Pascal Geldsetzer1, Maria Vaikath1, Jan-Walter De Neve1,2, Thomas J Bossert1, Sibusiso Sibandze3, Mandla Mkhwanazi4, Till Bärnighausen1,2,5. 1. Department of Global Health and Population, 665 Huntington Avenue, Building 1, Room 1104, Boston, Massachusetts 02115. 2. Institute of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, University of Heidelberg, Im Neuenheimer Feld 324, 69120 Heidelberg, Germany. 3. Afya Health Management Associates, Lamvelase Premises, Corner Sandlane & Nkoseluhlaza Street, Manzini, Swaziland. 4. Department of Demography and Statistics, University of Swaziland, Private Bag 4, Kwaluseni, Swaziland. 5. Africa Health Research Institute, R618 en Route to Hlabsia Somkhele, Mtubatuba, 3935 KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Patients are unlikely to share the personal information that is critical for effective healthcare, if they do not trust that this information will remain confidential. Trust in confidentiality may be particularly low in interactions with community health workers (CHW) because CHW deliver healthcare outside the clinic setting. This study aims to determine the proportion of Swaziland's population that does not trust the national CHW cadre with confidential medical information, and to identify reasons for distrust. METHODS: Using two-stage cluster random sampling, we carried out a household survey covering 2000 households across 100 census enumeration areas in two of Swaziland's four regions. To confirm and explain the quantitative survey results, we used qualitative data from 19 semi-structured focus group discussions in the same population. RESULTS: 49% of household survey participants stated that they distrust the national CHW cadre with confidential health information. Having ever been visited by a CHW was positively associated with trust (aOR: 2.11; P < 0.001), while higher levels of schooling of the respondent were negatively associated (aOR for more than secondary schooling versus no schooling: 0.21; P < 0.001). The following three primary reasons for distrusting CHW with confidential health information emerged in the qualitative analyses: (1) CHW are members of the same community as their clients and may thus share information with people who know the client, (2) CHW are mostly women and several focus group participants assumed that women are more likely than men to share information with other community members, and (3) CHW are not sufficiently trained in confidentiality issues. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that confidentiality concerns could be a significant obstacle to the successful rollout of CHW services for stigmatized conditions in Swaziland. Increasing coverage of the CHW program, raising the population's confidence in CHWs' training, assigning CHW to work in communities other than the ones in which they live, changing the CHW gender composition, and addressing gender biases may all increase trust with regards to confidentiality.
BACKGROUND: Patients are unlikely to share the personal information that is critical for effective healthcare, if they do not trust that this information will remain confidential. Trust in confidentiality may be particularly low in interactions with community health workers (CHW) because CHW deliver healthcare outside the clinic setting. This study aims to determine the proportion of Swaziland's population that does not trust the national CHW cadre with confidential medical information, and to identify reasons for distrust. METHODS: Using two-stage cluster random sampling, we carried out a household survey covering 2000 households across 100 census enumeration areas in two of Swaziland's four regions. To confirm and explain the quantitative survey results, we used qualitative data from 19 semi-structured focus group discussions in the same population. RESULTS: 49% of household survey participants stated that they distrust the national CHW cadre with confidential health information. Having ever been visited by a CHW was positively associated with trust (aOR: 2.11; P < 0.001), while higher levels of schooling of the respondent were negatively associated (aOR for more than secondary schooling versus no schooling: 0.21; P < 0.001). The following three primary reasons for distrusting CHW with confidential health information emerged in the qualitative analyses: (1) CHW are members of the same community as their clients and may thus share information with people who know the client, (2) CHW are mostly women and several focus group participants assumed that women are more likely than men to share information with other community members, and (3) CHW are not sufficiently trained in confidentiality issues. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that confidentiality concerns could be a significant obstacle to the successful rollout of CHW services for stigmatized conditions in Swaziland. Increasing coverage of the CHW program, raising the population's confidence in CHWs' training, assigning CHW to work in communities other than the ones in which they live, changing the CHW gender composition, and addressing gender biases may all increase trust with regards to confidentiality.
Authors: Jan-Walter De Neve; Henri Garrison-Desany; Kathryn G Andrews; Nour Sharara; Chantelle Boudreaux; Roopan Gill; Pascal Geldsetzer; Maria Vaikath; Till Bärnighausen; Thomas J Bossert Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2017-08-08 Impact factor: 11.069
Authors: David Musoke; Edwinah Atusingwize; Deborah Ikhile; Sarah Nalinya; Charles Ssemugabo; Grace Biyinzika Lubega; Damilola Omodara; Rawlance Ndejjo; Linda Gibson Journal: Global Health Date: 2021-01-07 Impact factor: 4.185
Authors: Robert Kalyesubula; Jessica Mitter Pardo; Stephanie Yeh; Richard Munana; Ivan Weswa; Joseph Adducci; Faith Nassali; Mennen Tefferi; John Mundaka; Sahai Burrowes Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2021-04-07 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Sonia Ahmed; Liana E Chase; Janelle Wagnild; Nasima Akhter; Scarlett Sturridge; Andrew Clarke; Pari Chowdhary; Diana Mukami; Adetayo Kasim; Kate Hampshire Journal: Int J Equity Health Date: 2022-04-11
Authors: Jan-Walter De Neve; Chantelle Boudreaux; Roopan Gill; Pascal Geldsetzer; Maria Vaikath; Till Bärnighausen; Thomas J Bossert Journal: Hum Resour Health Date: 2017-07-03