Jaden R Kohn1, Joseph M Armstrong2, Rachel A Taylor3, Diana L Whitney4, Anne C Gill5. 1. Undergraduate Medical Education, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA. 2. Department of Urology, University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA. 3. Department of Medicine, Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA. 4. Departments of Medicine and Pediatrics, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado, USA. 5. Department of Pediatrics and Center for Medical Ethics, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Barriers hinder medical students from reporting breaches in professional behaviour, which can adversely impact institutional culture. No studies have reported student perspectives on how to address these barriers successfully. Our study (i) evaluated the likelihood of reporting based on violation severity, (ii) assessed barriers to reporting and (iii) elicited students' proposed solutions. METHODS: Four medical students designed a cross-sectional study in 2015. In response to seven scenarios, students rated the likelihood of reporting the violation, indicated perceived barriers and identified solutions. Additional questions investigated the perceived importance of professionalism, confidence in understanding professionalism and trust in administrative protection from negative consequences. RESULTS: Two hundred and seventy-two students in their clinical years (MS2-4) responded to the survey (RR = 50%). Students were 70-90% likely to report major violations, but < 30% likely to report minor or moderate violations. Barriers included concerns about an uncomfortable relationship (41%), potential negative repercussions on grades or opportunities (23%), and addressing by direct discussion rather than reporting (23%). Solutions included simplified reporting, control over report release date, improved feedback to reporters, training for real-time resolution of concerns and a neutral resource to help students triage concerns. No differences existed between classes regarding the importance or understanding of professionalism. In linear regression, only importance of professionalism predicted likelihood of reporting and this did not change with training. CONCLUSIONS: Hindered by common barriers, students are unlikely to report a violation unless it is a serious breach of professionalism. Student-derived solutions should be explored by medical school administrators to encourage reporting of violation of professionalism.
BACKGROUND: Barriers hinder medical students from reporting breaches in professional behaviour, which can adversely impact institutional culture. No studies have reported student perspectives on how to address these barriers successfully. Our study (i) evaluated the likelihood of reporting based on violation severity, (ii) assessed barriers to reporting and (iii) elicited students' proposed solutions. METHODS: Four medical students designed a cross-sectional study in 2015. In response to seven scenarios, students rated the likelihood of reporting the violation, indicated perceived barriers and identified solutions. Additional questions investigated the perceived importance of professionalism, confidence in understanding professionalism and trust in administrative protection from negative consequences. RESULTS: Two hundred and seventy-two students in their clinical years (MS2-4) responded to the survey (RR = 50%). Students were 70-90% likely to report major violations, but < 30% likely to report minor or moderate violations. Barriers included concerns about an uncomfortable relationship (41%), potential negative repercussions on grades or opportunities (23%), and addressing by direct discussion rather than reporting (23%). Solutions included simplified reporting, control over report release date, improved feedback to reporters, training for real-time resolution of concerns and a neutral resource to help students triage concerns. No differences existed between classes regarding the importance or understanding of professionalism. In linear regression, only importance of professionalism predicted likelihood of reporting and this did not change with training. CONCLUSIONS: Hindered by common barriers, students are unlikely to report a violation unless it is a serious breach of professionalism. Student-derived solutions should be explored by medical school administrators to encourage reporting of violation of professionalism.
Authors: Anne C Gill; Elizabeth A Nelson; Ayesha I Mian; Jean L Raphael; David R Rowley; Amy L Mcguire Journal: Med Teach Date: 2014-05-12 Impact factor: 3.650
Authors: Marianne Mak-van der Vossen; Arianne Teherani; Walther N K A van Mook; Gerda Croiset; Rashmi A Kusurkar Journal: Med Educ Date: 2018-06-25 Impact factor: 6.251