| Literature DB >> 28421079 |
Tamara Tuuminen1, Kyösti Sakari Rinne2.
Abstract
The presence of toxic indoor molds with accompanying bacterial growth is clearly detrimental to human health. The pathophysiological and toxicological effects of toxins and structural components of molds and bacteria have been clarified in experiments conducted in tissue culture and animals, and there is convincing epidemiologic evidence; nonetheless their implications for human health are either ignored or denied, at least in Finland. In this communication, we describe two cohorts suffering severe sequelae to mold-related illness. One cohort is a nine-member family with pets that moved into a new house, which soon proved to be infested with pathogenic molds. The other cohort consists of 30 teachers and 50 students from a mold-infested school building. The first cohort experienced a plethora of mucosal irritation, neurological, skin, allergic, and other symptoms, with all family members ultimately developing a multiple chemical syndrome. In the second cohort, we detected a greatly elevated prevalence of autoimmune conditions and malignancies. We claim that mold-related illness exists in multiple facets; if not simply a transient mucosal irritation or even an increased risk of asthma onset or its exacerbation. We propose a scheme to explain the natural course of the mold-related illness. We recommend that future studies should combine data from, e.g., cancer, autoimmune, and endocrine disorder registers and neurological and mental health or neuropsychological registers with mold-exposed individuals being monitored for prolonged follow-up times.Entities:
Keywords: autoimmune conditions; environmental molds; hypothyroidism; indoor air; malignancies; mold-related illness; multiple chemical syndrome; sick building syndrome
Year: 2017 PMID: 28421079 PMCID: PMC5377931 DOI: 10.3389/fimmu.2017.00382
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Immunol ISSN: 1664-3224 Impact factor: 7.561
Figure 1The frequency of symptoms other than infections. The other symptoms were insomnia, migraine, motor and sensory peripheral neuropathy, headache, tremor, twitching, tic of the body and in the eyes; tiredness, exhaustion; increased blood pressure, increased heart rate; muscle pain, joint pain; numbness in the hands and feet; weakness; feeling thirsty; feeling cold, shivers; balance problems; muscle weakness; slightly cyanotic limbs; irritability, melancholy, nervousness, memory disorders; facial flushing, skin rash, full-body rash, urticaria of the whole body; intestinal disorders, e.g., diarrhea or constipation; increased allergic reactions; excessive sweating or no sweat at all; crusted skin behind the ears or in the scalp of children; increased secretion of ear wax, jamming in matters in children, restlessness, difficulty falling asleep; retardation in growth; gastrointestinal reflux; too high or too low acidity of the stomach; weight loss without deliberate dieting; swelling of the face and the abdomen region; increased frequency of urination; nightly horror scenes in children; unexplained fever spikes; pallor, dark under the eyes; prolonged jaundice in a newborn; hypothermia; bedwetting in a child who was for many years dry at nights; child’s rage; jaundice of skin; night waking in children; significant hair thinning; dermatitis of the face skin and acne-like symptoms also in adults; unexplained vomiting in children; easy bruising; hypersensitivity to noise in children; dark urine in children although well hydrated.
Figure 2Development of a multiple chemical syndrome (MCS illness) in every family member. Note that the symptoms developed gradually along with increased time of staying in the problem house. The presentation of the MCS illness was estimated by an arbitrary score. The blue line is the cumulative score of all the members. The explanation of the arbitrary score: +, hypersensitivity to strong detergents, softeners, and perfumed hygiene products. A child reacts to the odor by avoiding the perfume or the smell of a person or an object. ++, a clear hypersensitivity to detergents and perfumed products. A child avoids entering several departments in a department store with a strong smell burden (e.g., bags, shoes, textiles, toys, and detergents) and avoids contacts with people who have strong smell from their clothing, etc. +++, a clear hypersensitivity to perfumes and flagrancies, the same as above but in addition hypersensitivity to gasoline, exhaust, and windshield washing fluid, new fabrics, and new furniture. ++++, reacts strongly by a production of mucous excreta and itching feeling on the mucosa. The symptoms as above but in addition the hypersensitivity to adhesive surfaces, printing ink, plastic, rubber, markers, ballpoint pens, new toys, books, games, and textiles. Symptoms appear also in various dusty environment, e.g., to road dust. +++++, as above but in addition the hypersensitivity to perfume-free detergents and even to natural scents of flowers, trees, grass, soil, etc.
