings

Results obtained from ELISA tests suggested that the positive rate of anti-CCP antibody in the study group was 73.8% (59/80 cases), and the negative rate was 26.2% (21/80 cases) (Fig. 1). The positive rate in the control group was only 10% (5/50 cases), and the negative rate was 90% (45/50).

Figure 1.

The high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography manifestation of articulationes interphalangeae of digitus medius of the patients with bone erosion.

Comparison of the HCDU examination

HCDU examination results showed that the articulationes interphalangeae of digitus medius in patients with bone erosion in the study group showed articular surface roughness, and continuous interruption at the margins (Fig. 1). The detectable blood signal rate of articulationes interphalangeae in the study group was 65.7%, and blood signals were detected inside the articulationes interphalangeae and at the margins (Fig. 2). The eroded cartilage and subcortex medullary bone substance in the study group had lower echogenicity and irregularly defined tumor-like lesion. The internal echo was uneven (Table I).

Figure 2.

The high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography manifestation of the apterium blood of the articulationes interphalangeae of digitus medius of the patients with bone erosion.

Table I.

Comparison of the HCDU diagnoses for the two groups (n=130).

		Cortex of bone		Medullary substance of bone
Group	No. of arthroses	Continuously smooth	Discontinuously rough	Not displayed	Tumor-like lesion
Control, n=50	100	100	0	100	0
Study, n=80	162	28	134	32	134

HCDU, high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography.

No blood signals were detected in the finger joints in the control group, cortical bones and articular surfaces were relatively smooth with continuous integrity. The ultrasonic manifestation of cortical bones and subchondral bones showed a strong echo line with continuous smoothness at the posterior edge of cartilage. Behind that was the attenuation region and the medullary substance of bone that could not be displayed (Fig. 3 and Table I).

Figure 3.

The high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography manifestation of the articulationes interphalangeae of digitus medius of the control group.

Affected levels of bone erosion of 80 patients

HCDU examination results showed that the predominantly affected joint by bone erosion was MCP3 (16.7%), followed by PIP3 (14.1%), MCP2 (13.5%) and PIP2 (12.8%). The slightest affected joint was the thumb metacarpophalangeal joint, followed by thumb, little finger metacarpophalangeal joint and proximal interphalangeal joint (Fig. 4).

Figure 4.

Distribution of affected erosion suggested by high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography. MCP, thumb metacarpophalangeal joint; PPI, proximal interphalangeal joint; 1–5, thumb to little finger, respectively.

Result of diagnosing RA with a combination method of CCP antibody testing and HCDU examination. The sensitivity of diagnosing RA with both anti-CCP antibody testing and HCDU examination was obviously lower than using each one of these methods alone (P<0.05). The specificity was significantly higher (P<0.05; Table II) (Fig. 5).

Table II.

Result of diagnosing RA with a combination method of CCP antibody testing and HCDU examination.

Method	Sensitivity, %	Specificity, %
CCP antibody testing	72.7	82.4
HCDU examination	71.1	83.8
Combination of 2 methods	47.3[a,b]	98.5[a,b]

Compared with CCP antibody testing

P<0.05; compared with HCDU examination

P<0.05. RA, rheumatoid arthritis; CCP, cyclic citrullinated peptide; HCDU, high-frequency color Doppler ultrasonography.

Figure 5.

Cyclic citrullinated peptide antibody testing results of the study group.

Discussion

RA is a chronic inflammatory disorder that characteristically affects the small joints in hands and feet (7). RA generally starts in hand and foot joints progressing to other areas including the knees, hips, and shoulders. The key RA symptom is swollen joints, but RA can also cause fatigue, fever, and weight loss. RA symptoms can cause the joints to become permanently deformed over time which may lead to permanent disability. As there is no cure for this disease, disability caused by RA is irreversible. Prior studies demonstrated that early diagnosis and treatment were effective on the patient condition and lowered the osteoarticular damage and improved prognosis. X-ray, often, is used as a routine method for RA diagnosis; however, depending on the method of X-ray examination, RA could only be detected several years after the appearance of the symptoms (6,8,9).

Blood test to detect rheumatoid factors is also a diagnostic tool which has its limitations (10–12). In recent years, HCDU examination has received significant consideration for indication of early diagnosis in arthritis with no trauma that can be repeatedly operated (13–15). In this study, the HCDU examination was indicated in RA patients suffering from comparative articular surface roughness and continuous interruption at the margins. Blood signals could be observed on inner finger joints and at the margins. The eroded cartilage and subcortex medullary substance of bone had low echogenicity and irregularly defined tumor-like lesion, and the internal echo was uneven. By contrast, HCDU examination on the control group showed no blood signals in the finger joints, cortical bones and articular surfaces were relatively smooth with continuous integrity. Ultrasonic manifestation of cortical bones and subchondral bones had a strong echo line with continuous smoothness at the posterior edge of cartilage. Behind that was the attenuation region and the medullary substance of bone could not be displayed.

The positive blood ratio in interphalangeal joint detected with HCDU previously (16) was 10%, while the ratio in this study was 65.7%. Our results suggested that by HCDU examination, the predominantly affected joint by bone erosion was MCP3 (16.7%), followed by PIP3 (14.1%), MCP2 (13.5%) and PIP2 (12.8%). The least affected joint was the thumb metacarpophalangeal joint, followed by thumb, little finger metacarpophalangeal joint and proximal interphalangeal joint. Anti-CCP antibody test is particularly useful in the diagnosis of RA. Anti-CCP antibody is a rheumatoid factor and elevated level of anti-CCP is a sign that the patient may be more likely to develop the disease (17,18). Studies suggested (19) that CCP antigens appeared in the RA patients in early stage, and stimulated the proliferation of T cells. However, the appearance of the anti-CCP antibodies was highly related to the osteoarticular damage.

A prior study that conducted radiological evaluation of the RA patients with 6 years of follow-up showed that patients who were tested positive for anti-CCP antibody suffered more severe bone damage than those with negative results (20). Other studies suggested that anti-CCP antibody was related to RA bone erosion to a certain degree (21). Results obtained in this study showed that the positive rate of anti-CCP antibody in the study group was 73.8%, and the negative rate was 26.2% (Fig. 5). The positive rate in the control group was 10% (and the negative rate was 90%. Reports on the use of HCDU examination in combination with anti-CCP antibody testing in diagnosing RA are rare. Our results suggested that the sensitivity of diagnosing RA with both anti-CCP antibody testing and HCDU examination was obviously lower than using each of those methods alone, while the specificity was significantly higher.

We concluded that a combination of HCDU examination and anti-CCP antibody testing can be considered useful to improve the early diagnostic rate of RA. HCDU examination is a sensitive, secure, atraumatic and easily-operated diagnostic method for early RA patients with finger joint damage. Combined with anti-CCP antibody testing, it will provide a better chance for RA patients, and give them hope for a better treatment and improved prognosis.