Literature DB >> 28299410

The power law of movement: an example of a behavioral illusion.

Richard S Marken1, Dennis M Shaffer2.   

Abstract

The curved movements produced by living organisms follow a power law where the velocity of movement is a power function of the degree of curvature through which the movement is made. The exponent of the power function is close to either 1/3 or 2/3 depending on how velocity and curvature are measured. This power law is thought to reflect biological and/or kinematic constraints on how organisms produce movements. The present paper shows that the power law is actually a statistical artifact that results from mistaking a correlational for a causal relationship between variables. The power law implies that curvature influences the velocity of movement. In fact, the power law is a mathematical consequence of the way that these variables are calculated. The appearance that curvature affects the velocity of movement is shown to be an example of a "behavioral illusion" that results from ignoring the purpose of behavior.

Keywords:  Control theory; Movement control; Purposeful behavior

Mesh:

Year:  2017        PMID: 28299410     DOI: 10.1007/s00221-017-4939-y

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Exp Brain Res        ISSN: 0014-4819            Impact factor:   1.972


  22 in total

1.  Origins and violations of the 2/3 power law in rhythmic three-dimensional arm movements.

Authors:  S Schaal; D Sternad
Journal:  Exp Brain Res       Date:  2001-01       Impact factor: 1.972

2.  Velocity and curvature in human locomotion along complex curved paths: a comparison with hand movements.

Authors:  H Hicheur; S Vieilledent; M J E Richardson; T Flash; A Berthoz
Journal:  Exp Brain Res       Date:  2004-12-07       Impact factor: 1.972

Review 3.  Optical trajectories and the informational basis of fly ball catching.

Authors:  Richard S Marken
Journal:  J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform       Date:  2005-06       Impact factor: 3.332

4.  Spectrum of power laws for curved hand movements.

Authors:  Dongsung Huh; Terrence J Sejnowski
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2015-07-06       Impact factor: 11.205

5.  The 2/3 power law: when and why?

Authors:  R Plamondon; W Guerfali
Journal:  Acta Psychol (Amst)       Date:  1998-11

6.  When causality does not imply correlation: more spadework at the foundations of scientific psychology.

Authors:  Richard S Marken; Brittany Horth
Journal:  Psychol Rep       Date:  2011-06

7.  Relation between velocity and curvature in movement: equivalence and divergence between a power law and a minimum-jerk model.

Authors:  J Wann; I Nimmo-Smith; A M Wing
Journal:  J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform       Date:  1988-11       Impact factor: 3.332

8.  The cause of control movements in a tracking task.

Authors:  R Marken
Journal:  Percept Mot Skills       Date:  1980-12

9.  The speed-curvature power law in Drosophila larval locomotion.

Authors:  Myrka Zago; Francesco Lacquaniti; Alex Gomez-Marin
Journal:  Biol Lett       Date:  2016-10       Impact factor: 3.703

10.  Control blindness: Why people can make incorrect inferences about the intentions of others.

Authors:  Andrew B S Willett; Richard S Marken; Maximilian G Parker; Warren Mansell
Journal:  Atten Percept Psychophys       Date:  2017-04       Impact factor: 2.199

View more
  6 in total

Review 1.  The power law as behavioral illusion: reappraising the reappraisals.

Authors:  Richard S Marken; Dennis M Shaffer
Journal:  Exp Brain Res       Date:  2018-03-08       Impact factor: 1.972

2.  The speed-curvature power law of movements: a reappraisal.

Authors:  Myrka Zago; Adam Matic; Tamar Flash; Alex Gomez-Marin; Francesco Lacquaniti
Journal:  Exp Brain Res       Date:  2017-10-25       Impact factor: 1.972

3.  Comments on Marken and Shaffer: The power law of movement: an example of a behavioral illusion.

Authors:  M M Taylor
Journal:  Exp Brain Res       Date:  2018-02-21       Impact factor: 1.972

4.  The speed-curvature power law in tongue movements of repetitive speech.

Authors:  Stephan R Kuberski; Adamantios I Gafos
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2019-03-18       Impact factor: 3.240

5.  Bioinspired Implementation and Assessment of a Remote-Controlled Robot.

Authors:  Yves Rybarczyk; Diogo Gil Carvalho
Journal:  Appl Bionics Biomech       Date:  2019-09-11       Impact factor: 1.781

6.  Do bumblebees have signatures? Demonstrating the existence of a speed-curvature power law in Bombus terrestris locomotion patterns.

Authors:  Laura James; T G Emyr Davies; Ka S Lim; Andrew Reynolds
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2020-01-15       Impact factor: 3.240

  6 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.