The morbidities and mortalities diagnosed in a personnel working in the problem school (Cohort 2).
| Person | Years of exposure | Gender | Profession | Morbidities | Employment status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 25–30 | Male | School rector | Inclusion body myositis | Retired due to age |
| Exacerbation of allergy | |||||
| Irritation of mucosa | |||||
| Voice problems | |||||
| B | 20 | Female | Instructor | Asthma | Partly employed |
| Sjögren syndrome | |||||
| Thyroiditis | |||||
| Dystonia | |||||
| Migraine | |||||
| C | 12 | Male | Instructor | Vasculitis with purpura | Working |
| D | 13 | Female | Instructor | Goiter with hypothyroidism | Working |
| Diabetes | |||||
| Sleep apnea | |||||
| Skin symptoms | |||||
| E | 5 | Female | Instructor | Chronic flu-like illness | Working half time |
| Cough | |||||
| Sneezing | |||||
| Voice problems | |||||
| Eye irritation that led to iritis | |||||
| F | 20 | Female | Special teacher | Breast cancer | Retired due to age |
| G | 12 | Female | Teacher | Asthma exacerbation | Retired due to disability |
| Chronic sinusitis | |||||
| Chronic otitis | |||||
| Allergy | |||||
| Eosinophilia | |||||
| Hypothyroidism | |||||
| Nasal polyps (st post polypectomy) | |||||
| Difficulties to concentrate | |||||
| Memory problems | |||||
| Chronic fatigue | |||||
| Depression | |||||
| Altogether, history of sickness that lasted for 35 years | |||||
| H | 20 | Female | Special teacher | Breast cancer | Working |
| I | 5 | Female | Instructor | Chronic sinusitis | Working |
| Allergic rhinitis | |||||
| Partial hearing loss | |||||
| J | 10 | Female | Special teacher | Neurosarcoidosis | To be retired due to disability |
| Hypothyroidism (severe) | |||||
| Intestinal stoma | |||||
| K | 3 | Female | Instructor | Chronic sinusitis | Working |
| Chronic otitis | |||||
| Chronic eye irritation | |||||
| Joint pains | |||||
| L | 20 | Female | Instructor | Asthma | Retired due to age |
| Allergy | |||||
| Breast cancer | |||||
| M | 5 | Female | Special teacher | Underlying disease: | Retired due to disability |
| Cilium dysfunction | |||||
| The following symptoms exacerbated: | |||||
| Chronic sinusitis | |||||
| Bronchiectasias | |||||
| Chronic otitis | |||||
| Pneumonia | |||||
| Joint pains | |||||
| Fybromyalgy | |||||
| Asthma | |||||
| Hypothyroidism | |||||
| In the beginning during the holiday period, the symptoms relieved, but later they became chronic, and now her morbidity is severe | |||||
| N | 8 | Female | Instructor | Non-smoker, previously healthy | Dead |
| Chronic rhinitis | |||||
| Flu-like symptoms | |||||
| Chronic bronchitis | |||||
| After the prolonged period of flu illness died from sepsis | |||||
| O | 10 | Female | Special teacher | Lung cancer (non-smoker) | Dead |
| P | 10 | Female | Instructor | Asthma | Partly employed |
| Chronic sinusitis | |||||
| Multiple chemical syndrome illness | |||||
| Severe sleep apnea | |||||
| Memory problems | |||||
| At the time of this communication her thyroid function and neurological disorders are being investigated | |||||
| High sensitivity to poor indoor air | |||||
| R | 10 | Female | Instructor | Chronic sinusitis | Working |
| Psoriasis-like skin problems | |||||
| Eye irritation | |||||
| Chronic otitis | |||||
| Voice problems | |||||
| Memory problems | |||||
| Problems to concentrate | |||||
| Chronic fatigue that led to depression | |||||
| S | 4 | Female | Special teacher | Goiter | Retired due to age |
To make the assessment of the disease category more illustrative we use colors: blue for autoimmune diseases; violet for oncology; red for nervous disorder; brown for asthma, and green for upper and lower respiratory symptoms, eye and skin irritation.
Figure 3Graphical presentation of the natural course of the mold-related illness.